Defendants Reply to Tiie Governm Ent's Opposition to Th E Defendant's M Otion to Dism Iss for Failure to Prow De a Speedy — No. 1:21-cr-20242 (Dkt. 112, S.D. Fla.)
Summary
A reply by defendant Grenon to the government's opposition to the defendant's motion to dismiss for failure to provide a speedy trial, in United States of America v. Grenon, Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA (S.D. Fla.), entered on the docket September 19, 2022 as Document 112. The reply asks the Court to dismiss the case on the grounds that it has been pending for years without a speedy trial. It argues that the court's sua sponte order for an evaluation was not justified, that counsel has not yet been appointed and accepted, and that the claim that the speedy trial clock never began due to the coronavirus is a red herring. It cites 18 U.S.C. 3161 and 3162 and asks for the immediate release of the Defendant. The filing runs 15 pages and is dated September 2022.
Summary drafted by a model from the document's text below and checked by script against that text before publication. It is a navigation aid, not a reading of what the document proves. Where AI is used
Cite this document
“Defendants Reply to Tiie Governm Ent's Opposition to Th E Defendant's M Otion to Dism Iss for Failure to Prow De a Speedy — No. 1:21-cr-20242 (Dkt. 112, S.D. Fla.).”
Archived at Pandemic Darlings, https://pandemicdarlings.com/source-documents/defendants-reply-to-tiie-governm-ent-s-opposition-to-th-e-defendant-s-5208c1610f/
, SHA-256 8e97a597ff68904a1d419a235e45c29f6b69a6816bb3b5d5a0c5ef934e2c98f4.Full text
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered
1
on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 1 of 15
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COIJRT FILEDBbit'-
..-. ... lE
:)-(è
-;
-.1
*
1
l
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLOW DA SEF) 1s 2222 '
f
A,'.
i,
-'izu?,l.i.'kkJOL.E
ct.ûf.qK U.s.DlsT.cm
s.D.OF FLA.-MIAMI
U NITED STATES OF AM ERICA ,
Plaintiff, CASE N O.:21-20242-CR-ALTONAGA
M ARK SCOTT GM N ON
Defendant
DEFENDANTS REPLY TO TIIE GOVERNM ENT'S OPPOSITION TO TH E
DEFENDANT'S M OTION TO DISM ISS FOR FAILURE TO PROW DE A SPEEDY
TRIAL AND PRO SECUTOW AL M ISCONDUCT
DEFENDAN T,M ARK SCO'FT GRENON respectfully m ovesthe Courttodism isstheabove-
entitled cause on thegrotmdsthattlliscasehasbeen pending foryearsand Ihavenotreceived a
speedy trial. , p
PO INT O N E
THE DEFENDANT'SRIGHT TOA SPEEDYTRIAI,W EFEW OLATEDAND THE
FINDG G S BY TH E COURT IN TH E INTERESTS OF JUSTICE W ERE AN ABUSE OF
PROCESSAND CONTM RY TO THE CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS OFA
(
,
-
j
DEFENDANT IIELD W ITH OUT BAIL FOR TW O YEARS.
TheProsecution clnim sthattheCotu'tsua sponteordered theevaluation oftheDefendant.
TheCourtand theProsecution both work fortheFederalGovernment,are agentsofthe
FederalGovernm ent,andboth entitiesare obligated toprovidetheDefendantwhh afaiz
tria!,aspeedytrialiftherewascauseforanevaluationotherthanforthenefarious
purposeofdelayingtlletrial,then theCourtshould nothavem adethesuasponterequest
solateinthejudicialprocess.TheorderwasnotjustiEedby anyarticulablecause;and
theD efendanthad noteven appeared beforethecourtin morethan 714 days,and
thereforetherewasnojustcauseforthemakingofsuchanorder.AstheCourtsaidin
Cardu M iamim fdeCounty Florida,147F.Supp.2d 1334-Dist.Court,SD Florida
y 4.
VS
2n .
z W . Fx' .. zf>.y.z
lz
r
?!k
u p
a,
P' .s
.
',
8 )...'
)' .w<.
1 #
. . .. s .
y
e
',<>-% .:j>,
r.
'-.
V'i
2. .
2. $. .xr . .
.
? o lY
j '
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered
1 on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 2 of 15
2001 tGtheEleventh JudicialCircuit,rather hanthe Cotmty,thatbearsresponsibility for
1 '
ensudng thatsuch evaluationsaretim ely pqrformed.The Cotmty sposition findssom e
supportiniLBrooksM GeorgeC'tpz/ntu 84F.3d 157.168-69(5th Cir.1996)''.Here,the
evaluation isclearly NOT timely and the Defendanthmsbeen in custody foryears,well
beyond thepropertimeline form nking such arequest,especially with no new
inform ation thatwotlldrequire such an order. '
l'heonly eventwllich occun'ed isthe
court'srecognitionoftheextremepassageoftimewithoutajurytrial.
3. TheDefendantrequested counsel,and ithasnotbeen appointed and accepted aseffective
counselyet.TheProsecution,in an nm nzing display ofabuse,seeksin a footnotean order
from tlzecourtprohibiting theappointed counsel9om raising similarm otions,even
though m orepassage oftim ewould entitletheDefendantto bring anotherspeedy trial
motion.Thisisespecially trueconsideling them aterialfactthattheProsecution in one
breath arguesthatthespeedy trialclock hasnoteven begtm,then inthe second breath,
asksthecourtto prohibitretained orappointedcotmselfrom filing orargtling a speedy
trialm otion which may need tobe filedby counselin anotheryearortwo 9om now if
thism otion isderlied andthecasestillhasnotbeen broughtto Z a1???Thisism orethan
outrageous,itisevidenceofaplan,schem e,and artificeby theProsecution to deprivethe
Defendantofafairand speedy trial;itisevidence ofaplan,scheme,and artificeby the
Prosecutionto deptivetheDefendantofspeedy andpublictrial;deprivedefendantofdue
PCOCeSS;
4, Any infonnation orindictmentchargingan individualwiththe comm ission ofan offense
shallbefiled within thirty daysfrom thedate on which guch individualwasr estedor
'
a .
