Court filing
Exhibit B - Complaint in Anderson v. Plaid; No. 20-cv-4480 — In re Plaid Inc. Privacy Litigation (Dkt. 49-3, N.D. Cal. No. 4:20-cv-03056)
Filed July 17, 2020 in In re Plaid Inc. Privacy Litigation; one of 174 filings from this case.
Record facts
| Court | U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California |
|---|---|
| Filed | 2020-07-17 |
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California · No. 4:20-cv-03056-DMR · Doc. 49-3 · 2020-07-17 · Docket on CourtListener
Full text
EXHIBIT B
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 1 of 76
!"#!!%
&'()*+',-./01'.2',3 4
&'()*5*6*/,1'.2',3 4
72,)'68'09:5-/
'*5/;)9
/.<1 4
=
/.<1 4
=
>',-./0?>',-./0..@2A)B
.5*6*/,?>',-./0..@2A)B
C%"D EEC"FGHIEJEKKL%MDM
75..5'B2'.6/(
&/NN/,02@/A-),
&/NN,/02O)6,)NN
5'*'&2P5*(/,
1QRSUVWXYWZ[\\]YWV^YS_`aSR^bWScY_de
',f/--,//-9:5-/
>5.'6/.@>5'9
/.<1 4 =
'g<1 4 =
'.6/(?(,f'--),*/0(2A)B
&@/A-),?(,f'--),*/0(2A)B
&O)6,)NN?(,f'--),*/0(2A)B
P5*(/,?(,f'--),*/0(2A)B
"hGJ i"GJEKH
j!GDKh"!J
',,/--2.'*A>N5/.6
)k/,-'2l',6
1QRSUVWXYWZ[\\]YWV^YS_`aSR^bWScY_de
5**/()-'-,//-9:5-/7=
-2':.9
/.<1 4=
'g<1 4=
;2k.'*A>N5/.6?,8k.'8N5,B2A)B
,20',6?,8k.'8N5,B2A)B
[^^SR_Zm`aSRQ]VY_^Yaa`V_n^bZQRS\S`Zno]V``
+
p
9
A'*6&l
+7O9)*k/>'.N)N->/B(/.q/(
'*6'..)->/,((5B5.',.0(5-:'-/69
.'5*-5NN(9
q2
29'/.'8',/A),@),'-5)*9
/N/*6'*-2
'(/)2<rrrrrrrrr
DEF%!hG KEJFs"CGJ
J"D! E#GJ"tuh j!"
"!h"K
D!CCD hEG
J"FGJKEvu# h!
wxyz|}~
zz~xz
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 2 of 76
!"#$%&'!!()*
!#')+,"$!- )&) ")%
".
"#$&',$"#.............................................................................................................
"".
0,&"*'"$"#!#'1)#,)........................................................................................
""".
"#$&!'"*$&"$!**"(#)#$
...................................................................................
"1. $2)!&$")*
...................................................................................................................
1.
%!$,! -!3(&,#'
............................................................................................
!. -456789:;<9=>4<4;<?@A48?5B4?;7!BBC
......................................................
-. >4<'A5AB?DA>EF?4;C-4;6!559:;?8A<A;?4>C=89G!BB,CA8C
...................
. >4< ADA847AC8A<A;?4>C?99>>A5?14>:4F>A'4?49;44CCDA*54>A...........
'. >4<*A>>C4;<?@A8HCA)IB>9?C?@A,;>4H=:>>EF?4;A<8D4?A'4?4
...........
). >4<4;<"?C%;?A5@>A;?C9;5A4>>4<JC9;<:5?=89G9;C:GA8C
...............
%. >4<JC248G?99;C:GA8CC&A597;KA<FE-4;6C4;<";<:C?8E(89:BC
...........
(. >4<3;9H;7>E19>4?AC)C?4F>C@A<";<:C?8E*?4;<48<C4;<F>74?9;C
..........
. $@A( -!*?4;<48<C
.....................................................................................
. >4<JC!56;9H>A<7AGA;?9="?C'C5>9C:8AF>74?9;C
..............................
. 19>4?9;C9=( -!*?4;<48<C;>4<JC8D45E9>5E.............................
1". "#0,&L!#''!!()*$$2) !**................................................................
!. $@A#4GA<>4;?==CJ)IBA8A;5AC........................................................................
-. ";M:8AC=89G";D4C9;C9=8D45E4;<'7;?48E19>4?9;C
.................................
. )59;9G5'4G47AC
.................................................................................................
. 9CC9=14>:4F>A";<AG;=54?9;&7@?C......................................................
. 'G;C@A<14>:A9=&7@?C?989?A5?9;9='4?4
........................................
. 9CC9=9;?89>DA889BA8?EH?@486A?4F>A14>:A
.................................
. ";58A4CA<&C69="<A;??E$@A=?4;<%84:<....................................................
1"". 2")% !N
...........................................................................................................
1""".$ "#(O#)! )#$O!#')*$)
.........................................................
"P. !**!$"#! )(!$"#*................................................................................
P.
!"*%&&) ")%...................................................................................................
&!L)&%&&) ")%............................................................................................................... ')!#'%&0,&L$&"! ....................................................................................................
QRSTVWXYZ[\ZY]]^Y_`[abTcdefghTiYjkYjkXYlRmTX`njo
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 3 of 76
!" ##$%% &!'&%$(!)% !*%+''&!!',&##%&-*./&'(*012 !" ##$34)
!' 5 '+-!'$%&6%&$&!"" 5&$(#*$$(#$ 7 %-$ "+"&'6&%$(!$)8-".& %+!'&%$ 9!&'
*(+!$&)&9&$#((/$9 !$"&#&!'!" '!*:12 '34;
<=
<?@ABCDE@<B?
:
7(!9".&7($"5+8&!'$&!$ " 5&(#*(!$+7&%'" $".&6&%$(!
# !!* !#(%7" (!7 !" !&' !*(!$+7&%$H8!0 !9!'(".&%# !!* **(+!"$:.&
*(77(!/(#6% 5*-)$/&$7!-#&'&%!'$""&/$)$#&9+%'$+*. !#(%7" (!:
(!"%%-"(".&$&/$!'$(* &"!(%7$) '"0&$*(!$+7&%$H# !!* **(+!"(9 !
