Pandemic Darlings The pandemic economy, in original documents
Home Source documents Senate Session of February 3, 2021, Page S304 — Congressional Record

Senate Session of February 3, 2021, Page S304 — Congressional Record

Summary

Page S304 of the Senate section of the Congressional Record for February 3, 2021, in interleaved columns, as the Senate considers S. Res. 30 to amend a resolution of the Ninety-eighth Congress. Mr. Blumenthal, reserving the right to object, calls the measure a pretextual, ideological and extreme step and says the country is fast approaching 450,000 deaths, with more than 3,000 a day, which is his view. Another speaker says about 20 percent of working adults cite disrupted childcare arrangements and that women accounted for all jobs lost, and a further speaker describes rural internet access challenges in Arkansas.

Summary drafted by a model from the document's text below and checked by script against that text before publication. It is a navigation aid, not a reading of what the document proves. Where AI is used

Cite this document

“Senate Session of February 3, 2021, Page S304 — Congressional Record.” Original at www.govinfo.gov. Archived at Pandemic Darlings, https://pandemicdarlings.com/source-documents/crec-crec-2021-02-03-crec-2021-02-03-pt1-pgs304-0102b528be/, SHA-256 17c89c1f68f70b57df91a151282603f1d100a8c33734b9e764fabe75ba6b4861.

Full text

                                               S304                                              CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                   February 3, 2021
                                                 The PRESIDING OFFICER. The                              Here is the reality when it comes to                   The Senator from Connecticut.
                                               clerk will report the resolution by                     what happens in the midst of this pan-                   Mr. BLUMENTHAL. Madam Presi-
                                               title.                                                  demic: We know that families have                      dent, reserving the right to object, this
                                                 The senior assistant legislative clerk                many reasons they can’t make ends                      measure, essentially, is a pretextual,
                                               read as follows:                                        meet, but, also, many families have                    ideological, and extreme step that real-
                                                 A resolution (S. Res. 30) to amend S. Res             members of their families who want to                  ly detracts from what should be our
                                               458 of the Ninety-eighth Congress, as amend-            get back to work. We are told that                     primary purpose at this moment in our
                                               ed.                                                     about 20 percent of working adults say                 history.
                                                 There being no objection, the Senate                  the reason they are not working is that                  Literally, we are fast approaching
                                               proceeded to consider the resolution.                   COVID–19 has disrupted their childcare                 450,000 deaths in this country, and peo-
                                                 Mr. SCHUMER. I ask unanimous con-                     arrangements. So it is both a childcare                ple continue to die at the rate of more
                                               sent that the resolution be agreed to                   access and affordability question.                     than 3,000 per day. Our economic
                                               and that the motion to reconsider be                      The Bureau of Labor Statistics tells                 progress continues to be stalled. In
                                               considered made and laid upon the                       us that women accounted for all jobs                   fact, it is declining, with joblessness
                                               table with no intervening action or de-                 lost in December of 2020—not most                      increasing across Connecticut and the
                                               bate.                                                   jobs, not some jobs. All jobs lost in the              country. People are struggling to stay
                                                 The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without                        United States were among women.                        in their homes, put food on their ta-
                                               objection, it is so ordered.                            Women lost 156,000 jobs. Their labor                   bles, and pay for the medicine they
                                                 The resolution (S. Res. 30) was agreed                force participation rate is at its lowest              need. Our goal should be making sure
                                               to.                                                     point in a third of a century. One of the              people have vaccines and the economic
                                                 (The resolution is printed in today’s                 big reasons is childcare. We need to ex-               support that they need. Instead, we are
                                                                                                       pand the child and dependent care tax                  here on a measure that would, essen-
                                               RECORD under ‘‘Submitted Resolu-
                                                                                                       credit to give parents the ability to re-              tially, take away rights, burden rights,
                                               tions.’’)
                                                                                                       coup thousands—not hundreds but                        for people—women—who need that
                                                 Mr. SCHUMER. Thank you, Madam
                                                                                                       thousands—of dollars in childcare ex-                  right.
                                               President.
                                                                                                       penses.                                                  We ought to be focusing our energy
                                                 I thank my good friend, the Senator                     That is what my legislation will do.
                                               from Pennsylvania.                                                                                             and attention on winning our fight
                                                                                                       That is what the new administration                    against this pandemic, but, instead, we
                                                 I yield the floor.                                    wants to do, and that is what we should                are here, debating a pretextual and ide-
                                                                f                                      do in this next COVID bill, and there                  ological bill, another anti-choice bill—
                                                                                                       are a lot of reasons for it.                           yet another attempt to restrict a wom-
                                               SETTING FORTH THE CONGRES-                                I will end with this. Last year, the
                                                 SIONAL     BUDGET     FOR  THE                                                                               an’s right to choose about when and
                                                                                                       National Academy of Sciences released                  whether to have a child. This bill pur-
                                                 UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT                              a roadmap to reduce child poverty. We
                                                 FOR FISCAL YEAR 2021—Continued                                                                               ports to be about protecting individ-
                                                                                                       have heard of the good provisions in                   uals with Down syndrome, but it is
                                                 The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                       this legislation on the child tax credit
                                                                                                                                                              merely     a   pretext   for    requiring
                                               ator from Pennsylvania.                                 and the earned income tax credit and
                                                                                                                                                              healthcare providers to scrutinize
                                                                 S. CON. RES. 5                        of the substantial impacts they have
                                                                                                                                                              women for their decisions to seek an
                                                 Mr. CASEY. Madam President, I will                    had on lowering child poverty—one es-
                                                                                                                                                              abortion. The pretext is to take away
                                               continue with the brief discussion                      timate, by half.
                                                                                                         Also contributing to this and to                     those individual rights.
                                               about home and community-based                                                                                   As a matter of fact, this bill has
                                               services.                                               lower child poverty even more would be
                                                                                                                                                              nothing to do with protecting people
                                                 It is so critical, as I mentioned ear-                to enhance the child and dependent
                                                                                                                                                              with Down syndrome, and it has noth-
                                               lier, to have these services available                  care tax credit. Here are the numbers:
                                                                                                       9.2, 9.2, and 518. What do I mean? The                 ing to do with addressing discrimina-
                                               for seniors and for people with disabil-                                                                       tion. If my colleague would like to
                                               ities, and it is also relevant in the life              National Academy of Sciences says
                                                                                                       that, if you have a robust child and de-               genuinely help people with Down syn-
                                               of a child. We know—and as the Pre-                                                                            drome, he would ask for unanimous
                                               siding Officer knows well in her efforts                pendent care tax credit, you can reduce
                                                                                                       child poverty by 9.2 percent. Guess                    consent on legislation that the dis-
                                               to provide these services to those in                                                                          ability community actually has sup-
                                               the disability community and among                      what happens to wages. There are
                                                                                                       raised aggregate earnings across the                   ported. The National Down Syndrome
                                               seniors—that it is important to chil-                                                                          Society wants increased funding for
                                                                                                       country also by 9.2, but it just happens
                                               dren as well. Medicaid home and com-                                                                           medical research at the National Insti-
                                                                                                       to be billions—$9.2 billion. Then the 518
                                               munity-based services provide over $4                                                                          tutes of Health. It wants better edu-
                                                                                                       refers to the jobs—increased net em-
                                               billion right now in support so that                                                                           cational opportunities and settings for
                                                                                                       ployment by more than 518,000 jobs ac-
                                               children can receive therapy and other                                                                         people with Down syndrome. It wants
                                                                                                       cording to the National Academy of
                                               necessary services to participate in                                                                           laws and policies that ensure economic
                                                                                                       Sciences.
                                               school, and as I mentioned earlier, we                    So, among the many, many things we                   self-sufficiency and better workplaces
                                               know the impact upon seniors and peo-                   are doing in this bill, we need to invest              and a fight against discrimination.
                                               ple with disabilities. So that is the rea-              in home and community-based services                     Those are the legislative priorities of
                                               son we are emphasizing, among many                      and also invest in a much more robust                  this disability community, but what
                                               reasons, the investment in this bill for                child and dependent care tax credit.                   this bill actually does is it essentially
                                               home and community-based services in                      I yield the floor.                                   requires healthcare providers to inter-
                                               the context of the pandemic and the                       The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                      rogate women about their decisions to
                                               devastation of the virus and more                       ator from Oklahoma.                                    seek an abortion. Healthcare providers
                                               broadly.                                                       UNANIMOUS CONSENT REQUEST—S. 75                 who might violate this bill, if it ever
                                                 The second issue I will raise—I know                    Mr. INHOFE. Madam President, I ask                   became law, would incur fines, impris-
                                               we are short on time—is an issue that                   unanimous consent that the Com-                        onment, or both.
                                               I mentioned earlier. In addition to                     mittee on the Judiciary be discharged                    In conclusion, people have a right to
                                               home and community-based services,                      from further consideration of S. 75 and                make these kinds of deeply personal
                                               this is an issue that relates to the fam-               that the Senate proceed to its imme-                   decisions. Those rights are protected
                                               ily’s ability to pay for childcare. So it                                                                      under our Constitution. We should be




SSpencer on DSK126QN23PROD with SENATE
                                                                                                       diate consideration. Further, I ask
                                               affects the parents as well as the chil-                unanimous consent that the bill be                     protecting people with Down syn-
                                               dren. It is the child and dependent care                considered read a third time and passed                drome, and we should be expanding
                                               tax credit. Obviously, it is an existing                and that the motion to reconsider be                   their opportunities and fighting dis-
                                               tax credit, a credit that parents have                  considered made and laid upon the                      crimination, not using them as a pre-
                                               been able to rely on, but it is nowhere                 table.                                                 text for restricting and burdening a
                                               near robust enough to make it possible                    The PRESIDING OFFICER. Is there                      woman’s right to choose.
                                               for more parents to afford childcare.                   objection?                                               Therefore, I object.