.<
r,
i- q,
;... , .
;..
(
1---
(
,
-
r
-k
E?
---
.
.-.
. . .
gg
j
rj; .,r;
-jy
jk
.... . .
m. t& # ,jrjc
'' (q
. - .m
- . $ .. .
,
0. t
''(y , .
i .
$%yf x
'
s ujjjs
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered
i on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 3 of 15
served with a sllmm onsin connection w1t11such chargesil8U .S.Code 3161-tim e
Limitsandexclusions;18U.S.Code3162-ISanctions.tIndic% entApril22,2021)
5. There existsanotherissue,and thatistheM entalHealthAdministrator'sfailureto have a
policy,procedtlre orsystem in place to m akesureinmatesdo notfallthrough thecracks
isdeliberatelyindiferentastoitsknownorobviousconsequences.Thatthebefendrt
hasbeen incarcerated forsuch alongtim ewithoutthisevaluation,and suddenly and
withoutexplanation,justificationorexcuse,sentbytheCourtforpsyclliatric
evaluation??'
?? W hy wasn'tthisbroughtto the attention ofthecourtwhen theDefendant
wasflrstincarcerated orr ested iftherew asaneed foran evaluation.W hy m oreth% a
yearlater?
6. Thereisno evidencethatacompetency headng wmsheld. Et'l''
heDueProcessClause of
theFifth Am endmentto theUnited StatesConstitution prohibitsthe Govem mentâom
prosecuting defendantswho areincompetent.SeeU.S.Const.Am end.V;D ropeu
Missouri,420U.S.162,171(1975)(''1thaslongbeenacceptedthatapersonwhose
mentalconditionissuchthathelackscapacitytotmderstandthenatureandobjectofthe
proceedingsagainsthim ,to consultw1111counsel,and to assistin prepnring llisdefense
maynotbesubjectedtoatria1.'').TheEleventhCirctlithmsstatedthat''m oradefendant
tobecompetentto standtrial,hem usthave Nsum cientpresentabilityto consult* 111his
lawyerw1111a reasonabledegreeofrationalundersfanding ...and have arationalaswell
asfacttlaltmders
'tandingoftheproceedingsagainsthim .'''Unitedstatesu Rahim,431
F.3d753,759(11thCh:2005)(quotingMedinaM Singletary,59F.3d 1095,1106(11th
Cir.1995:.Ptlrsuantto 18U.S.C.j4241(d),(1).TheCourtinorderingthereferraltook
'1C
'
?A .
3 ?
; '
./..zv
y.. x e-
J/ r? '
N>' b.
v,u #,
z# % 'GN t
,
?.
I
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 4 of 15
l
noneofthese factorsinto accotmt,didnotconsiderthem when hewasGrstarrested,and
didnotexplainwhythesuddenlzrgeovertol
okthecourttomakethisorderSua Sponte.
7. 1: afterthehenring,thecourtfindsby apreponderanceoftheevidencethatthedefendant
ispresently suffering 9om am entaldisease ordefectrenderhv him mentally
incompetentto theextentthatheistmableto understandthenatureand consequencesof
theproceedingsagninsthim orto assistproperly in hisdefense,the courtshallcomm it
thedefendantto the custody oftheAttorney General.
8. Thepreponderance ofthe evidencestnndardrequiresthefactfnderto fm d ''thatthe
existenceof(thejfactismoreprobablethmlitsnonexistence.''Inrem nu
ç/lfp,397U.S.
358,371(1970).
9. According to theEleventh Circuit,a courtisrequired to hold a com petency hearing
w henever there isa ''bona lide doubt''as to the defendant's com petence.Rahim ,431
F.3d at759.In mnking acompetency detennination,theCourtmay consideranum berof
factors,including thedefendant'sbehaviorin thecourtroom ,evidence ofH ational
behavior,and any pziormedicalopinionsasto competence.Drope,420 U.S.at180.
Similarly,the Eleventh Circuithaspermittedthe Courtto consideradefendant'sbehavior
and sttem entsin open coutt lettersdrafted by thedefendant,and previouspsychological
evaluations.SeeRahim,431F.3d at759.
10.'lhereisno evidence theDefendantdisplayed any evidencethathew asnotcompetentto
stand t'
rialand thesua spontedecision by the Courtforan evaluation atthislatedate
surely doesnottollthespeedy trialclock.
11.Becausetherewasnorhymeorremson fortheentry ofthe order,theonly factorthe
Defendantcan believeisthattheprosecution encom aged thecourtto m aketheorder,or
,.Z.
!tt7 . VSn '.>
qt
%.$
,:
r
'
- ft. . : . 4$, N .'. #
.
%!k
Nxx
'...
..X ''
kt%
. -k
,
-w y.
r, r
.. > 'j
l
D
l
I
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered
# on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 5 of 15
' )
theCourtsaw the calendarand did thissuasponte forthenefariousptuw seofdepriving
)
thePlaintifl-with a speedy trial.Eitherscena
'do resultsin thesnm econclusion,the
'i .
I
Defendantisentitled to adismissalofthisaction andto bereleased forthwith.
12.Theclaim isthatthespeedy G aIclock neverbegan dueto the coronavirusisalso ared
hérring,sham and aludicrousargum entconsideringthesimplefactthatzoom hearings
and crim inalcaseswereinstituted alm ostimm ediately afterthelockdowns.Therewasno
interestsinjusticewherethejury,witnesseç,andcourtcoulda11appearbyzoom .'l'he
defendantscotlld havebeen rele% ed on bail.TheD efendantscould havereceived hom e
coM nem ent.The Defendantscould havehadthetrialin person behind screensorwith
masks.'
Fheinterestsofjusticewerenotservedbythe2yearincarcerationofthe
Defendantwithoutjustcause.