*%&'&!" $)**&$$&$".& %8!0 !9!'(".&%# !!* **(+!"$$&5&%" 7&$6&%'-)!'".&!
$&$!'(".&%/ $&7 $+$&$".&. 9.-6&%$(!!'6% 5"& !#(%7" (! ".$/%(!9#+-
(8" !&': '' $*($&$!(!&(#". $"(*(!$+7&%$:
:
'9".&%$". $'"".%(+9.$(#"/%&&78&''&' !/ '&-+$&'# !!*
"&*.!((9-1# !"&*.466$$+*.$I&!7()( !8$&)J+%&H$2$.66)3!'"% 6&: 'H$
$""&'7 $$ (! $"(70& "2&$-3#(%*(!$+7&%$"(2*(!!&*"3".& %8!0**(+!"$"(".&$&
# !"&*.66$)8+" '*(!*&$ "$*(!'+*"!'"%+& !"&!" (!$#%(7*(!$+7&%$:!'&&') '#(%
-&%$.$&K6( "&' "$6($ " (!$7 ''&7!"(*J+ %&66+$&%$H8!0 !9(9 !*%&'&!" $!'
".&!+$&".($&*%&'&!" $"(.%5&$"5$"7(+!"$(#6% 5"&"%!$*" (!. $"(%-!'(".&%
# !!* '")/ ".(+"*(!$&!": '.$6&%6&"%"&'". $$*.&7&"(7$$/." ""(+"$$
2(!&(#".&%9&$""%!$*" (!'"$&"$ !".&/(%':3
:
%$") ' !'+*&$*(!$+7&%$"(.!'(5&%".& %6% 5"&8!0(9 !*%&'&!" $"(
LMNOP8-70 !9 "66&%".($&*%&'&!" $%&8& !9*(77+! *"&'' %&*"-"(*(!$+7&%$H
QNRST:(!$+7&%$%& !#(%7&'".&*(!!&*" (! $26% 5"&3!'2$&*+%&)3!'".& %8!0 !9
*%&'&!" $/ 2!&5&%8&7'&**&$$ 8&3"(".&66:.&-%&".&!' %&*"&'"((9 !$*%&&!
"."((0$ 0& " $*(7 !9#%(7".& %8!0)*(76&"&/ ".".&8!0H$(9(!'8%!' !9:!
%& "-).(/&5&%)".(+9. ''(&$!("' $*($&". $)".&(9 !$*%&&! $*%&"&'8-)*(!"%(&'8-)
!'*(!!&*"&'"( ': '&K&*+" 5&$.5&*0!(/&'9&'". $6%(*&$$/$2(6" 7 U&'3"(
!*%&$&2+$&%*(!5&%$ (!$3V !(".&%/(%'$)"(6%(5 '&#$&$&!$&(#*(7#(%""(*(!$+7&%$8-
*(!*& !9 'H$%(&$!+!## "&'". %'6%"-:
WXYZ\]^_`ab`_ccd_efaghZijklmnZo_pq_pq^_rXsZ\ftpu
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 4 of 76
!"#$%&'($)* *!"#*)+ ,*-&".(#!, $ #/('&*/""0/'(#123456891:;<<'!! **/"
!"#*)+ ,*-= ,*"#'&>(#'#!('&0'#?(#.(#>",+'/("#>",&'($-*"@#!"++ ,!('&=),="* *@A"&&B
)#, &'/ $/"!"#*)+ ,*-)* ">/A '==*", '!A!"#*)+ ,%&'($$"@#&"'$*B ',*-@",/A">
/,'#*'!/("#A(*/",B>",4C43DE29F<4855G;96/A BA'H !"## !/ $/"/A'/0'#?I*)!A'*!A !?(#.%
*'H(#.*%!, $(/!',$%'#$0,"? ,'. '!!")#/*J%, .',$& **">@A /A ,/A $'/'(#'#B">/A
'!!")#/*0 ',*'#B, &'/("#*A(=/"/A '==>",@A(!A/A !"#*)+ ,*(.# $)=A)*%'!"#*)+ ,
@A"+'? *'*(#.& +"0(& ='B+ #/"#'#'==>,"+'!A !?(#.'!!")#/)#@(//(#.&B.(H *&'($
B ',*-@",/A">=,(H'/ %.,'#)&',>(#'#!('&(#>",+'/("#>,"+ H ,B'!!")#//A !"#*)+ ,
+'(#/'(#*@(/A/A 0'#?%(#!&)$(#.'!!")#/*+'(#/'(# $>","/A ,**)!A'*, &'/(H *'#$!A(&$, #
"$'/ %&'($A'*'+'** $/A(*/,"H ">$'/'>,"+"H ,KLLNOPPOQR$(*/(#!/>(#'#!('&'!!")#/*
&'($ S=&"(/*(/*(&&."// #(#>",+'/("#(#'H',( /B">@'B*%(#!&)$(#.+',? /(#.