                                         VerDate Sep 11 2014   06:24 Feb 04, 2021   Jkt 019060   PO 00000   Frm 00032   Fmt 0624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G03FE6.054   S03FEPT1
                                               February 3, 2021                                  CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                                 S305
                                                 The PRESIDING OFFICER. Objec-                           Tragically, instead of helping to pre-               BLACKBURN. Senator INHOFE’s bill, the
                                               tion is heard.                                          serve, strengthen, and sustain the lives               Protecting Individuals with Down Syn-
                                                 The Senator from Oklahoma.                            of women and children abroad, our tax-                 drome Act, would affirm that disability
                                                 Mr. INHOFE. Madam President, I                        payer dollars have been used to harm                   does not determine or demean the dig-
                                               have a hard time with that, I say to my                 women’s lives and to end the lives of                  nity and worth of a human life. And
                                               friend from Connecticut.                                their unborn children, especially baby                 Senator BLACKBURN’s bill would ensure
                                                 Somehow, in protecting those with                     girls.                                                 that taxpayer funds under the Title X
                                               Down syndrome, you are killing those                      In some of these countries, girls are                Family Planning Program do not go to
                                               with Down syndrome.                                     disproportionately aborted, precisely                  any facility that performs or provides
                                                 Right now, I am really shocked that                   because they are female. U.S. aid is                   referrals for abortions.
                                               people would talk about protecting                      used not to affirm the equal dignity of                  In our laws and throughout our lives,
                                               children. The previous speaker was                      girls and women but to violently deny                  we ought to uphold the dignity of each
                                               from Pennsylvania. He had a bill on                     it. And in some of these countries,                    and every human person, regardless of
                                               childcare and taking care of kids. Yet                  abortion has been forced on women                      the race, sex, appearance, abilities, or
                                               now we are talking about the fact that                  who don’t even want abortions—women                    age of the person in question. The
                                               a baby, in having been diagnosed with                   in countries like Vietnam or Peru, for                 measures before us today do just that,
                                               having Down syndrome, somehow                           instance, who were forced to endure                    and we should support them.
                                               should be aborted. I can’t think of how                                                                          And now I would like to yield time to
                                                                                                       the coercive abortion and sterilization
                                               anyone could oppose this bill, espe-                                                                           my friend and distinguished colleague,
                                                                                                       campaigns of the 1990s, just to name a
                                               cially because the American people                                                                             the Senator from Montana.
                                                                                                       few examples.
                                               overwhelmingly—70 percent of them—                        What kind of aid does violence to                      The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-
                                               oppose aborting a child on the basis                    women and girls? What kind of help is                  ator from Montana.
                                               that the child would be born with Down                                                                           Mr. DAINES. Madam President, I
                                                                                                       it to impose U.S. abortion extremism
                                               syndrome. That includes 56 percent of                                                                          want to thank my colleague from
                                                                                                       on countries that culturally and demo-
                                               the people who consider themselves to                                                                          Utah, Senator MIKE LEE, for his re-
                                                                                                       cratically reject it or contribute to
                                               be pro-abortion people. Fifty-six per-                                                                         marks.
                                                                                                       international organizations that allow
                                               cent of the people who support abor-                                                                             Last week, with the stroke of a pen,
                                                                                                       regimes to use abortion as a tool of op-
                                               tion oppose this on the basis of a Down                                                                        President Biden eliminated critical
                                                                                                       pression? And what kind of progress is
                                               syndrome diagnosis.                                                                                            pro-life protections. He reversed the
                                                 In the United States, over two-thirds                 it to encourage sex-selective abortion
                                                                                                       and the denigration of human dignity                   Mexico City policy and began the proc-
                                               of the unborn babies diagnosed with
                                                                                                       for both the baby and the mother?                      ess of dismantling title X protections
                                               Down syndrome are aborted right now.
                                                                                                         This cultural imperialism is not pro-                against abortion.
                                               Why? Instead of receiving information,
                                                                                                       woman. It is not pro-child. And it is                    I am glad to join Senator LEE, Sen-
                                               resources, and support, mothers often
                                                                                                       not pro-healthcare. It is pro-sexism and               ator BLACKBURN, along with several
                                               resort to feeling pressure to abort.
                                                 Justice Clarence Thomas put it a lit-                 pro-violence, and we must end it.                      other pro-life Senators fighting back
                                               tle bit more directly. He said: ‘‘I am                    According to the latest Marist poll,                 and calling on the Senate to pass the
                                               deeply concerned that for babies with                   the American people overwhelmingly                     important bills today to reverse Presi-
                                               Down syndrome, abortion has become                      agree. Nearly 60 percent of Americans                  dent Biden’s pro-abortion actions.
                                               ‘a tool of modern day eugenics.’ ’’ That                oppose using tax dollars to pay for                      The bottom line is, President Biden’s
                                               was from a U.S. Supreme Court Jus-                      abortions, and more than 75 percent of                 actions were basically a handout to
                                               tice.                                                   Americans oppose using tax dollars to                  Planned Parenthood. It is no surprise,
                                                 My bill would protect these innocent                  support abortions in other countries—                  as Planned Parenthood spent millions
                                               lives from systematic discrimination                    75 percent.                                            to get the President elected. Now they
                                               through abortion. We say that we sup-                     Now, thankfully, President Ronald                    are simply cashing in—this time, on
                                               port equality in the United States. Yet                 Reagan first took steps to reverse this                the taxpayer’s dime.
                                               countless babies’ lives have been stolen                kind of support in 1984, instituting                     The United States should not spend
                                               because of their chromosome counts.                     what became known as the Mexico City                   taxpayer dollars to support a radical
                                               So I am surprised that my colleagues                    policy to prohibit foreign aid from                    abortion agenda throughout the world,
                                               can object to this commonsense bill                     going to organizations that provide for                and we should absolutely not allow a
                                               and that they reject protecting the                     or promote abortions or that advocate                  slush fund of taxpayer dollars to line
                                               most vulnerable among us, and, cer-                     to change abortion laws within a for-                  the pockets of Planned Parenthood.
                                               tainly, those who are born with Down                    eign country.                                            I also want to thank my colleague
                                               syndrome are among the most vulner-                       Since then, the policy has, unfortu-                 Senator INHOFE, who urged the Senate
                                               able among us.                                          nately, been rescinded and reinstated                  to pass his bill today to protect babies
                                                 I just want the people to know out                    again and again between changing ad-                   with Down syndrome from being tar-
                                               there, our friends in the Down syn-                     ministrations. Between Republicans                     geted for abortion.
                                               drome community—and there is a com-                     and Democrats, it has been moved as a                    Now, I watched what happened here
                                               munity—that a lot of people are con-                    sort of political football.                            just minutes ago. The Democrats ob-
                                               cerned about this. I am going to keep                     But the lives of babies and the dig-                 jected. It is truly astounding. This bill
                                               fighting for you even though some are                   nity of women—these are not political                  should have passed unanimously, and it
                                               using any kind of excuse that they can                  footballs. Women and children every-                   really exposes a terrible hypocrisy.
                                               think of from protecting these babies.                  where have immeasurable, innate, in-                     Most Republicans and Democrats
                                                 Before I yield the floor, I will respond              herent dignity and worth, regardless of                today in Congress are unified in sup-
                                               to any comments from the Senator                        where they are from, and they ought to                 port for the Special Olympics. We are
                                               from Connecticut.                                       be entitled to the right to life and pro-              unified in supporting protecting those
                                                 Hearing none, I yield the floor.                      tection from harm, regardless of who                   individuals with disabilities. Yet my
                                                 The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                       happens to be in office at any given                   colleagues across the aisle today op-
                                               ator from Utah.                                         moment.                                                posed this commonsense legislation
                                                    UNANIMOUS CONSENT REQUEST—S. 137                     The Protecting Life in Foreign As-                   that would stop the most lethal kind of
                                                 Mr. LEE. Madam President, the                         sistance Act affirms this very truth.                  discrimination—the most lethal kind
                                               whole point of American foreign aid is                  This bill would permanently stop the                   of discrimination imaginable—and that




SSpencer on DSK126QN23PROD with SENATE
                                               to assist countries in times of need and                use of our foreign aid money from fund-                is being singled out and brutally killed
                                               in support of a common interest be-                     ing or promoting abortions overseas.                   simply because of a Down syndrome di-
                                               tween us and them. Yet, for many                          I also defend the women and babies                   agnosis.
                                               years, our foreign aid dollars have been                everywhere and value the women and                       Last week, I stood right here to bring
                                               used to impose violent, cultural impe-                  babies everywhere by supporting two                    attention to this very chilling issue.
                                               rialism by promoting and providing for                  other measures introduced by my                        Today, babies with Down syndrome are
                                               the practice of abortion.                               friends Senator INHOFE and Senator                     the most endangered on Earth. In fact,



                                         VerDate Sep 11 2014   06:24 Feb 04, 2021   Jkt 019060   PO 00000   Frm 00033   Fmt 0624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G03FE6.056   S03FEPT1
                                               S306                                              CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                     February 3, 2021
                                               sadly, in the United States, 67 percent                 contraception and pregnancy and new-                     Research published in the Lancet
                                               of babies diagnosed with Down syn-                      born healthcare, results in 49 million                 medical journal last July found that
                                               drome are aborted. That is two out of                   more women with unmet contraceptive                    the global gag rule under President
                                               three.                                                  needs; 15 million additional unintended                George W. Bush—which was imple-
                                                  And, for me, this is personal. Last                  pregnancies; 1.7 million women and 2.6                 mented on an exponentially smaller
                                               week, I shared the story of a sweet                     million newborns who will experience                   scale than what was done by President
                                               baby boy named Andrew. He is the son                    major complications due to not receiv-                 Trump and what is proposed in the law
                                               of some of my very good friends. An-                    ing the care they need; and most unfor-                that my colleague from Utah is asking
                                               drew has Down’s. He brings light and                    tunate and sad, 28,000 more maternal                   for unanimous consent to put forward,
                                               joy to his family’s life every day. He                  deaths and 168,000 more newborn deaths                 that kind of reduction in access to
                                               has an older brother, an older sister. I                because of this policy. And that is just               services increases a country’s typical
                                               can tell you, this world, their family                  a modest 10-percent reduction in fam-                  abortion rate by 40 percent while re-
                                               would not be the same without him.                      ily planning access.                                   ducing the use of modern contracep-
                                                  I am deeply concerned that for babies                  So if you really care about families                 tives by 3.5 percent.
                                               with Down syndrome, abortion has be-                    and newborns, you will ensure that                       See, this is what happens when you
                                               come a tool of eugenics. It is the duty                 they have access to the critical serv-                 don’t base policy decisions on scientific
                                               of this body to end this lethal discrimi-               ices that they need so they don’t have                 data. You get these kinds of narratives
                                               nation. It is our duty to protect every                 those unintended pregnancies.                          that are absolutely inaccurate. What
                                               innocent life, no matter how small, no                    It is safe to say that the COVID–19                  we know and what is repeatedly evi-
                                               matter how many chromosomes they                        pandemic, which has diverted care and                  dent through the research is that the
                                               may have.                                               shut down access to family planning                    global gag rule or, as my colleague
                                                  I believe every human being is cre-                  clinics across the globe, is greatly ex-               calls it, protecting life in global health
                                               ated with God-given dignity and God-                    acerbating the situation. So now is not                assistance, actually increases abor-
                                               given protection. No court, no legisla-                 the time to place draconian limits on                  tions.
                                               ture, no law can take that away.                        family planning dollars.                                 It is, unfortunately, simple logic. De-
                                                  I will not give up this fight, and I                   In fact, we need a renewed commit-                   creasing access to family planning
                                               know many of my colleagues standing                     ment to comprehensive family plan-                     methods like modern contraception,
                                               here today will not give up as well.                    ning. That is why last week, along with                counseling, and the health spacing and
                                                  I want to thank Senator LEE.                         47 of our colleagues, we reintroduced                  timing of pregnancies, directly leads to
                                                  I yield the floor back to Senator LEE.               the bipartisan Global Health Empower-                  more unwanted pregnancies. But be-
                                                  Mr. LEE. Madam President, I ask                      ment and Rights Act. The bill, also                    cause this policy also limits abortion
                                               unanimous consent that the Com-                         known as Global HER, would ensure                      services that organizations provide
                                               mittee on Foreign Relations be dis-                     that care is not limited based on the                  with other non-U.S. funds, women with
                                               charged from further consideration of                   President in the White House because                   unwanted pregnancies are forced to
                                               S. 137 and that the Senate proceed to                   if we are going to actually get serious                seek out unsafe abortions. That is why
                                               its immediate consideration. I further                  about improving the lives of women                     we see the abortion numbers increase.
                                               ask that the bill be considered read a                  and girls, we should be working to end                 So it is a lose-lose policy, and, of
                                               third time and passed and that the mo-                  the global gag rule, not to expand it.                 course, it is women and children who
                                                                                                         So for all of these reasons, I object to             pay the price.
                                               tion to reconsider be considered made
                                                                                                       my colleague’s request.                                  The Foundation for AIDS Research
                                               and laid upon the table.                                  The PRESIDING OFFICER. The ob-
                                                  The PRESIDING OFFICER. Is there                                                                             found that one-third of 286 PEPFAR
                                                                                                       jection is heard.                                      Programs implementing partners who
                                               objection?                                                The Senator from Utah.
                                                  The Senator from New Hampshire.                                                                             were surveyed had altered their serv-
                                                                                                         Mr. LEE. Madam President, 75 per-                    ices or organizational operations in re-
                                                  Mrs. SHAHEEN. Madam President,                       cent of Americans, regardless of how
                                               my colleague from Utah tells a nice                                                                            sponse to the global gag rule under
                                                                                                       they feel on other issues—I understand                 former President Trump—a great pro-
                                               story, but it is not accurate. He is not                my colleagues take different positions
                                               being honest about what is going on                                                                            gram, PEPFAR, under George W. Bush,
                                                                                                       on issues related to the sanctity of                   that has saved millions of lives, and
                                               with the global gag rule, and I am real-                human life. I understand that. As much                 yet what we saw under the Trump im-
                                               ly disappointed that he is once again                   as I disagree with them, I respect that                plementation of the global gag rule is
                                               trying to push this dangerous legisla-                  it is their right to hold that opinion.                that they had to alter the services that
                                               tion.                                                     This bill is about something much                    they provided, including reducing sex-
                                                  As I pointed out when I objected to                  narrower, something upon which Amer-                   ual and reproductive health and preg-
                                               the same bill less than a year ago, the                 icans—75 percent of them—overwhelm-                    nancy counseling, youth outreach, con-
                                               policy in question closes health clinics,               ingly agree, and that is that we                       traception services, and HIV coun-
                                               decreases care, and needlessly puts the                 shouldn’t be using U.S. foreign aid                    seling, testing, and treatment.
                                               lives of women, children, and families                  money to fund or promote abortions                       The policies that my colleague is ad-
                                               at risk. In fact, instead of protecting                 overseas.                                              vocating for makes the situation worse
                                               life, the global gag rule erects new bar-                 If we can’t accept that, it is terribly              for women and families, and if he
                                               riers to critical health services, includ-              disappointing and would be news to                     would look at the scientific data, he
                                               ing reproductive health services for                    most Americans.                                        would understand that.
                                               people and communities that already                       Thank you, Madam President.                            I yield the floor.
                                               have limited access to affordable, qual-                  The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                        The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-
                                               ity healthcare.                                         ator from New Hampshire.                               ator from Tennessee.
                                                  And let’s be clear: America’s tax-                     Mrs. SHAHEEN. Madam President,                              UNANIMOUS CONSENT REQUEST—S. 88
                                               payer dollars do not go to fund abor-                   again, I would just like to correct what                 Mrs. BLACKBURN. Madam Presi-
                                               tions overseas.                                         my colleague is saying. We do not use                  dent, since 1976, Federal law has pro-
                                                  What my colleague is objecting to is                 foreign aid money to perform abortions                 hibited the use of Federal funds—tax-
                                               funding for family planning services to                 overseas. In fact, a poll conducted by                 payer dollars—for abortion.
                                               help women protect their families. And                  CHANGE, Center for Health and Gen-                       Section 1008 of the Public Health
                                               the policy that he wants to codify into                 der Equity, demonstrates that 59 per-                  Service Act explicitly States that title
                                               law is dangerous in the best of times,                  cent of likely voters—if we want to




