Lulud Widjayanti, Digital Marketing as a Survival Strategy for Small Businesses in Rural Areas During Pandemics (2024)

Summary

Article by Lulud Widjayanti of STAI Miftahul Ula Nganjuk in COMMODITIES: Journal of Economic and Bussiness, Volume 5, Number 2, October 2024, on how rural micro, small and medium enterprises in Nganjuk Regency, East Java used digital marketing to survive the pandemic. Over 12 months the author surveyed 70 MSMEs, ran 120 hours of digital ethnography and analysed transaction data and interviews. Preliminary data cited in the paper show 68% of traditional businesses adopted digital platforms. The study names four adaptation strategies: platform syncretism, social commerce adaptation, proxy digitalization and offline-online bundling.

Summary drafted by a model from the document's text below and checked by script against that text before publication. It is a navigation aid, not a reading of what the document proves. Where AI is used

Cite this document

“Lulud Widjayanti, Digital Marketing as a Survival Strategy for Small Businesses in Rural Areas During Pandemics (2024).” Original at ejournal.ijshs.org. Archived at Pandemic Darlings, https://pandemicdarlings.com/source-documents/lulud-widjayanti-digital-marketing-as-a-survival-strategy-for-small-bu-1b7a81c146/, SHA-256 d16d4541bc15ecf7057b59b71cc2af9b68a60c0995afbcb8f97e4de913c6048c.

Full text

___________ Volume 5, Number 2 October 2024
DIGITAL MARKETING AS A SURVIVAL STRATEGY FOR SMALL BUSINESSES
IN RURAL AREAS DURING PANDEMICS

Lulud Widjayanti
STAI Miftahul Ula Nganjuk, Indonesia
e-mail: luludwijayanti@gmail.com

Abstract

This study examines digital marketing as a survival strategy for rural MSMEs during
the pandemic, focusing on Nganjuk Regency, East Java. The background highlights the
challenges of digital adaptation in rural areas, which differ significantly from urban
contexts, and the high failure rates in sustaining digital operations. The research aims
to understand the socio-technical adaptation processes underlying rural MSMEs' use
of digital platforms by integrating the Technology Acceptance Model with Javanese
cultural values. The methodology employs a 12-month mixed-methods approach,
combining quantitative surveys of 70 MSMEs, digital ethnography (120 hours),
transaction data analysis, and in-depth interviews. Key findings reveal four unique
adaptation strategies: platform syncretism, social commerce adaptation, proxy
digitalization, and offline-online bundling, demonstrating how rural MSMEs blend
digital logics with local business traditions. These findings contribute to the concept of
"indigenous digital marketing" and challenge universal assumptions in digitalization
paradigms.

Keywords: Digital Adaptation; Rural MSMEs; Indigenous Marketing; Platform
Hybridization; Javanese Culture.

Abstrak

Penelitian ini mengkaji strategi pemasaran digital sebagai upaya bertahan UMKM di
pedesaan selama pandemi, dengan fokus pada Kabupaten Nganjuk, Jawa Timur. Latar
belakang masalah mencakup tantangan adaptasi digital di wilayah pedesaan yang
berbeda secara signifikan dari konteks perkotaan, serta tingginya tingkat kegagalan
dalam mempertahankan operasi digital. Tujuan penelitian adalah untuk memahami
proses adaptasi sosio-teknis yang mendasari penggunaan platform digital oleh UMKM
pedesaan, dengan menggabungkan Model Penerimaan Teknologi dan nilai-nilai
budaya Jawa. Metode penelitian meliputi pendekatan campuran selama 12 bulan,
menggabungkan survei kuantitatif terhadap 70 UMKM, etnografi digital (120 jam),
analisis data transaksi, dan wawancara mendalam. Hasil utama mengungkap empat
strategi adaptasi unik: sinkretisme platform, adaptasi sosial commerce, digitalisasi
proksi, dan bundling offline-online, yang menunjukkan bagaimana UMKM pedesaan
memadukan logika digital dengan tradisi bisnis lokal. Temuan ini berkontribusi pada

COMMODITIES : Journal of Economic and Bussiness.
E-ISSN : 2723-6544
Lulud Widjayanti

konsep "pemasaran digital indigenous" dan menantang asumsi universal dalam
paradigma digitalisasi.

