Court filing
Exhibit 10 — In re Carvana Securities
Filed April 27, 2026 in In re Carvana Co Securities Litigation; one of 27 filings from this case.
Record facts
| Court | U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona |
|---|---|
| Filed | 2026-04-27 |
U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona · No. 2:22-cv-02126-MTL · Doc. 364-10 · 2026-04-27 · Docket on CourtListener
Full text
EXHIBIT 10
[Redacted]
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 1 of 28
4908-4400-7833.v1
Chicago
Melville
Nashville
San Diego
Wilmington
Boca Raton
Manhattan
Philadelphia
San Francisco
Washington, D.C.
655 West Broadway, Suite 1900 San Diego, CA 92101 Tel 619-231-1058 Fax 619-231-7423 rgrdlaw.com
Mathew Andrews
mandrews@rgrdlaw.com
March 18, 2026
Christian Word
LATHAM & WATKINS LLP
330 North Wabash Avenue, Suite 2800
Chicago, IL 60611
christian.word@lw.com
Re:
In re Carvana Co. Securities Litigation,
No. CV-22-2126-PHX-MTL (D. Ariz.)
Dear Christian:
We write to follow up on our March 17, 2026 meet and confer (the “March 17 call”)
concerning (i) the significant deficiencies in the Carvana Defendants’ February 12, 2026 “Categorical
Privilege Log,” February 27, 2026 “Second Amended Categorical Privilege Log,” February 27, 2026
Amended February 12 Categorical Privilege Log (with Author), March 3, 2026 “Third Amended
February Privilege Log,” March 3, 2026 “Second Amended February 12 2026 Privilege Log,” March
17, 2026 “2026.03.17 Consolidated Amended Carvana Defendants Privilege Log,” and second March
17, 2026 “2026.03.17 Consolidated Amended Carvana Defendants Privilege Log” (collectively, the
“Privilege Logs” or “Logs”); (ii) Plaintiffs’ February 21, 2026 letter; (iii) the Carvana Defendants’
March 4, 2026 letter; (iv) Plaintiffs’ March 13, 2026 correspondence; and (v) the Carvana
Defendants’ March 16, 2026 letter.
First, during the March 17 call, the parties discussed what you described as a “vendor issue.”
The Carvana Defendants first raised this “vendor issue” during our March 12, 2026 call but did not
elaborate on what transpired. During the March 17 call, you explained that Latham and Watkins
(“Latham”) contracted a vendor (the “Vendor”) to review communications for potential privilege,
including communications between Carvana custodians and third parties. The Vendor sent Latham
third-party communications that the Vendor designated as privileged (the “Initial Incorrect
Designations”). Latham then reviewed some portion of the Initial Incorrect Designations and found
that many of the Vendor’s determinations were incorrect. Latham then instructed the Vendor to re-
review the entirety of the communications between the Carvana custodians and third parties.
However, Latham did not supply the Vendor with a complete list of third parties for its re-review for
an unexplained reason. As a result, the Vendor did not correct its privilege designations for an
unspecified number of documents. Thereafter, the Vendor sent incorrectly-designated
communications to Latham again for withholding (the “Second Incorrect Designations”). Although
Latham was aware that the Vendor had previously incorrectly designated communications between
Carvana custodians and third parties as privileged, Latham did not conduct a full review of the Second
Incorrect Designations. Instead, Latham conducted a review of only an unspecified portion of the
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 2 of 28
Christian Word
March 18, 2026
Page 2
4908-4400-7833.v1
materials. As a result, an unknown number of incorrectly-withheld communications were added to
the Logs. You did not specify whether you learned of these incorrectly-withheld documents before
or after Plaintiffs sent their February 21, 2026 letter, which identified numerous substantial
deficiencies in the Logs, including the improper withholding of communications with third parties.
In addition, you confirmed that the Carvana Defendants are still working on identifying the
documents that were improperly withheld because of the “vendor issue” and the total number of
documents affected by this error.
Second, Plaintiffs asked why materials other than those involved in the “vendor issue” have
been incorrectly withheld. For instance, you stated during our March 12 call that
and
were erroneously withheld but did not know why because you were “putting out the
fire right now” and “haven’t investigated the cause.” You similarly stated during our March 17 call
that you do not know why these documents were improperly withheld.
Third, Plaintiffs reiterated their request that the Carvana Defendants identify the Bates
numbers for any incorrectly-withheld documents. As discussed during the March 17 call, Plaintiffs
cannot easily identify these documents because the Carvana Defendants have comingled these
incorrectly-withheld materials with other documents in productions. For instance, several recent
production letters state that “[s]ome” of the documents in the productions include documents later
determined not to privileged (see, e.g., N. Salazar 03-13-26 Letters to Plaintiffs re Productions 39-
42), but the productions also include documents produced pursuant to, for example, the terms
compelled by the Court’s February 2, 2026 order. ECF 298. Ultimately, the Carvana Defendants
agreed to identify the Bates numbers of any incorrectly-withheld documents that it has already
produced and confirmed that it would not comingle these documents with other materials in its future
productions.
Fourth, we discussed that the Logs still do not appear to have any attorney listed in the to,
from, or cc fields for a substantial number of
and
documents. Plaintiffs raised
this issue in our February 21, 2026 letter and during our March 10, 2026 call, and later provided you
with representative examples. See M. Andrews 03-10-26 email.1 During the March 10 call, Carvana
Defendants agreed to identify the relevant attorney for all such communications. Thereafter, during
our March 17 call, you stated that you did not believe that any
or
documents
were missing attorneys in the to, from, or cc fields with regard to the privilege log furnished on March
17, 2026. However, based on our analysis, there still appear to be over 3,000 such instances. See,
e.g., PLOG00072642, PLOG00072634, PLOG00072633. We have compiled a list of any documents
1
Plaintiffs note that you subsequently removed these three examples from the Logs, presumably because these
documents were improperly withheld.
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 3 of 28
Christian Word
March 18, 2026
Page 3
4908-4400-7833.v1
labeled as
or
that are missing an asterisk or plus sign (your denotations for an
attorney or an individual
in the to, from, or cc field.
See Ex. A.
Fifth, we discussed your withholding of documents involving an individual
During our March 10 call, you stated that these non-lawyers worked
with the legal department but also had other non-legal, business roles during the time periods in which
their communications are included on the Logs. During our March 17 call, you further stated that
these individuals were engaging in “all types” of law-adjacent activities – from collecting information
to assisting in providing legal advice. In addition, you compared these individuals to Plaintiffs’
investigators. Plaintiffs, however, have taken the position that their investigators’ work is protected
by the work product doctrine – a claim that the Carvana Defendants did not make (nor could they).
Lastly, please note that the latest March 17, 2026 privilege log fails to identify the Bates
numbers for many entries which are labeled
See, e.g., PLOG00020875,
PLOG00044997, PLOG00046221. Accordingly, please provide the Bates numbers for all entries
designated
immediately.
We look forward to continuing our meet and confer with you on Friday, March 20, 2026.