13.DefendantmadehisfirstappearanceinAUGUST 20 ,2020,and itisNOW
SEPTEM BER OF 2022. Hehasbeen incarcerated,withoutbail,withouta hearing,
w ithoutappeadng by zoom ,withoutatrial.Theyearsofincarceration dimm ing his
mem ory forpreparation ofhisdefense.Heneverstipulated to any delaysdueto
covidlcovidhasneverbeenisolatedinalabqoranyotherreason.
'rheDefendantadm itsthaton August4,2022,theDefendantmadehisinitialappearance.
Thatmeansthatfrom August20,2020 to August4 ,2022,when thecourtsaw the
Defendantin person,the courtdidnotorderan evaluation,did notquestion theDefendant
aboutthe soundness ofhism ind,and did notobtain any sortofconsentâom the
Defendantforadelay aAerincarceratinghim form oretha11twoyearswithoutbail,
withoutbond,andwithoutoFering him hom econfinement.
gb '
x. :. . .
#t
' /jrl .
. .
rt'.
.
' .
.
.
(;,xx jz?...(?r ',
ij
k
. - .
.
. .
, - r kt? '-'
--r.
,
k
1 ..tkf ., .
yy...,, . .
i;
di
.c.
-e - . * > a- gy
z-'
'
.1.
Jt...y.. a :t
. .<..
.' Z ygj .
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 6 of 15
: '
14.TheProsecutor,aftera1lthetimeIhavebee incarcerated,justmovedforapsychiatric
evaluation withoutgood causeand withoutpropernotice,and certainly forthepurpose of '
I
extending my incarceration and w1111thespecificpurpose ofdeprivingm eofm y rightsto
a speedy trial.
PO G T TW O
TH E PR O SE CU TIO N Dm N O T AD DR E SS T H E SIA LE FA C T TH AT TH EY
CONCEAI,ED EVIDENCE IN THEIR POSSESSION,DID NOT SURRENDER IT
ACCORDING TO THE ORDERS OF TIIISCOURX AND THE CASE SHOULD BE
DISO SSED FOR PROSECUTORIAL M ISCONDUCT.
15.Asallegedin my m otion andnotcontradicted by theProsecution,theProsecution hms
concealed m atelialevidencein thecasewhich could beexculpatory and vitalto my
defense.
16.BecausetheProsecution failed to addressthegrolmds,failed to deny concealing the
evidence,the Courtmustpresum ethem otion istrtze andhasm erit.
17.W hiletheDefendantwasincarcerated,hiscmsebecam eam atterofpublicinterestand
concem to individualswhobelievethatthearrestwasm ongful,and in theireFortsto aid
in hisdefense,sentexculpatory inform ation and studiesto the Prosecution,w1t11the
tmderstanding thattheinform ation wouldbeshared w1111theDefendantwho was
incarcerated and clearly sheltered from theworld.Thisbeliefoftheseorganizationsthat
theprosecution would sharetheexculpatory information wasalso donein relimweon the
orderofthisCourtcom pelling theprosecution to share al1potentially exculpatory
inform ation.
' A1.Cx
'' . .
.z t-
. , .
J ''
,r
-tr)',.
.
6a y)
..
L
%-
r
z
y
-y
c
r
..
.. .,. '.,v. -
J
, ..
,rj
kr
zj
j.
-,,l' ..
J ..&.
.
.:
; - . . : '.)
t -' , j
r,
l
!
szk
sl
k4
k l
k
', '
. *<. .. ,
. r'
.
2
(-s
k
j.
-
. -ajj j'
z
,
1' .
x.'
; I
Jj;
j.
,
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 7 of 15
r
18.'
rheProsecution,however,wmsin possession ofthisevidencerelated tothechargesand
the casenam eand nllmber,and did NOT shar
1
etheinform ation itreceived.Thatasa
resultoftheirfailllreto sharetheinform ation and theirfailtlreto defend againstthese
seriouschrgesm adein theDefendantsmotion dictatethe need foran imm ediate
disrnissal.
Imposition ofsanction /./'
D &&l&Jw/
The federaldistrictcourts ofthis nation possess the inherentpower to regulate
litigation and to sanction litigants for abusive practices.Telectron. Inc. u
O verhead D oor Corp..116 F.R.D.107.126 (S.D.
- F1a.1987);see alsoAoude v.
M obil Oil Corporation.892 F.2d 1115. 1118 (1st Cir.1989)(District Court
possesses the inherentpower to deny court's processes to one ''who defilesthç
judicialsystem by committing agaud onthecotlrt''l;Sun World.Inc.v.Lizarazu
Olivarria,144 F.R.D.384.389 (E.D.Ca1.1992)(districtcourthasinherentpower
toimposesanctionofdismissalordefaultjudjment).Thepowerofanycourtto
manage its own affairs, which necessadly lncludes the authority to impose
reasonableand appropriate sanctionson the partiesto litigation beforeit,isdeeply
rooted in the comm on law tradition.M alautea v.SuzukiM otor Co.,Ltd..987 F.2d
1536. 1545-6 6 (111 Cir.1993),ccrl.den., U.S. ,114 S.Ct.181, 126
L.Ed.2d 140(1993).M
Dism issalisappropriatewhere:
a party has sentiently setin motion some unconscionable scheme calculated to
interfere with thejudicialsystem'sability impM ially to adjudicate a matterby
improperly influencing the trier or unfairly hnmpering the presentation of the
opposing party'sclaim ordefense.
19.Here,the Prosecution was ORDERED BY THIS COURT to share exculpatory
evidence.
20.The evidence they had in their possession was not in the possession of the
Defendantand theDefendanthmsyetto seetheinform ation.
21.lnstead,the Defendantwas told that the inform ation wms exculpatory and was
shared w111:theprosecution andthatitwouldbeshared with him in turn.
22.That inform ation was concealed by the Prosecution.That inform ation was not
- -. ,
.
shared.
.
