Arizona House of Representatives Committee on Regulatory Affairs Meeting Minutes - March 15, 2023

Summary

Minutes of the regular meeting of the Arizona House of Representatives Committee on Regulatory Affairs held Wednesday, March 15, 2023, during the Fifty-sixth Legislature, First Regular Session. The report lists the members present, including Representative Hendrix as Chairman and Representative McGarr as Vice-Chairman, and records committee action on SB1168, SB1333, SB1087 and SB1162, with SB1202 held. Attachments include the meeting agenda and a Request to Speak report listing members of the public registered in support of or opposition to SB1087 and SB1162, with their comments. The document also includes a bill summary for SB 1162 on home-based businesses and roll call vote sheets for SB 1162 and SB 1202.

Summary drafted by a model from the document's text below and checked by script against that text before publication. It is a navigation aid, not a reading of what the document proves. Where AI is used

Full text

ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
Fifty-sixth Legislature - First Regular Session

COMMITTEE ON REGULATORY AFFAIRS

Report of Regular Meeting
Wednesday, March 15, 2023
House Hearing Room 5 -- 2:00 P.M.

Conyened

2:48 P.M.

Recessed
Reconvened
Adjourned 4:12 P.M,

Members Present

Representative Bravo

Representative Gutierrez
Representative Hernandez
Representative Marshall

Representative Pefia

Representative McGarr, Vice-Chairman
Representative Hendrix, Chairman

Agenda
Original Agenda — Attachment 1

Request to Speak
Report — Attachment 2

Committee Attendance
Report — Attachment 3

Committee Action

Bill Action
SB1168 DP
SB1333. DP
SB1087. DP
SB1162 DP

SB1202 HELD

Vote Attachments
7-0-0-0 4,5
7-0-0-0 6,7

4-3-0-0 8, 9, 10
5-2-0-0 i 12

_ lala. i=

yberg, Committee Secretary
ech 17, 2023

(Original attachments on file in the Office of the Chief Clerk; video archives available at http://www.azleg.gov)

COMMITTEE ON REGULATORY AFFAIRS
March 15, 2023

INUTES RECEIVED
CHIBF CLERK'S OFFICE

3-1 23
REVISED #2- 3/14/23 REVISED #2- 3/14/23 REVISED #2- 3/14/23

ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Ca.
Fifty-sixth Legislature - First Regular Session OW Chee) PY SF, fur

REGULAR MEETING AGENDA Cfeurieeh Fed fo07

COMMITTEE ON REGULATORY AFFAIRS

DATE Wednesday, March 15, 2023 ROOM HHR5 TIME 2:00 P.M.

Members of the public may access a livestream of the meeting here:
https://Awww.azleg.gov/videoplayer/?clientID=6361162879&event]D=202303 1042

Members: Mecota V

Representative Bravo Representative Representative McGarr, Vice-Chairman
Representative Gutierrez Representative Pefia Representative Hendrix, Chairman
Representative Hernandez A

Bills Short Title Strike Everything Title

(3) SB1087 LD fp professional licensure fees; waiver; reduction
——_~——— (Kern: Wadsack)
RA, RULES
2

4 Z—Q
Y SB1162 LP | \? home-based businesses; restrictions; prohibition

——§—— (Kaiser: Farnsworth, Mesnard, et al)

P20. RULES

(DP SB1168 ip) Pp real estate appraisers; licensure classifications.
(Kaiser: Rogers, Shamp)

WZ Dea) Rar RULES

$B1202 banking; fees; licensing
Held (Kaiser)

RA, RULES

Ce) SB1333 y 4 database; health professionals; license revocations
(Shamp: Smith)

J etve prec Rs RULES

requirements
(Shamp)
RA,RULES

ORDER OF BILLS TO BE SET BY THE CHAIRMAN
RA

93/08/2023
03/14/2023

People with disabilities may request reasonable accommodations such as interpreters, alternative formats, or
assistance with physical accessibility. If you require accommodations, please contact the Chief Clerk's Office at
(602) 926-3032 or through Arizona Relay Service 7-1-1.

Page 1 of 1 Attachment _/
Information Registered on the Request to Speak System

House Regulatory Affairs (3/15/2023)

$B1087, professional licensure fees: waiver: reduction

Support:

Brandon LaBorde, representing self; Michael Meacham, representing self; Robert Glass, representing self;
Josephine Di Gennaro, representing self; Joseph Myers, representing self; Juli Webb, representing self; Carol
Stines, representing self; Lisa Gentry, representing self; Judith Swietlik, representing self; Thomas Burke,
representing self; Michael Mustard, representing self; Kathy Madsen, representing self; Theresa Breithaupt,
representing self

Oppose:

kathleen mayer, representing self; Dave Long, representing self; Steve Ramos, representing self; Gina Griffiths,
representing self; Judith Simons, representing self; Shirley Muney, representing self; Sandra Kravetz, representing
self; Steven Linder, representing self; Rebecca Smith Gross, representing self; Judith Robbins, representing self;
marilyn duerbeck, representing self; Maria Salvucci, representing self; Kevin Brown, representing self; Mary Ann
Graffagnino, representing self; Beatriz Urrea, representing self; Paul Benz, representing self; Sallie Kladnik,
representing self; Christina Mollica, representing self; Daria Lohman, representing self; Dianne Post, representing
self; Elizabeth Putnam-Hidalgo, representing self; Cynthia Couture, representing self; Sherrilynn James,
representing self; Donita Ramos, representing self; Ruthanna Battilana, representing self; William Parker,
representing self; Mary Grove, representing self; Helen Kim, representing self; Darrell Boomgaarden, representing
self; Kathryn Kaczmarek, representing self; Elizabeth Schauer, representing self; Elizabeth Goff, representing self;
Charlie Silver, representing self; Barbara Oliver, representing self; cathy rutherford, representing self; Ronald Eich,
representing self; Shirley Hervatin, representing self; Barbara Hutchinson, representing self; Christine Whitley,
representing self; Becky Sayler, representing self; Janet Hamlin, representing self; Brent Gibbs, representing self;
Robin LaVole, representing self; Julie Golding, representing self; Christine Keitges, representing self: Patricia
Mullenix, representing self; Jackie Rich, representing self; Beverlee Loat, representing self; Sharon Lee,
representing self; Stephanie Romero, representing self; Lawrence Peters, representing self; Linda Reichert,
representing self; Cynthia Lehigh, representing self; Linda Edwards, representing self; Kathy Fraser, representing
self; Kimberlee McClure, representing self; Mary Martiniak, representing self; Lucy Marshall, representing self;
Janet Senf, representing self; Kathy Pyner, representing self; Jocelyn Dustan, representing self; Marilyn Coyle,
representing self; Penny Boone, representing self; Ralph Meredith, representing self; Gayle Meredith, representing
self; Anne Leota Hart, representing self; Mary Santy, representing self; GARY LEW OLIVER, representing self;
Valerie Policastro Edie, representing self; Margaret Adams , representing self; Amy Etzkorn, representing self;
Marilyn Childs, representing self; Vickey Finger, representing self; Nancy Santori, representing self; Alicia Lucas,
representing self; Sue Thorne, representing self; Kathleen Martin, representing self; Katherine Martin,
representing self; Mary-Jeanne Fincher, representing self; Matthew Nelson, representing self; Gail Prestera,
representing self; Roxanna Kearns, representing self; Stephen Coyle, representing self; Jo Ann Caruthers,
representing self; Michael Pyska, representing self; Norman Fuchs, representing self; Steve Gorman-Hackstadt,
representing self; Dorothy Reed-Inman, representing self; Rebecca Haynes, representing self; Mary Nelson,
representing self; Teresa Neiberg, representing self; Caroline Anderson, representing self; Kelly Colvard-Walter,