SSpencer on DSK126QN23PROD with SENATE
                                                                                                                                                              X funds ‘‘shall not be used in programs
                                               but during a global pandemic, when                      talk about polls—59 percent of likely                  where abortion is a method of family
                                               care is already stretched, it is down-                  voters in America oppose banning U.S.                  planning.’’
                                               right deadly.                                           global health assistance going to orga-                  But, as often happens in Federal law,
                                                  The Guttmacher Institute estimates                   nizations in other countries that pro-                 there is a loophole: Federal regulations
                                               that a 10-percent—just a 10-percent de-                 vide legal and safe abortions or abor-                 do allow abortion facilities to be co-
                                               cline in family planning services, in-                  tion referrals. Only 30 percent support                located within clinics that are fol-
                                               cluding reduced access to reversible                    this policy.                                           lowing the title X rules, and those



                                         VerDate Sep 11 2014   06:24 Feb 04, 2021   Jkt 019060   PO 00000   Frm 00034   Fmt 0624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G03FE6.058   S03FEPT1
                                               February 3, 2021                                  CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                                 S307
                                               rules are providing healthcare to                       to women and men across the country.                   week make it clear that they do not
                                               women.                                                  He has made clear that he wants                        have any intention of working with Re-
                                                 The Title X Abortion Provider Prohi-                  healthcare to be a right, not a privi-                 publicans on a bipartisan COVID pack-
                                               bition Act would close that loophole by                 lege, and he has already directed his                  age. There is no other explanation for
                                               prohibiting the awarding of these funds                 administration to review the damage of                 the budget resolution that was intro-
                                               to entities that perform abortions or                   title X gag rules that have been so                    duced this week.
                                               that provide funds to entities that per-                harmful to so many people—an impor-                      We are not considering this budget
                                               form abortions.                                         tant step toward rescinding the rule, as               resolution for the usual purpose of es-
                                                 The bill allows for exceptions to be                  I continue to push for.                                tablishing overall spending and rev-
                                               made in cases of rape or incest or to                      So I urge my Republican colleagues                  enue levels for the fiscal year. That has
                                               save the life of the mother. It would                   to stop these attacks on women’s                       already been done. The sole purpose,
                                               also require HHS to provide an annual                   healthcare and turn their attention to                 then, of this budget is to establish rec-
                                               report to Congress listing entities re-                 something families actually want,                      onciliation instructions whereby the
                                               ceiving grant funds, and specifying                     which is serious action to end this pan-               majority can pass a partisan COVID
                                               which of those grantees performed                       demic.                                                 package on a party-line vote, quite
                                               abortions under the exceptions.                            I object.                                           contrary to the inaugural address of
                                                 This is not a big change. As I said,                     The PRESIDING OFFICER. The ob-                      President Biden where he said he was
                                               this is a simple change. It is one that                 jection is heard.                                      going to be reaching out to Repub-
                                               would add to the protections of women                      The Senator from Tennessee.                         licans.
                                               and their unborn children. It is a statu-                  Mrs. BLACKBURN. Madam Presi-                          I know there has been some discus-
                                               tory fix that will redirect tens of mil-                dent, I appreciate the opportunity to                  sion with Republicans but not a serious
                                               lions of dollars in funding to providers,               respond to much of what my colleague                   effort to compromise. Embarking down
                                               our community care clinics that are of-                 had to say about we are in the middle                  this inherently partisan path of going
                                               fering comprehensive healthcare serv-                   of a pandemic. Families are struggling.                the budgetary reconciliation route now
                                               ices for women.                                         Yes, indeed, that is very true. And if                 poisons the well for any fruitful bipar-
                                                 Madam President, I ask unanimous                      you want to talk about making                          tisan negotiation. And you can’t say it
                                               consent that the Committee on Health,                   healthcare services more available to                  too many times that it is completely
                                               Education, Labor, and Pensions be dis-                  more women, then, yes, indeed, what                    at odds with President Biden’s call for
                                               charged from further consideration of                   you want to do is make certain that                    unity and bipartisanship during the
                                               S. 88, and the Senate proceed to its im-                these taxpayer funds are not used to                   campaign and told to the people of the
                                               mediate consideration. I ask unani-                     provide abortion services, that these                  United States in the inaugural address.
                                               mous consent that the bill be consid-                   funds are going to the community clin-                   It doesn’t have to be this way. My
                                               ered read a third time and passed and                   ics that are the ones that are providing               Republican colleagues and I stand
                                               that the motion to reconsider be con-                   the screenings.                                        ready to engage in bipartisan discus-
                                               sidered made and laid upon the table.                      Many of the Planned Parenthood                      sions to reach an agreement to provide
                                                 The PRESIDING OFFICER. Is there                       clinics do abortions. They refer women                 targeted COVID relief. A consensus
                                               objection?                                              to the community clinic around the                     package could be done very quickly,
                                                 The Senator from Washington.                          corner for the cancer screenings, for                  just as happened with the bipartisan
                                                 Mrs. MURRAY. Madam President, re-                     the breast exams, for the Pap smears.                  CARES package back in March of last
                                               serving the right to object. We are in                  So there should be agreement that,                     year. The relief package Congress
                                               the middle of a pandemic. Families are                  yes, individuals should have access to                 passed in December came together very
                                               struggling, and we should be doing ev-                  this healthcare. And if you say: If you                quickly once both sides agreed to set
                                               erything we can to make it easier for                   perform abortions, you cannot have                     aside partisan poison pills. Republicans
                                               them to get the care they need from                     these title X dollars, then the hundreds               did that for things we wanted, and
                                               providers that they trust.                              of community clinics that are access                   Democrats did that for things they
                                                 The title X program has been incred-                  points to healthcare for women in un-                  wanted.
                                               ibly helpful to people seeking all kinds                derserved communities, these funds                       Now, hardly 6 weeks later, here we
                                               of healthcare, from cancer screenings                   would be made available to them.                       are back on a partisan approach to
                                               to STI screenings, to birth control, and                   I think we also have to talk about                  helping the needy people because of the
                                               more. And before the Trump adminis-                     rights and privileges and touch on that                pandemic and helping the healthcare
                                               tration’s gag rule slashed the capacity                 for just a moment. I fully appreciate,                 crisis because of the pandemic. In the
                                               of the title X network in half by cut-                  we all have different opinions, and it is              past year or so, we have done a lot. We
                                               ting out trusted healthcare providers,                  wonderful that we live in a country                    have been able to come together in a
                                               over 4 million patients a year turned to                that allows freedom of speech, where                   bipartisan way to pass around $4 tril-
                                               title X-funded providers for their                      we can express our difference of opin-                 lion in COVID-focused relief, and we
                                               healthcare.                                             ions.                                                  did that all—you can’t say it too many
                                                 These patients are disproportionately                    What we do have to realize is this,                 times—with strong bipartisan support.
                                               young people, women who have low in-                    that we have in this country 1,700 lives               Why not now? There is no reason we
                                               comes, and women of color. An over-                     lost every day to abortion—1,700 voice-                can’t come together for the American
                                               whelming majority of them have his-                     less and vulnerable—and to me that is                  people and do it once more and prob-
                                               torically turned to providers like                      just an absolutely heartbreaking stat                  ably have to do it again after some-
                                               Planned Parenthood, which would be                      that these unborn children do not have                 thing would be passed the early part of
                                               permanently kicked out of the program                   the opportunity to enjoy that right to                 this year.
                                               by this bill.                                           life. I find that very sad.                              Instead of wasting our time with a
                                                 We need to be tearing down barriers,                     As I said, this legislation would make              weeklong partisan exercise, we could
                                               like former President Trump’s title X                   certain that all of this money goes to                 be working together today to forge a
                                               gag rule, that are jeopardizing access                  these health clinics but not to a clinic               bipartisan compromise. If this was the
                                               to care for patients, not reinforcing                   that provides abortion service.                        course that the majority were to take,
                                               them. And we need to be focused on ad-                     This is the kind of access that, yes,               I think there is much that we could
                                               dressing the pain of this pandemic and                  indeed, many families would appreciate                 agree to with near universal support
                                               on taking steps to finally end it, not                  having more access and more services                   and do it in short order. Everyone rec-




SSpencer on DSK126QN23PROD with SENATE
                                               wasting time with blatantly ideolog-                    available to women at their commu-                     ognizes we need to get control of the
                                               ical bills that appeal to the far-right                 nity clinics.                                          virus as a first priority. That is nec-
                                               base at the expense of our families.                       The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                     essary to save lives and get back to
                                                 While Republicans seem intent on                      ator from Iowa.                                        anything close to resembling a nor-
                                               keeping patients from getting the                                          S. CON. RES. 5                      mally functioning economy.
                                               healthcare they need, I am glad we fi-                    Mr. GRASSLEY. Thank you. The ac-                       Rapid deployment of the vaccine is
                                               nally have a President who is listening                 tions of my Democratic colleagues this                 our best hope for our getting there to