/A $'/'/"(/*'==!)*/"+ ,*%'#'&BT(#./A $'/'/"$ ,(H (#*(.A/*(#/"!"#*)+ ,0 A'H(",%'#$%
+"*/, ! #/&B%* &&(#.(/*!"&& !/("#">$'/'/"U(*''*=',/">'+)&/(0(&&("#$"&&','!V)(*(/("#
&'($A'*)#>'(,&B0 # >(/ $>,"+/A = ,*"#'&(#>",+'/("#">+(&&("#*">+ ,(!'#*'#$
@,"#.>)&&B(#/,)$ $)="#/A (,=,(H'/ >(#'#!('&'>>'(,*
!!",$(#.&B%&'(#/(>>*%"#0 A'&>">/A +* &H *'#$*(+(&',&B*(/)'/ $!"#*)+ ,*%
0,(#./A(*'!/("#/"* ?$ !&','/",B'#$(#W)#!/(H , &( >, V)(,(#.&'($/"! '* (/*+(*!"#$)!/%
=),. /A $'/'(/A'*)#&'@>)&&B!"&& !/ $%#"/(>B!"#*)+ ,*">(/*+(*!"#$)!/%'#$(#>",+
!"#*)+ ,*">/A */ =*/A B!'#/'? /"=,"/ !//A +* &H *>,"+>),/A ,(#H'*("#*&'(#/(>>*'&*"
* ? !"#"+(!, $, **>",&'($-*H("&'/("#*">!"#*)+ ,*-$(.#(/',B,(.A/*%=,(H'!B%'#$@ &&
0 (#.!')* $0B&'($-*)# /A(!'&'#$)#$(*!&"* $(#H'*("#*(#/"/A (,>(#'#!('&'>>'(,*
XXY
[\]X^_X`aXbcdc_efc\f
),*)'#//"g %/A(*"),/A'*",(.(#'&*)0W !/+'// ,W),(*$(!/("#
"H ,/A !&'(+*/A'/',(* )#$ ,/A "+=)/ ,,')$'#$0)* !/% g
%'#$/A
/", $"++)#(!'/("#*!/% g
A(*"),/'&*"A'**)==& + #/'&W),(*$(!/("#"H ,/A '** ,/ $*/'/ &'@!&'(+*
=),*)'#//"g
hijkmnopqrsqpttupvwrxykz{|}~kppopiktw
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 5 of 76
!"#$%& '"(!)*%"!&+,$%!"(!-&!#./$%"$'.&� 1(2$.(*%& *
3'""-&!#.'!%.*""-&4*-'$"*& *'5#$.&!.-#.&%#)*%"+*6-**("78
8
8*6-3$"!)*#9
!.&*%*"&'.(-#"&"8'.('&3*'"&#.*3'""5*54*%!"'-!&!:*.#9'"&'&*(!99*%*.&9%#53'!(
!"#$%& '"/*%"#.'3,$%!"(!-&!#.#)*%*9*.('.&4*-'$"*3'!( '"-#.($-&*(
4$"!.*""!.& *&'&*#9'3!9#%.!'8'.(4*-'$"*3'!( '"-#55!&&*('-&"'.(#5!""!#."
-#5/3'!.*(#9 *%*!.!.& *&'&*#9'3!9#%.!'
;*.$*!"/%#/*%!.& !"!"&%!-&/$%"$'.&� 4*-'$"*3'!((#*"
4$"!.*""!.'.(!""$4,*-&&#/*%"#.'3,$%!"(!-&!#.!.& !"!"&%!-&;*.$*!"'3"#/%#/*%4*-'$"*'
"$4"&'.&!'3/'%	& **)*.&"#%#5!""!#."<!)!.<%!"*&#& *-3'!5"#--$%%*(!.#%*5'.'&*(9%#5
& !"!"&%!-&
===> =@ABCD=EAB=FACEE=H@IJ@A
$%"$'.&&#!)!31-28'""!<.5*.&&#& *'.%'.-!"-#!)!"!#.#9& !"
!"&%!-&!"/%#/*%4*-'$"*'"$4"&'.&!'3/'%	& *-#.($-&K !- <!)*"%!"*'!.&!99"L-3'!5"
#--$%%*(!.& *!&+'.(#$.&+#9'.%'.-!"-#3'!(5'%M*&"'.((*/3#+"!&"/%#($-&"
& %#$< #$&& *.!&*(&'&*"8!.-3$(!.<!.'.%'.-!"-#((!&!#.'33+83'!(!" *'(N$'%&*%*(!.
'.%'.-!"-#'.((*)*3#/*(& *"#9&K'%*'&!""$*!.& !"'-&!#.!.& !"!"&%!-&
=O> APJQCBA=JE
QRSTUVTWWFSXXTYCUZYX[\U!"'-!&!:*.'.(%*"!(*.	& *&'&*#9*K
]'5/" !%*
QRSTUVTWW^XTSUI_FX`ZZYU!"'-!&!:*.'.(%*"!(*.	& *&'&*#9#$&
'%#3!.'
QRSTUVTWWaYWWXYbE_cdYZ\_e!"'-!&!:*.'.(%*"!(*.	& *#55#.K*'3& #9
*.."+3)'.!'
DYWYUZSUVQRSTZ=U_>!"'9!.'.-!'3&*- .#3#<+-#5/'.+& '&(*"-%!4*"!&"
4$"!.*""'"4$!3(!.<& *&*- .!-'3!.9%'"&%$-&$%*& '&-#..*-&"-#."$5*%"89!.'.-!'3!."&!&$&!#."8
'.(9!.&*- (*)*3#/*%".'((!&!#.83'!("'+"& '&!&(*3!)*%"fM*+!."!< &"g#.&#/#9('&''--*""
hijkmnopqrsqpttupvwrxykz{|}~kppopik
w
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 6 of 76
!"#$%%"$&!'()(*+$,%- !.",%/
*($.$%(&*(0( &,! -! ($!)0$$%- $),$-(*-*(,&!'