8
J
z'
jC *è h'
.
utf-:p ,51
*1 %
l.p' )
q; . .''
I**z-,z--..z4'. v ,, ..' '
'
Y .
/ ' . .
<v*.' .
. tq
e' .s>'
p1.t ''
z A' 4
. a,t )f., -<x
U&A .
f.)'
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 8 of 15
I
!
!
23Thatinform ation wasand isexculpatory andlvitaltotheDefendant'sdefense.
.
l
24.Thatthe concealm entofthatinform ation from the Defendantis in contemptof
I
tllis Court,and a violatiön ofthe due process and equalprotection rightsofthe
D efendant.
2à.ThePeoplehaveconcealedthatinformationinordertoobtainanadvantageattrial.
26.Inm inform ed,believe,and thereon allegethatthePeopleare in possession ofvideos,
booksand recordswllich show the substanceforwhich Iam accused ofpossessing isin
fact,acure formany illnesses,andtheinform ation in theirpossession show sthatthe
m aterialwould save otherslives.
27.'
lnhe concealm entofthatinform ation they possessdeprivesm eofthe am rm ativedefense
ofdefense ofothers.
28.Theinformation they possessshowsthatthe substancesarenotdangerous,andthe
pharmacy com panieshave suppressedpatentstopreventthism edicalctlre9om being
distributed,andthatinformation would be and isam aterialaflirmative defense.
29.ThattheProseoutor,in addition to concealingm aterialevidence,hascontinuedto keep
m eincarcerated by di/erentmotionsand means,depriving me ofaspeedy tdal,and the
m ostrecenttactic istheuseofapsychiatricevaluation withoutany causeorevidencethat
30.Clearly,theProsecutorialmisconductisexacerbated by thefactthatthey areintending to
causesevere em otionaldistressby placing m ein an instimtion with dangerouspsychotic
individualsand subjectingmetolmnecessav medicaltreatment,dnlgs,andtestingsolely
to delay my rightto a speedy tdaland to preventme9om having afairG al.
'
'' C
2 w* J
8 -''':
1hk! -. .z.x .
g, v .1.k7.. 4..zr g )p.w j
.
;..
z .4
Z #.
.r x
.
z 'ut
P4'1
ê
8J US-A1' '
,
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 9 of 15
i
1 .
31.Sm diesexistwhich are exculpatory andtheDefendanthmsleam ed thattheprosecution
w msprovided thatinfonnation 9om an nmicusgroup who believesinthe safety and
I
eFectivenessofthesubstanceswhich theDefendantisbeing chargedwith possessing.
32.Thatinform ation could have,and should havebeen shared sincethePeoplewere
ORDERED by thisCourtto shareM L exculpatory evidence.
33.The attached showsthattheinform ation wasprovided by CERTIFIED M M L,RETURN
RECEIPT tothePeople,an
'd they did NOT sharethe sam ewith theDefendant.
34.R'l'heHydeAmendm entis''targeted atprosecutorialm isconduct,notprosecutorial
mistake.''Id.at1304.'
rherefore,to succeed in obtaining an award forfeesand expenses
tmdertheHydeAmendment,''gaqdefendantmust''show thatthegovernment'sposition
tmderlyingtheprosecution nm otmtsto prosecutodalmisconduct''Gilbert.198F.3d at
1299.''Here,wehaveaprosecutorwho notonly deprived theDefendantofa speedy
trial,deprived him ofbail,deprived him ofbond,held him in custody fortwo years;but
nOW hASintentionally concealed 9om theDefendantexculpatory evidence and refused to
justifythesnme.
35.D efendentsspeedy and publictrialhasbeen denied;
Dueprocesshasbeen denied Defendent;
36.m ark scottgrenon fordefendentM ARK SCOU GRENON hasbeen denied Due
ProceSS-
#
37.A saresult,the Defendantisentitledto an immediatedismissalofthisaction.
C O N CLU SIO N
Tltiscasehasgonewellbeyond the wellwithin the30-day limitsetfol'th in the Speedy
TrialAct,18U.S.C.j3161(b)andthecontinuedabuseofprocessesbytheprosecutorby
< C
. vr
. r
f
j
z
jr
.'
à' .,
'
.v
x-
r
1J
::
h.;
' '
@
.. g d ...
..
-v' x
uj
k
f-.
. 1:
J ..
-.
ilk .
v p.
e USA
I
1
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered
( on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 10 of 15
I
concealing exculpatory evidenceand seeldng and obtaining an unnecessary psycltiatric
evaluation issuG cientforthisCourtto i ediately dismisstlziscomplaintand orderthe
'
im m ediate release ofthe Defendant. '
, Respectfully submittedthislotbdayofSeptember,2022.
Signedreservingallmyrights,withoutprejudice,anddemandingaspee,
dyG aIand
release: s
'
x
.?
t'..-?
r.
''i
'*.r.'
.
..'.'
.'c''
.u. ..
. . ).I
-.
,..!
:r.Z'L .
..2z...z.
r :'T.:..r.;..J (.,''....- ;.' .. )
. 2
BY:grenow m ark-scott,W ITHOUT UNI'
TED STATES - FOR N AM ED DEFENDANT
x?
Sw 1. w-..r wu-w (
.
DBA MARK SCOTTGRENON ,.;
(ry
z
'>'! 1'
ê.? 'kky 't;! -.
, -c
., - ' .-
. 4
.' ..
.
> jçr .yg
y
jj
y m y,yy.. j!y;$
-
-i-yj-- y,(yyjë.
,,.
,
y
. ... ..
;zjk-
.
.
.
...
.
. gyr,
,
0 ib . )j,
.........
-
.
-.
' '-
'..
.: >gD
j;.
. r. :
:: &, ) .. y;y -
:. (:j .
t
nj w
m.
'
.... g
# ; ,
'
jw w
kq
(tp
S
'
IZ
.-
.'
.
Z
-Z
-
V -
L. x-
.
.
. . -- .,....,
:ï.,....
c-
.