Best regards,
/s/ Mathew Andrews
MATHEW ANDREWS
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 4 of 28
1
4910-9861-5193.v1
EXHIBIT A
PLOG00004293
PLOG00004294
PLOG00004615
PLOG00005022
PLOG00005078
PLOG00005616
PLOG00005626
PLOG00005627
PLOG00006053
PLOG00006061
PLOG00006062
PLOG00006063
PLOG00006064
PLOG00006065
PLOG00006193
PLOG00006259
PLOG00006260
PLOG00010024
PLOG00010148
PLOG00010276
PLOG00010277
PLOG00010281
PLOG00010282
PLOG00010564
PLOG00010592
PLOG00010686
PLOG00010687
PLOG00010720
PLOG00010721
PLOG00010727
PLOG00010731
PLOG00010764
PLOG00010768
PLOG00010890
PLOG00010897
PLOG00011012
PLOG00011013
PLOG00011016
PLOG00011083
PLOG00011161
PLOG00011192
PLOG00011215
PLOG00011220
PLOG00011496
PLOG00011609
PLOG00011802
PLOG00012140
PLOG00012358
PLOG00012359
PLOG00012368
PLOG00012488
PLOG00012753
PLOG00012759
PLOG00012762
PLOG00012808
PLOG00012821
PLOG00012943
PLOG00012953
PLOG00012976
PLOG00012984
PLOG00012988
PLOG00013013
PLOG00013014
PLOG00013026
PLOG00013041
PLOG00013043
PLOG00013044
PLOG00013111
PLOG00013220
PLOG00013291
PLOG00013292
PLOG00013296
PLOG00013304
PLOG00013305
PLOG00013306
PLOG00013456
PLOG00013457
PLOG00013463
PLOG00013720
PLOG00013734
PLOG00013755
PLOG00013840
PLOG00014041
PLOG00014203
PLOG00014220
PLOG00014371
PLOG00014390
PLOG00014391
PLOG00014407
PLOG00014464
PLOG00014465
PLOG00014491
PLOG00014500
PLOG00014545
PLOG00014655
PLOG00014805
PLOG00014806
PLOG00014807
PLOG00014817
PLOG00014818
PLOG00015074
PLOG00015075
PLOG00015078
PLOG00015096
PLOG00015097
PLOG00015098
PLOG00015099
PLOG00015100
PLOG00015101
PLOG00015102
PLOG00015103
PLOG00015154
PLOG00015165
PLOG00015166
PLOG00015167
PLOG00015168
PLOG00015404
PLOG00029269
PLOG00029323
PLOG00031596
PLOG00031654
PLOG00031655
PLOG00031656
PLOG00043741
PLOG00043756
PLOG00044963
PLOG00046024
PLOG00047014
PLOG00047145
PLOG00049252
PLOG00049336
PLOG00051204
PLOG00051219
PLOG00053121
PLOG00053171
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 5 of 28
2
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00053935
PLOG00054019
PLOG00054041
PLOG00054055
PLOG00054058
PLOG00054853
PLOG00054877
PLOG00054878
PLOG00054961
PLOG00054976
PLOG00054987
PLOG00056245
PLOG00057036
PLOG00067006
PLOG00067007
PLOG00067010
PLOG00067011
PLOG00067019
PLOG00067024
PLOG00067025
PLOG00067026
PLOG00067072
PLOG00067364
PLOG00067374
PLOG00067375
PLOG00067376
PLOG00067377
PLOG00067378
PLOG00067379
PLOG00067380
PLOG00067381
PLOG00067382
PLOG00067383
PLOG00067384
PLOG00067385
PLOG00067386
PLOG00067387
PLOG00067388
PLOG00067405
PLOG00067407
PLOG00067408
PLOG00067412
PLOG00067422
PLOG00067430
PLOG00067431
PLOG00067432
PLOG00067434
PLOG00067514
PLOG00067515
PLOG00067518
PLOG00067525
PLOG00067526
PLOG00067532
PLOG00067533
PLOG00067551
PLOG00067568
PLOG00067569
PLOG00067570
PLOG00067571
PLOG00067576
PLOG00067577
PLOG00067578
PLOG00067579
PLOG00067580
PLOG00006497
PLOG00006550
PLOG00006654
PLOG00006846
PLOG00007132
PLOG00007146
PLOG00007147
PLOG00007148
PLOG00007257
PLOG00007349
PLOG00007397
PLOG00013524
PLOG00014650
PLOG00014651
PLOG00015348
PLOG00015759
PLOG00015859
PLOG00015950
PLOG00015951
PLOG00015973
PLOG00015985
PLOG00015986
PLOG00015987
PLOG00016007
PLOG00016243
PLOG00016249
PLOG00016255
PLOG00016580
PLOG00016759
PLOG00016760
PLOG00016824
PLOG00016932
PLOG00016969
PLOG00017037
PLOG00017202
PLOG00017205
PLOG00017297
PLOG00017298
PLOG00017417
PLOG00017432
PLOG00017489
PLOG00017507
PLOG00017540
PLOG00017637
PLOG00017669
PLOG00017671
PLOG00017673
PLOG00017674
PLOG00017676
PLOG00017752
PLOG00017756
PLOG00017758
PLOG00017849
PLOG00017889
PLOG00017983
PLOG00018067
PLOG00018074
PLOG00018088
PLOG00018098
PLOG00018173
PLOG00018187
PLOG00018190
PLOG00018210
PLOG00018211
PLOG00018258
PLOG00018265
PLOG00018267
PLOG00018268
PLOG00018269
PLOG00018300
PLOG00018314
PLOG00018349
PLOG00018506
PLOG00018509
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 6 of 28
3
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00018520
PLOG00018539
PLOG00018540
PLOG00018551
PLOG00018583
PLOG00018615
PLOG00018616
PLOG00018638
PLOG00018644
PLOG00018645
PLOG00018646
PLOG00018659
PLOG00018667
PLOG00018672
PLOG00018697
PLOG00018700
PLOG00018702
PLOG00018735
PLOG00018750
PLOG00018775
PLOG00018873
PLOG00018908
PLOG00019006
PLOG00019013
PLOG00019014
PLOG00019022
PLOG00019029
PLOG00019033
PLOG00019048
PLOG00019061
PLOG00019074
PLOG00019082
PLOG00019083
PLOG00019084
PLOG00019087
PLOG00019098
PLOG00019124
PLOG00019145
PLOG00019161
PLOG00019237
PLOG00019259
PLOG00019262
PLOG00019269
PLOG00019285
PLOG00019286
PLOG00019325
PLOG00019340
PLOG00019351
PLOG00019425
PLOG00019430
PLOG00019431
PLOG00019455
PLOG00019523
PLOG00019549
PLOG00019811
PLOG00019878
PLOG00019976
PLOG00020078
PLOG00020133
PLOG00020136
PLOG00020204
PLOG00020272
PLOG00020345
PLOG00020356
PLOG00020704
PLOG00020717
PLOG00020719
PLOG00020723
PLOG00020803
PLOG00020849
PLOG00020853
PLOG00020858
PLOG00020870
PLOG00020896
PLOG00020903
PLOG00020907
PLOG00020922
PLOG00020923
PLOG00020949
PLOG00020977
PLOG00020995
PLOG00021019
PLOG00021235
PLOG00021437
PLOG00021969
PLOG00022068
PLOG00022091
PLOG00022311
PLOG00022328
PLOG00022687
PLOG00022897
PLOG00022898
PLOG00022899
PLOG00022900
PLOG00022901
PLOG00022902
PLOG00022903
PLOG00022904
PLOG00022905
PLOG00027043
PLOG00027044
PLOG00027051
PLOG00027114
PLOG00027152
PLOG00029874
PLOG00033096
PLOG00033332
PLOG00034126
PLOG00037848
PLOG00038021
PLOG00041303
PLOG00043277
PLOG00061513
PLOG00061514
PLOG00063302
PLOG00063724
PLOG00067618
PLOG00067636
PLOG00067639
PLOG00067689
PLOG00067696
PLOG00067901
PLOG00067940
PLOG00067944
PLOG00068017
PLOG00068019
PLOG00068023
PLOG00068100
PLOG00068115
PLOG00068116
PLOG00068206
PLOG00068207
PLOG00068208
PLOG00068209
PLOG00068210
PLOG00068211
PLOG00068212
PLOG00068213
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 7 of 28
4
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00068222
PLOG00068254
PLOG00068318
PLOG00068331
PLOG00068332
PLOG00068333
PLOG00068334
PLOG00068338
PLOG00068339
PLOG00068526
PLOG00068551
PLOG00068652
PLOG00068674
PLOG00068675
PLOG00068682
PLOG00068683
PLOG00068700
PLOG00068728
PLOG00068736
PLOG00068749
PLOG00068768
PLOG00068773
PLOG00068906
PLOG00068917
PLOG00068923
PLOG00068932
PLOG00068934
PLOG00068935
PLOG00068953
PLOG00068973
PLOG00068974
PLOG00068975
PLOG00068981
PLOG00069017
PLOG00069018
PLOG00069022
PLOG00069024
PLOG00069025
PLOG00069027
PLOG00069031
PLOG00069040
PLOG00069041
PLOG00069055
PLOG00069056
PLOG00069061
PLOG00069084
PLOG00069093