Attachment@& |
representing self; Rosalind Wattel, representing self; Gary Rulapaugh, representing self; Ariana Flores,
representing self; Emily Norton, representing self; Dale Cohen-Bruno, representing self; Margaret Owen,
representing self; John Propster, representing self; Charlotte Lis, representing self; William Yohey, representing
self; Michael Weingarten, representing self; Elizabeth Brauer, representing self; Margaret Bruns, representing self;
Robert Fisher, representing self; Alice Patricia Price, representing self; Carol Garnett, representing self; Jennifer
Dawson, representing self; Linda Guarino, representing self; Patricia Edelen, representing self; Linda Block,
representing self; Mariann Leahy, representing self; Paula Van Derven, representing self; Diane Klock, representing
self; Allison Jackson, representing self; ALICE BUCK, representing self; Loretta O'Connor, representing self; Claudia
Oreck-Teplitsky, representing self; Cynthia Wagner, representing self; Nancy Hancock, representing self; Claire
Bickel, representing self; Barbara Swenson, representing self; Nelson Morgan, representing self; Catherine Hopkins,
representing self; Karen Robbins, representing self; Linda Cooke, representing self; Christine McLachlan-Comer,
representing self; Carol Campbell, representing self; Lisa Maczura, representing self; Nicole Fordey, representing
self; Karolyn Switzer, representing self; Linda Paul, representing self; Jacqueline deSa, representing self; Julian
Donahue, representing self; Katharine Donahue, representing self; Sarah Bihms LD29, representing self; Nataly
Reed, representing self; Evan Deaubl, representing self; Rebecca Shook, representing self; George Ehrlich,
representing self; Sharon Ehrlich, representing self; Angela Buer, representing self; Gary Townsend, representing
self; Marilyn Murov, representing self; Margaret Tinsley, representing self; Connie Cockrell, representing seif;
Jerrold Borchardt, representing self; Melanie Howe , representing self; William Bowlus-Root, representing self;
Thomas Dunning, representing self; Sheila Green, representing self; Jerry Wegenast, representing self; Patricia
Brunner, representing self; Rivko Knox, representing self; Kathleen Sauer, representing self; STACEY NORDWALL,
representing self; Sally Caruso, representing self; Judy Wegenast, representing self; Eric Kadel, representing self;
Marcia Tingley, representing self; Frederick James, representing self; David Myers, representing self; Eric Harris,
representing self; Kathleen Butler, representing self; marcia stewart, representing self; Carmen Terrell,
representing self; Don Howard, representing self; Nancy Lecrone Nonini, representing self; Abigail Hlavacek,
representing self; Devon Sloan, representing self; Barbara Jones, representing self; Brenda Parker, representing
self; jeff green, representing self; Teresa Gerschutz, representing self; Gabe Leadley, representing self; Nora
Plonsky, representing self; Christian Trujillo Cruz, representing self; RITA DEPUYDT, representing self; Lisa Koenig,
representing self; Charlene Campbell, representing self; Joyce Howard, representing self; Roger Blain, representing
self; Joan Patrick, representing self; Jill Anderson, representing self; Suzette Taillac-Streit, representing self; Lora
Lida Walradt, representing self; Beth Ballmann, representing self; Mitchell Smith, representing self; Shelley
Stephenson, representing self; Lois Hansen, representing self; Janie Smieszek, representing self; Janis Newton,
representing self; Shirley Isaacson, representing self; Valarie Bryant, representing self; Erlinda Bates, representing
self; Cheryl Stafford, representing self; Peggy Church, representing self

All Comments:

Brandon LaBorde, Self: commonsense budgeting with the taxpayer in mind, rather than the bureaucracy; Joseph
Myers, Self: | believe the purpose of the amended language is to provide an “open book" disclosure of a
department's finances. These are department's funded by the state's taxpayers. Stronger accountability for usage
of funds; Carol Stines, Self: It makes sense to provide a savings to people when there is an overage; kathleen mayer,
Self: another bad policy pushed by deregulation fanatics; Judith Simons, Self: Please pay attention to the
consequences of deregulation that have caused such damage in just the past few weeks, from railroads to banks.
Learn the lesson: regulation serves a useful purpose which profit doesn’t eliminate the need for.; Mary Ann
Graffagnino, Self: Plain and simpie, this bill would harm public safety and state finances; Beatriz Urrea, Self: This is
yet another r deregulation measure that will harm public safety and state finances..; Paul Benz, Self: No legislation
FBO Koch Bros and the Scam Goldwater institute Reject/Veto this one Paul Benz pbenz54@gmail.com; Elizabeth
Putnam-Hidalgo, Self: High bank balances have no coincidence with honesty! Stop deregulation!; Kathryn
Kaczmarek, Self: State regulatory boards and agencies protect AZ citizens. This bill appears to attempt to tie the
hands of these agencies. Not good for AZ.; Lawrence Peters, Self: How does this bill better the lives of daily
Arizonans. Gives another financial break to corporations and delivers a hit to the state coffers. Unduly influenced
by lobbyists.; Cynthia Lehigh, Self: Strong NO; Kathy Pyner, Self: This is a good method to regulate professional
licenses. Eliminate fraud.; Penny Boone, Self: Motivated by lobbyists Az Republican lawmakers are routinely
sponsoring deregulation measures that would harm public safety and state finances as this bill would. ! oppose.;
Anne Leota Hart, Self: Bank deregulation isn't working out so well in California right now. We need common sense
regulation and this isn't it.; Sue Thorne, Self: We need to strengthen regulation of banks that hold our money.
Reestablish the Frank Dodd laws that were put in place after the great Recession in 2008 to keep financial sector
from high risk gambling with our money!INO; Mary-Jeanne Fincher, Self: Stop the attack on licensing boards and
regulators - they are protecting the public and are necessaryl; Rebecca Haynes, Self: Another deregulation effort
that would harm public safety and state finances.; Mary Nelson, Self: More socialism for the wealthy; Margaret
Owen, Self: This sounds like some sort of a deregulation measure that would harm public finances, and, by
extension, harm public safety. Big NO.; John Propster, Self: Sounds like one of them ALEC bills. We see what you're
doing. Vote NAY!; Elizabeth Brauer, Self: 1 am completely opposed to bank regulation. That is a terrible idea. In
fact, we need to increase bank regulation, give the two recent bank failures. Do your Job and protect the tax paying
public from risky business practices.; Jennifer Dawson, Self: ABSOLUTELY NOT. Sponsored by the Koch bros. and
the Goldwater Institute. Deregulation measures that would harm public safety and state finances.; Patricia Edelen,
Self: Deregulation of fees for the rich - no thanks.; Cynthia Wagner, Self: would harm public safety and state
finances; Catherine Hopkins, Self: Bill does nothing to protect us. Bill will hurt citizens. Try to come up with a bill to
help Arizonan‘s not hurt them; Lisa Maczura, Self: Oh brother, reatly?; Karolyn Switzer, Self: There's no good
reason why a license should cost more or less depending on the bank balance of the regulatory agency.; Katharine
Donahue, Self: And what would that balance be? And what about planning ahead, adjusting priorities, planning for
the future. if these companies need licenses, then they should pay and it has nothing to do with the agency that
collects it.; Sarah Bihms LD29, Self: This bill waives or reduces license fees if bank balance hits limit. Republican
lawmakers sponsor deregulation despite risk to public safety and state finances, urged by Goldwater Institute and
Koch-funded Americans for Prosperity. Vote no.; Gary Townsend, Self: Banks need to be even more strictly
regulated, not less.; Marilyn Murov, Self: This bill has potential to harm public safety and it decreases revenue for
the state. i benefited greatly from the AZ Board of Physical Therapy as did my patients due to training and rules
provided by this board. | was happy to pay my license fees.; Margaret Tinsley, Self: This is a bad idea for Arizona.
Please vote no; Thomas Dunning, Self: Are the sponsors of this bill insane? Do they not remember the Great
Recession, when BANKS aimost broke the entire United States? Banks can be the worst of bad-faith actors. Who
may be behind this bill? Not the people. Banks.; Rivko Knox, Self: Part of a nationwide movement toward
deregulation that will harm public safety & state finances.; Eric Kadel, Self: If this Silicon Bank failure doesn't make
you want more regulation then your living under a rock.; marcia stewart, Self: this is a harm to our state's finances
and has no real value to it.; Teresa Gerschutz, Self: This extreme bill would harm public safety and state finances,
OPPOSE.; Lora Lida Walradt, Self: Dangerous bill that will hurt ordinary citizens. Two banks have recently failed
thanks to banking deregulation. The billionaires are NOT the ones impacted, workers ARE.; Beth Ballmann, Self:
Especially in light of recent events with Silicon Valley Bank, this is not the time to be reducing bank management
accountability.; Lois Hansen, Self: this type of deregulation measure would harm public safety and state finances.;
Shirley Isaacson, Self: i am an Az. registered citizen; Cheryl Stafford, Self: This is an unnecessary deregulation
measures that would harm public safety and state finances.
$B1162, home-based businesses: restrictions; prohibition