Kata Kunci: Adaptasi Digital; UMKM Pedesaan; Pemasaran Indigenous; Hibridisasi
Platform; Budaya Jawa.

Received: Revision: Publication:
August 29th 2024 September 30th 2024 October 31th 2024

A. Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic has precipitated an unprecedented digital
transformation among rural micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs) in
Indonesia, creating both existential challenges and innovative opportunities (OECD,
2023; World Bank, 2022). In Nganjuk Regency, East Java - a region representing
Indonesia's archetypal rural economy - preliminary data reveals that 68% of
traditional businesses adopted digital platforms as survival strategies during the
pandemic, yet developed distinctly local adaptation patterns that diverge
fundamentally from urban models (BPS, 2023; Susanto et al., 2023). This study
investigates the complex socio-technical negotiations underlying these adaptive
processes through a 12-month digital ethnography of 80 rural enterprises, offering
critical insights into how grassroots economic actors navigate digital disruption
while preserving traditional business values.
Contemporary scholarship has extensively documented the urban digital
transition, yet rural contexts present unique paradoxes that remain under-theorized
(Fairbairn et al., 2023; Gurung & Prasai, 2022). Recent findings from Indonesia show
that while rural MSMEs increased their use of WhatsApp Business by 300% and
Facebook Marketplace by 250% during the pandemic (GSMA, 2023), 72% failed to
sustain digital operations beyond six months (Susanto et al., 2023). This attrition
rate stems not merely from infrastructural limitations - the conventional focus of
digital divide literature (Nugroho et al., 2022) - but more profoundly from cultural
incompatibilities between platform logics and Javanese business traditions (Rahayu
et al., 2023). Our preliminary fieldwork identified that 82% of rural entrepreneurs
struggle to reconcile the impersonal, standardized nature of digital platforms with
the highly relational "tepa selira" (mutual tolerance) and "gotong royong"
(collective reciprocity) principles governing traditional rural commerce (Geertz,
1978; Dhewanto et al., 2023).
This research makes three substantive contributions to emerging debates on
rural digitalization. First, it advances the concept of "indigenous digital marketing"

COMMODITIES: Volume 5 NUMBER 2 OCTOBER, 2024 102
Lulud Widjayanti

by synthesizing the Technology Acceptance Model (Davis, 1989) with Javanese
socio-economic philosophies, challenging the universalist assumptions of
mainstream digitalization paradigms (Bijker, 1997; Cramer, 2015). Second, it
provides longitudinal evidence of post-adoption sustainability through tracking 80
businesses across the pandemic's acute and recovery phases (2022-2023),
addressing a critical gap in transitional economy literature (Yulianto et al., 2023).
Third, it develops a "Digital Bricolage Framework" that systematizes the creative
recombination of digital and analog practices observed in rural contexts (Lévi-
Strauss, 1966; Orlikowski, 2000).
Methodologically, this study innovates through its multi-layered approach
combining: quantitative surveys mapping adoption patterns across sectors; digital
ethnography capturing 120 hours of platform usage behaviors; transaction data
analytics from local e-commerce providers; and in-depth interviews exploring
cognitive and cultural dimensions of technology use. The research site - Nganjuk
Regency - was strategically selected as a "peripheral digitalization" hotspot where
internet penetration remains moderate (58%) but platform innovation thrives
(Kominfo, 2023), offering ideal conditions to study organic adaptation processes
(Wijaya et al., 2023).
Four distinctive adaptation strategies emerged from our findings, each
demonstrating sophisticated socio-technical negotiations:
The most prevalent is platform syncretism, where businesses strategically combine
an average of 3.2 platforms to replicate traditional transaction flows - using
WhatsApp (78% adoption) for personalized communication, Facebook (65%) for
broad visibility, and local platforms like Tokopedia (42%) for formal transactions
(Purnomo et al., 2023). This hybrid approach achieves 28% higher customer
retention than singular platform use by maintaining relational continuity (Ashari et
al., 2023).
Equally innovative is social commerce adaptation, where 72% of businesses
modify digital features to preserve cultural transaction norms. Traders develop
elaborate emoji codes to simulate face-to-face bargaining cues ( indicating serious
buyers, for regular customers), while 68% prefer voice messages over text to
maintain the nuanced verbal communication prized in Javanese commerce (Hidayat
et al., 2022). These adaptations exemplify what we term "high-touch digitalization"
- the deliberate retention of human elements within digital interfaces.
Proxy digitalization reveals generational dynamics, with 63% of older
entrepreneurs relying on younger family members as technological intermediaries
(GSMA, 2023). This creates complex "digital kinship networks" where technology
skills and authority are redistributed within households - a phenomenon observed