1"%$)&%%(&,!). &&2"$&
2() (),$%,!2(*$'! )$(
/
34
6789:7;=78>?@A:BC
74
=DEFGHIJKLIMNODPLDKLQRSNDHQPEPTDQPKG7TTU
/ *($.0(%'!").&.$)
1+W(,& &().X$**$(YZ!,[&+/&0!$)$$(**+
'!").&.*($.0$&$)&)$!)!'1"$*.$)#(,!)%"Y& '(,$)#'$)&,(--/+&( *+
2
!0&\& 2&+-$\!&.!1"$*.$)#(1&$).&%,&)&%.(((## &#(! ()..((1 ![& (#&
!-& ($!)]&'$)&,$)' (% "," &- !.",[)!0)(%*($./
/ *!"#*($.^%,!'!").& %,!),&(**($.^% "&)(" &().$)&)$!)%' !Y
,!)%"Y& %2&+&\$.&),&.&$ (,"(*$)&)$!)%0$$)&'$)(),$(*&,)!*!#+$)."% +&( *+$)
&,!Y-()+^%&_$%&),&0$*&&+0& &%$**'! Y"*($)#&$ % (&#+/%&( *+(%&1 "( +
20&)& &().Z!,[&+$) !.",&.*($.(&$)%"*( `a(("%$)&%%&&"-2b&
,!'!").& %Y(.&,*&( (*($.^% "&-" -!%&$%!Y!)&$c&,!)%"Y& ()%(,$!)(*().!&
1()[$)#.((/!**&,$)#().(## &#($)#.((' !Y'$)(),$(*$)%$"$!)%0(%Y& &*+&`(1*&
%([&%2b(%*($.^% &(*#!(*0(%!` &%!*\&.((().Y([&(%!Y&$)#$)& &%$)#/b&+
&Y-(%$c&.&`$YY&)%&b(Y!")!',!)%"Y& %-&).$)#.((&,!Y-()+,!"*.,!**&,' !Y
1()[%d#!$)#1(,["-!'$\&+&( %d().&`(0&%!Y&b$)#%*($.,!"*..!0$&.((/
($Y&2&+ &-! &.(*($.,!"*.,!**&,.&($*&.$)'! Y($!) &#( .$)#2
()%(,$!)%
e,!\& $)#(1!"f
2
!'%-&).$)#g'! &(\& (#&,!)%"Y& 2(*!)#0$ 2
")$h"&
#&!*!,($!)%!0$,& ()%(,$!)%0& &Y(--&./& &&_-*($)&.($%1 !(.().
&_&)%$\&.((,!**&,$!)%&%*($.(-( ' !Y!& (--%$)&` $&.(). "&b1()[,!))&,$!)
()..(((## &#($!)- !,&%%/
/ " & 2$)(&1 "( +
&(.!)a!Y1$)(! ^%Z(,[& &0%'! "Y2
Z!,[&+%(&.(*($.^%%!'0( &Y(.&$%$Y-*&'! ()(--*$,($!)!*$)[0$,!)%"Y& , &.$
ijj-%]kk-*($./,!Yk,!Y-()+k/
ijj- / 2
! 1&% $,*&]lmnojpqrsuvwwxyz{|}j~s2-%]kk000/'! 1&%/,!Yk-*($.
'$)&,k, ' k k $)& \$&00$W(,& &((( $\&)a&\&)2
-%]kk000/+!""1&/,!Yk0(,\%#)%Y!-0/
ijj&1/
- &%&)($!)1+W(,& &().X$**$(YZ!,[&+(a(("%$)&%%&&"-
(]!]2-%]kk000/+!""1&/,!Yk0(,\1Y/
¡¢£¤
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 7 of 76
!"#$%& '(! #) $*%+,!#!%!$-$.+/0 !,!$/001&+%2!$0# #$+/'!"13+&!
$-4
((0#%$#+'$+ 156+%2!10'+'$$! 7"/$.+/0 2!!(-# !8&+3%+'/3!&'9$-$
#$-!(&+%!''+8(&+,# #)$-$%+!%$#+40# .':)!!&$#)+!+8$-!0&)!'$$&'%$#+0
$'!$'#$-!.+&0 4 /'#)3%-#!0!&#) '$$#'$#%001'#'$+ &.#'#)-$'"+/$
-+.%+'/3!&''(! $-!#&$#3!43+!14 $$!$#+5;
#3#0&014# #88!&!$$-&! +$-!
'3!8+&/33+$-0$!&4!&&!$'$$! $-$0# .':"/#0 #)$-!3#''#)<((0#%$#+
&+)&33#)$!&8%!=
8+&(! #)$4; $-$#$-!(&+%!''40# .':)!!&$#)+!
+8$-!0&)!'$$&'%$#+0 $'!$'#$-!.+&0 4 /'#)3%-#!0!&#)$+ &.#'#)-$'
"+/$-+.%+'/3!&''(! $-!#&$#3!43+!14 $$!$#+5;
5 ,!0# ?'%+3(13!#'-# !$&#"/$!$+#$'$&/!(/&(+'!7%+$&&1$+#$'
(/"0#%#3)!'#8&'$&/%$/&!$++04$+$-!!@$!$$-!(/"0#%0!&'+80# $0094.-#%-#'
3+!$#A#)%+'/3!&$&'%$#+0 $5%%+& #)$+%+8+/ !&!&&!$4-! 6+%2!1%3!/(
.#$-$-!3!:0# ;"'! +$-!%&+''-$%-($$!&'8+&3! .-!$-!13((! +/$-+.$-!#&
0)+&#$-3.+&2! $+%+3(&!%+'/3!&'?'(! #)($$!&'.#$-$-+'!+8+$-!&%+'/3!&'4.-#0!
0'+3$%-#)$-+'!%+'/3!&'?$&'%$#+ $$+0# ?'$#+.# !3!&%-$ $"'!5
5 +$'/&(&#'#)014'8#$!%- !,!0+(!&'"!%3!.&!+8$-!'%0! !($-+8
$0# %+/0 !0#,!&4$-!10'+&!%+)#A! #$',0/!$+$-!#&+."/'#!''!'5
!+8$-!