Testified in support:
Jenna Bentley, BARRY GOLDWATER INSTITUTE FOR PUBLIC POLICY RESEARCH; Dennis J Legere, ARIZONA
HOMEOWNERS COALITION; Luis Acosta, Goldwater Institue

Testified as opposed:

Jeff Speliman, representing self; Jacob Emnett, COUNTY SUPERVISORS ASSN OF AZ; Kate Bauer, representing self;
Larisa Balderrama, representing self; david mason, representing self; Sandra Scanlan, representing self; Tom
Savage, LEAGUE OF ARIZONA CITIES & TOWNS; Susan Edwards, representing self; Tom Dorn, City Of Phoenix

Support:

Allison Stein, representing self; Eric Crump, representing self; Cynthia Finnegan, representing self; Susanne Wright,
representing self; Charles McCorkle, representing self; Shirley Dye, representing self; Dwight Kadar, representing
self; Andrea Kadar, representing self; Jere Fredenburgh, representing self; Rose Sperry, representing self; Lou
Sniderman, representing self; Cathy Schwanke, representing self; Bill Blewster, representing self; Barbara Blewster,
representing self; Dennis Genge, representing self; Jennifer Wellsman, representing self; Nancy Hawkins,
representing self; Aimee Yentes, AZ FREE ENTERPRISE CLUB; Janelle Solomon, representing self; David Schafranka,
representing self; Susan Leeper, representing self; David Riley, representing self; Mark Logan, representing self;
Paul Fitch, representing self; Dan Goebel, representing self; Michael Schroeder, representing self; Teddi Thompson,
representing self; Michael Infanzon, NORTH PHOENIX CHAMBER OF COMMERCE; Theresa Logan, representing self;
Charles McCain, representing self; Michael Meacham, representing self; Rachel Bauer, representing self; Deanna
Schreckler, representing self; Stephen Harris, representing self; Corinne Haynes, representing self; Buffalo Rick
Galeener, representing self; Ute Edge, representing self; Bill Edge, representing self; Steve Hetsler, representing
self; Robert Puckett, representing self; Anita Bruner, representing self; Robert Glass, representing self; Hilton C.
Harrison, representing self; Charles Schinke, representing self; Maryclare Abatecola, representing self; Pam
Anderson, representing self; Charles Mackey, representing self; Tom Booth, representing self; Ruth Foelber,
representing self; Debbie Joy, representing self; DEBRA SCHINKE, representing self; Nikki Colletti, representing
self; Dianna Gates, representing self; Carole Challoner, representing self; Darla Gonzalez, representing self; Gary
Saxhaug, representing self; Claribeth Davis, representing self; Randy Brown, representing self; Sydney Brown,
representing self; Kim Miller, representing self; James McFadzean, representing self; Jana Relble, representing
self; Lori Huff, representing self; Linda Barnes, representing self; Pam Lauck, representing self; Brenda Marts,
representing self; April Smith, representing self; Jean Ferguson, representing self; M Macek, representing self;
Tamara Holley, representing self; Josephine Di Gennaro, representing self; Stacy Shepard, representing self; Joseph
Myers, representing self; Richard Burke, representing self; Vicki Smith, representing self; John Tanzi, representing
self; Mary Ann Johnston, representing self; Mary Kay Ruwette, representing self; Vickie Parks, representing self;
Susan Kelly, representing self; Philip Bryson, representing self; Catherine Tunget, representing self; Cherie Anello,
representing self; Peter Anello, representing self; Ed O'Brien, representing self; Amy Ross, representing self; Matt
Davidson, representing self; Tim Johnson, representing self; Shawn Smith, representing self; Brynlee Smith,
representing self; Braeden Smith, representing self; Brooklyn Smith, representing self; Susan Sigl, representing self;
Ruth Denny, representing self; Kathy DuFresne, representing self; A B, representing self; Gary DeBerge,
representing self; Cynthia Newswander, representing self; Janet Wilson, representing self; Joe Fiumara,
representing self; Nathan Moss, representing self; Nancy Osgood, representing self; Sandra Lowery, representing
self; Pam Reinke, representing self; Louie Caparelli, representing self; Mozelle Ault, representing self; Kristin
Baumgartner, representing self; Kristi Macdonald, representing self; Stan Howard, representing self; Thaya Howard,
representing self; Joyce Mansur, representing self; Marcella Cronenberg, representing self; Starr Costa,
representing self; Sallie Orbas, representing self; Daryl Lassen, representing self; Harold DarcAngelo, representing
self; Brent Meadows, representing self; Mary Evelyn Simpson, representing self; Janet Klepacz, representing self;
christopher klepacz, representing self; Mark Stevens, representing self; Dale Brewer, representing self; Indy
Rebhun, representing self; Jeff Specter, representing self; Nancy Durband, representing self; Henry Ganster,
representing self; Denise Lockwood, representing self; Sue Harrison, representing self; Kelly Walterscheid,
representing self; Patricia Cipro, representing self; Marc Monterey, representing self; Donna Booth, representing
self; Lana O'Brien, representing self; Sandra Carlson, representing self; Doris Hinton, representing self; Janet
Manecke, representing self; Laurie Johnson, representing self; Elizabeth Olmstead, representing self; Dan Goebel,
representing self; Karen Sherrell, representing self; Debbie Russo, representing self; Jane Evans, representing self;
Roy Scott Lassell, representing self; Jeanine Gouveia, representing self; Raymond Darragh, representing self; John
Matthews, representing self; Lynda Patrick-Hayes, representing self; Catherine Day, representing self; Darlene Jung,
representing self; David Fountain, representing self; Ann Starr, representing self; Jessica O'Connor, representing
self; Judy Alonzo, representing self; Bob Alonzo, representing self; Richard Freeze, representing self; Marcia Sahag,
representing self; Susan Gavigan, representing self; Patricia Moore, representing self; Janice Rimer, representing
self; K Caillier, representing self; Paul Johnson, representing self; Wendy Radimer, representing self; Wanda Lund,
representing self; Joyce Haver, representing self; Mary Jamsa, representing self; Cheri Raimonde, representing self;
Susan Whittemore, representing self; Susan Kay, representing self; eileen acosta, representing self; Charles
Moffett, representing self; Elizabeth Piccolo, representing self; Chris Russo, representing self; Sue Norton-Scoit,
representing self; Ken Wolfe, representing self; Nancy Thornes, representing self; George Duffield, representing
self; Teresa Schrader, representing self; Wayne Throw, representing self; Jim Jensen, representing self; Sady Flynn,
representing self; Doyle Taraba, representing self; John Reed, representing self; Marie Scillieri, representing self;
Patricia Keitel, representing self; Joelene Williamson, representing self; James Ault, representing self; Cynthia Starr,
representing self; Laura Belcourt, representing self; Gary Zimmerman, representing self; C Dupree, representing
self; Pam Throw, representing self; Christine Stoner, representing self; Margaret Barnes, representing self; Julie
Harrod, representing self; Ted Burwell, representing self; Bonnie Lund, representing self; Judith Swietlik,
representing self; Gisela Aaron, representing self; Teresa Tere Nunez, representing self; Michael Aaron,
representing self; Theresa Breithaupt, representing self; Barton Anderson, representing self; Daniel Spencer,
representing self; Lois Dold, representing self; Jerri Dingledine, representing self; Susan Garvey, representing self;
Joel Gleason, representing self; Ron Brooks, representing self; Patricia Phillips, representing self; Judy Ponto,
representing self; Wendy Jonessee, representing self; Sharon Lang Merdovic, representing self; deana corsa,
representing self; Barb Hinderland, representing self; kare hetrick, representing self; Lee Chadbourn, representing
self; Kay Bateman, representing self; Paul Marriott, representing self; Jennifer Marriott, representing self; Sue
VanRiper, representing self; Jeannette Bovert, representing self; Kathryn Farkas, representing self; Merl Nielsen,
representing self; brenda simon, representing self; Douglas Simon, representing self; E Seeley, representing self;
LW Forster, representing self; Gaye Champine, representing self; KAREN VOLLIS, representing self; Lisa Gentry,
representing self; Sherry Proctor, representing self; Dan Gleason, representing self; louise liggett, representing self;
Nancy Barrett, representing self; Doug Stewart, representing self; Shay Cardell, representing self; Darrin Bergstad,
representing self; Tambra Herbert, representing self; Paul Thompson, representing self; john shepard, representing
self; Carol Utecht, representing self; Beth Pojman, representing self; Irene Lavor, representing self