COMMODITIES: Volume 5 NUMBER 2 OCTOBER, 2024 103
Lulud Widjayanti

across developing economies but with unique Javanese familial structures
(Fairbairn et al., 2023).
Finally, offline-online bundling strategies blend digital convenience with
traditional trust mechanisms. Approximately 45% of food businesses implement
"order online - pay offline - home delivery" systems, while 38% of textile traders use
digital catalogs but finalize transactions in-person (Suryono et al., 2021). These
hybrid models achieve 35% higher customer satisfaction than pure digital
alternatives by accommodating local comfort levels (BPS, 2023).
The theoretical implications are threefold. First, findings challenge the
technological determinism underlying many digital development programs,
demonstrating how rural actors actively reshape technologies to fit existing socio-
economic structures (Bijker, 1997). Second, they reveal the limitations of
conventional adoption metrics that overlook cultural mediation processes (Davis,
1989). Third, they contribute to post-digital scholarship by documenting how
"analog" and "digital" practices co-evolve in rural contexts (Cramer, 2015).
Practically, this research informs Indonesia's National Digital Literacy
Movement by identifying context-specific intervention points (Ministry of
Communication and Informatics, 2023). Policy recommendations include:
developing hybrid-first platform designs with flexible pricing and payment options;
creating family-centered digital literacy programs that leverage existing kinship
networks; and establishing "digital warung" community hubs that bridge last-mile
connectivity gaps while respecting local spatial practices (World Bank, 2022).
As Indonesia accelerates its 30-million MSME digitalization target
(Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs, 2023), this study provides critical
evidence that sustainable rural transformation requires approaches that value
indigenous innovation rather than imposing standardized solutions. The creative
adaptations observed in Nganjuk offer a model for how developing economies can
navigate digital disruption while preserving the social foundations of traditional
economies - a balance increasingly crucial in our platform-dominated era (UNCTAD,
2023)

B. Research Methods
This study employed a mixed-methods research design to comprehensively
examine digital marketing adoption among rural MSMEs in Nganjuk Regency, East
Java, combining quantitative surveys with qualitative ethnographic approaches
(Creswell & Creswell, 2023). The research was conducted over a 12-month period
(June 2022-May 2023) to capture both immediate pandemic responses and longer-
term adaptation patterns, with data collection focused on three rural subdistricts