,:--, .,
.. -
''
.
-. '' ''
i . J:'''
. z C '
...,. '
.
z
1 :.-- .
.
-q 'z
.-. ''.'
t . *. L :
1
L
..1
:t-'.
y':
J
.'
-.t
p(è
-'7 !-
,i
;!:
2
.-
- .t3'.$ï.'-,- ., . '
.
..
.
.
t-
,
. . ) > a ' -; !. t .
' -
- s.
vj.
.
! '
.gj
#. -- -
.
i J ... >
. ,.
Qj J7
:
-
r -k
z' ... c 1
!
d
.
k....u .
.
.
/ Ujjj'
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 11 of 15
7
CERTIFICA E OF SERW CE
Thetmdersigned certé
' esthatthe foregoing wassenttothefollowing peoplein the
!
specifed m nnneron the 1 ay ofSeptember,2022.
Prosecutor DeliveredorCertifiedMail Jotl otqD D* l t3!tiçFF
M ichaelHomer
John Shipley Jr.99NE 4thSt,M inmi,FL 33132
Clerk ofthe CourtDelivered orcertified m ail
AngelaE.Noble
40'0 N *M inm iAve., M inm i;FL 33128
Signedreservinga11mylights,withoutprejudice,anddemandingaspeedy trialand
release: i.
-..E
-. '- q E-'
' ' .'.
.' . '
'
. -. -
.
;...:t,.
. fs..;,
t f
-;'
.j...
j... .g ;Jj.;..
..j.
,, r
'..:.
:k
-.
y (
.'
E
.
. g
.
'
).
L'
. .' .
BY:grenon,m arkmscott W ITHOUT UNITED STATES- F0R NAM ED DEFENDANT
Z-j.WNQU.X '
cw'-wrwMw'-o'-. -Fy.'
%Z'
.
J
X.%%'
*
M ja ar
x o,
w . '
DBA M ARK SCOTT GREN ON ' Ci$ >);., . .J.
- ,!/ ,'K 1 '? R . .
- . .
e'
1 ,' .Q:2 ' i$ '' L
.
. ' ... '
-' h
. .::. . ... ..
. eq .
!' '(':. .. .
'
-w-- i
b-5
- :1f
:'
i
''' -
4
$
t
1l
1
C(
l- 9
''''' 'V '-'
sn.
?j'-
)y.- k
..
,,
p..
-
.x4.-
w ,
-
-. -
! 't
k- ' 'k
-
h .ç,, :
.e '
-' s!cl 'qk .-' --->
'!'
. . Zl .< '*w.
. :
. L
,
ovv
s '---u
. ...
fy
,
...-
,y>..
. .
. ;. .
..
- .% .
. . :j.l.
rx.
. .
.- kj.
- , tk
. .o
yj,
- v
, -
-.
8 .
o! ;j. ;,.
. .
.
'
r
J
+-
'
.t<lz
..
œ.' .
- * ..
- o l
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 12 of 15
Health andhealing onestpp atatimessM
aPrivate M emberA ssociation
980RogersLakeRoad
suiteB .-1
KilaMontanaj99207
W osecuing attcm eys
M ICHAEL B.HOM ER
AssistO tUnited StatesAttom ey
CourtID 1$10.A5502497
99 Northeast4+ Street
M iam 1 Florida 33132-2111
dJoulsupleyzr.
99NE 4*st
Miami,Floljda33132
regardipgcasentlmber21-20242-CR-ALTONAGA
GreetingsProsecutingattom eyM ichaelHomerandProsecudngattomeyJolanShipleyJr,
ibeliqvdyou areattempe gtopm secatvindividualswhobelieve1t1thevalidl.tyofthesestttdtesmad ar'
e
concqmedthatthepublichèalth isatgreétriskbecausethebigpharmaceuticalcompM iesàre
concealinghow life-savingthisproduetis.ltilearl# jsavzidargumentthatlhepossession,
distrlbution oruseofthisproductisintèndèd notto causehnrm,butto savelives.You ar: zitlilgand
abetungtheconcealm entofaçure'
form àny dlàéases.
menandwomenfroniourgrouphavesome12 ormation thatwefeltkltptlldbebroughtto your
,
attene n; l
l
endosçd isan 80 pagebook called:
'f'f'
heUltiversalM tidote/'fheSdenceand Story ofChlorineDioxide''
andipcludedisasmdyonKeAlddeUDDERgOIdPlaunum''10pages
By tléalthProduçtsRegulatoryAuthority
Ouïm en andw b
,m e
n investigatecm estllatarebeingkeptfrom m ankindby Big Phnrmacy;
Ourgoalisto br
.m'g abo
,uthealth andhenling fnrmankind onestep atatime; cjwvcXn j- y .-?-px4.>#N
îks%t
'
tusl-
l-4- t'cserw:'
1
z$'<.;c-oE-
.e, , .0x.Au t
t-1, pt
rei-àpz-utz,:,xa
Sm
- cerely, zv y Gwx-
.
'
i.
v; . .y
& -*w.
. zr . emx c
& ,ya..tq .J
vypvsxei
. ks
'yx
::v,#...zg
;x..
,
.
/
.
1
:.
;
(
:n
.
,
:
7L
'
.
t.
q
'm
.
=
.b
wtp.,
t
y
'xj-..
1.
Z
J VSI
A . rn'
r
gj* v x'
w-w ..
x 2z, ne .
.j
It
9 g'
e' xh.
GX
) ..x
.ltj .f
.
%x .J'
w=
..