Neutral:
Donald Koeppen, representing self

Oppose:
Nathan Barrett, representing self; Karen Kruse, CITY OF WINSLOW, TOWN OF SAHUARITA; Judy Reid, representing
self; Judy Wegenast, representing self; larry berger, representing self; William Hunter, representing self; Scott

Grzybowski, representing self; Counilwoman Sharron Grzybowski, representing self; Tina Gomez, representing self;
Julie Catlett, representing self; Dana Jolly, representing self; Adam Newberg, representing self; Karen Begier,
representing self; Jason Elliott, representing self; Dominique Contreras, representing self; Michelle Perkins,
representing self; Maureen Sheldon, representing self; John Sheldon, representing self; Ann Bommersbach,
representing self; William Yohey, representing self; Alexis Apodaca, CHANDLER, CITY OF; maureen mason,
representing self; Liz Barker Alvarez, AVONDALE, CITY OF; Stacia Erkenbrack, representing self

All Comments:

Dennis J Legere, ARIZONA HOMEOWNERS COALITION: This is a sound well constructed bill that protects
communities as well as enabling the safe and non-intrusive development of home based businesses.; Cynthia
Finnegan, Self: Reduce regulations; Shirley Dye, Self: With the increases in internet provision there are many folks
that can do business from home. Their own business or working for an employer. Restrictions on traffic, sound,
etc, and maybe a city/town license should make this a good deal.; Jere Fredenburgh, Self: BUILD small family
owned businesses! it is what this country was built on.; Cathy Schwanke, Self: Working from home has shown to
work well so let's encourage productivity and freedom.,; Bill Blewster, Self: Let's reduce government regulations,
especially on small businesses.; Barbara Blewster, Self: Reducing regulations on private businesses is necessary.;
Dennis Genge, Self: Absolutely. Give small businesses a fighting chance; Jennifer Wellsman, Self: A good idea; Dan
Goebel, Self: Registered voter and grandparent, please support this Bill.; Stephen Harris, Self: Reducing undue
regulation of home businesses by municipalities and counties is a good thing.; Maryclare Abatecola, Self: I'ma
business owner, registered voter, an active PC.; Charles Mackey, Self: Support this bill for those home-based
businesses that do not generate odor, noise, on-street parking or cause a substantial increase in traffic in the
residential neighborhood. Low impact home businesses help our economy.; Darla Gonzalez, Self: I'm PC in
Chandler, I'm a business owner, and support businesses!; Gary Saxhaug, Self: Reducing undue regulation of home
businesses by municipalities and counties is a good thing.; Randy Brown, Self: Stop government overreach with
trying to contro! "no impact" activities. Get the government's nose out of our business.; Sydney Brown, Self: We
need to get the government’s nose out of our business.; Linda Barnes, Self: | support reducing regulations on
home-based businesses.; Pam Lauck, Self: TO much regulations is not good. This should lessen that!; April Smith,
Self: | am a PC in Mesa, Please protect home based businesses; Philip Bryson, Self: | am an elected PC in Pima
County LD18 precinct 262; Nancy Osgood, Self: As a PC in LD12 | support this bill.; Kristin Baumgartner, Self: 'ma
PC captain and | support this bill.; Daryl Lassen, Self: Keep the capitalistic incentives going. Stop socialism!; Harold
DarcAngelo, Self: LD15 PC; Mary Evelyn Simpson, Self: YAVGOP PC, We should not discourage or discriminate
against folks who want to work at home in unintrusive business models.; Mark Stevens, Self: Reducing undue
regulation of home businesses by municipalities and counties is a good thing.; Dale Brewer, Self: ! am a concerned
Precinct committeeman, and a former business owner.; Jeff Spellman, Self: Home-based businesses exist today in
every community in this state. Cities and towns are successfully balancing the needs of property owners who
want to run a home-based business. There is no need for this legislation.; Kate Bauer, Self: Where is evidence of
the problem that merits this Bill?; Larisa Balderrama, Self: Neighborhoods area against this. Cities and towns have
existing rules and laws on the books that govern this well today. This bill would override all of that. There are no
issues existing with cities today that poses a need for this.; Elizabeth Olmstead, Self: | am a PC in Navajo County
and i support this bill; Dan Goebel, Self: Registered voter and grandparent hoping you support this Bill.; Karen
Sherrell, Self: This is a well written bill for No Impact Home Businesses, we need to help budding, small business
owners as much as we can.; Debbie Russo, Self: Home based businesses should not be taxed out of existence. They
should be allowed to thrive.; Jane Evans, Self: Millions of us have home based businesses. | am a PC and Member
at Large and strongly support this bill.; Judy Reid, Self: | oppose the bill; Roy Scott Lassell, Self: | fully support. We
need less government involvement in our businesses.; Lynda Patrick-Hayes, Self: 1 think all types of businesses
should be supported.; Catherine Day, Self: Stop taking freedom to thrive away; David Fountain, Self: | support this
Bill LD9, SD4; Paul Johnson, Self: | am a precinct Captain and | am in favor of this bill; Wendy Radimer, Self: | ama
Precinct Co-Captain and | agree with this Bill; Wanda Lund, Self: Thank you; Joyce Haver, Self: please support this
bill...; Mary Jamsa, Self: This bill in the long run helps to strengthen the growth of the Arizona economy . | support
this bill.; Donald Koeppen, Self: Please strengthen the wording for support of restrictions in homeowners
associations; Susan Whittemore, Self: | am a precinct committeeman. | represent 175 voters on this Issue.; Susan
Kay, Self: Republican, LD3; eileen acosta, Self: | support $B1162; Elizabeth Piccolo, Self: Support an Act Amending
Section 32-3248.01, Arizona Revised Statutes; Relating to Controlled Substances .; Chris Russo, Self: I'm a PC from