                                         VerDate Sep 11 2014   06:24 Feb 04, 2021   Jkt 019060   PO 00000   Frm 00035   Fmt 0624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G03FE6.059   S03FEPT1
                                               S308                                              CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                    February 3, 2021
                                               get the economy functioning. I doubt a                    I yield the floor.                                     Democrats have no problem going on
                                               single Member of this Senate body                         The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                      the record as the party that fought for
                                               would object to additional funds for                    ator from Washington.                                  people during the pandemic because,
                                               vaccine distribution if it will get more                  Mrs. MURRAY. Madam President, I                      when your house is in flames, you do
                                               people vaccinated sooner. I am also                     rise today to discuss the urgent chal-                 not argue about how much of the fire
                                               confident that many on my side could                    lenge our Nation is facing and the ur-                 to put out or how much water to use or
                                               agree to additional relief for individ-                 gent response that it requires.                        how many lives to save; you do what-
                                               uals and small businesses that have                       I am always willing to work across                   ever it takes until the crisis is over and
                                               been hardest hit by the pandemic. I am                  the aisle to look for common ground                    everyone is safe, and you do it as fast
                                               sure of that because we have done it                    and commonsense solutions. I think                     as you can.
                                               twice in the past. We can have a discus-                my colleagues know this and my record                    This crisis is not over. Everyone is
                                               sion on unemployment assistance,                        shows it. I am going to keep talking to                not safe—not from this virus and not
                                               rental assistance, funds for reopening                  my Republican colleagues in hopes                      from this economic crisis. There are
                                               schools, and additional grants to small                 that there are areas where we can find                 440,000 people who have died. We are
                                               businesses to help them keep the lights                 common ground to help our workers                      still averaging 140,000 new cases a day.
                                               on. I can say that very positively be-                  and our families and get our arms                      New strains are presenting new chal-
                                               cause we have done it twice in the past.                around this pandemic. But what we                      lenges. Underlying disparities are
                                                 But any relief, from our point of                     cannot do is allow the possibility of                  growing deeper, and we are already see-
                                               view, ought to be targeted and focused                  further delay or weaken our response                   ing with vaccination rates that com-
                                               on the task at hand. At $1.9 trillion,                  efforts.                                               munities of color are being left behind.
                                               the President’s proposal is far from                      With the resources in this resolution,
                                                                                                                                                                We do have to take action, and that
                                                                                                       we will be able to reinforce our public
                                               being targeted and far from being fo-                                                                          is exactly what Democrats are doing
                                                                                                       health workforce, our community
                                               cused. It includes permanent, liberal,                                                                         today.
                                                                                                       health centers, and our supply chain,                    I yield the floor.
                                               structural economic reforms. This is
                                                                                                       all of which are stretched incredibly                    I suggest the absence of a quorum.
                                               using a crisis to enact long-term Demo-
                                                                                                       thin.                                                    The PRESIDING OFFICER. The
                                               cratic policy priorities rather than ad-                  We will be able to scale up testing
                                               dressing the immediate needs of the                                                                            clerk will call the roll.
                                                                                                       and tracing and vaccination and
                                               day.                                                                                                             The bill clerk proceeded to call the
                                                                                                       genomic sequencing and surveillance
                                                 It also includes a bailout of fiscally                                                                       roll.
                                                                                                       for new strains of virus and address                     Mr. MURPHY. I ask unanimous con-
                                               irresponsible States at the expense of
                                                                                                       harmful health inequities that con-
                                               States that have managed their budg-                                                                           sent that the order for the quorum call
                                                                                                       tinue to make this crisis so much more
                                               ets very wisely, like my home State of                                                                         be rescinded.
                                                                                                       deadly for communities of color.                         The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr.
                                               Iowa. This is fundamentally unfair to                     We will be able to provide needed
                                               the taxpayers in responsibly governed                                                                          OSSOFF). Without objection, it is so or-
                                                                                                       support to our students, our educators,
                                               States.                                                                                                        dered.
                                                                                                       our public schools, and those in higher
                                                 The President putting forward his                                                                              Mr. MURPHY. Mr. President, I am
                                                                                                       education as they grapple with this cri-
                                               proposal should have marked the be-                                                                            here today to speak in favor of the un-
                                                                                                       sis and work towards safely reopening
                                               ginning of the discussion, not the end.                                                                        derlying resolution and urge my col-
                                                                                                       for in-person learning.
                                               If my Democratic colleagues would                         We will be able to provide to parents                leagues to support it. I will be very
                                               abandon this partisan exercise, bipar-                  in need of quality, affordable childcare               brief.
                                               tisan discussions could start in ear-                   and to a childcare sector staring down                   I would like to tackle three topics,
                                               nest. In fact, 10 Republicans made an                   mass closures and layoffs.                             amongst many, in this package. I
                                               attempt to do that by spending 2 hours                    We need to help workers who are                      would like to talk a bit about the crisis
                                               with President Biden at the Oval Of-                    struggling today to make ends meet,                    that stands ahead of us with respect to
                                               fice. They reached out, obviously, and                  who are unemployed, and who are wor-                   summer learning and summer program-
                                               President Biden listened and discussed                  ried about their retirement being                      ming for kids all across this country. I
                                               in good faith, but it doesn’t seem like                 thrown into jeopardy. We need to help                  would like to talk a little bit about the
                                               anything can come of it. This may                       families across the country who are                    importance of expediting the pace of
                                               mean that you have to compromise on                     struggling today to make ends meet,                    vaccinations and then, lastly, about
                                               some priorities. That is a simple part                  by providing them with direct financial                the global fight that lies ahead of us to
                                               of life here in the U.S. Senate if you                  assistance. We need to help States and                 make sure that we are building a pan-
                                               want to get anything done.                              Tribes and cities and communities                      demic response infrastructure around
                                                 The excuse that there isn’t enough                    whose budgets have been stretched                      the world that makes sure this never,
                                               time or the need for relief is so urgent                dangerously thin, by providing needed                  ever happens again.
                                               that bipartisanship must go out the                     funds.                                                   Before delving into those three top-
                                               window is just that—nothing but a sim-                    I see no reason why pursuing this                    ics, let me just say that we have an op-
                                               ple excuse. By following the current                    path has to be partisan. After all, if Re-             portunity to pass programming to
                                               path, this entire week is being wasted                  publicans can use budget reconciliation                meet this moment that is wildly pop-
                                               on partisan theater, with no tangible                   to give huge tax breaks to the wealthi-                ular. There was a poll out yesterday
                                               benefit for the American people. At the                 est corporations, surely they are will-                that suggests that many of the most
                                               end of this week, the Senate will be no                 ing to use it to give relief to commu-                 important programming in this pack-
                                               closer to drafting actual relief legisla-               nities and families who are struggling                 age enjoy 70 percent support amongst
                                               tion.                                                   in this economic crisis. If they can try               the public. The relief checks, which
                                                 We should instead be working to-                      to use reconciliation to cause a                       will total $2,000—$600 from last year,
                                               gether to iron out our differences, to                  healthcare crisis by taking health cov-                $1,400 in this package—have 74 percent
                                               get bipartisan relief to the American                   erage and healthcare protections away                  support among the American public.
                                               people, and that can be done sooner                     from hundreds of millions of people,                   Only 13 percent of Americans oppose
                                               than using the reconciliation process                   surely they can support this process,                  those checks. Increased Federal fund-
                                               that turns out to be a partisan ap-                     using it to fight the healthcare crisis                ing for vaccinations—69 percent favor
                                               proach that is needless to do based on                  that has claimed over 440,000 lives in                 that increased funding; 17 percent op-
                                               the fact that twice in the last 11                      our country and counting. But if they                  pose it. Those are difficult numbers to




SSpencer on DSK126QN23PROD with SENATE
                                               months, we have passed bipartisan                       do not, if they insist that using this                 get on any major area of policy in the
                                               virus relief packages to help fight the                 process to provide relief during a his-                United States today. To have 74 per-
                                               pandemic, to help people who are hurt                   toric pandemic is a partisan vote or                   cent in favor of anything is pretty im-
                                               by the economic consequences of that                    that the amount of the relief is too                   pressive.
                                               pandemic, and also to give confidence                   much, I think they are going to have a                   But it speaks to the moment. It
                                               to the American people. Let’s move in                   tough time explaining what and whom                    speaks to the expectations that Ameri-
                                               a bipartisan way.                                       they stand for.                                        cans have. But it also speaks to the