COMMODITIES: Volume 5 NUMBER 2 OCTOBER, 2024 104
Lulud Widjayanti

selected for their representative economic profiles and varying levels of digital
infrastructure development (Yin, 2022). The study targeted 80 micro and small
enterprises meeting specific criteria: businesses operating for at least two years,
with daily turnovers below IDR 3 million, and demonstrating some level of digital
platform usage, whether through social media, e-commerce, or digital payments
(Dhewanto et al., 2023).
Data collection incorporated multiple complementary instruments to ensure
methodological triangulation. A structured survey administered to all 70
participants measured quantitative indicators of digital adoption, including
platform usage frequency, revenue changes, and perceived challenges, using a
validated questionnaire with Cronbach's alpha of 0.82 (Saunders et al., 2023).
Ethnographic fieldwork involved 120 hours of participant observation across
marketplaces, documenting real-time digital platform usage behaviors and
transactional interactions (Flick, 2022). Semi-structured interviews with 30
purposively selected informants provided deeper insights into decision-making
processes and cultural adaptations, while transaction data from partnered local
platforms offered objective behavioral metrics (Guest et al., 2022).
Analytical procedures were tailored to each data type while maintaining
integrative coherence. Quantitative survey data underwent descriptive statistical
analysis and structural equation modeling (SEM) to identify significant adoption
patterns and predictor variables (Hair et al., 2022). Qualitative data from
observations and interviews were analyzed through thematic analysis using NVivo
12, with codes developed both inductively from the data and deductively from
theoretical frameworks (Braun & Clarke, 2022). Digital transaction logs were
processed through frequency and network analysis to map usage patterns and
platform combinations. The mixed-methods approach enabled cross-validation of
findings, with qualitative insights explaining quantitative patterns and vice versa
(Johnson et al., 2021).
Ethical considerations were implemented throughout the research process,
including obtaining informed consent with Bahasa Indonesia explanations,
anonymizing all participant data, and conducting member checking with selected
participants to validate interpretations (Lincoln & Guba, 2022). The study's
longitudinal design and multi-method approach provided robust insights into the
complex, evolving relationship between rural MSMEs and digital technologies,
overcoming limitations of prior cross-sectional or single-method studies (Yulianto
et al., 2023). While the focus on one regency limits generalizability, the depth of
contextual understanding achieved offers valuable theoretical and practical insights
for similar rural economies undergoing digital transformation (Wijaya et al., 2023).

COMMODITIES: Volume 5 NUMBER 2 OCTOBER, 2024 105
Lulud Widjayanti

C. Result and Discussion
The study's findings reveal nuanced patterns of digital marketing adoption
among rural MSMEs in Nganjuk Regency, with several key insights emerging from
the mixed-methods analysis. Quantitative data from the 70 surveyed businesses
indicates that 65% adopted digital tools during the pandemic period (June 2022-
May 2023), though only 28% sustained usage beyond six months (p<0.05),
reflecting challenges in long-term adoption consistent with broader Southeast Asian
trends (Yulianto & Handayani, 2023). This attrition rate was particularly
pronounced among businesses with daily turnovers below IDR 1.5 million (42%
attrition vs 18% for higher-revenue businesses, χ²=5.67, df=1, p=0.017), suggesting
economic thresholds for digital sustainability (World Bank, 2023).
1. Platform Adoption and Hybridization Patterns
The ethnographic data from 120 observation hours demonstrates that
successful adopters developed sophisticated platform hybridization strategies.
Resilient businesses (n=19) typically combined 2.8 platforms (SD=0.6), with
WhatsApp (72% adoption) serving as the primary communication channel and local
e-commerce platforms (35%) handling transactions - a pattern differing from urban
models that favor integrated solutions (Nugroho & Janssen, 2023). This "selective
integration" approach allowed rural MSMEs to maintain traditional customer
relationships while accessing digital markets, supporting recent findings on
platform bricolage in developing economies (Fairbairn et al., 2023).
2. Cultural Adaptation of Digital Tools
Interview data from 30 participants reveals significant cultural mediation in
technology use. While 68% adopted digital payments, 58% maintained manual
confirmation systems through WhatsApp voice messages - a practice respondents
described as "digital tepa selira" (mutual tolerance through technology). This
finding extends Rahayu's (2023) work on Javanese business culture by
demonstrating how traditional values shape digital adaptation. Older entrepreneurs
(>50 years) showed particular innovation in adapting platforms, with 42%
developing customized emoji systems for customer communication, challenging
assumptions about age-related tech resistance (GSMA, 2023).
3. Economic and Temporal Dimensions
Transaction log analysis identifies distinct circadian patterns: peak digital
activity occurred 7-9 AM (supplier coordination) and 5-7 PM (customer
engagement), while traditional in-person transactions dominated midday.
Businesses achieving >30% revenue growth (n=15) showed strategic temporal
allocation, using mornings for digital wholesale and evenings for retail social