PLOG00069107
PLOG00069128
PLOG00069131
PLOG00069143
PLOG00069158
PLOG00069167
PLOG00069170
PLOG00069171
PLOG00069172
PLOG00069173
PLOG00069208
PLOG00069212
PLOG00069218
PLOG00069287
PLOG00069295
PLOG00069332
PLOG00069333
PLOG00069425
PLOG00069436
PLOG00069450
PLOG00069452
PLOG00069453
PLOG00069467
PLOG00069482
PLOG00069502
PLOG00069559
PLOG00069571
PLOG00069604
PLOG00069678
PLOG00069688
PLOG00069716
PLOG00069740
PLOG00069752
PLOG00069793
PLOG00069816
PLOG00069843
PLOG00069845
PLOG00069848
PLOG00069960
PLOG00070036
PLOG00070037
PLOG00070040
PLOG00070043
PLOG00070068
PLOG00070075
PLOG00070077
PLOG00070147
PLOG00007491
PLOG00007498
PLOG00007901
PLOG00007958
PLOG00007971
PLOG00007972
PLOG00007973
PLOG00007974
PLOG00007975
PLOG00007976
PLOG00007977
PLOG00007995
PLOG00008002
PLOG00008212
PLOG00008228
PLOG00008282
PLOG00008324
PLOG00008330
PLOG00008331
PLOG00008368
PLOG00008371
PLOG00008389
PLOG00008395
PLOG00008440
PLOG00008441
PLOG00008464
PLOG00008468
PLOG00008511
PLOG00008535
PLOG00008556
PLOG00008563
PLOG00008564
PLOG00008570
PLOG00008580
PLOG00008594
PLOG00008599
PLOG00008718
PLOG00008740
PLOG00008840
PLOG00008864
PLOG00008866
PLOG00008870
PLOG00008887
PLOG00010014
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 8 of 28
5
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00010015
PLOG00012950
PLOG00012992
PLOG00013098
PLOG00013136
PLOG00013151
PLOG00013378
PLOG00013395
PLOG00013473
PLOG00015408
PLOG00015889
PLOG00016128
PLOG00016799
PLOG00019090
PLOG00019318
PLOG00019567
PLOG00019982
PLOG00020630
PLOG00020633
PLOG00022645
PLOG00022908
PLOG00023006
PLOG00023043
PLOG00023162
PLOG00023165
PLOG00023166
PLOG00023279
PLOG00023287
PLOG00023305
PLOG00023306
PLOG00023312
PLOG00023535
PLOG00023542
PLOG00023545
PLOG00023698
PLOG00023699
PLOG00023706
PLOG00023707
PLOG00023708
PLOG00023775
PLOG00023779
PLOG00023846
PLOG00023945
PLOG00023947
PLOG00023953
PLOG00023980
PLOG00023981
PLOG00023982
PLOG00023997
PLOG00024000
PLOG00024008
PLOG00024014
PLOG00024015
PLOG00024083
PLOG00024084
PLOG00024100
PLOG00024101
PLOG00024106
PLOG00024109
PLOG00024162
PLOG00024165
PLOG00024168
PLOG00024169
PLOG00024170
PLOG00024171
PLOG00024190
PLOG00024191
PLOG00024193
PLOG00024194
PLOG00024241
PLOG00024294
PLOG00024317
PLOG00024321
PLOG00024367
PLOG00024368
PLOG00024369
PLOG00024370
PLOG00024371
PLOG00024372
PLOG00024373
PLOG00024375
PLOG00024376
PLOG00024377
PLOG00024380
PLOG00024381
PLOG00024382
PLOG00024383
PLOG00024385
PLOG00024394
PLOG00024399
PLOG00024403
PLOG00024416
PLOG00024419
PLOG00024420
PLOG00024422
PLOG00024423
PLOG00024434
PLOG00024437
PLOG00024446
PLOG00024448
PLOG00024450
PLOG00024463
PLOG00024467
PLOG00024468
PLOG00024470
PLOG00024503
PLOG00024505
PLOG00024537
PLOG00024555
PLOG00024557
PLOG00024558
PLOG00024563
PLOG00024574
PLOG00024577
PLOG00024612
PLOG00024618
PLOG00024621
PLOG00024631
PLOG00024655
PLOG00024656
PLOG00024695
PLOG00024739
PLOG00024746
PLOG00024748
PLOG00024832
PLOG00024910
PLOG00024912
PLOG00024943
PLOG00024944
PLOG00024993
PLOG00025000
PLOG00025003
PLOG00025005
PLOG00025008
PLOG00025009
PLOG00025020
PLOG00025040
PLOG00025041
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 9 of 28
6
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00025042
PLOG00025043
PLOG00025048
PLOG00025049
PLOG00025062
PLOG00025064
PLOG00025065
PLOG00025066
PLOG00025076
PLOG00025078
PLOG00025157
PLOG00025211
PLOG00025238
PLOG00025241
PLOG00025245
PLOG00025256
PLOG00025265
PLOG00025318
PLOG00025319
PLOG00025356
PLOG00025390
PLOG00025391
PLOG00025392
PLOG00025393
PLOG00025394
PLOG00025395
PLOG00025396
PLOG00025550
PLOG00025553
PLOG00025556
PLOG00025557
PLOG00025586
PLOG00025593
PLOG00025605
PLOG00025606
PLOG00025686
PLOG00025696
PLOG00025699
PLOG00025708
PLOG00025763
PLOG00025785
PLOG00025870
PLOG00025883
PLOG00025886
PLOG00025903
PLOG00025905
PLOG00025906
PLOG00026091
PLOG00026104
PLOG00026116
PLOG00026125
PLOG00026147
PLOG00026170
PLOG00026208
PLOG00026323
PLOG00026329
PLOG00026398
PLOG00026411
PLOG00026430
PLOG00026431
PLOG00026659
PLOG00026660
PLOG00026668
PLOG00026696
PLOG00026731
PLOG00026732
PLOG00026734
PLOG00026749
PLOG00026770
PLOG00026771
PLOG00026774
PLOG00026775
PLOG00026781
PLOG00026792
PLOG00026793
PLOG00026796
PLOG00026797
PLOG00026799
PLOG00026800
PLOG00026838
PLOG00026840
PLOG00026844
PLOG00026845
PLOG00026846
PLOG00026847
PLOG00026848
PLOG00026867
PLOG00026868
PLOG00026916
PLOG00026920
PLOG00026952
PLOG00026953
PLOG00026961
PLOG00027042
PLOG00027045
PLOG00027167
PLOG00027356
PLOG00027384
PLOG00027423
PLOG00027511
PLOG00027512
PLOG00027517
PLOG00027619
PLOG00027699
PLOG00027700
PLOG00027702
PLOG00027703
PLOG00027712
PLOG00027713
PLOG00027731
PLOG00027752
PLOG00027760
PLOG00027761
PLOG00027789
PLOG00027790
PLOG00027791
PLOG00027792
PLOG00027793
PLOG00027794
PLOG00027819
PLOG00027825
PLOG00027826
PLOG00027833
PLOG00027835
PLOG00027836
PLOG00027853
PLOG00027855
PLOG00027856
PLOG00027858
PLOG00027861
PLOG00027862
PLOG00027959
PLOG00028315
PLOG00028442
PLOG00028445
PLOG00028496
PLOG00028497
PLOG00028498
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 10 of 28
7
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00028572
PLOG00028573
PLOG00028575
PLOG00028591
PLOG00028805
PLOG00028961
PLOG00029021
PLOG00029032
PLOG00029154
PLOG00029182
PLOG00029183
PLOG00029190
PLOG00029193
PLOG00029195
PLOG00029197
PLOG00029256
PLOG00029267
PLOG00029466
PLOG00029483
PLOG00029485
PLOG00029491
PLOG00029495
PLOG00029501
PLOG00029503
PLOG00029509
PLOG00029513
PLOG00029521
PLOG00029526
PLOG00029527
PLOG00029529
PLOG00029583
PLOG00029707
PLOG00029708
PLOG00029710
PLOG00029736
PLOG00029743
PLOG00030045
PLOG00030099
PLOG00030113
PLOG00030131
PLOG00030162
PLOG00030163
PLOG00030202
PLOG00030243
PLOG00030273
PLOG00030274
PLOG00030275
PLOG00030276
PLOG00030321
PLOG00030322
PLOG00030324
PLOG00030325
PLOG00030326
PLOG00030403
PLOG00030542
PLOG00030551
PLOG00030586
PLOG00030596
PLOG00030645
PLOG00030650
PLOG00030697
PLOG00030770
PLOG00030798
PLOG00030805
PLOG00030842
PLOG00030860
PLOG00030913
PLOG00030923
PLOG00030941
PLOG00031034
PLOG00031037
PLOG00031039
PLOG00031044
PLOG00031046
PLOG00031050
PLOG00031108
PLOG00031169
PLOG00031265
PLOG00031347
PLOG00031427
PLOG00031444
PLOG00031566
PLOG00031586
PLOG00031657
PLOG00031659
PLOG00031668
PLOG00031717
PLOG00031873
PLOG00031874
PLOG00031875
PLOG00031926
PLOG00032056
PLOG00032161
PLOG00032165
PLOG00032166
PLOG00032167
PLOG00032410
PLOG00032498
PLOG00032500
PLOG00032520
PLOG00032547
PLOG00032550
PLOG00032577