PV. Home based businesses should not be punished by excessive taxes. It seems people who contribute the least
to society get the most benefits from it. It's time for this to change. Give a break to those who give the most, their
alll; Sue Norton-Scott, Self: Let's do this for everyone with a home based business. Makes sense.; Sady Flynn, Self:
REAL ESTATE AGENT and ESTATE COMMITMENT; Doyle Taraba, Self: Pc; Joelene Williamson, Self: | support this bill
because many of the small businesses started out as home businesses and the state shouldn't stand in the way of
starting a small business.; Gary Zimmerman, Self: Reduces undue regulation of home businesses.; Julie Harrod,
Self: Pro home-based business, less regulation, smart regulation; William Hunter, Self: Don't stomp on residents‘
rights to the quiet enjoyment of their home in a non-commercial neighborhood. Commerce belongs in commercial
areas. Residents deserve quiet, safe, residential neighborhoods; Daniel Spencer, Self: encourage home-based
businesses; Patricia Phillips, Self: Precinct Committeeman, Coconino County State Committeeman, Small business
owner. Reduce red tape by providing clear, concise small business requirements. Some small businesses started as
home businesses.; Counilwoman Sharron Grzybowski, Self: People that live in a residential area move there
thinking that it is just that. This bill makes it hard for people to determine what their moving in to. “no impact"
business is subjective, it and the increased traffic are difficult to enforce; Judy Ponio, Self: | am. PINAL COUNTY PC,
it's important to make govt accountable. Thank u for what u dol; Sharon Lang Merdovic, Self: This bill makes
better sense and keeps up with the times, especially post Covid.; deana corsa, Self: It is good to get a more defined
explanation of home businesses, Deana Corsa PC; david mason, Self: What problem merit this sweeping, “no
regulation” solution that means "anything anywhere"? Who Benefits from this Bill? Redefining local zoning
decisions denies communittes and residents the benefit of local zoning decisions and regulations.; Tina Gomez,
Seif: Here we go again! HB 2333 did not pass in 2018 and PAID legislators continue to push legislation through the
system with the intention of diminishing the integrity and character of neighborhoods. This bill is detrimental to

residential communities.; Julie Catlett, Self: Businesses need to stay in areas zoned for businesses. Please keep our ’

neighborhoods safe for families. Businesses generate more traffic, distracted drivers, and Increase risks to children,
properties, and pets.; Kathryn Farkas, Self: Small business took a big hit with government overreach during COVID.
This should help!; LW Forster, Self: Please support our small businesses wherever they are!; KAREN VOLLIS, Self:
allow no-impact home-based businesses; Michelle Perkins, Self: Should be MORE regulation,not less. We have this
& it causes blight, congestion & HUGE safety issues. Degrades areas, values & deters people who want to move
to/improve areas. Decreases community, ups crime. Those w/ business aggressive to neighbors,; Maureen Sheldon,
Self: There should be MORE regulation, not less. We have this in our area & it causes blight, congestion & HUGE
safety issues--this degrades property values and deters people who want to move to and improve the area. It
decreases community, increases crime; John Sheldon, Self: Businesses in neighborhoods w/ no regulation leads to
degradation of neighborhoods, especially w/o enforcement (dealing w/ this in ours now)-leads to safety issues,
congestion & lack of community. Have junk cars all over street & blight b/c of this.; Sandra Scanian, Self: ll!
conceived idea. Internet and Zoom has replaced home businesses. Protect AZ neighborhoods.; Susan Edwards,
Self: Trying to completely destroy the safety and character of Arizona's neighborhoods? The 500,000 AZ families
already next to short-term rentals, with strangers coming and going, can now have a tattoo parlor open next door.
How's that child-friendly?; Nancy Barrett, Self: America was created by people with a spirit of owning their own
businesses. We need to support bills that prohibit restrictions; maureen mason, Self: SB 1162 is too problematic,
too radical, many glaring inconsistencies: does not justify a sweeping “no regulation” that allows “anything,
anywhere”. damages property rights of residents and communities. damages public safety.; john shepard, Self: I'm
a PC and support this bill. Keep the bureaucrats out of home based businesses.; Carol Utecht, Self: =Support this
bill C) Utecht; Luis Acosta, Goldwater Institue: N/A; Stacia Erkenbrack, Self: We've already seen the demise of
neighborhoods & loss of communities with $B1350. $B1162 is the same bad legislation. Local government is
better for residents & can better appropriate balance of community standards within our local nelghborhoods.

$B1168, real estate appraisers: licensure classifications.

Support:
Stephen Briggs, AZ DEPT OF INSURANCE AND FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS

$B1202, banking; fees; licensing

Support:

Lisa Gentry, representing self

$B1333, database; health professionals; license revocations
Support:

Lisa Gentry, representing self; Kathy Madsen, representing self; Theresa Breithaupt, representing self
ARIZONA STATE LEGISLATURE
Fifty-sixth Legislature - First Regular Session

COMMITTEE ATTENDANCE RECORD

COMMITTEE ON REGULATORY AFFAIRS
CHAIRMAN: Laurin Hendrix VICE-CHAIRMAN: Cory McGarr
DATE 03/15/23 (23 /23 123 123
CONVENED 2.48 pm m m m m
RECESSED
RECONVENED
ADJOURNED he pun
MEMBERS
Bravo wa
Gutierrez Va
Hernandez A /
Marshall i
Pefia Vl
McGarr, Vice-Chairman uw“
Hendrix, Chairman “

V Present --- Absent exc Excused

Attachment 4

ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

Fifty-sixth Legislature

First Regular Session

Senate: COM DP 6-0-1-0 | 3rd Read 29-0-1-0

DE Ea iin ESAS NESSES TEE Od SAT TET oe TT TTT ey
SB 1168: real estate appraisers; licensure classifications.