                                         VerDate Sep 11 2014   06:24 Feb 04, 2021   Jkt 019060   PO 00000   Frm 00036   Fmt 0624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G03FE6.061   S03FEPT1
                                               February 3, 2021                                  CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                                 S309
                                               fact that there is unity in the Amer-                   kids—programming that is emotion-                      the correct allocation. So inside Presi-
                                               ican public about what we need to do.                   ally healthy, that addresses some of                   dent Biden’s package is funding to
                                                 President Biden rightly talked about                  this learning loss.                                    start to rebuild the global pandemic
                                               unifying the country around an agenda                     In a typical year, middle-class kids—                prevention infrastructure.
                                               to build back this country better, and                  kids with families that have some                        I won’t go into the details of how we
                                               these polling numbers show that he has                  means—are five times as likely as                      do that today, but there are estimates
                                               done that because you don’t get to 74                   those living in poverty to attend a                    suggesting that we are going to need
                                               percent support for an initiative with-                 summer camp, twice as likely to visit a                over $20 billion globally in order to
                                               out a whole bunch of Democrats, Inde-                   museum or go to a performance. We                      stand up greater capacities. That
                                               pendents, and Republicans supporting                    can’t allow for that disparity to be                   means more resources at a reformed
                                               that measure.                                           present this summer, not this summer.                  WHO. That means more U.S. diplomats
                                                 So we hope—we want to get to a                        We have to have funding in this bill.                  who are working in the public health
                                               place where we have bipartisan support                  We have to pass funding through Con-                   space. That means doing partnerships
                                               in the Senate, but we know we have bi-                  gress to make sure that every kid in                   with developing nations in which we
                                               partisan support for this agenda out in                 this country, especially kids coming                   put some money on the table in ex-
                                               the American public. These polling                      from limited-means backgrounds, can                    change for public health reform so that
                                               numbers and polling numbers to come                     get into quality summer programming.                   they can strengthen their own systems
                                               will prove that. The reason is that the                 This summer we have to make that                       of pandemic detection and prevention.
                                               crises we are trying to address don’t                   promise to them.                                         But even if you drive this thing down
                                               really care what your politics are.                       Second, let me talk about vaccines. I                in the United States, so long as there
                                                 Let me talk about these three dis-                    know my colleague from Connecticut                     are outbreaks that exist on the other
                                               tinct areas.                                            is going to talk about this as well.                   side of the world, we are still at risk.
                                                 First, I want to talk about what is                     We did well this past week. There                    And there may come along a virus
                                               happening in our schools. Others have                   were 1.36 million doses administered. I                down the road that is even more con-
                                               done that in a far more articulate way,                 say ‘‘well’’ because that is 20 percent                tagious, that spreads even faster than
                                               so I want to drill down specifically on                 more than we did the following week,                   this one, so shame on us if we don’t, at
                                               what is going to happen this summer.                    but it is not good enough.                             the same time, lock down this virus do-
                                                 Schools are in crisis right now. I                      In this plan from President Biden is                 mestically and set up a system of de-
                                               know that because I have two kids in                    $10 billion to operationalize the De-                  fense internationally to make sure
                                               public school—in a big, urban public                    fense Production Act. Senator BALDWIN                  that we are ready for the next one.
                                               school. They haven’t been back in the                   and I have been working on this issue                    We can walk and chew gum at the
                                               classroom at all. They have continued                   for the better part of a year. If you                  same time. And President Biden’s focus
                                               to learn from home the entire time.                     want to produce more vaccine, if you                   on rebuilding our alliances comes at
                                               But they have all the support that they                 want to produce more testing equip-                    the right time because we are not
                                               need around them—two loving parents                     ment, more PPE, then you have to or-                   going to be able to do this by ourselves.
                                               who are willing and able to help in any                 ganize America’s industrial base better                  We have to meet the moment. We
                                               way that we can. Not every child has                    than what was happening under the                      can’t go small right now. The problems
                                               that. So schools have been scrambling                   Trump administration. You have to go                   are too big.
                                               just to make sure that they are doing                   out and find every potential manufac-                    Senator BLUMENTHAL and I have
                                               instruction right, that they are open-                  turing partner who can help Pfizer and                 spent lots of time at food banks in Con-
                                               ing schools safely, that they are build-                Moderna and Johnson & Johnson and                      necticut. We have never, ever seen the
                                               ing support systems around students.                    any vaccine maker that comes after                     desperate need that exists today in our
                                                 But come this summer, you are going                   them be able to make more and make                     State. Shame on us if we don’t use the
                                               to have all sorts of kids who aren’t                    it faster.                                             power that has been granted us to both
                                               going to have programming ready for                       We are standing up capacity in Con-                  take on this virus and deliver economic
                                               them, aren’t going to have a safe place                 necticut. We are doing well—No. 3 na-                  prosperity to people who have had it
                                               to go, and are going to have tremen-                    tionally in terms of the percentage of                 robbed from them through no fault of
                                               dous amounts of learning loss.                          shots that we get into people’s arms—                  their own.
                                                 You are also going to have kids who                   but we can do a lot more. We just need                   I urge my colleagues’ support for the
                                               are in need of a really healthy, safe                   that production to be ramped up. In                    budget resolution.
                                               place to be this summer. Some kids                      this    bill  is   specific   money    to                I yield the floor.
                                               will need deep academic experience,                     operationalize the Defense Production                    The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-
                                               but others kids are just going to need                  Act so that we can make more vac-                      ator from Connecticut.
                                               some emotional growth, are going to                     cines. That is one of the most impor-                    Mr. BLUMENTHAL. Mr. President, I
                                               need something fun to do so that they                   tant parts of this bill.                               am really pleased to follow my col-
                                               have the ability to restart and be ready                  Finally, I wanted to talk about the                  league Senator MURPHY after that very
                                               to reenter what will, hopefully, be a                   global challenge that we have ahead of                 articulate case and to build on the case
                                               much more normal-looking classroom.                     us. This virus didn’t start in the United              for keeping our promises to America.
                                                 In this bill is over $100 billion for                 States. But, man, it moved quick—                      The Presiding Officer knows that
                                               schools, to support the safe reopening                  from a wet market in China to the west                 promises made must be kept, including
                                               of schools. And what we do in this plan                 coast of the United States to today,                   another $1,400 in stimulus payments to
                                               that the President is proposing to us is                with 400,000 lives having been lost. And               every individual, bringing that total to
                                               to allow for some of that money to be                   the question is: Why? Why was this                     $2,000, which is what we promised; to
                                               used for summer programming.                            virus able to move so quickly? Why                     make sure that vaccines are available
                                                 I am going to make a pitch to have a                  weren’t we able to contain it? Why                     broadly across this country and that
                                               set-aside, a portion of money dedicated                 didn’t we learn more about it earlier?                 schools become places of learning
                                               to summer programming. But what we                      Why wasn’t the world ready for this                    again, in person for students and teach-
                                               all agree on—those of us who support                    moment?                                                ers in a safe learning environment.
                                               this package—is that the challenge                        Now, China has a lot to answer for.                    What we are doing in this package,
                                               ahead of us is not just how we keep                     But, frankly, the whole world has to                   which is big and bold—and it has to
                                               schools open and open those that have                   understand that we didn’t allocate re-                 be—is to put money in people’s pock-




SSpencer on DSK126QN23PROD with SENATE
                                               had their doors closed, but what we do                  sources properly. The United States                    ets, put vaccinations in people’s arms,
                                               to support kids for 12 months of the                    didn’t allocate resources properly. We                 and put children back in schools safely.
                                               year, not just 9 months of the year.                    spent, last year, $740 billion on hard-                And I emphasize ‘‘safely.’’
                                                 This is going to be a tough summer                    ware for the Department of Defense                       Now, I was very excited over this
                                               for a lot of kids, and we have to have a                and $12 billion on global public health.               past week or 10 days to travel through-
                                               specific focus—as this plan does—on                     Nobody today, living in the United                     out the State of Connecticut and visit
                                               meaningful summer programming for                       States, would tell you that that was                   clinics where vaccinations are being



                                         VerDate Sep 11 2014   06:24 Feb 04, 2021   Jkt 019060   PO 00000   Frm 00037   Fmt 0624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G03FE6.063   S03FEPT1
                                               S310                                              CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                   February 3, 2021
                                               provided to thousands of people in Con-                 which is thought to be a very sophisti-                The people of Nevada, the American
                                               necticut, raising our rate to one of the                cated and advanced State, still lack                   people—they are desperately calling
                                               highest in the country—about 10.3 per-                  that connectivity—a third of our sen-                  out for a lifeline, and we must deliver
                                               cent.                                                   iors. Safe and fair learning environ-                  a real one and as soon as possible.
                                                 I saw nurses and doctors at Danbury                   ments mean broadband, and that is                         COVID–19 is a global public health
                                               Hospital, led by John Murphy, making                    also another reason for that $130 billion              emergency, and it requires the full
                                               promises real for people.                               in this package.                                       force of the U.S. Government. We must
                                                 I visited Rentschler Field, a former                     Many of these students face serious                 act boldly and efficiently as we work to
                                               runway turned into a vaccination site                   gaps—1 to 3 months and even longer for                 overcome this crisis and meet the
                                               for people receiving those shots in                     some students who have lacked that                     needs of this moment.
                                               their arms from the Community Health                    connectivity—up to 6 months in basic                      We need real relief—real relief for
                                               Center, headed by Mark Masselli.                        skills: reading, writing, and arith-                   families who are struggling to pay
                                                 I saw vaccinations at Griffin Hos-                    metic. These kinds of gaps have to be                  their bills, for those who are struggling
                                               pital, a wonderful team headed by Pat                   filled.                                                to afford basic necessities, for parents
                                               Charmel. But here is the story at Grif-                    We need a major effort to focus on                  who are struggling just to feed their
                                               fin Hospital. Last week they did 6,000                  our students who have been left behind,                kids.
                                               doses. This week it will be 2,000, not be-              and that is why this kind of package is                   We need real relief. We need real re-
                                               cause of any lack of skilled vaccination                a moral imperative. It is a social obli-               lief for our travel and tourism indus-
                                               person power, not because of any lack                   gation. We will lose talents and skills,               tries. We need to ensure that they can
                                               of determination—because of lack of                     but students will also lose their future.              make it through this turbulent time.
                                               vaccine.                                                   We should come together on a bipar-                 We need a framework for ensuring that
                                                 Shortages in Connecticut and around                   tisan basis. There is nothing wrong                    health and safety standards are met,
                                               the country are impeding and setting                    with cooperation, and I hope that my                   and we need a path toward restoring
                                               back our effort. They are lengthening                   colleagues across the aisle will join                  consumer confidence.
                                               the tunnel. There is light at the end of                                                                          We need real relief—real relief for
                                                                                                       with us as we move forward, but we
                                               the tunnel, but it is longer as we delay                                                                       our small businesses, including tax
                                                                                                       will move forward. We cannot repeat
                                               the vaccine that is necessary to do the                                                                        credits to help businesses get by and
                                                                                                       the mistakes of the past when efforts
                                               job.                                                                                                           full EIDL loans and grants without ar-
                                                 There is not enough. It is not reach-                 to wait meant unconscionable delay.
                                                                                                       We have no such luxury in this human-                  bitrary caps.
                                               ing the people who need it in enough
                                                                                                       itarian crisis. We must move forward,                     We need real relief—real relief for
                                               supply, and it is not being delivered eq-
                                                                                                       and we will.                                           our workers, including increased unem-
                                               uitably. The numbers in Connecticut
                                                                                                          I yield the floor to my colleague from              ployment benefits and proper IT infra-
                                               show that people in communities of
                                                                                                       Nevada.                                                structure to get those benefits out fast-
                                               color are nowhere near as likely to re-
                                                                                                          The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                     er to Americans in need.
                                               ceive that vaccine—in fact, perhaps
                                                                                                       ator from Nevada.                                         We need real relief—real relief for
                                               three times less likely.
                                                 We need to make sure that delivery                       Ms. ROSEN. Mr. President, the                       State and local governments so that
                                               is fair and effective in this country, or               American people need our help, and                     they can continue working tirelessly to
                                               we will never conquer this pandemic                     they need it now. Far too many fami-                   save the lives of Americans in every
                                               and put America back to work. Using                     lies are struggling just to get by.                    corner of our Nation, so that they can
                                               the national Defense Production Act is                     My home State of Nevada has been                    continue testing and tracing in our
                                               absolutely necessary, but so is the                     hit especially hard during this pan-                   communities, so that they can con-
                                               commitment of $160 billion in this big                  demic. Before COVID, Nevada was sta-                   tinue to provide childcare for essential
                                               and bold relief program.                                ble, and Nevada was thriving, but since                workers, and so that they continue to
                                                 It has to be big and bold. It also has                the pandemic began, our industries—                    provide PPE and things to limit the
                                               to be done now. Time is not on our                      especially our travel and tourism, key                 spread of COVID–19.
                                               side. I have no tolerance for delay or                  economic pillars of our State—were                        We need real relief—real relief that
                                               dithering. I have no patience for cuts                  devastated. In fact, countless Nevada                  supports a greater vaccine distribution
                                               in this package; $1.9 trillion ought to                 businesses have struggled, and unfortu-                and accelerates vaccine deployment,
                                               be our floor, not our ceiling. And if                   nately many have had to close their                    including to our communities of color
                                               there is a need for targeting those                     doors permanently. This is forcing Ne-                 and rural areas where healthcare ac-
                                               stimulus payments, the money ought                      vadans out of work and putting their                   cess is too frequently a challenge.
                                               to be reallocated to vaccines and to                    financial well-being in jeopardy. Now,                    Senator CORTEZ MASTO and I have
                                               creating safer environments to work                     during this public health and economic                 been working with our Governor. We
                                               and to learn.                                           crisis, Nevada is close to having the                  have been working with our Governor
                                                 Vaccines are important to our                         highest rate of unemployment in the                    and working with all of our local gov-
                                               schools. Teachers are essential work-                   Nation.                                                ernments to get more shots in arms
                                               ers. They are on the frontlines. They                      Here in Congress, we have passed                    across the State of Nevada, but we
                                               are putting their lives at risk. They                   stopgap packages to try to help all                    need more.
                                               have been demonstrating the courage                     those who are facing these tough                          When so many in our country are
                                               and conviction to come to school, but                   times. The relief measures we have de-                 hurting and they are struggling, we
                                               they should receive this vaccine.                       livered for the American people have                   must ask ourselves why American fam-
                                                 A safe learning environment means                     been a good start, but they are not                    ilies, why members of our commu-
                                               also personal protective equipment,                     enough to safely see our country                       nities, why would they deserve any
                                               barriers such as we are seeing in res-                  through this pandemic.                                 less? It is time for a comprehensive re-
                                               taurants and other public places—                          Small business owners risk losing                   lief package that truly provides relief
                                               plexiglass and other kinds of dividers.                 their businesses if they cannot access                 to the American people.
                                               These kinds of essential equipment are                  the full loans and grants that Congress                   I urge all of my colleagues to join me
                                               the reason that we are advocating $130                  promised them but that the last ad-                    in this effort to help see our Nation
                                               billion for our schools.                                ministration failed to deliver. Our                    through this challenge. Lives are de-
                                                 There are many other steps that                       State and local governments have ex-                   pending on us. Our States are counting
                                                                                                       hausted their budgets responding to                    on us. The whole country is looking to




SSpencer on DSK126QN23PROD with SENATE
                                               must be taken to ensure not only that
                                               our learning environments are safe but                  this public health crisis, and as a re-                us—looking to us to show leadership,
                                               also     that    students     have     the              sult, they face looming cuts to essen-                 to stand up, to save lives and liveli-
                                               connectivity they need remotely be-                     tial support and services that our com-                hoods. So let’s ensure that we don’t let
                                               cause for some period of time, that will                munities are relying on.                               them down. Let’s pass that real relief,
                                               be the way they learn.                                     This isn’t something that is hap-                   thoughtful and targeted relief, and do
                                                 More than a third of communities of                   pening just in my State; this is the                   it now.
                                               color in the State of Connecticut,                      common experience across our country.                     I yield the floor.