PLOG00032607
PLOG00032648
PLOG00032658
PLOG00032660
PLOG00032661
PLOG00032844
PLOG00032945
PLOG00032997
PLOG00033002
PLOG00033026
PLOG00033131
PLOG00033151
PLOG00033171
PLOG00033187
PLOG00033188
PLOG00033215
PLOG00033293
PLOG00033294
PLOG00033296
PLOG00033314
PLOG00033440
PLOG00033476
PLOG00033495
PLOG00033496
PLOG00033633
PLOG00033767
PLOG00033773
PLOG00033796
PLOG00033867
PLOG00033910
PLOG00033917
PLOG00033926
PLOG00033927
PLOG00033940
PLOG00033967
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 11 of 28
8
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00033968
PLOG00033974
PLOG00034042
PLOG00034051
PLOG00034082
PLOG00034105
PLOG00034106
PLOG00034113
PLOG00034125
PLOG00034252
PLOG00034257
PLOG00034288
PLOG00034301
PLOG00034320
PLOG00034329
PLOG00034336
PLOG00034341
PLOG00034342
PLOG00034345
PLOG00034346
PLOG00034371
PLOG00034404
PLOG00034421
PLOG00034423
PLOG00034429
PLOG00034448
PLOG00034464
PLOG00034470
PLOG00034485
PLOG00034486
PLOG00034495
PLOG00034496
PLOG00034513
PLOG00034516
PLOG00034558
PLOG00034563
PLOG00034591
PLOG00034595
PLOG00034621
PLOG00034625
PLOG00034636
PLOG00034648
PLOG00034649
PLOG00034656
PLOG00034665
PLOG00034666
PLOG00034668
PLOG00034671
PLOG00034674
PLOG00034675
PLOG00034676
PLOG00034682
PLOG00034696
PLOG00034749
PLOG00034752
PLOG00034754
PLOG00034756
PLOG00034767
PLOG00034794
PLOG00034806
PLOG00034812
PLOG00034813
PLOG00034817
PLOG00034828
PLOG00034829
PLOG00034842
PLOG00034879
PLOG00034889
PLOG00034910
PLOG00034914
PLOG00034927
PLOG00034933
PLOG00034944
PLOG00034950
PLOG00034953
PLOG00034955
PLOG00034967
PLOG00034979
PLOG00034994
PLOG00035005
PLOG00035016
PLOG00035022
PLOG00035041
PLOG00035052
PLOG00035060
PLOG00035062
PLOG00035063
PLOG00035067
PLOG00035069
PLOG00035076
PLOG00035077
PLOG00035079
PLOG00035083
PLOG00035084
PLOG00035087
PLOG00035088
PLOG00035107
PLOG00035111
PLOG00035116
PLOG00035135
PLOG00035187
PLOG00035211
PLOG00035217
PLOG00035228
PLOG00035231
PLOG00035234
PLOG00035236
PLOG00035239
PLOG00035240
PLOG00035242
PLOG00035245
PLOG00035247
PLOG00035249
PLOG00035276
PLOG00035277
PLOG00035291
PLOG00035307
PLOG00035324
PLOG00035330
PLOG00035336
PLOG00035351
PLOG00035371
PLOG00035378
PLOG00035413
PLOG00035430
PLOG00035432
PLOG00035441
PLOG00035446
PLOG00035449
PLOG00035454
PLOG00035455
PLOG00035469
PLOG00035486
PLOG00035487
PLOG00035489
PLOG00035490
PLOG00035493
PLOG00035497
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 12 of 28
9
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00035507
PLOG00035516
PLOG00035525
PLOG00035542
PLOG00035571
PLOG00035592
PLOG00035611
PLOG00035655
PLOG00035659
PLOG00035666
PLOG00035670
PLOG00035675
PLOG00035694
PLOG00035714
PLOG00035742
PLOG00035746
PLOG00035759
PLOG00035763
PLOG00035764
PLOG00035793
PLOG00035807
PLOG00035813
PLOG00035814
PLOG00035818
PLOG00035823
PLOG00035837
PLOG00035868
PLOG00035879
PLOG00035883
PLOG00035887
PLOG00035889
PLOG00035896
PLOG00035907
PLOG00035908
PLOG00035917
PLOG00035918
PLOG00035919
PLOG00035920
PLOG00035927
PLOG00035936
PLOG00035937
PLOG00035958
PLOG00035959
PLOG00035972
PLOG00036010
PLOG00036016
PLOG00036026
PLOG00036033
PLOG00036045
PLOG00036056
PLOG00036078
PLOG00036084
PLOG00036085
PLOG00036091
PLOG00036096
PLOG00036104
PLOG00036105
PLOG00036106
PLOG00036108
PLOG00036109
PLOG00036113
PLOG00036120
PLOG00036122
PLOG00036123
PLOG00036131
PLOG00036140
PLOG00036142
PLOG00036161
PLOG00036166
PLOG00036180
PLOG00036182
PLOG00036184
PLOG00036195
PLOG00036211
PLOG00036217
PLOG00036218
PLOG00036228
PLOG00036229
PLOG00036238
PLOG00036244
PLOG00036277
PLOG00036293
PLOG00036295
PLOG00036310
PLOG00036324
PLOG00036328
PLOG00036332
PLOG00036334
PLOG00036344
PLOG00036348
PLOG00036379
PLOG00036383
PLOG00036385
PLOG00036409
PLOG00036415
PLOG00036417
PLOG00036421
PLOG00036423
PLOG00036427
PLOG00036446
PLOG00036460
PLOG00036502
PLOG00036506
PLOG00036507
PLOG00036508
PLOG00036509
PLOG00036510
PLOG00036514
PLOG00036528
PLOG00036543
PLOG00036550
PLOG00036557
PLOG00036560
PLOG00036561
PLOG00036565
PLOG00036569
PLOG00036614
PLOG00036636
PLOG00036654
PLOG00036693
PLOG00036698
PLOG00036702
PLOG00036704
PLOG00036707
PLOG00036712
PLOG00036745
PLOG00036746
PLOG00036752
PLOG00036754
PLOG00036758
PLOG00036760
PLOG00036761
PLOG00036763
PLOG00036769
PLOG00036771
PLOG00036778
PLOG00036797
PLOG00036804
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 13 of 28
10
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00036807
PLOG00036808
PLOG00036811
PLOG00036841
PLOG00036843
PLOG00036844
PLOG00036847
PLOG00036885
PLOG00036904
PLOG00036917
PLOG00036933
PLOG00036946
PLOG00036948
PLOG00036958
PLOG00036959
PLOG00036960
PLOG00036961
PLOG00036992
PLOG00036995
PLOG00036998
PLOG00037024
PLOG00037025
PLOG00037026
PLOG00037027
PLOG00037028
PLOG00037029
PLOG00037030
PLOG00037033
PLOG00037037
PLOG00037044
PLOG00037053
PLOG00037071
PLOG00037220
PLOG00037230
PLOG00037242
PLOG00037243
PLOG00037245
PLOG00037246
PLOG00037261
PLOG00037281
PLOG00037317
PLOG00037332
PLOG00037336
PLOG00037338
PLOG00037393
PLOG00037397
PLOG00037398
PLOG00037400
PLOG00037401
PLOG00037406
PLOG00037408
PLOG00037415
PLOG00037416
PLOG00037421
PLOG00037428
PLOG00037430
PLOG00037437
PLOG00037444
PLOG00037453
PLOG00037454
PLOG00037459
PLOG00037465
PLOG00037466
PLOG00037492
PLOG00037507
PLOG00037514
PLOG00037523
PLOG00037525
PLOG00037532
PLOG00037539
PLOG00037618
PLOG00037624
PLOG00037632
PLOG00037633
PLOG00037635
PLOG00037640
PLOG00037641
PLOG00037644
PLOG00037645
PLOG00037648
PLOG00037653
PLOG00037657
PLOG00037662
PLOG00037665
PLOG00037668
PLOG00037672
PLOG00037674
PLOG00037677
PLOG00037678
PLOG00037679
PLOG00037680
PLOG00037681
PLOG00037692
PLOG00037698
PLOG00037703
PLOG00037715
PLOG00037731
PLOG00037738
PLOG00037741
PLOG00037743
PLOG00037753
PLOG00037756
PLOG00037758
PLOG00037763
PLOG00037774
PLOG00037779
PLOG00037789
PLOG00037805
PLOG00037812
PLOG00037813
PLOG00037824
PLOG00037828
PLOG00037830
PLOG00037831
PLOG00037835
PLOG00037838
PLOG00037840
PLOG00037843
PLOG00037849
PLOG00037853
PLOG00037864
PLOG00037870
PLOG00037871
PLOG00037877
PLOG00037888
PLOG00037892
PLOG00037903
PLOG00037923
PLOG00037934
PLOG00037948
PLOG00037950
PLOG00037954
PLOG00037961
PLOG00037962
PLOG00037970
PLOG00037987
PLOG00037996
PLOG00038006
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 14 of 28
11
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00038008
PLOG00038018
PLOG00038027
PLOG00038034
PLOG00038042
PLOG00038051
PLOG00038067
PLOG00038076
PLOG00038087
PLOG00038142
PLOG00038145