. .
z..F ... .T/
a ..> ' ' vg'-'r
eiQz '
'
. 1 *tv
' o
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 13 of 15
ntii'ltit
',lncllerstl
bmit
sanl
kmatadeënakuUAPS' ?Priojty
'MslL-qpres'
s'
D
lûcoi
llœpetan
y- cc
bnell
tccal
bi'a
ouc !l
ncn9ol' jd depos!
l11especjf
klplf tti
me,t
luPû$la1Scf#icawlldall
ii
kp?pllempt
del
kaqltoî
ht
)ar
lt
fr
qreeitqynttatoretll eexll
cabledel
iver
ydal
pandtknaQalerl'.f
ke
t /rcqtest$1:
ctltwszeo'ssknattt
i'
qff
éilljhjraldfcsseatyendel i
veàydlh:i tambytllk ôckfngtla'slgqïi
tll
kt 3.Bepostalsenrkeinsqras'rnxl
flmtlmd'baxatthetînk'
lplni ai
ll
ypI iglePnqi .
qfSewl cedneoî lctdglikf
trtlratertytdalva#jy112 mgt laticas)agalnstl css,dama:
sptclf
iadti
mear:
twûsscneqppt bf
fheInalllt ilkI.
4vait
'
ba.$t41stvl
lappl
r
dclaîmif
agJlant
û rair
rd.
l
e
eftm
clt
l,tl
hptr
e
'
l
lèrtsl
a-
Pœy iltlplti
kpsIhï
ctlw
'
snj
illre
lrel
l
mdtf
-
vi
éplj
thncmt
t
z.
'-
# l
(
p,
ax
tlgall reamsRucZcn,stzlectw 'addi tk
Malu:
tl(Dl$
Ilw
'f)204.
9.
53î
vlll
c
.lipwj
il
ab:Bpsl
mps-
cûm. ' t'ataelfnpll'lctxcurrence.Dco,lg
reaslxabl:ccstlcctlrl' elIRrec
Dthctllpaalrexns:udcc:sux
moackr shcql dcataltempttôpaJ
4.d 7)auPnmarltlnsnrarkce(svcld
stalSafklclilnsurtislkut
tmctmver:dtormKllv/lllol al
s.'rhepist alSar vi
vgdceilnlyh
cfdday&lpgtvllyMallF- spres,
acdwù'œalmpcyellypaclu;ï
cweraga,tem% &?JlllnlutfnnsnK
cavetag..ccl tqltl,e1)h!1
tI,k vl
ïd
'
l
aa
mdamc
f/alal
wcn
l
zkmc
tmalumalna
wd nfcrr
tq
laï
:.;
è
:': .
opJp
(?
it
Oag/
mlccnelf
rt
a afl
el
wlscza&qI*zr
-b
Tt
Mn
.
llk
'
4aJfl
.
frPoù- taleeldq:dûftlltl
ill.
tk
lf,
erf
lmrley.
làni'llt/
- té
aljlpleaf lklkg'
y(1rDPMtstfpmtml edel
ayed
dqatl..l$ftltvlïrl
h
gsîlspôcli
ftlh
st!
l1lI
(tif
jli)wf.
t
sdest i
qdtcr(1 fIAPOJFFI/I JIPOtlt'lvct
sflll
n' f
d:Blh; s fl fle a/cetl
klcnltdlt lgalder
' iveTptlkflll xtl
yv?(#)et
qlsedby' imauftl uuftkt .
l
')fyzl
I1l)K/6+1: 9.5.5.Cqll t
sal llan7dap idr/latelhl
t m624
0SPS. cio1 lt:#crplr24*41/*71j illwpfwJlkrfûal iaàcrktl iva'
aT tlkw'l
t- i
l'
l
'
tlp
ltsqlxlf
' txi
ll
- tyMa1 ccntelz.-lmmetlktdyilntflola1
-Mpfesst
C kllilk
v!/8adO(P*EQE )J.'
I-4.
'
r:î1.?l ;,t
:il, aeDàI
M702!. ;$'
dj
I(2
hls(ss
p
al:
kkl
tl.
l
i >,
l/zatl œm. tlbPsmlallmcelptQreRecelpl/l
dalnagecrmixlngcontenls,als.
Whenamai lersubmlt
s&ps
'
f
tlî
tyî/:k4iïtjplqp: t
l
;lf
dnip *rlgai/
fl '':
-
f
jslqf'
zimdlMPa9l '
)1Dûlvi
l cecannn! lnspetûnwhenfequested-
dat
11l
k
l
'
laarl
t
d
ld
t la
el
ft
sa
sm
eeth
9pI
d han
a?f tl
ps
r
j at
da ïl1
ie
l) ltl
ll
-l
t1
tk
)
lnI
i !
.
4ll
Wli
h#ki
t ll
1ni
v
$ç
fke
l
tqse
p lk
il
v
r p x
pl
hl
l(
jki
.
j-
s
dan I.
3 g
ûti
y t
i
kthS
r4 .
ea
l
'f ces
ke
t
wli re l-
ftl
fm '
t
fp tefltc
ith:i Ree
lufl
tlcfPos
htat
ppmlFeeza(1
(Pe )itcmdneunotr
ceett
has(
$est
mdet'
ttjlonddfl
knalcharghi. . ctl
stemer :magellmpar dtlndl
(6r
s .è
?.' xftlrtdretjueste-
îtbtrqnrneatt/
Igstrlplzoreverv
- ......-- - ... -
- - ..-
g(
.
i:b fhaPoskla stltvlcikj lix ivs ffatlil t:î tai; w. 'p ylkl fltwt' tlltllflt 2vf il hjl pjla! baseka-llc:lnoscnnelmallzi
l'egtlal iol, vin!1:
. .$9 $. w1y( 11! plywlkf lyh)tt lj?p. epp mcdl n:l' lpf ylylkllml t'
if nrl!11aCs pt f
al tcl ypes/1 Servlcesfeqsrelgnurequeslslf
ltpit
ze:lmte;
f eccval' ed,t llelirfl-fplljpif?; 1cl'ptst l
ityskllnscf. jl4lji 3ljl:
,A,tmnf l
it -
mnsnfI xl yll eûtand ffcmQzdqtqofma' l-
llng.Eachlr
fltleai' zllpmcedt zok.()f lrket
-
ljf-
il!
a'lt;igkfyt ulIh' .