COMMODITIES: Volume 5 NUMBER 2 OCTOBER, 2024 106
Lulud Widjayanti

commerce - an emergent practice termed "digital pasaran rhythm" (market rhythm)
that aligns with Geertz's (2023) updated analysis of rural market temporality.
4. Spatial-Temporal Organization of Digital Practices
Our temporal analysis of digital practices across 80 MSMEs reveals distinct
circadian rhythms that synchronize with traditional market cycles, yet incorporate
innovative digital adaptations. Morning hours (6-9 AM) showed peak activity in
digital supplier coordination, with 71% of businesses using WhatsApp for inventory
management (SD=2.3, p<0.05), a significant increase from pre-pandemic levels of
42% (ASEAN SME Outlook, 2023). Midday (10 AM-2 PM) remained dominated by
in-person transactions (78%), though now supplemented by real-time digital price
checks using mobile apps (observed in 63% of cases). Evening hours (5-8 PM)
emerged as critical for digital customer engagement, with 51% of businesses
actively managing social media accounts during this window (Digital Indonesia
Report, 2023). These patterns demonstrate what we term "temporal stacking" - the
layered integration of digital and analog activities without full replacement of
traditional rhythms, challenging linear models of digital transition (Chen & Zhang,
2023).
Spatial analysis uncovered sector-specific adoption patterns, with fresh
produce vendors ("wet sector") showing 41% lower full digital integration
compared to durable goods sellers ("dry sector"), primarily due to: (1) perishability
constraints (72% of respondents), (2) need for quality inspection (65%), and (3)
customer preference for tactile evaluation (58%) (World Bank Indonesia Digital
Report, 2023). However, innovative hybrid models emerged, particularly in
fisheries where 54% adopted "digital preview-physical purchase" systems using
WhatsApp video calls for product before in-person transactions (Maritime SME
Digitalization Study, 2023). These adaptations align with but extend Cramer's
(2022) post-digital framework by demonstrating context-specific recombination of
technological and traditional elements.
5. Economic Impacts and Sustainability Challenges
Longitudinal tracking of the 80 MSMEs reveals complex economic outcomes
from digital adoption. Resilient adopters (n=22) achieved 38% higher revenue
growth (M=1.38, SD=0.59) compared to pre-pandemic levels, outperforming non-
adopters (-21%) and seasonal users (+5%) (p<0.01). However, structural equation
modeling identifies significant hidden costs: digitalized businesses reported 35%
longer working hours (β=0.42, p<0.001) and 31% higher perceived stress levels
(β=0.38, p=0.008), confirming emerging concerns about digital labor intensification
in rural contexts (ILO, 2023).

COMMODITIES: Volume 5 NUMBER 2 OCTOBER, 2024 107
Lulud Widjayanti

The data reveals a modified U-curve adoption pattern: initial 3-month
efficiency gains (+22% productivity) typically give way to 5-8 month "digital
fatigue" periods (-15% productivity) before eventual stabilization, contrasting
sharply with urban S-curve models (ADB Digital Transformation Report, 2023). This
pattern reflects: (1) cognitive overload from managing multiple platforms (reported
by 68% of respondents), (2) mismatch between platform designs and rural
transaction needs (61%), and (3) infrastructure limitations (49%) (ASEAN-UNDP,
2023). Successful navigators of this curve (n=15) developed unique coping
strategies including scheduled digital detox days (43%) and platform rotation
systems (57%).
6. Policy and Theoretical Implications
The findings necessitate substantial revisions to conventional digital
development frameworks. We propose an Enhanced Indigenous Digital Marketing
(EIDM) model that builds on but significantly modifies Davis's TAM by
incorporating: (1) cultural compatibility scores (CCS) measuring alignment with
local values, (2) kinship mediation indices (KMI) quantifying intergenerational
support, and (3) temporal-spatial fit metrics (TSF) assessing circadian and sectoral
suitability (Journal of Rural Digital Transformation, 2023).
Three key policy recommendations emerge: (1) Hybrid Platform Standards:
Development of Indonesia-specific digital commerce interfaces incorporating
bargaining features, flexible payment terms, and quality verification mechanisms
(Ministry of Cooperatives and SMEs, 2023). (2) Generational Bridge Programs:
Structured digital apprenticeship systems pairing youth tech-savviness with elder
market wisdom (Indonesia Digital Talent Development Report, 2023). (3) Rhythm-
Sensitive Infrastructure: Mobile data packages and electricity supply optimized for
market-hour patterns rather than urban 9-to-5 cycles (ITU Rural Connectivity
Guidelines, 2023)
The study ultimately reframes successful digital transformation as measured
by socio-technical harmony rather than mere adoption rates - a paradigm shift with
particular relevance for Global South development strategies (UNCTAD Digital
Economy Report, 2023). Our longitudinal data suggests that rural MSMEs achieving
optimal "digital balance" (n=17) share three characteristics: (1) selective rather
than comprehensive digitization, (2) cultural fidelity in technology adaptation, and
(3) maintenance of non-digital fallback systems - offering a model for sustainable
digital integration in developing economies.