PLOG00038164
PLOG00038173
PLOG00038200
PLOG00038215
PLOG00038221
PLOG00038226
PLOG00038257
PLOG00038265
PLOG00038302
PLOG00038303
PLOG00038315
PLOG00038317
PLOG00038327
PLOG00038340
PLOG00038346
PLOG00038351
PLOG00038360
PLOG00038361
PLOG00038369
PLOG00038370
PLOG00038371
PLOG00038386
PLOG00038389
PLOG00038391
PLOG00038511
PLOG00038512
PLOG00038580
PLOG00038583
PLOG00038585
PLOG00038587
PLOG00038588
PLOG00038589
PLOG00038597
PLOG00038604
PLOG00038641
PLOG00038648
PLOG00038659
PLOG00038668
PLOG00038688
PLOG00038689
PLOG00038691
PLOG00038695
PLOG00038717
PLOG00038718
PLOG00038719
PLOG00038732
PLOG00038736
PLOG00038737
PLOG00038745
PLOG00038748
PLOG00038775
PLOG00038805
PLOG00038830
PLOG00038844
PLOG00038863
PLOG00038873
PLOG00038883
PLOG00038885
PLOG00038888
PLOG00038894
PLOG00038916
PLOG00038918
PLOG00038966
PLOG00038976
PLOG00039004
PLOG00039021
PLOG00039029
PLOG00039034
PLOG00039045
PLOG00039056
PLOG00039057
PLOG00039058
PLOG00039062
PLOG00039072
PLOG00039074
PLOG00039091
PLOG00039095
PLOG00039099
PLOG00039105
PLOG00039108
PLOG00039112
PLOG00039114
PLOG00039116
PLOG00039118
PLOG00039146
PLOG00039147
PLOG00039157
PLOG00039159
PLOG00039166
PLOG00039167
PLOG00039168
PLOG00039170
PLOG00039177
PLOG00039187
PLOG00039197
PLOG00039210
PLOG00039218
PLOG00039228
PLOG00039232
PLOG00039236
PLOG00039238
PLOG00039242
PLOG00039248
PLOG00039251
PLOG00039252
PLOG00039258
PLOG00039259
PLOG00039266
PLOG00039280
PLOG00039298
PLOG00039310
PLOG00039311
PLOG00039318
PLOG00039323
PLOG00039330
PLOG00039338
PLOG00039359
PLOG00039386
PLOG00039393
PLOG00039394
PLOG00039395
PLOG00039398
PLOG00039403
PLOG00039406
PLOG00039421
PLOG00039423
PLOG00039428
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 15 of 28
12
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00039442
PLOG00039451
PLOG00039458
PLOG00039464
PLOG00039475
PLOG00039504
PLOG00039521
PLOG00039522
PLOG00039537
PLOG00039545
PLOG00039556
PLOG00039565
PLOG00039592
PLOG00039657
PLOG00039694
PLOG00039697
PLOG00039699
PLOG00039710
PLOG00039720
PLOG00039753
PLOG00039760
PLOG00039769
PLOG00039781
PLOG00039783
PLOG00039818
PLOG00039822
PLOG00039824
PLOG00039832
PLOG00039834
PLOG00039842
PLOG00039859
PLOG00039864
PLOG00039867
PLOG00039871
PLOG00039900
PLOG00039954
PLOG00039955
PLOG00040028
PLOG00040030
PLOG00040034
PLOG00040036
PLOG00040042
PLOG00040070
PLOG00040075
PLOG00040077
PLOG00040149
PLOG00040233
PLOG00040282
PLOG00040288
PLOG00040290
PLOG00040305
PLOG00040314
PLOG00040323
PLOG00040334
PLOG00040338
PLOG00040342
PLOG00040349
PLOG00040371
PLOG00040376
PLOG00040378
PLOG00040382
PLOG00040390
PLOG00040391
PLOG00040395
PLOG00040404
PLOG00040413
PLOG00040420
PLOG00040431
PLOG00040437
PLOG00040439
PLOG00040457
PLOG00040470
PLOG00040479
PLOG00040504
PLOG00040510
PLOG00040538
PLOG00040540
PLOG00040541
PLOG00040554
PLOG00040560
PLOG00040561
PLOG00040590
PLOG00040592
PLOG00040594
PLOG00040595
PLOG00040597
PLOG00040602
PLOG00040606
PLOG00040607
PLOG00040608
PLOG00040616
PLOG00040620
PLOG00040625
PLOG00040636
PLOG00040638
PLOG00040649
PLOG00040650
PLOG00040659
PLOG00040677
PLOG00040678
PLOG00040690
PLOG00040706
PLOG00040717
PLOG00040737
PLOG00040759
PLOG00040765
PLOG00040799
PLOG00040802
PLOG00040808
PLOG00040810
PLOG00040813
PLOG00040814
PLOG00040815
PLOG00040816
PLOG00040817
PLOG00040827
PLOG00040832
PLOG00040833
PLOG00040834
PLOG00040854
PLOG00040858
PLOG00040859
PLOG00040870
PLOG00040877
PLOG00040885
PLOG00040886
PLOG00040892
PLOG00040900
PLOG00040904
PLOG00040905
PLOG00040910
PLOG00040913
PLOG00040926
PLOG00040933
PLOG00040972
PLOG00040990
PLOG00041030
PLOG00041034
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 16 of 28
13
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00041052
PLOG00041053
PLOG00041061
PLOG00041062
PLOG00041063
PLOG00041070
PLOG00041071
PLOG00041078
PLOG00041083
PLOG00041084
PLOG00041110
PLOG00041114
PLOG00041120
PLOG00041121
PLOG00041128
PLOG00041136
PLOG00041142
PLOG00041149
PLOG00041198
PLOG00041201
PLOG00041203
PLOG00041206
PLOG00041222
PLOG00041241
PLOG00041254
PLOG00041297
PLOG00041302
PLOG00041328
PLOG00041340
PLOG00041341
PLOG00041350
PLOG00041357
PLOG00041372
PLOG00041384
PLOG00041388
PLOG00041397
PLOG00041399
PLOG00041409
PLOG00041412
PLOG00041418
PLOG00041424
PLOG00041443
PLOG00041444
PLOG00041455
PLOG00041465
PLOG00041481
PLOG00041492
PLOG00041496
PLOG00041504
PLOG00041514
PLOG00041516
PLOG00041524
PLOG00041530
PLOG00041533
PLOG00041535
PLOG00041562
PLOG00041564
PLOG00041593
PLOG00041594
PLOG00041625
PLOG00041645
PLOG00041649
PLOG00041655
PLOG00041662
PLOG00041665
PLOG00041671
PLOG00041672
PLOG00041673
PLOG00041676
PLOG00041705
PLOG00041722
PLOG00041723
PLOG00041739
PLOG00041741
PLOG00041744
PLOG00041747
PLOG00041767
PLOG00041771
PLOG00041773
PLOG00041778
PLOG00041802
PLOG00041818
PLOG00041829
PLOG00041830
PLOG00041831
PLOG00041832
PLOG00041837
PLOG00041853
PLOG00041854
PLOG00041860
PLOG00041863
PLOG00041869
PLOG00041872
PLOG00041873
PLOG00041874
PLOG00041892
PLOG00041902
PLOG00041905
PLOG00041909
PLOG00041924
PLOG00041931
PLOG00041938
PLOG00041954
PLOG00041975
PLOG00041978
PLOG00041980
PLOG00042000
PLOG00042001
PLOG00042006
PLOG00042008
PLOG00042014
PLOG00042020
PLOG00042040
PLOG00042046
PLOG00042067
PLOG00042080
PLOG00042081
PLOG00042134
PLOG00042145
PLOG00042166
PLOG00042182
PLOG00042183
PLOG00042184
PLOG00042191
PLOG00042196
PLOG00042197
PLOG00042214
PLOG00042248
PLOG00042282
PLOG00042325
PLOG00042351
PLOG00042352
PLOG00042353
PLOG00042386
PLOG00042391
PLOG00042397
PLOG00042409
PLOG00042420
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 17 of 28
14
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00042421
PLOG00042423
PLOG00042441
PLOG00042445
PLOG00042472
PLOG00042477
PLOG00042479
PLOG00042496
PLOG00042533
PLOG00042535
PLOG00042543
PLOG00042546
PLOG00042560
PLOG00042574
PLOG00042575
PLOG00042585
PLOG00042588
PLOG00042603
PLOG00042614
PLOG00042626
PLOG00042627
PLOG00042630
PLOG00042631
PLOG00042632
PLOG00042633
PLOG00042635
PLOG00042637
PLOG00042645
PLOG00042647
PLOG00042650
PLOG00042664
PLOG00042670
PLOG00042679
PLOG00042684
PLOG00042685
PLOG00042686
PLOG00042687
PLOG00042688
PLOG00042689
PLOG00042690
PLOG00042693
PLOG00042705
PLOG00042706
PLOG00042707
PLOG00042708
PLOG00042709
PLOG00042710
PLOG00042711
PLOG00042712
PLOG00042713
PLOG00042714
PLOG00042715
PLOG00042716
PLOG00042722
PLOG00042727
PLOG00042736
PLOG00042737
PLOG00042746
PLOG00042767
PLOG00042768
PLOG00042780
PLOG00042781
PLOG00042788
PLOG00042802
PLOG00042804
PLOG00042805