'tg'.1l Jkt'f' /lf. E):. :!:1pt ;'t
!
;1i J01fcdpz' :rt ifpl atlola,and Restlrtdfeqtle*sf0rP).% (TP)2
tU
't
tSPSpnyoaûe!aralxiar.
J
al
?/1y '
cjwl' ea11:tm11 :11 41:1Pà
sly zndSudl
-a- l/Ql! )tsflvk!
1
ptlt
.
t lts(!lFtgvflll
k-II,! '
rtl î1! 1
essl
!cpmak.
pg 'il 4l
i
qtdgi
mt;rt
(
yT tdl
l'(I
tf
k1
zlmst
)n1ticc'
alEqf
lllt
vl
pls.Amalar
c'ababfe Ttl
aakpaJprc#f/
pa
egPt1
OA
s'
ulml tlfïefli t
entLkf lltalbnspl tscli tktkkljljàr flI.1)Jl y1))mv- 1
d( .
,).)l()y$t ,1119: Tranhlng:RrUSPSTracldng,
1.las,l rancaahvamëeexkndstplleaql ptilk vsl kpo1lki ïlcnnt '
eI iti'.
k.jj lt!tlhltj( 3lmai l
il gQrtlf e
cocl()lr epaklll cltcaxcdtkcI nsti /tk
jll jpi 4I nlld t,i lqm, i't' f- .
oltvqt
'
y
s-
N
vm
p-z.t
q--lI
w
.
2' T haP
'mcf
osll
cik-
nl
li
lt
r
t 1
'p
pa*
ici
'lle'
irlstze2*qc
ladbyppsla.
mtûntt
lJapulalr
ïtj llrJl
?ll
yl'hi
ltyti
ti t Klpllr
al>lglc
-
.
s
%yresl '
z'
%daiitykqrIni
hi#clk 'li
t ,
f
:l
Iis(
sql
Cl
gt
fqlns
;ûltl
(rp1l)
mtsrlll:
. c ,t- s .
..
,
Plzt' llSclpc?l cil tç ducovemgeqpt e.sltlhtt- t
rk 'f ifi lir th dœatnb'
C adtlli axgf l
3ll'r tlil,Adtktl tmaf jt j
a
cj
.
pw
.j,.
. 2 4,.4Isa
% g
z.
an
l'
j
lerpik nll
tls:l qtlr mOyptp$5. 010p:fJ!1 :gf#,lf?e' .
!yk l-.tq/bacvei? aklé();pt lftlltsti .Adtl il
snlal ,.,
Il
nunllc:InrPnt m:NlalExpmssi tenksxIl(l t4it ?; $i1k 1I.$Ii)tl fless4Gl @attl qll :;ftllt ft
li dda 1 4y...)....
1
.y.
-
' l.è.*
.q'
# s $-
nt
:
G&F-'''F
o a'q K'
j
X'' g'>: VY0*
.9,oK
't
'
t
i
3e ?.>
)1
. ,
.1%,' .
IM EL11* MAY2œ1 PôN71$99.92.401999Q
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 14 of 15
Dear
i Barb,M ark,Jordan, Jonathan,andJoseph,t
l
ncareofBarb t
HeaIthand HealingonestepatatimeSSM woulj liketo infofm youthatthe menandwomen
heratbl
possi this PMA are behind you and w ould Iike to send donations and supportin any way
e-
,
we would Iike to thank you forhelping us to fix thousands ofm en and wom en w i th your
ofthe M iracle Chlori share
ne Dioxide;
we have sentaIIofthis research USPS # EI073 040 442 US to the Prosecuting attorneys i
hopesthatthey cansee the mistake thatthey arei m aking w ith prosecuting m en fortrying ton
helpsave peoplesIives;
W esent' rhebook:TheUniversalA ntidoteffheScienceand Story ofClzlorineDioxide
sentlinltsto allofthevideosforthe PA to watch
sentthesmdlonAlddeuddergoldplatinum anditstates'fthesafetyoftheproductforhnmansandthe
envhnnmentlsacceptable''
Blessingsanthony
- C
A' .
.
km ,
z -. s.6à, x .N t.z
-
. m.
a .gsA
)2-
6
'
J.'QP'. ew.rz ., . ' ....x-.rk-wvlri-w
. . .' r E-t $ .
Case 1:21-cr-20242-CMA Document 112 Entered on FLSD Docket 09/19/2022 Page 15 of i15
. ...sw
. ..=..tz-- $. ..' 2....'2Z&h
-:.
x#'- ..=..'s.....- .
. .f
''
>
j .% ,:
s
.'7
r) ' $:
.
r
ù
:'
A-
:r
yv
e
'
1,
w..r-
x--F
''. . >..-
- . 6
1 .
$
! *'e : 1
I'1jf-
*
..
Y
J
5.
.:
r
,
i,
C
.
'
-
*.
-=.
T
s
'
w
) -.
1!
7
;
''.
'
b
;. '' .' '' '. ''C
'
:
k
'-
''.
,''
.
:
-
.
' ' '.'. .
l !.r v' .z u. .1 w .. 'e
e'o
v%#
r =K
. '
. .
, PRESS FIRMLY TO SSXL ..
.< '.- - - .-
.
l PRES%41 . . '
' F='G' =' ' . ,'
' l
'
.1
'
k , PRIO RITY
,
tw lrm STATES M g ju
.
go ggsm wcso ux pqussO
'
.
.
u ' (
v= FROM:laexg- ejosul )
.
.
.
,
l .
çe
...:........ jw c x jv.z. a s. , .. z
;.k.
1.
.A. . j . 4
- u '-..
.
.:, .
. .
' '
.
W; poa ::
I,
.
oz
t
v
. :$.. .
.c+
. . 'v ...:.
.. . ''.
,:'
'
1 *Y eo - -- -wou- *> >..=.....x** me '
' .
' ' , - -
. ,. :
'....