Sponsor: Senator Kaiser, LD 2
Committee on Regulatory Affairs

Overview
Permits state-licensed real estate appraisers to conduct the appraisal of complex residential units
under $400,000.

History

The Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions (DIFI) licenses and authorizes the
transactions of insurance-related entities and regulates state-chartered financial entities such as
money transmitters, motor vehicle dealers and real estate appraisal entities (JLBC FY2023
Baseline Book — Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions).

The Appraisal Qualifications Board (the Board) sets universal standards adopted by DIFI for
minimum criteria necessary to either be certified, licensed, or registered as a real estate appraiser.
(A.R.S. § 32-3605). The Board standards for a state-licensed real estate appraiser are as follows:

1) Must complete the Board licensed residential real property appraiser examination;

2) Must complete 150 credit class hours under the Board required core curriculum; and

3) Have 1,000 hours of qualifying experience in no fewer than 6 months.

Associated fees for state-licensed real estate appraisers are composed of new application and
national registry fees of $400.00 and $80.00. For license renewal, there is a biennial renewal and

national registry fee of $425.00 and $80.00 (Department of Insurance and Financial institutions).

According to DIFI, there is a total of 170 active state-licensed real estate appraisers in Arizona.

in 2019, the Federal Government issued the Appraisal Rule, which required federally related real
estate transactions valued at more than $400,000 to require a state-certified appraiser. For
transactions under that threshold, an evaluation of real property collateral is required instead
(C.F.R. 12-3B-323).

Complex one to four residential units are properties that are considered atypical for the
marketplace considering factors such as: 1) architectural style; 2) age of improvements; 3) size
of improvements; 4) size of lot; 5) neighborhood land use; 6) potential environmental hazard
liability; 7) leasehold interest; and 8) limited readily available comparable sales or other unusual

factors (A.R.S. § 32-3601).

Provisions
1. Expands the vaiue threshold that state-licensed real estate appraisers can appraise complex
one to four residential units from $250,000 to $400,000. (Sec. 1)

2. Makes a technical change. (Sec. 1)

01 Prop 105 (45 votes) C) Prop 108 (40 votes) OO Emergency (40 votes) [1 Fiscal Note

SB 1168
Initials DC Page 1 Regulatory Affairs

Attachment S
ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
Fifty-sixth Legislature - First Regular Session

ROLL CALL VOTE

COMMITTEE ON Regulatory Affairs BILLNO. SB 1168

DATE March 15, 2023 MOTION: Pr

PASS AYE NAY PRESENT | ABSENT

Bravo

Gutierrez

Hernandez A

Payne \\yysnal\

Pefia

McGarr, Vice-Chairman

Hendrix, Chairman

NIA AIAIARA INA

QO 1s a,

A

APPROVED: 77 COMMITTER/SECRETARY

“7 AURIN HENDRIX; Chairman
CORY MCGARR, Vice-Chairman

a
ATTACHMENT. call

ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

Fifty-sixth Legislature
First Regular Session
Senate: HHS 6-0-1-0 | 28-1-1-0
SSN TNT NTE ET RTT ER EE TT
$B1333: database; health professionals; license revocations

Sponsor: Senator Shamp, LD 29

Committee on Regulatory Affairs

Overview

By July 1, 2024, requires the Department of Health Services (DHS) to create and maintain on its
website an online searchable database containing pertinent information regarding health
professionals who have had a professional license or certification revoked in the preceding five
years,

History
A health profession regulatory board is any board in Arizona that regulates one or more health

professions. A health professional is a person who is licensed or certified in podiatry,
chiropractics, dentistry, medicine and surgery, naturopathic medicine, nursing, dispensing
opticians, optometry, osteopathic physicians and surgeons, pharmacy, board of physical therapy,
psychologists, veterinarians, physician assistants, radiologic technologists, homeopathic
physicians, behavioral health physicians, occupational therapy, respiratory care, acupuncture,
athletic trainers and massage therapy (A.R.S. 32-3201.) A health professional also includes
nursing care institution administrators, assisted living facilities managers, practitioners in
midwifery, hearing aid dispensers, audiologists and speech pathologists (A.R.S. Title 36.)

When a formal complaint against a licensed or certified individual is filed with the appropriate
regulatory entity, that entity gathers pertinent information, investigates and decides the case
outcome on each complaint. Based on the facts at hand for each complaint, an individual's license
or certification may be suspended or revoked if unprofessional conduct or other violations are
substantiated.

Provisions
1. Requires each health profession regulatory board to report to DHS the following:
a) the revocation of licenses or certifications; and
b) all revocations of licenses and certifications for the five years beginning July 1, 2019 to
July 1, 2024. (Sec. 1)

2. Prescribes, by July 1, 2024, that information be included in an online searchable database
that is available on the DHS website as follows:
a) names of health professionals who have had a license or certification revoked during the
preceding five years;
b) date of the revocation; and
c) names of health profession regulatory boards that revoked the license or certification.
(Sec. 1)

3. Instructs DHS to inform all health profession regulatory boards of the information that must be
reported to DHS for inclusion in the database. (Sec. 1)

4. Defines health profession regulatory board and health professional, (Sec. 1)

Ct Prop 105 (45 votes) O Prop 108 (40 votes) 0 Emergency (40 votes) 1 Fiscal Note

SB 1333
Initials DC Page 1 Regulatory Affairs

Attachment o
ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
Fifty-sixth Legislature - First Regular Session

COMMITTEE ON

ROLL CALL VOTE

Regulatory Affairs

DATE March 15, 2023

BILLNO. $B 1333

MOTION: DY

PASS

AYE NAY

PRESENT

ABSENT

Bravo

Gutierrez

Hernandez A

Payne. (Varena\\

Pefia

McGarr, Vice-Chairman

Hendrix, Chairman

APPROVED:

Ze? _ Zon

AENDRIX, Chaitman
CORY MCGARR, Vice-Chairman

NAYAINAAARKY

CC

Oo

Lo

Y, OMMITTEE ETARY
“

ATTACHMENT. VA

ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

Fifty-sixth Legislature
First Regular Session
Senate: COM DP 5-0-2-0 | 34 Read 16-14-0-0

SB 1087: professional licensure fees; waiver; reduction
Sponsor: Senator Kern, LD 27
Committee on Regulatory Affairs

Overview
Requires a regulatory board or agency (regulatory entity) to waive or reduce its license or
certification fees when its licensing fund exceeds 50% of its appropriation for the same fiscal year.

History
Arizona's professions and occupations are regulated by boards and commissions charged with

protecting the health, welfare and safety of its citizens through licensing, certification and
registration. Title 32 contains the laws related to the various professions and occupations, while
Title 36 comprises public health and safety laws. The statutes are generally divided into three
categories as follows:
1) Article 7 - establishes the regulatory entity, membership qualifications, powers, duties and
responsibilities;
2) Article 2— prescribes the training and education requirements to qualify for licensure; and
3) Article 3- outlines disciplinary and non-disciplinary actions the regulatory entity may take
to enforce standards of practice, such as continuing education, letter of censure, license
suspension or license revocation.