!&0#!'$'/%- !,!0+(!&'.'B!3+4.-+'!-! +8 !,!0+(3!$((&+%-! 0# "+/$
#%+&(+&$#)#$''+8$.&!5
$$-$$#3!4$-!3#8+%/'+80# ?''+8$.&!.'$-! !0#,!&1+8
!@$!'#,!$&'%$#+ $8+&$-!(/&(+'!+8&/#)01$#%'+$-! $5
CDD-$$('EFF!.'51%+3"#$+&5%+3F#$!3G# H
5
CDD-$$('EFF!.'51%+3"#$+&5%+3F#$!3G# H
5((0#%$#+&+)&33#)$!&8%!#'
'+8$.&!#$!&3! #&1$-$00+.'$.+((0#%$#+'$+%+33/#%$!.#$-!%-+$-!&5
CDD-$$('EFF!.'51%+3"#$+&5%+3F#$!3G# H
5
CDD1 4
#$!&,#!..#$-I%-!&&!$$$&#,!J!,!$$
E$+ E4
-$$('EFF...51+/$/"!5%+3F.$%-G,H')'3+(.5
CDDKLMNOQMRSTUDVWUDXYZOD[S\K]^Z[_MS`NSabMWMcd
-$$('EFF-+3!"&!.5%+F"0+)F
F
F F(0# 0/%-!'$-!3+ !&(#8+&"2#) $
7:,!&1+!'# eJ!'4"/$.-!&! +.!)!$$-$ $Gf!? "'+0/$!010+,!$+/'!#$5?+I%-
f#00#3 !%# ! $+$/&0# 8&+3((#$+5;95
CDD1 4
#$!&,#!..#$-I%-!&&!$$$&#,!J!,!$$ E$+ E 4
-$$('EFF...51+/$/"!5%+3F.$%-G,H')'3+(.5$$-!$#3!4B!3+.'# !(! !$
%+&(+&$!!$#$1&!)#'$!&! #!.J+&27B!3+95
4B!3+.'%g/#&! "1104
hijkmnopqrsqpttupvwrxykz{|}~kppopikw
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 8 of 76
!"#$%&'()**)+"#$,'-!./*-"0. 11''0'0"#$'%%"#$"%..)(%+-!''23'00'0"#-
4-.%-!!-,)(5)5 *-!1)#. 2'!(-1"#$2)3"*'-#0+'33-.'0("#%'1&-55.%&-%'#-3*'6
5-,2'#%.-#0%!-#.('!.%&!) $&1)#. 2'!.7("#-#1"-*-11) #%.81)**'1%"4'*,/9-!%"1"5-%"#$
55.:;/"#1* 0"#$5)5 *-!-55.. 1&-.<'#2)/)"#3-.'/= -!'7.9-.&55/:-#0%!"5'
<'#2)&-0)4'!2"**")#-1%"4' .'!-11) #%.-%%&''#0)(
>
)"#3-.'!'5)!%'0*,&-.
2)!'%&-#
2"**")# .'!.>
-#0-.&55!'5)!%'0*,&-.2)!'%&-#2"**")#2)#%&*,-1%"4'
.'!.
%!"5'7.5-,2'#%.'!4"1'!'5)!%'0*,". .'03,2"**")#.)(3 ."#'..'./-#0%& .-
1)22'#. !-%'# 23'!)(1)#. 2'!.
*-"07.)+#.%-%".%"1."#0"1-%'%&-%<'#2)-#0)%&'!
5-,2'#%-55.2-?' 5)4'!&-*()(("#%'1&-55 .-$'
@A
CDEFGIJKJLMFNJDOPQMEFRS@ERTUKKVWRMXYJGJRMFEDSZYV[ULL\SJYS
*-"0&-.-1&"'4'0"%.. 11'..3,-11'.."#$-**)(%&'0-%-.%)!'0"#1)#. 2'!.7
("#-#1"-*-11) #%.+"%&) %1)#. 2'!.7?#)+*'0$')!1)#.'#%&'5!"2-!,.'!4"1')(('!'03,
*-"0%)%&'-!%"1"5-%"#$55.8]^_^/-55. .'03,1)#. 2'!.%).'#0-#0!'1'"4'2)#',(!)2
%&'"!("#-#1"-*-11) #%.;/".3-#?9*"#?"#$:-#04'!"("1-%")#<'!"(,"#$%&-%-1)#. 2'!)+#.-
5-!%"1 *-!3-#?-11) #%"."25)!%-#%()!%&'.-('%,-#0.'1 !"%,)(5-,2'#%%!-#.('!. ."#$2)3"*'
-55."#%'1&-55*"1-%")#.%,5"1-**,4'!"(,-11) #%.'"%&'!3,2-?"#$2"1!)0'5)."%.%)-
1)#. 2'!7.-11) #%/%&'#!'= "!"#$%&-%%&'1)#. 2'!!'5)!%%&'-2) #%.3-1?%)%&'-558+&"1&
1-#%-?'.'4'!-*0-,.;/)!3,-.?"#$-1)#. 2'!%)*)$"#%)%&'"!3-#?0"!'1%*,%)1)#("!2%&'"!
"0'#%"%,-.-#-11) #%&)*0'!
#-%,5"1-*.1'#-!")/1)#. 2'!.*)$"#%)%&'"!3-#?.4"--#9
%&:5!)1'0 !'/
+&'!'3, .'!.-!'!'0"!'1%'0(!)2%&')!"$"#-*+'35-$')!-550"!'1%*,%)%&'"!3-#?.&'!'/
#1-#0. 3.'= '#%*,2'!$'0+"%&%&-%1)!5)!-%")#
`__&%%5.abb"#4'.%)!5-,5-*1)!51)2b.%-%"1("*'.b
33
00--'' '''1
3'
1
`__&%%5.abb+++1)"#3-.'1)2b-3) %
`__&%%5.abb+++3 ."#'.."#."0'!1)2b.= -!'.1-.&-55!'-1&'02"**")# .'!.-#0
2)#'%"c-%")#. !$'
`__&%%5.abb+++.%!"5'1)2b1 .%)2'!.