                                         VerDate Sep 11 2014   06:24 Feb 04, 2021   Jkt 019060   PO 00000   Frm 00038   Fmt 0624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G03FE6.064   S03FEPT1
                                               February 3, 2021                                  CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                                  S311
                                                 The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                         The senior assistant legislative clerk               friends and their families. Mental ill-
                                               ator from New Mexico.                                   proceeded to call the roll.                            ness is soaring with increased numbers
                                                 Mr. LUJÁN. Mr. President, more                         Mr. SANDERS. Mr. President, I ask                    of depression, anxiety, and suicidal ide-
                                               than 3,000 of my fellow New Mexicans                    unanimous consent that the order for                   ation.
                                               have lost their lives to COVID–19. They                 the quorum call be rescinded.                            This country faces just terrible, ter-
                                               were New Mexicans like Teresa, an es-                     The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without                       rible problems. I think we can agree
                                               sential medical worker from Springer,                   objection, it is so ordered.                           that the year 2020 was the worst year
                                               NM. She bravely went to work to test                      The Senator from Vermont.                            in so many ways in our lifetime, maybe
                                               Haitians for COVID–19 and to stop the                     Mr. SANDERS. Mr. President, as the                   in the history of this country. And
                                               spread of the disease. Tragically, Te-                  new chairman of the Budget Com-                        now, right now, it is absolutely impera-
                                               resa contracted COVID–19 and passed                     mittee, I wanted to take a few mo-                     tive that the Congress of the United
                                               away over the Christmas holiday, leav-                  ments to talk about the $1.9 trillion                  States understands that reality and
                                               ing behind her husband Roger and their                  budget resolution that I hope will be                  keeps faith with the American people.
                                               three children.                                         passed late tomorrow night.                              One of the reasons, by the way—and
                                                 But Congress has another chance to                      I think sometimes our friends in the                 I say this to the Presiding Officer
                                               spare other families the pain that Tere-                media make the political process much                  today, who is from Georgia and re-
                                               sa’s family is experiencing, the very                   more complicated than it is. Real poli-                cently won his election—it is doubly
                                               thing that drove Teresa every day to                    tics in a democracy is not that com-                   important that we keep faith with the
                                               go and save others. This resolution will                plicated. What it is about is assessing                American people is because promises
                                               allow Congress to mount an aggressive                   the problems facing the Nation and                     were made in this election in Georgia,
                                               public health response and prioritize                   coming up with solutions to those                      which was not just a Senate race. It
                                               resources where they are needed                         problems.                                              was more of a national race. President
                                               most—for vaccines, testing, and public                    One of the great tragedies that has                  Biden was involved. Majority Leader
                                               health programs that fight COVID.                       occurred, in my view, in recent years is               SCHUMER was involved. I was involved.
                                                 Funding included in this package will                 that for working-class people, middle-                 A lot of leading Democrats were in-
                                               be aimed at dramatically increasing                     class people, lower-income people,                     volved.
                                               rates of testing, bolstering the supply                 these are folks who in a variety of                      We said to the people in Georgia and
                                               chain to increase the availability of                   ways are hurting and have hurt for                     we said to the people in America: If we
                                               testing supplies and personal protec-                   many, many years. Wages in this coun-                  gain the majority, we are going to sig-
                                               tive equipment, hiring and training                     try have been stagnant for decades.                    nificantly improve lives for working
                                               public health workers to administer                     Young people are finding it increas-                   people all over this country. Those are
                                               the vaccine, and increasing vaccine                     ingly difficult to go to college. Ninety               promises made that must be kept.
                                               production.                                             million Americans are uninsured or                       I want to just spend a few moments
                                                 As Congress focuses on getting vac-                   underinsured. We have a political sys-                 to talk about what is in this bill. We
                                               cinations into every arm as quickly as                                                                         throw out numbers—$1.9 trillion. Who
                                                                                                       tem which is significantly corrupt be-
                                               possible, strong Federal funding is es-                                                                        knows what $1.9 trillion is? It is such
                                                                                                       cause big money can buy elections.
                                               pecially critical for States like New                                                                          an unfathomable number. It is such a
                                                                                                       And people look around them and they
                                               Mexico, where vaccines and medical                                                                             huge number. What does it mean? Who
                                                                                                       say: Who cares about me? Who is wor-
                                               supplies must travel longer distances                                                                          knows? Who understands that?
                                                                                                       ried about me or my parents or my                        I want you to understand what is in
                                               to reach the communities that need
                                                                                                       kids?                                                  this bill. For a start, what I believe and
                                               them.
                                                 We know we have the capacity to get                     When that happens—when that kind                     I know you believe is that when people
                                               these vaccines in people’s arms. We                     of political alienation happens—people                 are hurting, when they owe back rent,
                                               need more vaccine. Vaccines are essen-                  can become prone to conspiracy theo-                   when they can’t afford to feed their
                                               tial to the priorities I have heard from                ries and all kinds of big lies and every-              kids, when they can’t afford to go to
                                               many of my constituents—safely open-                    thing else. Here is the simple truth,                  the doctor, we need to get cash into the
                                               ing schools as soon as possible because                 not complicated. Right now in this                     pockets of those people as soon as we
                                               this pandemic is widening the achieve-                  year 2021, we face more crises than this               possibly can.
                                               ment gap that already existed. To meet                  country has faced certainly since the                    I was one of the people here a month
                                               this goal, Congress must invest in safe-                Great Depression and maybe going                       ago when a whole lot of people were
                                               ly reopening schools and make facility                  back to the Civil War, when the very                   talking about it. I said we need direct
                                               improvements to ensure every educa-                     existence of this country was at stake.                payments. We need to get cash into the
                                               tor, the people who prepare the food,                     As we speak right now, whether it is                 hands of people. I fought very hard. We
                                               drive the buses, keep the schools look-                 in the State of Georgia or my State of                 ended up with just $600 in the last bill.
                                               ing clean, social workers and nurses,                   Vermont and all over this country,                     It wasn’t enough. It is a start, but not
                                               and every student is safe to return.                    there are tens of millions of working                  enough. We said our goal was $2,000.
                                                 America must provide quality dis-                     families who have lost their jobs, lost                And in this bill, there will be an addi-
                                               tance learning to those who are not yet                 their incomes, and they are worried to-                tional $1,400 for every working-class
                                               ready to return and work to address                     night as to how they are going to be                   man, woman, and child.
                                               widespread learning loss that exacer-                   able to feed their families. They are                    So if you are an individual, a single
                                               bates the achievement gap. It is also                   worried about the back rent they owe.                  person making $75,000 or less, when we
                                               clear that the toll of COVID–19 on stu-                   We have a moratorium on evictions,                   pass this legislation you are going to
                                               dents’ learning and mental health will                  but that moratorium some day is going                  get a check for $1,400. If you are a cou-
                                               last for years, meaning investments                     to end. People say: How am I going to                  ple earning less than $150,000, and let’s
                                               are necessary well beyond this aca-                     pay thousands of dollars in back rent?                 just say you have two kids, each person
                                               demic year.                                             I am going to be evicted. I am going to                in the family, the husband, the wife,
                                                 The Senate must act for the families                  be out on the street.                                  and the two kids get $1,400 apiece. That
                                               who have lost loved ones, for Roger and                   People are in the midst of this ter-                 is $5,600.
                                               Teresa and their three kids, and for                    rible, terrible pandemic, where we have                  Let me tell you something. For a
                                               parents struggling to keep their stu-                   lost over 400,000 lives—well over 400,000              struggling working-class family, that
                                               dents safe and healthy.                                 lives. There are over 90 million people                $5,600 is going to mean an enormous
                                                                                                       who are uninsured or underinsured and




SSpencer on DSK126QN23PROD with SENATE
                                                 The Senate must act to defeat this                                                                           amount. It will allow people to pay the
                                               virus and to rebuild our Nation’s econ-                 are having difficulty affording going to               rent, allow people to pay off their
                                               omy. It must pass this budget resolu-                   the doctor, and on and on it goes.                     debts, allow people to go to the doctor.
                                               tion.                                                     Kids. I have seven grandchildren.                    That is what this legislation is about.
                                                 I yield the floor.                                    Kids all over this country have had                      We made a promise. Some of us made
                                                 I suggest the absence of a quorum.                    their education disrupted.                             that promise—I did—that we would
                                                 The PRESIDING OFFICER. The                              As a result of the pandemic, people                  make sure that in working-class fami-
                                               clerk will call the roll.                               have become isolated from their                        lies, each individual gets $2,000 and we