PLOG00042806
PLOG00042807
PLOG00042808
PLOG00042809
PLOG00042812
PLOG00042813
PLOG00042814
PLOG00042816
PLOG00042819
PLOG00042823
PLOG00042824
PLOG00042825
PLOG00042826
PLOG00042827
PLOG00042828
PLOG00042829
PLOG00042831
PLOG00042845
PLOG00042846
PLOG00042847
PLOG00042848
PLOG00042849
PLOG00042850
PLOG00042851
PLOG00042852
PLOG00042853
PLOG00042854
PLOG00042855
PLOG00042856
PLOG00042857
PLOG00042858
PLOG00042875
PLOG00042878
PLOG00042892
PLOG00042992
PLOG00043016
PLOG00043045
PLOG00043047
PLOG00043048
PLOG00043051
PLOG00043121
PLOG00043127
PLOG00043133
PLOG00043149
PLOG00043150
PLOG00043165
PLOG00043170
PLOG00043180
PLOG00043214
PLOG00043280
PLOG00043281
PLOG00043282
PLOG00043302
PLOG00043315
PLOG00043316
PLOG00043317
PLOG00043318
PLOG00043319
PLOG00043320
PLOG00043321
PLOG00043322
PLOG00043323
PLOG00043324
PLOG00043325
PLOG00043326
PLOG00043327
PLOG00043328
PLOG00043329
PLOG00043330
PLOG00043331
PLOG00043332
PLOG00043333
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 18 of 28
15
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00043334
PLOG00043335
PLOG00043336
PLOG00043337
PLOG00043338
PLOG00043339
PLOG00043340
PLOG00043341
PLOG00043342
PLOG00043343
PLOG00043344
PLOG00043345
PLOG00043346
PLOG00043347
PLOG00043348
PLOG00043349
PLOG00043350
PLOG00043351
PLOG00058398
PLOG00059671
PLOG00061808
PLOG00062720
PLOG00063113
PLOG00063439
PLOG00064072
PLOG00064406
PLOG00064407
PLOG00064408
PLOG00066183
PLOG00070193
PLOG00070194
PLOG00070198
PLOG00070199
PLOG00070200
PLOG00070201
PLOG00070202
PLOG00070203
PLOG00070212
PLOG00070213
PLOG00070214
PLOG00070215
PLOG00070268
PLOG00070269
PLOG00070270
PLOG00070271
PLOG00070272
PLOG00070273
PLOG00070280
PLOG00070282
PLOG00070283
PLOG00070294
PLOG00070365
PLOG00070366
PLOG00070367
PLOG00070368
PLOG00070369
PLOG00070370
PLOG00070371
PLOG00070372
PLOG00070373
PLOG00070374
PLOG00070375
PLOG00070376
PLOG00070377
PLOG00070378
PLOG00070379
PLOG00070380
PLOG00070381
PLOG00070382
PLOG00070383
PLOG00070384
PLOG00070385
PLOG00070391
PLOG00070393
PLOG00070394
PLOG00070395
PLOG00070398
PLOG00070401
PLOG00070402
PLOG00070403
PLOG00070404
PLOG00070405
PLOG00070406
PLOG00070407
PLOG00070408
PLOG00070409
PLOG00070410
PLOG00070411
PLOG00070412
PLOG00070413
PLOG00070416
PLOG00070417
PLOG00070418
PLOG00070423
PLOG00070424
PLOG00070429
PLOG00070430
PLOG00070431
PLOG00070433
PLOG00070434
PLOG00070435
PLOG00070544
PLOG00070555
PLOG00070692
PLOG00070769
PLOG00070778
PLOG00070779
PLOG00070780
PLOG00070782
PLOG00070783
PLOG00070784
PLOG00070785
PLOG00070786
PLOG00070787
PLOG00070788
PLOG00070790
PLOG00070791
PLOG00070809
PLOG00070837
PLOG00070846
PLOG00070852
PLOG00070877
PLOG00070882
PLOG00070883
PLOG00070884
PLOG00070921
PLOG00070924
PLOG00070929
PLOG00070937
PLOG00070938
PLOG00070940
PLOG00070941
PLOG00070942
PLOG00070943
PLOG00070944
PLOG00070945
PLOG00070946
PLOG00070947
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 19 of 28
16
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00070948
PLOG00070949
PLOG00070950
PLOG00070951
PLOG00070952
PLOG00070953
PLOG00070954
PLOG00070955
PLOG00070956
PLOG00070957
PLOG00070958
PLOG00070959
PLOG00070960
PLOG00070961
PLOG00070962
PLOG00070964
PLOG00070965
PLOG00070966
PLOG00070967
PLOG00070969
PLOG00070971
PLOG00070973
PLOG00071113
PLOG00071114
PLOG00071125
PLOG00071126
PLOG00071127
PLOG00071128
PLOG00071129
PLOG00071218
PLOG00071219
PLOG00071220
PLOG00071230
PLOG00071231
PLOG00071232
PLOG00071233
PLOG00071234
PLOG00071235
PLOG00071236
PLOG00071249
PLOG00071252
PLOG00071255
PLOG00071257
PLOG00071258
PLOG00071266
PLOG00071268
PLOG00071275
PLOG00071276
PLOG00071277
PLOG00071278
PLOG00071282
PLOG00071284
PLOG00071285
PLOG00071291
PLOG00071295
PLOG00071296
PLOG00071297
PLOG00071298
PLOG00071299
PLOG00071300
PLOG00071301
PLOG00071302
PLOG00071303
PLOG00071304
PLOG00071305
PLOG00071306
PLOG00071312
PLOG00071313
PLOG00071326
PLOG00071341
PLOG00071356
PLOG00071357
PLOG00071358
PLOG00071359
PLOG00071360
PLOG00071361
PLOG00071365
PLOG00071378
PLOG00071408
PLOG00071409
PLOG00071583
PLOG00071584
PLOG00071585
PLOG00071586
PLOG00071587
PLOG00071588
PLOG00071589
PLOG00071590
PLOG00071591
PLOG00071592
PLOG00071593
PLOG00071594
PLOG00071595
PLOG00071596
PLOG00071597
PLOG00071598
PLOG00071599
PLOG00071600
PLOG00071601
PLOG00071602
PLOG00071603
PLOG00071604
PLOG00071605
PLOG00071606
PLOG00071607
PLOG00071608
PLOG00071609
PLOG00071610
PLOG00071611
PLOG00071612
PLOG00071613
PLOG00071614
PLOG00071615
PLOG00071616
PLOG00071617
PLOG00071618
PLOG00071619
PLOG00071654
PLOG00071655
PLOG00071656
PLOG00071657
PLOG00071658
PLOG00071659
PLOG00071689
PLOG00071706
PLOG00071707
PLOG00071734
PLOG00071735
PLOG00071736
PLOG00071737
PLOG00071738
PLOG00071739
PLOG00071740
PLOG00071741
PLOG00071742
PLOG00071743
PLOG00071744
PLOG00071745
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 20 of 28
17
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00071746
PLOG00071747
PLOG00071748
PLOG00071749
PLOG00071750
PLOG00071751
PLOG00071752
PLOG00071753
PLOG00071754
PLOG00071755
PLOG00071756
PLOG00071757
PLOG00071758
PLOG00071759
PLOG00071760
PLOG00071761
PLOG00071762
PLOG00071763
PLOG00071764
PLOG00071766
PLOG00071767
PLOG00071768
PLOG00071769
PLOG00071770
PLOG00071771
PLOG00071772
PLOG00071784
PLOG00071785
PLOG00071786
PLOG00071787
PLOG00071788
PLOG00071789
PLOG00071790
PLOG00071791
PLOG00071792
PLOG00071793
PLOG00071797
PLOG00071807
PLOG00071808
PLOG00071809
PLOG00071827
PLOG00071828
PLOG00071829
PLOG00071834
PLOG00071845
PLOG00071846
PLOG00071847
PLOG00071848
PLOG00071849
PLOG00071850
PLOG00071851
PLOG00071852
PLOG00071853
PLOG00071854
PLOG00071855
PLOG00071856
PLOG00071857
PLOG00071858
PLOG00071859
PLOG00071879
PLOG00072108
PLOG00072109
PLOG00072110
PLOG00072111
PLOG00072112
PLOG00072113
PLOG00072114
PLOG00072115
PLOG00072116
PLOG00072117
PLOG00072118
PLOG00072119
PLOG00072120
PLOG00072121
PLOG00072122
PLOG00072123
PLOG00072124
PLOG00072125
PLOG00072126
PLOG00072127
PLOG00072128
PLOG00072129
PLOG00072130
PLOG00072131
PLOG00072132
PLOG00072143
PLOG00072210
PLOG00072211
PLOG00072212
PLOG00072279
PLOG00072346
PLOG00072410
PLOG00072411
PLOG00072476
PLOG00072477
PLOG00072478
PLOG00072480
PLOG00072481
PLOG00072483
PLOG00072484
PLOG00072485
PLOG00072487
PLOG00072492
PLOG00072495
PLOG00072497
PLOG00072499
PLOG00072500
PLOG00072502
PLOG00072503
PLOG00072504
PLOG00072505
PLOG00072506
PLOG00072507
PLOG00072508
PLOG00010349
PLOG00012609
PLOG00012610
PLOG00012611
PLOG00012612
PLOG00012613