`__
1%
*-"0 3*"1-%")#ae]fgfh]gijgkgghh_llm_knojlpqr_gk]fsgtgigfh_j
guuroghn/55'#0"v%)*-"07.!'.5)#.'%)/&%%5.abb5*-"01)2b0)1 2'#%.b*-"0
)#. 2'!-%-11'..'1&#"1-*)*"1,'.5)#.'50(
wxyz|}~
zz~xz
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 9 of 76
!"#$%!&'( ))*$+, -.!/$+0,'$%,001, 2)*$ )*$3,%$%$2(%$)$2+,-))*$%('( ,&
,004
$*( 2)*$!$ $!1)*$+, -%$)"% !,5)-$ 6)*,),&&/!)*$%('( ,&,00),$!!)*$
!"#$%.!+, -( 7%#,)( ,! $$!!,%3, 2,")*%(8$2+3)*$ !"#$%1+")/()*")'(9( '
)*$,000%9(2$%,$!!))*$&'( ( 7%#,)( 4
4 &,(2*,! $9$%,2*$%$2))*$!), 2,%2, 2!$"%$
")*0%$2"%$7%)*$%()(,&
0%$!!7*,9( ' !"#$%!&'( ))*$(%+, -," )!4 !)$,217%)*$7(%!)!$9$%,&3$,%!7
&,(2.!0$%,)( !1&,(2,%%, '$27%()!7( )$*&($ )!)&&$) !"#$%!.+, -&'(
( 7%#,)( , 2)*$ 0,!!)*,)( 7%#,)( )&,(21/*(*)*$ ,00%,*$2)*$+, -!2(%$)&34
%,%" 2
1&,(2;+$&,)$2&31'(9$ )*$!$"%()3%(!-!<=$))(! $2)*(!0%$!!7% $$9$
#%$+$ $7((,&)&,(24
4 %,%" 2
&,(2(#0&$#$ )$2,#$)*2)>?>?@)*$
")*0%$2"%$1+")
&,(2.!#$)*22(77$%!#,)$%(,&&37%#,)%"$
")*0%$!!4 2$%)*(!"%%$ )!3!)$#1&,(2
52(%$)&3&&$)A!B6%$2$ )(,&!7%#)*$ !"#$%4%2( ')C-$31)*$',&/,! ))
$&(#( ,)$)*$!$"%()3%(!-&,(2()!$&7*,2%$,)$21+"))5$ )%,&(8$AB)*,)%(!-6,)&,(24
4 &,(2%$7$%!))*(! $/#$)*2,!,5, ,'$2
")*6!3!)$#4&,(2.!, ,'$2
")*0%$!!*,!+$$ ( %0%,)$2( ()!5&,(2( -6!7)/,%$1/*(* !(!)!7!7)/,%$1
( &"2( '&'( !%$$ !12$9$&0$2+3&,(2, 22(!)%(+")$2)()!7( )$*&($ )!7%( %0%,)(
( ))*$(%,00!4
4 &,(22$!(' !)*$&'( !%$$ !( ()!, ,'$2
")*( )$%7,$)'(9$)*$#)*$
&-, 27$$&7&'( !%$$ !"!$2+3( 2(9(2",&7( , (,&( !)()")( !;- / ,!5!07( '6<4
$,"!$&,(22$! )2(!&!$()(! ))*$,)",&+, -1 !"#$%!,%$&"&&$2( ),7,&!$!$ !$7
!$"%()3+3)*(!&'( 0%$!!1, 2)*(!%$!"&)!( ( %$,!$2"!)#$% 9$%!( 4*(!0%$!!(!
- / ,!50*(!*( '46
DEEFEHIH1*))0!JKK///4,")*4#K,")*!$%9$%!K%$2(%$)"%(!K4
DEE$041
%$!$ ),)( +3L(&&(,#C-$31MEENM?OEPQRST?UVW?SS?T>XY@ZE[F\Y]
^Y_`UEab\cd1,) J) J
1*))0!JKK///43")"+$4#K/,)*e9f /)9'4
gUH,) J ) J 4
gUH,) J ) J4
DEE*))0!JKK7( 40&,(24#K,%)(&$!K2$#3!)(73( '!%$$ &$!!$h*, '$K4
ijklnopqrstrquuvqwxsyzl{|}~lqqpqj
lx
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 10 of 76
!"#$%&'"()*"+, +-.%"!-$!"&! %&/"0/ 1"!234/*"2! )+"!-*2& 35$+6
$,, .+/-3 !7"+% .-2+8$% 52'"0"12," !)"55! )-"!(/*"4$!"02!",/"0/ $' 82+-,!""+
5!$+0"0)2/*/*"2!,* -"+5$+69-' 8 $+0, ' !-,*"%"! %$, +-.%"!9-&"!-&",/21"(/*"
&! ,"--$&&"$!-/ 5"/*"/4&2,$'
./*&! ,"0.!"/*$/02!",/-/*"%/ /*"2!5$+6/ 1"!234/*"
$,, .+/& +-"'",/2+8$5$+6(/*"-,!""+-*23/-$+0821"-/*"2%&!"--2 +/*$//*".-"!*$-5""+
02!",/"0$)$43! %7"+% / 2+/"!$,/)2/*$+ /*"!"+/2/4(+$%"'4(/*"2!32+$+,2$'2+-/2/./2 ++
!"$'2/4(/*"4*$1"5""+02!",/"0/ $, ++",/2 +-,!""+0"-28+"0$+02+-"!/"054'$20:;<=;>/*"
7"+% $&&($+0/*"2!, %%.+2,$/2 +-$!"/ '$202+-/"$0 3/*"2!/!.-/"032+$+,2$'2+-/2/./2 +
*"3 '' )2+8$!""#$%&'"- 3'$209-5$+65!$+0"0' 82+-,!""+-12")"02+$% 52'"0"12,"?