In general, an agency cannot charge or receive a fee without specific statutory authority (A.R.S.
§ 41-1008.) Regulatory entities are funded by user fees and most are 90/10 entities, since 90%
of revenue is retained by the regulatory entity and the remaining 10% is transferred to the state
General Fund.

Provisions

1. Requires, by September 1 each year, the regulatory entity to review pertinent fees and costs
to determine if its year-end licensing fund balance will exceed 50% of its current fiscal year
appropriation. Items for review include monies in the fund, incurred costs and collected fee
revenues. (Sec. 2)

2. Outlines the procedures the regulatory entity should follow if the ending balance in the
licensing fund exceeds 50% of its appropriation as follows:

a) requires a one-time fee waiver or reduction in license or certificate renewal fees for the
upcoming fiscal year or within the normal renewal cycle if longer than one year, to reduce
the licensing fund balance to below the 50% appropriation amount;

b) in determining the amount of waiver or reduction, directs the regulatory entity to ensure
existing licensees or certificate holders receive one waiver or reduction and that fees for
new licensees or certificate holders are waived or reduced the next fiscal year;

c) requires the regulatory entity to attempt to reduce fees the same for initial and renewal
licenses and certificates;

C1 Prop 105 (45 votes) C1 Prop 108 (40 votes) OO Emergency (40 votes) OD Fiscal Note

SB 1087
Initials DC Page 14 Reaulatory Affairs

Attachment &
d) allows a temporary reduction or waiver of initial or renewal license or certification fees;
and

e) by July 1 each fiscal year, outlines notification to existing licensees and certificate holders
of an intention to reduce or waive license fees along with the expected amount, which
must be prominently noted on the regulatory entity's website. (Sec. 2)

3. Instructs each regulatory entity to report its fee plan by September 1 annually, to the Governor,
President of the Senate and Speaker of the House of Representatives. (Sec. 2)

4. Lists the minimum requirements a report of fee plan must include as follows:
a) the amount of revenues and expenditures expected in the current fiscal year;
b) the projected ending balances for the licensing fund; and
c) the justification for how the regulatory entity's waiver or reduction plan will achieve required
fee reductions. (Sec. 2)

5. Allows a regulatory entity that believes it will require one-time monies greater than 50% of its
annual appropriation for one-time capital, information technology or similar costs to include a
report of the expected need in its budget estimate submission to the Governor. (Sec. 2)

6. Applies the provisions to chapters of law that regulate professions and occupations as follows:

State Board of Technical Registration (Title 32, Ch. 1)
Barbering and Cosmetology Board (covers two chapters of law — Title 32, Ch. 3, 5)
Arizona State Board of Accountancy (Title 32, Ch. 6)
Board of Podiatry Examiners (Title 32, Ch. 7)
Board of Chiropractic Examiners (Title 32, Ch. 8)
Registrar of Contractors (Title 32, Ch. 10)
State Board of Dental Examiners (Title 32, Ch. 11)
State Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers (Title 32, Ch. 12)
Arizona Medical Board (also Physician Assistants — Title 32, Ch. 13, 25)
Naturopathic Physicians Medical Board (Title 32, Ch.14)
State Board of Nursing (Title 32, Ch. 15)
State Board of Dispensing Opticians (Title 32, Ch. 15.1)
. State Board of Optometry (Title 32, Ch. 16)
AZ Board of Osteopathic Examiners in Medicine and Surgery (Title 32, Ch. 17)
Arizona State Board of Pharmacy (Title 32, Ch. 18)
Board of Physical Therapy (Title 32, Ch. 19)
State Board of Psychologist Examiners (Title 32, Ch. 19.1)
Arizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board (Title 32, Ch. 27)
Board of Homeopathic and Integrated Medicine Examiners (Title 32, Ch. 29)
State Board for Private Postsecondary Education (Title 32, Ch. 30)
Board of Behavioral Health Examiners (Title 32, Ch. 33)
Board of Occupational Therapy Examiners (Title 32, Ch. 34)
Board of Respiratory Care Examiners (Title 32, Ch. 35)
Acupuncture Board of Examiners (Title 32, Ch. 39)
Board of Athletic Training (Title 32, Ch. 47)
Board of Massage Therapy (Title 32, Ch. 42)
. Board of Examiners Nursing Care Institution Administrators and Assisted Living Facility
Managers (Title 36, Ch. 4, Art. 6) (Sec. 2)

7. Makes a conforming change. (Sec. 1)

NS X ERE ™MHRAQDOSR MST SQ OQ OSH

>
»

SB 1087
lnitials DC Page 2 Regulatory Affairs
ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
Fifty-sixth Legislature - First Regular Session

ROLL CALL VOTE
COMMITTEE ON Regulatory Affairs BILL NO. SB 1087
DATE March 15, 2023 MOTION: LY
PASS AYE NAY PRESENT | ABSENT
Bravo a
Gutierrez —
Hernandez A “a
Payne: (Y\yrsha)\ i
Pefia ae
McGarr, Vice-Chairman ae
Hendrix, Chairman “a
JF | 2 OC? LD
pe Lye
APPROVED: VA COMMITTEE SECRETARY
Ao “LAY RIN HENDRIX, Chairman
MCGARR, Vice-Chairman
ch
ATTACHMENT__/
Regulatory Boards FY 2023 Budget Information