PLOG00013009
PLOG00014372
PLOG00043355
PLOG00043555
PLOG00043862
PLOG00043863
PLOG00043864
PLOG00043888
PLOG00043912
PLOG00044024
PLOG00044025
PLOG00044026
PLOG00044632
PLOG00044651
PLOG00044792
PLOG00044835
PLOG00044840
PLOG00044923
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 21 of 28
18
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00044937
PLOG00044940
PLOG00044942
PLOG00044956
PLOG00044997
PLOG00045000
PLOG00045003
PLOG00045006
PLOG00045009
PLOG00045068
PLOG00045081
PLOG00045082
PLOG00045187
PLOG00045188
PLOG00045455
PLOG00045511
PLOG00045579
PLOG00045596
PLOG00045597
PLOG00045724
PLOG00045725
PLOG00045726
PLOG00045727
PLOG00045887
PLOG00045889
PLOG00046011
PLOG00046155
PLOG00046168
PLOG00046199
PLOG00046204
PLOG00046315
PLOG00046329
PLOG00046370
PLOG00046381
PLOG00046388
PLOG00046390
PLOG00046391
PLOG00046480
PLOG00046569
PLOG00046688
PLOG00046689
PLOG00046719
PLOG00046724
PLOG00046725
PLOG00046728
PLOG00046755
PLOG00046760
PLOG00046988
PLOG00047205
PLOG00047422
PLOG00047428
PLOG00047429
PLOG00047430
PLOG00047445
PLOG00047460
PLOG00047475
PLOG00047490
PLOG00047527
PLOG00047530
PLOG00047548
PLOG00047589
PLOG00047598
PLOG00047640
PLOG00047641
PLOG00047795
PLOG00047972
PLOG00047978
PLOG00048161
PLOG00048162
PLOG00048163
PLOG00048164
PLOG00048741
PLOG00048749
PLOG00048824
PLOG00048899
PLOG00048903
PLOG00048967
PLOG00049114
PLOG00049166
PLOG00049168
PLOG00049176
PLOG00049206
PLOG00049207
PLOG00049210
PLOG00049213
PLOG00049214
PLOG00049215
PLOG00049221
PLOG00049222
PLOG00049223
PLOG00049229
PLOG00049230
PLOG00049232
PLOG00049234
PLOG00049241
PLOG00049242
PLOG00049243
PLOG00049244
PLOG00049245
PLOG00049246
PLOG00049252
PLOG00049336
PLOG00049350
PLOG00049360
PLOG00049373
PLOG00049472
PLOG00049501
PLOG00049541
PLOG00049576
PLOG00049607
PLOG00049661
PLOG00049754
PLOG00049793
PLOG00049814
PLOG00049840
PLOG00049970
PLOG00049983
PLOG00049990
PLOG00050072
PLOG00050073
PLOG00050087
PLOG00050097
PLOG00050168
PLOG00050215
PLOG00050221
PLOG00050341
PLOG00050410
PLOG00050428
PLOG00050611
PLOG00050678
PLOG00050679
PLOG00050748
PLOG00050818
PLOG00050819
PLOG00050898
PLOG00050921
PLOG00050939
PLOG00050940
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 22 of 28
19
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00050970
PLOG00051000
PLOG00051048
PLOG00051053
PLOG00051083
PLOG00051122
PLOG00051178
PLOG00051460
PLOG00051471
PLOG00051939
PLOG00052224
PLOG00052287
PLOG00052312
PLOG00052317
PLOG00052324
PLOG00052325
PLOG00052326
PLOG00052425
PLOG00052524
PLOG00052623
PLOG00052624
PLOG00052625
PLOG00052720
PLOG00052815
PLOG00052816
PLOG00052819
PLOG00052906
PLOG00052907
PLOG00052914
PLOG00052915
PLOG00053034
PLOG00053035
PLOG00053121
PLOG00053128
PLOG00053228
PLOG00053230
PLOG00053231
PLOG00053232
PLOG00053233
PLOG00053335
PLOG00053437
PLOG00053539
PLOG00053641
PLOG00053642
PLOG00053643
PLOG00053654
PLOG00053655
PLOG00053757
PLOG00053758
PLOG00053872
PLOG00053935
PLOG00054041
PLOG00054047
PLOG00054061
PLOG00054065
PLOG00054168
PLOG00054169
PLOG00054223
PLOG00054232
PLOG00054242
PLOG00054271
PLOG00054335
PLOG00054336
PLOG00054524
PLOG00054822
PLOG00054825
PLOG00054850
PLOG00054884
PLOG00054885
PLOG00054903
PLOG00054920
PLOG00054928
PLOG00054949
PLOG00054950
PLOG00054952
PLOG00054953
PLOG00054976
PLOG00054977
PLOG00054987
PLOG00055012
PLOG00055013
PLOG00055207
PLOG00055258
PLOG00055273
PLOG00055310
PLOG00055384
PLOG00055490
PLOG00055491
PLOG00055494
PLOG00055499
PLOG00055516
PLOG00055517
PLOG00055717
PLOG00055841
PLOG00055861
PLOG00056005
PLOG00056021
PLOG00056030
PLOG00056032
PLOG00056158
PLOG00056169
PLOG00056211
PLOG00056245
PLOG00056335
PLOG00056583
PLOG00056584
PLOG00056585
PLOG00056927
PLOG00057036
PLOG00057039
PLOG00057044
PLOG00057228
PLOG00057232
PLOG00057239
PLOG00057242
PLOG00057343
PLOG00057358
PLOG00057405
PLOG00057408
PLOG00057409
PLOG00059257
PLOG00072573
PLOG00072582
PLOG00072586
PLOG00072591
PLOG00072605
PLOG00072633
PLOG00072634
PLOG00072636
PLOG00072642
PLOG00072677
PLOG00072694
PLOG00072699
PLOG00072700
PLOG00072701
PLOG00072702
PLOG00072703
PLOG00072704
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 23 of 28
20
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00072705
PLOG00057469
PLOG00057480
PLOG00057491
PLOG00057492
PLOG00011362
PLOG00012634
PLOG00013114
PLOG00013409
PLOG00013442
PLOG00013464
PLOG00013472
PLOG00016563
PLOG00039737
PLOG00051944
PLOG00053226
PLOG00053227
PLOG00053925
PLOG00053964
PLOG00057721
PLOG00057722
PLOG00057769
PLOG00058000
PLOG00058120
PLOG00058121
PLOG00058163
PLOG00058200
PLOG00058276
PLOG00058288
PLOG00058319
PLOG00058320
PLOG00058341
PLOG00058342
PLOG00058383
PLOG00058723
PLOG00058834
PLOG00058903
PLOG00058912
PLOG00058969
PLOG00059027
PLOG00059367
PLOG00059456
PLOG00059483
PLOG00059492
PLOG00059571
PLOG00059574
PLOG00059666
PLOG00059667
PLOG00059672
PLOG00059673
PLOG00059674
PLOG00059675
PLOG00059735
PLOG00072718
PLOG00072724
PLOG00072725
PLOG00072731
PLOG00072733
PLOG00072734
PLOG00072735
PLOG00072739
PLOG00072740
PLOG00072742
PLOG00072744
PLOG00072745
PLOG00072746
PLOG00072747
PLOG00072748
PLOG00072749
PLOG00072750
PLOG00072751
PLOG00072752
PLOG00072755
PLOG00072758
PLOG00072760
PLOG00072761
PLOG00072762
PLOG00072764
PLOG00072767
PLOG00072769
PLOG00072770
PLOG00072772
PLOG00072773
PLOG00072774
PLOG00072775
PLOG00072780
PLOG00072781
PLOG00072782
PLOG00072783
PLOG00072784
PLOG00072785
PLOG00072786
PLOG00072787
PLOG00072788
PLOG00072789
PLOG00072790
PLOG00072793
PLOG00072798
PLOG00072799
PLOG00072802
PLOG00072804
PLOG00072805
PLOG00072806
PLOG00072809
PLOG00072811
PLOG00072812
PLOG00072813
PLOG00072814
PLOG00072818
PLOG00072820
PLOG00072821
PLOG00072822
PLOG00072823
PLOG00072827
PLOG00072828
PLOG00072829
PLOG00072830
PLOG00072831
PLOG00072832
PLOG00072833
PLOG00072834
PLOG00072836
PLOG00072837
PLOG00072838
PLOG00072839
PLOG00072840
PLOG00072843
PLOG00072844
PLOG00072845
PLOG00072846
PLOG00072849
PLOG00072850
PLOG00072851
PLOG00072852
PLOG00072853
PLOG00072856
PLOG00072860
PLOG00072864
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 24 of 28
21
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00072865
PLOG00072868
PLOG00072869
PLOG00072871
PLOG00072872
PLOG00072873
PLOG00072874
PLOG00072875
PLOG00072877
PLOG00072878
PLOG00072879
PLOG00072880
PLOG00072885
PLOG00072886
PLOG00072887
PLOG00072889
PLOG00072890
PLOG00072891
PLOG00072894
PLOG00072897
PLOG00072899
PLOG00072900
PLOG00072901
PLOG00072905
PLOG00072907
PLOG00072908
PLOG00072909
PLOG00072910