+/*"5$+65!$+0"0'$20' 82+-,!""+(, +-.%"!-"+/"!/*"2!' 82+2+3 !%$/2 +
+-/"$0 38 2+8-/!$28*// /*"5$+6($-) .'05"/*",$-"2+$+
./*&! ,"0.!"(/*"' 82+
2+3 !%$/2 +2+-/"$02-/!$+-%2//"002!",/'4/ '$20'$20/*"+.-"-/*"2+3 !%$/2 +/ $,,"--/*"
, +-.%"!9-5$+6$,, .+/
@ABCEFGHIJKIHLLMHNOJPQCRSTUVWCXHYZHYZGH[A\CTHO]Y^
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 11 of 76
!"#$%&%'()*!+, (-(%!+#.( (/%.0'1'%2!+#30'(4'/! #'%"-+()30'
"+3'/)!.'2!/'"+3'+3"(+! 5#'.'63"4'+6/"
2 !"#$%0!/ '5!%3!3'#"+!.(11'+3
30/'!#(+.(16&3'/%."'+.'!+#'+3/'6/'+'&/%0"6%"3'78!.,'/'9%:30!330'.(16!+50!#
7.(16 '3' 5(63"1";'#:"3%7#/(6"+1(#& '&%'#)(/(+*(!/#"+-*!+,!..(&+3%:
6&* ".!3"(+
)(/#'4' (6'/%(+ !"#$%9'*%"3')/(1 !3'/30!35'!/%0'#% "-03(+90!330"%7(63"1";!3"(+:
'+3!" '#+30!36&* ".!3"(+2 !"#3(&3'#0(97#'%"-+' '1'+3%:"+"3%!+!-'#
&306/(.'%%
9'/','53(30'%&..'%%()"3%%()39!/'"+7"+./'!%"+-&%'/.(+4'/%"(+2:"+. &#"+-*5.&%3(1";"+-
30'7 ((,!+#)'' ()6'/1"%%"(+"+-!..'%%:)(/)"+!+."! "+%3"3&3"(+%
+(30'/9(/#%2 !"#
%6'.")".! 5#'%"-+'#"3%%5%3'13(0!4'30'!66'!/!+.'()!/'#"/'.3*!%'#
&30%5%3'19"30(&3
!.3&! 5/'#"/'.3"+-30'.(+%&1'/3(30'*!+,$%9'*%"3'+# !"##"#%()(/30'6&/6(%'()
'+%&/"+-30!330' ((,!+#)'' ()"3%6/(.'%%9(& #)(( .(+%&1'/%"+3(30"+,"+-30'59'/'
!.3&! 5 (--"+-"+3(30'"/*!+,/!30'/30!+/'! ";"+-30!330'59'/'0!+#"+-30'"/ (-"+
"+)(/1!3"(+3(!30"/#6!/35
+!
* (-6(%3#"/'.3'#3("3%#'4' (6'/. "'+3!&#"'+.'2 !"#!-!"+.(+.'#'#
30!3 !"#$% (-"+6/(.'%%9!%#'%"-+'#3(1"1".30' ((,!+#)'' ()30'*!+,$%9'*%"3'<
"+. &#"+-30/(&-030'&%'() (-(%!+#*!+,*/!+#'#.( (/%.0'1'%<7%(30!3'+#&%'/%)'' !
-/'!3'/%'+%'()%'.&/"35!+#)!1" "!/"35:
!"#$%%.0'1'#')"'%"+#&%3/5+(/1%!+#.(+%&1'/%$/'!%(+!* ''=6'.3!3"(+%
0"%"%/') '.3'#2!1(+-(30'/30"+-%2"+30'/'!.3"(+()30(%')'91'1*'/%()30'!66#'4' (6'/
.(11&+"3590("#'+3")"'#!%6'.3%() !"#$%.(+#&.3(/'=!16 '2"+'.'1*'/
2".0!'
>' 52! !"#%()39!/''+-"+''/29!%!%,'#*5!6/(-/!11'/"+!+(9#' '3'#30/'!#(+ !"#$%
"38&*6!-'905 !"#)(( %&%'/%"+3(30"+,"+-30'5!/'!..'%%"+-30'"/*!+,%$9'*%"3'%90'+
(--"+-"+30/(&-0 !"#?
@AAB&+
2
C(1*"+!3(/8!.,'/'9%30/'!#?DEFGAHIDEKLMNOEPQOERARSTTU2
0336%?VV+'9%5.(1*"+!3(/.(1V"3'1W"#X
@AA(4 2
!"#/3". '?YALZRGE[ZEF\@HKAAFNARR]^HIOF\A2
0336%?VV)"+6 !"#.(1V!/3". '%V#'15%3")5"+-%./''+ '%%'=.0!+-'V
@AA'. 2
!"#* (-6(%3?_L`KabEF\RAOKHI[aKcdeffghOFiR2
0336%?VV* (-6 !"#.(1V"16/(4'#%'!/.0V
jklmopqrstusrvvwrxytz{m|}~mrrqr
km~~y
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 12 of 76
!"##$%&!'($)'($)*+ !, #,-.#$- , ('/$#*0"12'1!
,"..3 / 1"3$0/ 1"-' 1,"!$+ 3.$'1.,$4- .5 3.'-6.
,7--'1!7,",)"'/+4 #'8"#$+5"-$($1$1/$.#*0"126.) ! -
8 )#$'1- -5'12'1!9
#"44$..'1!#*0"126..'-$+5'.'.
"0. )7-$)*71"44$,-"0)$:$!"/)$.. 835"-4)"'#.* 7#"2$ 1
* 7.$47'-*,"!$+
'45"$);$))*%&<%$",,$4'"-$* 74 14$1.:35'45'.35* 7
4 #,)'"14$-$"#($-."1*0 /*35 7.$.'12+.- #")'4' 7.
21 42 88.:-5'.'."#"--$-5"-# .-.744$..87)4 #,"1'$.) 2 7-
8 "1//$")3'-5".3$"1/ 7.$47'-*-$"#/ +8* 7.$$
. #$ 1$'#,$. 1"-'1!'12'1.745"3"*:,)$".$/ ,7."1 -$
"-.$47'-*=,)"'/+4 #+-6."). 3 -51 -'1!-5"-:'1"//'-' 1- -5$
.$47'-*3$, ('/$:0"12., -$4--5$'7.$.8 #4$/$1-'")0".$/
"--"42.('"#7)-'8"4- "7-5$1-'4"-' 1+
;$))*/'/1 -/$1*-5"-)"'/3".., 8'1!0"12.63$0.'-$.:07-'1.-$"/ 1)*4 18'#$/)"'/3".
"3"$-5"-#")'4' 7.,"-'$.4 7)/-*- '#,$. 1"-$)"'/6.#$-5 /8 ,5'.5'1!8'1"14'")
"44 71-4$/$1-'").8 #8'1-$45",,47.- #$.+
+ 1.7#$.-5$#.$)($.3$$)$8-'1-5$/"2+ $?"#,)$: 1""*
@"42$
$3.-5$"/:@ 42$*$., 1/$/- 4 14$1."0 7--5$4 ))$4-' 1 80"12"44 71--"1."4-' 1/"-"
('")"'/0*, '1-'1!- 35$-5$"8'1-$45",,7.'1!)"'/A-5$",, 0'15 /B3".CDEFGH
4 ))$4-'1!-5$/"-":-57./$8)$4-'1!"3"$1$.. 8)"'/6. 31#'.4 1/74-&
.$%&J3 7)/$"))*4"7-' 14 11$4-'1!* 70"12"44 71-
-5 7!5)"'/ 1 0'15 /%+-6.$"))*714)$"35"-/"-"-5$*"$
4 ))$4-'1!07--5$','("4*, )'4*.7!!$.-.-5$*"$4 ))$4-'1!