                                         VerDate Sep 11 2014   06:24 Feb 04, 2021   Jkt 019060   PO 00000   Frm 00039   Fmt 0624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G03FE6.066   S03FEPT1
                                               S312                                              CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                    February 3, 2021
                                               will keep that promise: $600 then, $1,400               long way to reducing child poverty in                  My own view is that we need to put in
                                               now.                                                    America, and that is something that                    a Medicare for All, single-payer pro-
                                                 As a result of this pandemic, we have                 we must do.                                            gram so that we are not spending twice
                                               seen a horrific increase in unemploy-                     It is no great secret that, as a result              as much per capita on healthcare as
                                               ment. Unemployment is soaring all                       of the pandemic, our revenues going                    any other country on Earth despite so
                                               over this country. Millions of workers                  into State and local governments are                   many people being uninsured or under-
                                               have lost their jobs. They have no in-                  in significant decline. The result of                  insured. Well, Medicare for All is not in
                                               come coming in. The extended unem-                      that is that, in the last year, well over              this bill, but what is in this bill is a
                                               ployment benefits that were previously                  a million State and local employees                    significant amount of money to expand
                                               passed are going to expire in mid-                      have been laid off. We are talking                     healthcare, and we are still looking at
                                               March. What this legislation does—                      about teachers. We are talking about                   the best ways to do that. One of the
                                               very importantly—if you are unem-                       firemen. We are talking about police                   ways will probably be by expanding
                                               ployed right now and you are worried                    officers and other municipal and State                 Medicaid and also investing signifi-
                                               you are going to lose your employ-                      employees. When you have those lay-                    cantly in community health centers
                                               ment, when we pass this legislation,                    offs, not only is that a crisis unto itself            and the National Health Service Corps.
                                               your unemployment is going to be ex-                    for those workers, it means that State                 We have a crisis in terms of the num-
                                               tended through the end of September.                    and local governments cannot provide                   ber of doctors and nurses that we need,
                                               And on top of the normal unemploy-                      the services that need to be provided in               and the National Health Service Corps
                                               ment benefits you get from your                         the midst of this terrible crisis. So this             is a program which will forgive debt for
                                               State—and they vary State to State—                     legislation would provide $350 billion to              doctors and nurses if they practice in
                                               you are going to get an additional $400                 State and local governments, many of                   underserved areas.
                                               a week. We will not turn our backs on                   which are facing bankruptcy.                             I know sometimes we get consumed
                                               the millions of unemployed workers in                     Now, obviously, the crisis that we are               by numbers. It is going to be $2.1 tril-
                                               this country.                                           facing today is not only an economic                   lion, $1.9 trillion, $1.7 trillion. That is
                                                 Included in the legislation that we                   crisis, it is clearly a health crisis. The             not the issue. The issue is whether we
                                               are fighting for is the need to raise the               good news is that, in a relatively short               are prepared to address the crises fac-
                                               minimum wage in this country from                       period of time, at least two manufac-                  ing the American people. Will this bill
                                               the starvation wage that currently ex-                  turers in this country—and more, I                     solve all of the problems that we face?
                                               ists of $7.25 an hour to a living wage of               think, are coming on board—have in-                    No, it will not. Will it go a long way to
                                               $15 an hour. Now, we understand that                    troduced and created vaccines, which                   addressing many of the crises and eas-
                                               restaurants and small businesses are                    are now being distributed. That is the                 ing the anxiety of so many working
                                               hurting, and in this legislation, there                 good news. The bad news is that we                     families? Yes, it will, but this should
                                               will be a significant amount of money                   need to significantly increase the pro-                not be the end of the process. As soon
                                               to make sure that small businesses will                 duction of those vaccines. We don’t                    as we pass this, we are going to come
                                               be able to afford that wage increase.                   have enough. Even more importantly,                    back with another major piece of legis-
                                                 You know, when we talk about the                      we have to do a heck of a lot better job               lation, and that will deal with some of
                                               economy, the media very often focuses                   in distributing those vaccines and get-                the long-term structural problems our
                                               on the stock market. That is impor-                     ting those vaccines into the arms of                   country faces in terms of a crumbling
                                               tant. We can focus on unemployment—                     people, and this legislation will provide              infrastructure and in terms of the need
                                               terribly important. Yet what we don’t                   billions and billions of dollars to do                 to deal with the existential threat of
                                               focus on enough is that half of our                     just that.                                             climate change. We need to create mil-
                                               workers in this country are living pay-                   At a time when we are looking at the                 lions of good-paying jobs. That is some-
                                               check to paycheck. They have nothing                    highest level of hunger in this country                thing that this Congress has got to ad-
                                               in the bank, and they have to live off                  in decades, many billions of dollars are               dress. Too many of our people are un-
                                               the paychecks they make. If they have                   going to make sure that our children                   employed, and too many of our people
                                               an automobile problem—the car breaks                    and our families do not go hungry.                     are underemployed. This we will be
                                               down—or somebody in the family gets                     Clearly, one of the major crises facing                dealing with in the next COVID rec-
                                               sick, they are in deep financial trouble.               this country is that schools in every                  onciliation bill.
                                               It seems to me that, in the richest                     State are either not open or they are                    Now, there has been some discussion
                                               country in the history of the world, it                 open with irregular hours. Kids are try-               on—and the media seems fixated on—
                                               is not too much to demand that, if you                  ing to get an education online. Some-                  the issue of partisanship. Oh, my God.
                                               work 40 hours a week, you don’t live in                 times it works and sometimes it                        We are being so partisan here. Let me
                                               poverty. Fifteen bucks an hour is not                   doesn’t, but our goal is to make sure                  remind everybody that, under the
                                               going to make anybody rich, but I have                  that we can reopen schools and expand                  Trump administration, massive tax
                                               seen workers and talked to workers all                  after-school and childcare programs for                breaks were passed that went to the
                                               over this country who are trying to                     working families and do it in a way                    top 1 percent and large corporations.
                                               raise their kids on $10, $12 an hour, and               that is safe. We want parents to feel                  Eighty-three percent of the benefits in
                                               you can’t do it. So $15 an hour is an im-               good and know that the facilities they                 the Trump tax plan went to the 1 per-
                                               portant start in making sure that all                   are sending their children to are safe,                cent and large corporations. Do you
                                               working people in this country can live                 and we have a whole lot of money in                    know how bipartisan that bill was that
                                               with dignity.                                           this bill to do just that.                             passed in reconciliation? There was not
                                                 This legislation will expand the child                  In this bill, in order to protect work-              one Democrat who voted for that bill.
                                               tax credit from $2,000 to $3,000 and to                 ers, there is a sizable sum of money to                It was voted just with Republican
                                               $3,600 for families with kids under the                 prevent the pensions of millions of                    votes.
                                               age of 6. Now, what is not talked about                 workers and retirees from being                          Then, outrageously, as part of the
                                               very much in America—not by politi-                     slashed by 30, 40, or even 65 percent. A               reconciliation, the Republicans came
                                               cians, not by the media—is the fact                     number of years ago, in the middle of                  forward and said: Hey, we think it is a
                                               that we have one of the highest rates of                night, in some big omnibus bill, lan-                  brilliant idea to repeal the Affordable
                                               childhood poverty of almost any major                   guage was put in that would destroy                    Care Act and throw up to 32 million
                                               country on Earth, and that is a ter-                    the promises made to millions of work-                 people off the healthcare that they
                                               rible, terrible thing. You know, politi-                                                                       have. I don’t know what people are




SSpencer on DSK126QN23PROD with SENATE
                                                                                                       ers in terms of the pensions that they
                                               cians give speeches of ‘‘the future of                  were guaranteed, and we rectify that in                thinking about when they propose to
                                               this country is with our children,’’ so                 this bill.                                             throw tens of millions of people off the
                                               forth and so on, but they have millions                   Right now, in America, as I men-                     healthcare that they have, but that
                                               of kids living in poverty. Millions of                  tioned earlier, some 90 million of our                 was their idea to repeal the Affordable
                                               families can’t afford to send their kids                people are either uninsured or under-                  Care Act. By one vote by the late John
                                               to decent quality childcare. So expand-                 insured, which speaks to the need, in                  McCain, that did not happen, but not
                                               ing the child tax credit will go a very                 my view, of major healthcare reform.                   one Democrat voted for that bill.



                                         VerDate Sep 11 2014   06:24 Feb 04, 2021   Jkt 019060   PO 00000   Frm 00040   Fmt 0624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G03FE6.067   S03FEPT1
                                               February 3, 2021                                  CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                                  S313
                                                 My point is that it is one thing for                  as a country. We used American inge-                   crucial unemployment programs, boost
                                               my Republican friends here to be talk-                  nuity to build an arsenal of democracy,                the child tax credit and earned-income
                                               ing about the need for bipartisanship,                  which, by the middle of 1944, was                      tax credit, which will lift half of Amer-
                                               which all of us support, but the reality                churning out B–24 bombers every 60                     ican children out of poverty this year.
                                               is they used exactly the same process                   minutes at Ford’s Willow Run plant in                    Can you imagine? We have an oppor-
                                               to pass or at least try to pass major,                  Michigan.                                              tunity here in Congress, working with
                                               major pieces of legislation.                              Now is the time again to take bold                   our wonderful new President and Vice
                                                 So all that I want to say is that we                  action on behalf of the American peo-                  President, to pass a policy that will lift
                                               are living in an unprecedented moment                   ple. We are now a year into a pandemic                 half the children in poverty out of pov-
                                               in American history. Again, it is quite                 that has claimed the lives of nearly                   erty—not 10 years from now, not 5
                                               likely that this Congress today and                     450,000 Americans—450,000 Americans—                   years from now—this year. What an ex-
                                               President Biden are facing more seri-                   parents and grandparents and friends                   citing prospect. And we need to get it
                                               ous crises than any President—cer-                      and neighbors and cousins and cowork-                  done.
                                               tainly, since FDR and maybe going                       ers and community leaders. Almost                        This means struggling families will,
                                               back to Abraham Lincoln—has faced.                      15,000 lives have already been lost in                 with all of this help, be able to cover
                                               We have a healthcare crisis. We have a                  Michigan—dear souls lost to us.                        the rent or the mortgage, pay their
                                               pandemic. We have an economic melt-                       And it is not just lives that have                   bills, keep food on the table. And keep-
                                               down. We have an education crisis. We                   been lost. Businesses have closed,                     ing food on the table is especially cru-
                                               have an infrastructure crisis. We have                  workers have been laid off, folks have                 cial in a time when so many of our
                                               a criminal justice crisis. We have an                   been without paychecks for months                      neighbors are going hungry.
                                               immigration crisis. You name it, we                     and months.                                              In fact, we know that 50 million
                                               got it. Either we are going to have the                   Parents are struggling to keep food                  Americans across the country—moms
                                               courage to address those problems or                    on the table and the heat on while                     and dads and children—right now are
                                                                                                       troubleshooting the spotty internet                    facing hunger every day. We are better
                                               we are not, and I think now is the time
                                                                                                       their children depend on to keep their                 than this as a country.
                                               to do it. We certainly look forward to
                                                                                                       classes going on Zoom.                                   We have all heard stories about sen-
                                               the support from our Republican col-                      And grandmas and grandpas are                        iors waiting hours in lines for a box of
                                               leagues, but what is most important is                  missing out on seeing their families                   food or parents skipping meals so their
                                               that, at a time of massive pain and                     grow up. Babies born last March are al-                children can have a little more to eat.
                                               anxiety, this Congress acts boldly on                   ready learning to walk and talk, and                     The agriculture and nutrition fund-
                                               behalf of working families.                             too many have not had a chance to be                   ing in this American Rescue Plan will
                                                 For too long, we have seen the Con-                   with them in person.                                   tackle hunger head-on by extending
                                               gress give tax breaks to billionaires.                    Americans know how to meet the                       pandemic EBT for the duration of the
                                               We have seen lobbyists work to get                      moment, and it is time for us to do it                 pandemic. What does that mean? This
                                               hundreds of billions of dollars in cor-                 again. It is time to pass a rescue plan                is about children. This is about feeding
                                               porate welfare for people who don’t                     bold enough to stamp out this pan-                     children—children who otherwise may
                                               need it. We have seen a tax system in                   demic, get families the immediate help                 get fed at school but aren’t able to do
                                               which major corporations like Ama-                      they need to weather the economic cri-                 that to be able to have the resources
                                               zon—maybe the most profitable cor-                      sis, and get our children safely back in               they need from moms and dads to feed
                                               poration in America or one of the most                  school.                                                them while they are not in school, as
                                               profitable corporations and owned by                      That is just what our American Res-                  well as in the summer.
                                               the wealthiest guy in America—pay                       cue Plan will do, and we need to get it                  It will also provide more fruits and
                                               zero in Federal taxes, and, right now,                  done as soon as possible. American                     vegetables for moms and babies and
                                               the very rich have an effective tax rate                families have waited long enough.                      make sure that families who are eligi-
                                               which is lower than that of working                       There are a lot of good things hap-                  ble for help are getting it. People who
                                               families.                                               pening right now. A home COVID–19                      need help in this country need to get
                                                 So I know it may sound like a radical                 test was just approved. Soon we will                   that help. They need to know we have
                                               idea, but the time is now for the U.S.                  have three effective vaccines available.               their back.
                                               Congress to begin to represent the vast                 We know that we can’t get back to nor-                   We know that two-thirds of SNAP
                                               majority of the people—the working                      mal, though, or revive our battered                    benefits—the Supplemental Nutrition
                                               class of this country, the middle class                 economy unless we get vaccine off                      Assistance Program—two-thirds of it
                                               of this country, and lower income peo-                  shelves and into American arms.                        goes to families with children. By ex-
                                               ple—who are struggling. Let us work                       That is why our plan will increase                   tending the bump-up in SNAP funding
                                               together. Let us crush this terrible                    the number of people being vaccinated,                 through the end of September, we can
                                               pandemic. Let us get our kids back to                   boost our testing capacity, and ensure                 make sure families aren’t running out
                                               school. Let us reopen our economy. Let                  that our healthcare professionals and                  of food and going hungry at the end of
                                               us create a government that works for                   other frontline workers have adequate                  the month.
                                               all of us and not just the very few.                    protective equipment.                                    That is especially important for chil-
                                                 I yield the floor.                                      The plan will also provide additional                dren because it is hard to learn—it is
                                                 The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr.                            funding for rural health infrastructure                hard to learn how to read and write,
                                               KELLY). The Senator from Michigan.                      through the agriculture portion of our                 and it is hard to focus when your stom-
                                                 Ms. STABENOW. Mr. President, it is                    bill, which I am so pleased to lead.                   ach is rumbling, when you have got a
                                               wonderful to see you in the Chair.                        Our rural hospitals are struggling to                headache because you haven’t eaten.
                                                 The PRESIDING OFFICER. My first                       survive right now like places where I                  Our children need to be fed, and they
                                               time.                                                   grew up in Northern Michigan. This                     need to be back in class as well.
                                                 Ms. STABENOW. Mr. President, one                      funding will help them keep their doors                  We can’t get our economy moving
                                               thing you can say about Americans, we                   open, purchase necessary supplies, vac-                again if parents can’t return to work,
                                               know how to meet the moment.                            cinate more people, and treat more pa-                 and parents can’t return to work if
                                                 When the world was upended by a                       tients via telehealth, which has become                they are worried that their children
                                               Great Depression and a quarter of our                   so important.                                          aren’t safe at school or one of the par-
                                               people were out of work, we took bold                     In the meantime, we know that                        ents or the only parent has to be home
                                               action. A brandnew President, Frank-