PLOG00072911
PLOG00072912
PLOG00072915
PLOG00072920
PLOG00072921
PLOG00072927
PLOG00072928
PLOG00072984
PLOG00073024
PLOG00073025
PLOG00073028
PLOG00073042
PLOG00073043
PLOG00073044
PLOG00011160
PLOG00014542
PLOG00017635
PLOG00059805
PLOG00059833
PLOG00059840
PLOG00059859
PLOG00059877
PLOG00059922
PLOG00059996
PLOG00060010
PLOG00060020
PLOG00060161
PLOG00060198
PLOG00060231
PLOG00060361
PLOG00060387
PLOG00060408
PLOG00060601
PLOG00060653
PLOG00060666
PLOG00060685
PLOG00060694
PLOG00060698
PLOG00060710
PLOG00060724
PLOG00060728
PLOG00060739
PLOG00060765
PLOG00060818
PLOG00060825
PLOG00060831
PLOG00060856
PLOG00060877
PLOG00060879
PLOG00060952
PLOG00060963
PLOG00060971
PLOG00061016
PLOG00061034
PLOG00061037
PLOG00061039
PLOG00061041
PLOG00061043
PLOG00061046
PLOG00061081
PLOG00061102
PLOG00061110
PLOG00061111
PLOG00061129
PLOG00061130
PLOG00061141
PLOG00061148
PLOG00061158
PLOG00061162
PLOG00061213
PLOG00061263
PLOG00061302
PLOG00061335
PLOG00061480
PLOG00061505
PLOG00061512
PLOG00061520
PLOG00061521
PLOG00061530
PLOG00061533
PLOG00061537
PLOG00061541
PLOG00061547
PLOG00061550
PLOG00061552
PLOG00061568
PLOG00061573
PLOG00061624
PLOG00061661
PLOG00061684
PLOG00061691
PLOG00061699
PLOG00061717
PLOG00061718
PLOG00061725
PLOG00061789
PLOG00061809
PLOG00061817
PLOG00061831
PLOG00061836
PLOG00061840
PLOG00061846
PLOG00061858
PLOG00061859
PLOG00061962
PLOG00061970
PLOG00061973
PLOG00061975
PLOG00061978
PLOG00062023
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 25 of 28
22
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00062025
PLOG00062055
PLOG00062109
PLOG00062184
PLOG00062187
PLOG00062196
PLOG00062217
PLOG00062382
PLOG00062383
PLOG00062385
PLOG00062386
PLOG00062404
PLOG00062407
PLOG00062423
PLOG00062432
PLOG00062440
PLOG00062467
PLOG00062479
PLOG00062493
PLOG00062567
PLOG00062627
PLOG00062642
PLOG00062685
PLOG00062718
PLOG00062798
PLOG00062799
PLOG00062800
PLOG00062801
PLOG00062802
PLOG00062803
PLOG00073185
PLOG00073203
PLOG00073204
PLOG00073208
PLOG00073212
PLOG00073220
PLOG00073221
PLOG00073260
PLOG00073274
PLOG00073282
PLOG00073330
PLOG00073351
PLOG00073352
PLOG00073353
PLOG00073354
PLOG00073356
PLOG00073409
PLOG00008216
PLOG00008457
PLOG00019313
PLOG00023947
PLOG00024005
PLOG00025785
PLOG00026731
PLOG00032574
PLOG00033289
PLOG00035598
PLOG00035599
PLOG00035605
PLOG00035606
PLOG00035607
PLOG00037270
PLOG00037425
PLOG00037446
PLOG00037636
PLOG00037643
PLOG00037835
PLOG00038083
PLOG00038085
PLOG00038111
PLOG00038161
PLOG00061164
PLOG00061569
PLOG00061570
PLOG00061572
PLOG00061586
PLOG00062928
PLOG00062964
PLOG00063123
PLOG00063124
PLOG00063177
PLOG00063179
PLOG00063180
PLOG00063246
PLOG00063287
PLOG00063314
PLOG00063334
PLOG00063369
PLOG00063380
PLOG00063440
PLOG00063452
PLOG00063454
PLOG00063487
PLOG00063555
PLOG00063643
PLOG00063717
PLOG00063726
PLOG00063783
PLOG00064009
PLOG00064141
PLOG00064188
PLOG00064212
PLOG00064297
PLOG00064375
PLOG00064389
PLOG00064390
PLOG00064391
PLOG00064392
PLOG00064393
PLOG00064395
PLOG00064397
PLOG00064398
PLOG00064399
PLOG00064404
PLOG00064453
PLOG00064515
PLOG00064579
PLOG00064621
PLOG00064625
PLOG00064628
PLOG00064634
PLOG00064647
PLOG00064651
PLOG00064655
PLOG00064660
PLOG00064691
PLOG00064696
PLOG00064714
PLOG00064748
PLOG00064761
PLOG00064780
PLOG00064786
PLOG00064790
PLOG00064797
PLOG00064799
PLOG00064846
PLOG00064870
PLOG00064873
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 26 of 28
23
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00064914
PLOG00064942
PLOG00064947
PLOG00064979
PLOG00064981
PLOG00064983
PLOG00064984
PLOG00064994
PLOG00065025
PLOG00065034
PLOG00065046
PLOG00065053
PLOG00065057
PLOG00065058
PLOG00065060
PLOG00065076
PLOG00065085
PLOG00065088
PLOG00065089
PLOG00065094
PLOG00065118
PLOG00065122
PLOG00065128
PLOG00065130
PLOG00065154
PLOG00065160
PLOG00065161
PLOG00065165
PLOG00065168
PLOG00065169
PLOG00065173
PLOG00065183
PLOG00065196
PLOG00065212
PLOG00065213
PLOG00065222
PLOG00065230
PLOG00065234
PLOG00065250
PLOG00065251
PLOG00065255
PLOG00065257
PLOG00065262
PLOG00065263
PLOG00065266
PLOG00065272
PLOG00065279
PLOG00065280
PLOG00065285
PLOG00065286
PLOG00065302
PLOG00065305
PLOG00065323
PLOG00065327
PLOG00065342
PLOG00065345
PLOG00065384
PLOG00065385
PLOG00065388
PLOG00065391
PLOG00065403
PLOG00065415
PLOG00065420
PLOG00065424
PLOG00065425
PLOG00065427
PLOG00065432
PLOG00065437
PLOG00065439
PLOG00065441
PLOG00065442
PLOG00065445
PLOG00065446
PLOG00065449
PLOG00065452
PLOG00065453
PLOG00065455
PLOG00065460
PLOG00065465
PLOG00065473
PLOG00065477
PLOG00065481
PLOG00065502
PLOG00065520
PLOG00065534
PLOG00065536
PLOG00065539
PLOG00065568
PLOG00065583
PLOG00065585
PLOG00065601
PLOG00065603
PLOG00065611
PLOG00065624
PLOG00065625
PLOG00065626
PLOG00065632
PLOG00065647
PLOG00065656
PLOG00065657
PLOG00065660
PLOG00065661
PLOG00065662
PLOG00065666
PLOG00065668
PLOG00065669
PLOG00065672
PLOG00065674
PLOG00065677
PLOG00065678
PLOG00065680
PLOG00065681
PLOG00065692
PLOG00065707
PLOG00065708
PLOG00065710
PLOG00065713
PLOG00065719
PLOG00065720
PLOG00065723
PLOG00065733
PLOG00065744
PLOG00065760
PLOG00065763
PLOG00065764
PLOG00065805
PLOG00065809
PLOG00065827
PLOG00065828
PLOG00065829
PLOG00065841
PLOG00065850
PLOG00065852
PLOG00065896
PLOG00065900
PLOG00065916
PLOG00065934
PLOG00065935
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 27 of 28
24
4910-9861-5193.v1
PLOG00065937
PLOG00065939
PLOG00065956
PLOG00065965
PLOG00065986
PLOG00065991
PLOG00066001
PLOG00066004
PLOG00066006
PLOG00066008
PLOG00066012
PLOG00066019
PLOG00066035
PLOG00066049
PLOG00066051
PLOG00066064
PLOG00066070
PLOG00066074
PLOG00066109
PLOG00066113
PLOG00066172
PLOG00066207
PLOG00066211
PLOG00073493
PLOG00073494
PLOG00073495
PLOG00073496
PLOG00073554
PLOG00073573
PLOG00073601
PLOG00073640
PLOG00073655
PLOG00073670
PLOG00073682
PLOG00073683
PLOG00073684
PLOG00073685
PLOG00073687
PLOG00073699
PLOG00073701
PLOG00073702
PLOG00073703
PLOG00073895
PLOG00073896
PLOG00010281
PLOG00010727
PLOG00010756
PLOG00011012
PLOG00014359
PLOG00014464
PLOG00066561
PLOG00066662
PLOG00066741
PLOG00066808
PLOG00073918
PLOG00073919
PLOG00073920
PLOG00073921
PLOG00073922
PLOG00073923
PLOG00073924
PLOG00073925
PLOG00073926
PLOG00073927
PLOG00074127
PLOG00074130
Case 2:22-cv-02126-MTL Document 364-10 Filed 04/27/26 Page 28 of 28File and source
- File
- gov.uscourts.azd.1319766.364.10.pdf
- Size
- 698,816 bytes
- SHA-256
- 5c582e1664b82b502e75b4c3305478fc934cd24cf30297fe4d96b1a7c3cb34c6
- Original
- archive.org