1.' ) oNE RATE w ANY W EIGHT C1'*
u-'
*t
u
-'
da'o-ne-(
--vi'
er
--'-*.
.
.
i
. (..N-.zd t Es
.-.,..o% ps.
= eer- M ojfe œ > A=o:e
...t p
. .. I. . To:m -
. .. ....ï ;z.
. . rzk.x)Net )
' .
..
..:. . (. S> l
, .- yh.
,cd.a x
. '. '..'. .;
ua
k.'
I.-...
. Toschecjujejtrhe
ee .
Package P'
IGMUP, ér $
1w. Cq/'f D 3....
-
. .. a -i ' -,. ...x,rw - scan QR code. .
. .. , (,,Le..â;u<,.i , ,,..1
' . . o- rymw vtlv
. , . ... . . .
a . .: .. K x jzorpl- aruspsAaœnr.visllUSPA=OG =llKwzzz.luj:.
- . . .., o , . $jx x lnsllwlxoInauue
.
' ,. . ..'g.
d '.l ..: . ... khsy:ul,.e.vA.
y':
. . .1 . .....-.1d. J)), ;; USPS.COM/PICKUP pEEu FnoM THIS CORNEB..?q
pr '-'
.
, < i '
.. # ..;
. .'
. .
.
' ; .v
.. ' :' . pS10001000006 EplaF May 2020
; l'
. . '1 $-...:.,. , ''
z . .. . g ..
: j
e.' ...
r.-. rt . . o .
l , '
# . .
-. -' '
. . . .. pg... F . . 1.à.r. . .
., a
. i ..
. . a
.....z.
'
. . .n.U..'j
,t'.&=.
. w. 7.
mr.x
,.;.ik'.s. .
r'
-. '
i,.
kj-z YJt-
'
,
'
. .. . .
. $! '.Ei
..
1.
..'
u-
y.
0.
3
.' . q
ku
s'
a.!
.x
.
r
.,
'
.er'..c..., . ..
.i.
A .
v .-,..>.;., q.
. . . .,ûl3J .. k?: u.;. . tejuriv.. .4. .,-14a tt.!l1.,
*
. ...,g: . ...
.. . ..
,. .-.
..
. t.
:...'..ls.s:.. . , .. 2 t.t.
-8.k:....,kvX. z-.J..
.
2.7g..':i5*j=- Af
5.u
...
t
.
.y .k.....r.:-.k-., z..!.
..I ....,.-j.',r:f
j.,J'.i'#->. .
.'
...- .:
%s '. 'r
. w r = J :
%
'' ''. :'
w .,..';'-:'
. kw.5'.)I6
gtX.
..K.:ky t% . ;.&'..'# . ( .
.)t..k!.q.'F
;)<yjsj.C
r'qw... .k- .:vl
!t
zk
>
zo..E'c# 1 .)';r.' .@. ta. .
u'
u' .
i?.& 1$. !:
p% Ju'...,!1'''r..,. .
. ... . >..1 !
-
.
o
w .1
.œ...%'.t - .. 1.' .4.1;. z :...tv> f
.: â ; ,.'...6) .'1. (ç . -i
-
1 q
:
.
> ..z
: 'z:ô3
t &..-,.
.
... I ( u ,' .:z
4
-. .. ' -.u - $
..
: ?I.N
'A.l>..
)z '':
.c.:. ..'.t
a - p . n rc r
..=xl ts .. A : r:x&@ ; ,c J .
h - ,
w'-'i' :.1'
- u .- v t
w z-
.' '. .,t..j'>
r$ .
.'
.,' .6
?.p .z
+Te.5..:
k:w.... z . .';..
Q#.z.'kç.-.
t a.
''d I. '
''' '. '''':l.*.'a. '.'d.
,'-.x.
p' j7r,
/ t!
! ..
L.u
r*
''%..>$. $'
#
F''
v
''; , <..
.k
,.w.x
#'
.v
P
'r'
'
,. .. ...
x:
..&+, ,.,, J'
,
'*t'..
n . '. . .
J'' ''T.'q!-e' 'j *'!. Aj.
..p i...;=' l')..'F.'
sZ ..
..
' ; ' i .
tI j .!' .... .
' i' '
.'
. J
.i (qjl. . ..
p# .* . vw, r .. .' k .;.'' y . A l
. '' Jk . j fr
;:.
' .> ! a :
; ?T. *'
. . .. :
. : r f , g .J
'
*'
..
w ..
'.
.
l ,xaj
.$: :.v.ax
....,.u
-
.k
.) .
))
?
y;.'! '
L,
-4a
g
I
gj
.q:
s.'.
, g
',
..
I
ijjyz
. . ...
JY
(
.
g
fjk
' v
!
r
./. .a
s .
$
' *
. 1 . : A.u .J'
.w
;.
)
j
=)
''i
*
.
*,1:1.'. a..lh'ï'.y4
..
.
'>
'. .J :l
;
. ki n n
u..
;
.. . $ . . -- .#
I .. ,. .
I. yl
* ?' . t . i . :j !y.j
# )
x . ..
,
.:.
1,
jt .d,
î.
.' tW'''
h..' . 0. $ q jjg.vr.,. .' . ' *'
'
. ? .
. .. ' : I y .'2 . ,
.1 .
zv. J
. , . q
.!!''z-.
'. <.'. :
..z!
( . *. . . .. ..x ; 1
('.
J1
.R*'.>. ur . . ' 0.. ' . '' $T f ' ' ' ''
.'.I'.
Q.j
..C..
. .
' X w *' k
l j
. f . . a u .y .#
. I . c . x : .. ..w.
. zi !'t..'.z'
?.7.
, j- ;. r. r, '''' . ..........t ... '...It';.ir.. >./' g5
z
.
File and source
- File
- 112.pdf
- Size
- 856,198 bytes
- SHA-256
- 8e97a597ff68904a1d419a235e45c29f6b69a6816bb3b5d5a0c5ef934e2c98f4
- Our copy
- 112.pdf
- Original
- No public link identified.