SSpencer on DSK126QN23PROD with SENATE
                                                                                                       American families need help to survive                 with the children. What do they do?
                                               lin Delano Roosevelt, and large majori-                 during this pandemic. They need help.                    So all of this fits together, and this
                                               ties in Congress ushered in a New Deal                  They need to know we have got their                    American Rescue Plan will provide the
                                               that put folks back to work, stabilized                 backs. They have got to know that, in                  support needed to safely reopen the
                                               our economy, and invested in Amer-                      all of this, somebody has got their                    majority of K–12 schools within Presi-
                                               ica’s future.                                           back.                                                  dent Biden’s first 100 days.
                                                 When freedom abroad was threatened                      The American Rescue Plan will give                     How important is that? What a great
                                               by fascism, we again took bold action                   working families direct checks, extend                 goal for us to have, and we can do that.



                                         VerDate Sep 11 2014   06:24 Feb 04, 2021   Jkt 019060   PO 00000   Frm 00041   Fmt 0624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G03FE6.069   S03FEPT1
                                               S314                                              CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                   February 3, 2021
                                               We are just days away from working                      opportunity. Those things have created                 experienced long delays at meat pack-
                                               together and being able to get that                     better economies and more jobs.                        ing plants where workers were hard hit
                                               done, and it will serve all students, no                  So, broadly, we are committed to                     by COVID–19. Those workers need help
                                               matter how, no matter where they                        making sure everyone shares in the                     too. The pandemic also made it harder
                                               learn.                                                  prosperity of our country, and these                   to find workers to cultivate the land
                                                 And for our farmers, speaking as the                  policies create the conditions nec-                    and tend to the animals.
                                               incoming chair of the Agriculture, Nu-                  essary to help people dream big dreams                   This resolution also supports a provi-
                                               trition, and Forestry Committee, our                    and actually achieve them.                             sion I advocated for to provide debt re-
                                               farmers who have been directly af-                        It is a new year. It is a new Congress.              lief for minority and disadvantaged
                                               fected by the ups and downs of the pan-                 It is time to act. It is time to end this              farmers and ranchers who did not re-
                                               demic, the plan addresses the break in                  pandemic, give families the economic                   ceive their fair share of COVID relief
                                               the food supply chain, and it enables us                support they need, and get our children                under the last administration.
                                               to buy and donate their products to                     safely back to school. This is the mo-                   It is said that societies are judged by
                                               food banks.                                             ment. This is the moment we need to                    how they treat their most vulnerable.
                                                 You know, we had so many selling to                   think big. We need to be bold. We need                 It is sad because not everybody opens
                                               restaurants and big enterprises, the                    to lean in on policies that we know                    their eyes to see how this should be
                                               food supply chain stopped. They have                    work—because they have worked be-                      measured.
                                               excess food. I know dairy farmers in                    fore.                                                    The Senate must act for the families
                                               Michigan; it breaks their hearts to                       Americans know how to meet the                       and children facing hunger and for our
                                               think of the idea of dumping milk                       moment, and our moment is now.                         hard-working farmers and ranchers—
                                               when we need that.                                        I yield the floor.                                   those that are producing food, picking
                                                 So the efforts that are in this bill                    Ms. STABENOW. Mr. President, I                       food, preparing food, and getting it to
                                               will help them be able to move from a                   suggest the absence of a quorum.                       market and stocking the shelves.
                                               bulk supply chain to be able to get gal-                  The PRESIDING OFFICER. The                             We must pass this budget resolution.
                                               lon jugs, put the milk into the hands of                clerk will call the roll.                                I yield the floor.
                                               families, and stop the wasting of pre-                    The senior assistant legislative clerk                 I suggest the absence of a quorum.
                                               cious, valuable food that our families                  proceeded to call the roll.                              The PRESIDING OFFICER. The
                                               need. This is going to help farmers’                      Mr. LUJÁN. Mr. President, I ask                     clerk will call the roll.
                                               bottom lines, and it feeds families in                  unanimous consent that the order for                     The senior assistant legislative clerk
                                               need.                                                   the quorum call be rescinded.                          proceeded to call the roll.
                                                 Our agriculture provisions also pro-                    The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without                         Mr. SCHUMER. Mr. President, I ask
                                               vide critical funding for PPE for farm-                 objection, it is so ordered.                           unanimous consent that the order for
                                               workers and workers who labor every                       The Senator from New Mexico.                         the quorum call be rescinded.
                                               day in food processing plants so we                       Mr. LUJÁN. Mr. President, 50 million                  The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without
                                               have the food that we need—protective                   Americans, including 17 million chil-                  objection, it is so ordered.
                                               equipment that they need and that                       dren, are facing food insecurity because
                                                                                                                                                                                f
                                               they deserve.                                           of this public health and economic cri-
                                                 The plan also targets help for farm-                  sis, with Black and Latino families                             MORNING BUSINESS
                                               ers of color who have been hit espe-                    more likely to go hungry. In New Mex-                    Mr. SCHUMER. Mr. President, I ask
                                               cially hard by the pandemic, on top of                  ico, one in three children and one in                  unanimous consent that the Senate be
                                               the historical challenges and discrimi-                 five adults are at risk of hunger. In the              in a period of morning business, with
                                               nation they have faced in accessing                     wealthiest country in the world, this is               Senators permitted to speak therein
                                               land and capital. The plan provides                     simply unacceptable.                                   for up to 10 minutes each.
                                               critical debt relief to help them weath-                  The budget resolution focuses on get-                  The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without
                                               er the storm and keep their operations                  ting relief to the people who need it                  objection, it is so ordered.
                                               going until the next growing season.                    most, beginning with an extension of
                                                                                                                                                                                f
                                                 Vaccinating Americans, providing                      the 15-percent increase in supplemental
                                               economic help for families, getting our                 nutrition assistance benefits through                         ADDITIONAL STATEMENTS
                                               children back to school safely, those                   September of 2021. Increasing SNAP
                                               are the three main goals of this plan.                  benefits has proven to be one of the
                                                 All of these goals have one thing in                  most effective forms of economic stim-                    RECOGNIZING ARKANSAS PBS
                                               common: It is about investing in peo-                   ulus, and it has the dual benefit of al-               ∑ Mr. BOOZMAN. Mr. President, I rise
                                               ple. It is about putting people first—                  lowing families to purchase the food                   today to congratulate Arkansas Public
                                               the American people first. Over our Na-                 that they need to stay healthy, as well                Broadcasting Service, PBS, for its tre-
                                               tion’s history, the policies that have                  as supporting businesses that accept                   mendous work to provide educational
                                               truly been lifting people out of poverty                SNAP dollars.                                          resources throughout the COVID–19
                                               and moved them forward have invested                      The budget resolution also bolsters                  health crisis.
                                               in people, from our land grant univer-                  the WIC Program to ensure that chil-                     Arkansas PBS was recently recog-
                                               sities to social security and Medicare                  dren and their mothers have access to                  nized with five national Public Media
                                               and Medicaid, to the Civil Rights Act,                  a nutritious diet necessary for healthy                Awards from the National Education
                                               to the Children’s Health Insurance Pro-                 development, an important investment                   Telecommunications         Association,
                                               gram, to increasing the minimum                         in the future of our country. This fund-               NETA, including honors for overall ex-
                                               wage. And these are all policies, I am                  ing increase is especially significant                 cellence for the programing it provided
                                               proud to say, created and supported by                  for States like New Mexico, where                      to children, parents, and teachers
                                               Democrats.                                              nearly a quarter of children are born                  through Arkansas AMI, Alternative
                                                 Investing in our people helps Amer-                   into families with incomes that fall                   Methods of Instructions.
                                               ican families, and it helps our economy                 below the Federal poverty line.                          As the COVID–19 emergency pro-
                                               too. We have seen these Democratic                        In addition to addressing hunger, this               gressed in March 2020, Arkansas PBS
                                               policies create more jobs when you                      resolution includes critical support for               upended its weekday schedule and
                                               look at the numbers. When we look at                    the people who grow our food, produce                  began broadcasting streamlined, cur-
                                               the numbers, under which policies and                   our food—our farmers and ranchers. In                  riculum-based programming for chil-




SSpencer on DSK126QN23PROD with SENATE
                                               which Presidents have we seen more                      New Mexico, farmers and ranchers, who                  dren from Pre-K through eighth grade.
                                               good-paying jobs? And over and over                     were already struggling due to drought                   When schools first closed in Arkan-
                                               again it is Democratic Presidents be-                   conditions, face new challenges due to                 sas, educators were immediately chal-
                                               cause of the way that we invest. It is                  COVID–19. Shuttered restaurants left                   lenged by the lack of internet access in
                                               what we do, how we invest, to create                    chile growers and dairy farmers with-                  many rural areas of the State. This
                                               opportunity to give everybody a fair                    out their customer base and scram-                     made the Arkansas AMI project even
                                               shot to succeed, to invest in people and                bling to find new markets. Ranchers                    more important. For many without



                                         VerDate Sep 11 2014   06:24 Feb 04, 2021   Jkt 019060   PO 00000   Frm 00042   Fmt 0624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G03FE6.071   S03FEPT1


File and source

File
CREC_crec-2021-02-03_crec-2021-02-03-pt1-pgs304.pdf
Size
284,213 bytes
SHA-256
17c89c1f68f70b57df91a151282603f1d100a8c33734b9e764fabe75ba6b4861
Our copy
CREC_crec-2021-02-03_crec-2021-02-03-pt1-pgs304.pdf
Original
www.govinfo.gov
Back to top