Excess Balance

FY 2023 Fund FY 2023 % of FY 2023 Above 50% of
Chapter * Agency Name Balance Appropriation Appropriation Anpropriation
7.32, Ch.1 State Board of Technical Registration $ 6,832,100 $ 2,641,000 259% $ 5,571,600
_____ 1.32, Ch.3 and $ Barbering and Cosmetology Board $ 1,623,700 S$ 2,864,800 57% §$ 191,300
_ T.32, Ch.6 Arizona State Board of Accountancy $ 2,336,100 $ 2,236,600 104% $ 1,217,800
: 7.32, Ch.7 Board of Podiatry Examiners $ 208,000 $ 185,800 112% $ 115,100
7.32, Ch.8 Board of Chiropractic Examiners $ 724,300 $ 488,700 148% $ 479,950
_ 1.32, Ch.10 Registrar of Contractors $ (943,500) $ 13,754,600 7% § .
7.32, Ch.11 State Boarcl of Dental Examiners $ 1,976,000 $ 1,937,500 102% $ 1,007,250
T.32, Ch.12 State Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers $ 845,600 $ 494,800 171% $ 598,200
1.32, Ch.13 and 25 Arizona Medical Board $ 10,826,900 $ 8,291,700 131% § 6,681,050
____7.32, Ch.14 Naturopathic Physicians Medical Board $ 2,143,100 $ 212,000 1011% $ 2,037,100
7 7.32, Ch.15 State Board of Nursing $ 13,833,700 $ 5,885,000 235% $ 10,891,200
7.32, Ch,15.1 State Board of Dispensing Opticians $ 350,000 $ 193,100 181% $ 253,450
_. 1.32, Ch.16 State Board of Optometry $ $50,200 $ 298,800 184% $ 400,800
Arizona Board of Osteopathic Examiners in Medicine and
7.32, Ch.17 Surgery $ 3,237,700 $ 41,384,500 234% $ 2,545,450
. ¥.32, Ch.18 Arizona State Board of Pharmacy $ 10,360,600 $ 3,537,000 293% $ 8,592,100
7.32, Ch.19 Board of Physical Therapy $ 1,679,300 $ 630,900 266% $ 1,363,850
7.32, Ch.19.1 State Board of Psychologist Examiners $ 2,273,900 $ 650,500 350% $ 1,948,650
_ 7.32, Ch.21 Arizona State Veterinary Medical Exami ting Board S 2,551,500 $ 770,500 331% $ 2,166,250
Board of Homeopathic and Integrated Medicine
_ T.32, Ch.29 Examiners 7 $ 47,300 $ $1,900 91% $ 21,350
7.32, Ch.30 State Board for Private Postsecondary Education 5 123,700 $ 453,800 27% $ -
T.32, Ch.33 Board of Behavioral Health Examiners 5 5,413,300 $ 2,179,700 248% $ 4,323,450
7.32, Ch,34 Board of Occupational Therapy Examiners $ 1,092,000 $ 266,400 410% $ 958,800
7,32, Ch.35 Board of Respiratory Care Examiners $ 306,600 $ 406,800 75% $ 103,200
1.32, Ch.39 Acupuncture Board of Examiners $ 8,900 $ 196,800 5% $ ;
; 7.32, Ch.41 Board of Athletic Training $ 290,300 $ 157,300 185% $ 211,650
1.32, Ch.42 Board of Massage Therapy $ 1,248,200 $ 603,800 207% $ 946,300
Board of Examiners Nursing Care Institution
Administrators and Assisted Living Facility
136, Ch,4, Art.6 Managers $ 272,300 $ 627,400 43% $

Total Revenue of Boards and Agencies Exceeding 50% of Appropriation...............

GF Reduction Share.......

Peete ares ee tenenee ees etehinteseeaeas tereeececers

*- Note: 29 referenced parts of statute, but only 27 agencies. This is because
Physician Assistants are under the Medical Board, and the Barbering and
Cosmetology Board cavers two chapters.

Methodolugy reflects IRC Hscal note on 482267 (2021).

Leeeten ees eeeaeenececuseueenarsenaaueeeerees peeeetneeeees $ $2,565,850

Sead

5,840,650

SN
ww
c
iP)
&
<=
o
£
<
ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

Fifty-sixth Legislature
First Regular Session

SB 1162: home-based businesses; restrictions; prohibition
Sponsor: Senator Kaiser, LD 2
Committee on Regulatory Affairs

Overview

Establishes that a home-based business must be allowed as a use by right, if the business does
not supersede any existing restrictions. Authorizes a municipality or county to establish
reasonable regulations on home-based businesses.

History

A municipality or county may not restrict or regulate a license holding owner of a home-based
business from: 1) making residential property improvements to add doors, shelving or display
racks for use by the business; 2) displaying a temporary commercial sign during business hours;
3) selling or offering for sale any goods; 4) generating traffic, parking or delivery activity that does
not cause parking congestion or a substantial increase in traffic in the residential area; or 5) having
more than one client on the property at once. Furthermore, a home-based business may employ
residents of the primary dwelling and immediate family members, as well as 1-2 employees who
are not residents or immediate family members.

Currently, the owner of a home-based business must hold a valid ficense, as defined in statute.
Additionally, a home-based business means any business for the limited manufacture, provision
or sale of goods or services that is owned and operated by the owner or tenant of the residential
property.

Finally, statute authorizes a county to impose reasonable operating requirements on a home-
based business or a residential property used by a home-based business (A.R.S. § 11-820).

Provisions

1. States that a home-based business is allowed as a use by right if it does not supersede any
deed restrictions, covenants or land use agreement, master deed or other document that
applies to a common interest ownership community. (Sec. 4, 2)

2. Restricts a municipality or county from prohibiting a no-impact home-based business or

requiring a person to obtain a permit, license or prior municipal approval to operate. (Sec. 1,

2)

3. Permits a municipality or county to establish reasonable regulations on a home-based
business within the confines of:

a. protecting the public health and safety, including the current regulations pertaining to fire
and building codes, health, sanitation, transportation or traffic control, solid or hazardous
waste, pollution and noise control;

b. limiting or prohibiting the use for purposes of maintaining a structured sober living home,
selling illegal drugs or liquor, pornography, obscenity, nude or topless dancing or other
adult oriented businesses; and

C1 Prop 105 (45 votes) C0 Prop 108 (40 votes) OO Emergency (40 votes) 1 Fiscal Note

SB 1162
Initials Page 1 Reaulatory Affairs

Attachment / /

c. ensuring the business activity is compatible with the residential property use, secondary
to its use as a residential dwelling and that it complies with state and federal laws, as well
as applicable taxes. (Sec. 1, 2)

4. Prohibits a municipality or county, as a condition for a person to operate a home-based
business, to do any of the following:
a. apply to rezone the property for commercial use;
b. obtain a home-based or other business license; or
c. install fire sprinklers in a residential dwelling with one or two dwelling units. (Sec. 1, 2)

5. Stipulates that whether a city or county regulation complies with the statutory provisions is a
judicial question and the regulatory entity must establish by clear and convincing evidence
that the provision complies with state law. (Sec. 1, 2)

Removes the requirement for a home-based business to obtain a license. (Sec. 2)
7. Revises the county restrictions and regulations for home-based businesses. (Sec. 2)

. Defines goods, home-based business, immediate family member and no-impact home-based
business. (Sec. 1, 2)

9. Makes a conforming change. (Sec. 2)

SB 1162
Initials Page 2 Regulatory Affairs
ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
Fifty-sixth Legislature - First Regular Session

ROLL CALL VOTE
COMMITTEE ON Regulatory Affairs BILL NO. SB 1162
DATE March 15, 2023 MOTION: if?
PASS AYE NAY PRESENT | ABSENT

Bravo i

Gutierrez aA

Hernandez A —

Payre MNarehal| a

Pefia a ;

McGarr, Vice-Chairman a

Hendrix, Chairman “a

Sa |e | co

APPROVED:
Lg LoD

~~“ CABRIN-TENDRIX, Chairman
CORY MCGARR, Vice-Chairman

COMMITT

+

ECRETARY

ATTACHMENT. JR

ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
Fifty-sixth Legislature - First Regular Session

ROLL CALL VOTE
COMMITTEE ON Regulatory Affairs BILLNO. — $B 4202
DATE March 15, 2023 MOTION: _ “2 fe

PASS AYE NAY PRESENT | ABSENT

Bravo

Gutierrez

Hernandez A

Payre- Marshall

Pefia

McGarr, Vice-Chairman

Hendrix, Chairman

APPROVED: WA COMMITYES’ SECRETARY

LAURIN HENDRIX, Chairman
CORY MCGARR, Vice-Chairman

ATTACHMENT. /3

File and source

File

2023-03-15_regulatory-affairs-minutes.pdf

Size

1,474,382 bytes

SHA-256

0c86eec38e665ef28fbc96f3c63250cc1300df0b942ef69986c2b7cb6d44d4a8

Our copy

2023-03-15_regulatory-affairs-minutes.pdf

Original

www.azleg.gov