* 70"12"44 71--"1."4-' 15'.- *7.'1!)"'/6.+
K"
/$")0$"2$8 #$+L
@ 42$*%&J% 8 71/$ 8)"'/5$$+4"16-!'($-5$"-' 1")$ 1
35*@3 -$-5$,'("4*, )'4*-5$3"*-5$*/'/:07-4"1
!7""1-$$* 7-5"--5$*"$1 -,7))'1!-"1."4-' 1")/"-"+5$*6$
1)*7.'1!)"'/8 -5$@"7-5$1-'4"-' 1+L
@ 42$*8"')$/- /'.4) .$-5$('-")'18 #"-' 1-5"-)"'/'-.$)83".4 ))$4-'1!-5$0"12'1!/"-"
0$5'1/-5$.4$1$.+
+ )"'/6.4 1/74-'.,"-'47)")*$!$!' 7.'1)'!5- 83'/$.,$"/8'1"14'")'1/7.-*
$4 !1'-' 1-5"-'-'.'#, ,$- ".24 1.7#$.- .5"$-5$') !'1'18 #"-' 13'-5-5'/,"-'$.
MFF$0+ :
'-570-5$"/ 1)"'/J,'("4*N.$47'-*4 14$1.:L
5--,&NN3$0+"45'($+ !N3$0N
N5--,.&NN!'-570+4 #N,)"'/N)'12N'..7$.N+
MFF"* :
O #0'1"- @"42$$3.-5$"/&MDPQRSDTUVCWXUYYZP[CW\PPV]UE
TF^FQDFV[_`aCWbFEDPTE:5--,.&NN1$3.+*4 #0'1"- +4 #N'-$#c'/d
+
efghjklmnopnmqqrmstouvhwxyz{|h}m~m~lmfhylt~
Case 4:20-cv-03056-DMR Document 49-3 Filed 07/17/20 Page 13 of 76
!"#$%
&'()!*
+',!(%-./!*%"%&"*('!&'(%.*!".0123*!!"-!#"-!'
(4(%-./!**('!&'(%*%&5!-*!"'!#'(#"'""66*!6"'(%-!*7&!--.&,"-',(-!(44!*!#)8
"#$,!*!&(6%9!#',"'(%!(4',!&(*!5*%&5!-4(*5*('!&'%6&(%-./!*-:)"% %6
#"'";,!*!'-)!%6"&&!--!#)8#"'""66*!6"'(*--',"'-.&,"&&!---,(.#%('1*!<.*!
&(%-./!*-'(-,"*!',!*"&&(.%'&*!#!%'"-;',',*#5"*'!-2=>?@?+&*!#!%'"--,(.#%(')!
-,"*!#;',5"*'!-(',!*',"%',!)"% $!-5'!',-(44&"6.#"%&!+"#,"-5!*--'!#;','-
5*"&'&!(4&(!&'%6&(%-./!*(6%%4(*/"'(%$
$ B,!',!*.%#!*'-(*6%"5*(&!#.*!(*'-!7!%/(*!-(5,-'&"'!#0"%#
#!&!5'7!31"%"6!#
.',25*(&!#.*!+"#,"-&(%--'!%'8-'*.&'.*!#',!)"% (6%5*(&!--
%'--(4';"*!'("(;''(%'!*&!5'&(%-./!*-:)"% (6%%4(*/"'(%$-',!&(/5"%8
"#/''!#%'-!)*."*8
*!-5(%-!'(',!:-!<.!-'4(*%4(*/"'(%0123*!6"*#%6
&(%-./!*#"'""&&!--+1"#,"-#!7!(5!#"-(.'(%',"'5"--!-&*!#!%'"-#*!&'8'(',!
'*.-'!#%'!*/!#"*80"#3$2
$ %"!&!/)!*
%'!*7!;+"#:-C!"#(4%6%!!*%6&(%4*/!#',"'',!
4((;%6#!-&*5'(%(4"#:-6!%!*"/!',(#(4&"5'.*%6"%#.-%6)"% (6%%4(*/"'(%
;"-1
D"&&.*"'!2E0 3-!'.5")*(;-!*(%"7*'."/"&,%!+03,"7!',!.-!*6('(',!)"% :-
;!)-'!+03,"7!',!.-!*5.'%',!)"% %6&*!#!%'"-+"%#03-&*"5!',!-&*!!%'(&(!&'
)"% %6#"'";',(.'',!.-!* %(;%6',!#44!*!%&!$
F!'',!#44!*!%&!-5*"&'&"8"%#
!6"8-6%4&"%'E"#%!7!*,"#&(%-./!*-6('(',!)"% :-;!)-'!+).'%-'!"#&(!&'!#',!*
&*!#!%'"-#*!&'8$
$ (*!(7!*+"#4"-'(5*(5!*85*('!&'',!-!%-'7!(6%&*!#!%'"-'"&<.*!-$
"#/" !-5"*'""%##!&!5'7!*!5*!-!%'"'(%-'(&(%-./!*-',"'',!-(4';"*!',"'"&&!--!-',!
)"% .-!-1!%#'(!%#2!%&*85'(%+',!*!)8!%-.*%6',"'',!.-!*:-(6%&*!#!%'"-1;%!7!*
)!/"#!"&&!--)!2'(',!"*'&5"'%655$%*!"'8+"#:-/!',(#(4!%&*85'(%-4"*4*(/
G@@!)$ +
!-5(%-!)8"#'(:-(%-./!*"'"&&!--+
,''5-EHH5"#$&(/H#(&./!%'-H"#(%-./!*"'"&&!--!&,%&"(&8!-5(%-!$5#4+
"'