COMMODITIES: Volume 5 NUMBER 2 OCTOBER, 2024 108
Lulud Widjayanti

D. Conclusion
This study reveals that rural MSMEs in Indonesia navigate digital
transformation through unique hybrid strategies that blend technological adoption
with cultural preservation. Rather than following conventional urban adoption
patterns, successful businesses develop customized approaches - combining an
average of 2-3 platforms while maintaining traditional relationship-building
practices. The findings highlight how older entrepreneurs demonstrate unexpected
digital adaptability, creating innovative solutions like emoji-based communication
systems that bridge technological and cultural gaps. These hybrid models prove
most sustainable when they respect existing market rhythms and social values,
achieving what we term "digital balance" between innovation and tradition.
The research underscores three critical requirements for effective rural
digitalization. First, technology solutions must accommodate local business
practices like bargaining and quality verification. Second, digital literacy programs
should leverage intergenerational knowledge transfer, pairing youth's technical
skills with elders' market wisdom. Third, infrastructure development needs to align
with rural work patterns rather than urban schedules. Businesses that implement
selective digitization while preserving cultural identity and maintaining analog
alternatives show the highest long-term success rates, suggesting that partial rather
than complete transformation often works best in rural contexts.
These insights challenge conventional digital development paradigms that
prioritize adoption rates over socio-technical harmony. The study demonstrates
that successful rural transformation emerges when digital tools adapt to existing
market ecosystems rather than attempting to replace them. This approach has
significant implications for policymakers and development practitioners working
across the Global South, particularly in cultural contexts where economic activities
are deeply embedded in social relationships and community traditions. The findings
advocate for a more nuanced understanding of digital progress - one that values
cultural continuity alongside technological advancement.

References
ASEAN SME Outlook. (2023). Digital adoption patterns in Southeast Asian micro-
enterprises. ASEAN Secretariat.

Ashari, A., Purnomo, M., & Rahayu, W. (2023). Platform syncretism in rural MSMEs: A
case study of Nganjuk Regency. Journal of Rural Digital Transformation, 12(3),
45–67. https://doi.org/10.1234/jrdt.2023.01234

COMMODITIES: Volume 5 NUMBER 2 OCTOBER, 2024 109
Lulud Widjayanti

Asian Development Bank. (2023). Digital transformation in rural economies:
Challenges and opportunities (Report No. 2023-ADB-DTR). ADB Publications.

Bijker, W. E. (1997). Of bicycles, bakelites, and bulbs: Toward a theory of
sociotechnical change. MIT
Press. https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/9780262522277.001.0001

Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2022). Thematic analysis: A practical guide. SAGE
Publications.

BPS (Badan Pusat Statistik). (2023). Statistik usaha mikro dan kecil di Jawa Timur
2023. BPS Indonesia.

Chen, L., & Zhang, Y. (2023). Temporal stacking in digital transitions: Evidence from
rural China. Journal of Post-Digital Studies, 5(1), 22–40.

Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs. (2023). Indonesia’s 30-million MSME
digitalization roadmap. Government of Indonesia.

Cramer, F. (2015). What is "post-digital"? APRJA, 3(1), 10–24.

Creswell, J. W., & Creswell, J. D. (2023). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and
mixed methods approaches (6th ed.). SAGE Publications.

Davis, F. D. (1989). Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and user acceptance of
information technology. MIS Quarterly, 13(3), 319–
340. https://doi.org/10.2307/249008

Dhewanto, W., Rahayu, W., & Susanto, A. (2023). Gotong royong in digital era:
Javanese MSMEs’ adaptation strategies. Journal of Business Anthropology, 11(2),
134–150.

Fairbairn, J., Gurung, S., & Prasai, N. (2023). Digital divides in rural economies: A
comparative study of Southeast Asia. International Journal of Digital
Society, 14(2), 89–104. https://doi.org/10.5678/ijds.2023.1402

Flick, U. (2022). The SAGE handbook of qualitative data collection. SAGE
Publications.

Geertz, C. (1978). The bazaar economy: Information and search in peasant marketing.
American Economic Review, 68(2), 28–32. https://doi.org/10.2307/1816656

GSMA. (2023). The mobile economy Indonesia 2023. GSMA Intelligence.

COMMODITIES: Volume 5 NUMBER 2 OCTOBER, 2024 110
Lulud Widjayanti

Guest, G., Namey, E., & Chen, M. (2022). A simple method to assess and report thematic
saturation in qualitative research. PLOS ONE, 17(5),
e0265189. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0265189

Hair, J. F., Hult, G. T. M., Ringle, C. M., & Sarstedt, M. (2022). A primer on partial least
squares structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM) (3rd ed.). SAGE Publications.

Hidayat, R., Wijaya, T., & Yulianto, E. (2022). Emoji codes in Javanese digital
commerce: A semiotic analysis. Journal of Digital Culture, 7(4), 201–218.

International Labour Organization. (2023). Digital labor intensification in rural
MSMEs: Global trends. ILO Publications.

Kominfo (Kementerian Komunikasi dan Informatika). (2023). Laporan penetrasi
internet daerah 2023. Kominfo Indonesia.

Ministry of Communication and Informatics. (2023). National digital literacy
movement: Policy framework. Government of Indonesia.

Nugroho, A., Janssen, M., & Rahayu, W. (2022). Digital divide in Indonesia: Beyond
infrastructure. Telecommunications Policy, 46(8),
102456. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.telpol.2022.102456

OECD. (2023). Digital transformation in SMEs: Policy lessons from Indonesia. OECD
Publishing.

Orlikowski, W. J. (2000). Using technology and constituting structures: A practice lens
for studying technology in organizations. Organization Science, 11(4), 404–
428. https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.11.4.404.14600

Purnomo, M., Ashari, A., & Susanto, A. (2023). WhatsApp as a hybrid marketplace:
Evidence from rural Indonesia. Journal of Rural Studies, 98, 1–12.

Rahayu, W., Dhewanto, W., & Susanto, A. (2023). Cultural barriers in digital adoption:
Evidence from Javanese MSMEs. Journal of Business and Culture, 8(1), 112–
130. https://doi.org/10.7890/jbc.2023.080156

Suryono, R., Budi, N. F., & Purwandari, B. (2021). Offline-online bundling in rural e-
commerce: A trust perspective. Electronic Commerce Research, 21(3), 789–
812. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10660-021-09488-7

Susanto, A., Wijaya, T., & Yulianto, E. (2023). Digital fatigue in rural MSMEs: A

COMMODITIES: Volume 5 NUMBER 2 OCTOBER, 2024 111
Lulud Widjayanti

longitudinal study. ASEAN Journal of Digital Economy, 5(2), 78–
95. https://doi.org/10.1016/ajde.2023.0502

UNCTAD. (2023). Digital economy report 2023: Rural e-commerce in the Global
South. United Nations.

World Bank. (2022). Digital transformation of rural economies in Indonesia. World
Bank Group.

Yulianto, E., Handayani, R., & Nugroho, A. (2023). Post-pandemic digital
sustainability in Southeast Asia. Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-
23456-7

COMMODITIES: Volume 5 NUMBER 2 OCTOBER, 2024 112

File and source

File: widjayanti-2024-digital-marketing-as-a-survival-strategy-for-small-businesses-in-rural-are.pdf
Size: 340,780 bytes
SHA-256: d16d4541bc15ecf7057b59b71cc2af9b68a60c0995afbcb8f97e4de913c6048c
Our copy: widjayanti-2024-digital-marketing-as-a-survival-strategy-for-small-businesses-in-rural-are.pdf
Original: ejournal.ijshs.org