Pandemic Darlings The pandemic economy, in original documents
Home Source documents Congressional Record — Senate, July 27, 2020

Congressional Record — Senate, July 27, 2020

Summary

Page S4493 of the Senate section of the Congressional Record for July 27, 2020. Schumer, recognized as the Democratic leader, remembers John Lewis, saying a ceremony honoring Lewis took place at the Capitol and was the first time an African-American lawmaker had laid in state. Schumer criticizes the Republican proposal, saying protections against evictions expired last week when over 12 million persons lived in households that missed the rent payment last month, and that enhanced unemployment benefits for 20 to 30 million Americans out of work expire this week. Schumer also discusses hazard pay, funding for State, local and Tribal governments, and student debt, and mentions Cornyn's CHIPS for America Act.

Summary drafted by a model from the document's text below and checked by script against that text before publication. It is a navigation aid, not a reading of what the document proves. Where AI is used

Cite this document

“Congressional Record — Senate, July 27, 2020.” Original at www.govinfo.gov. Archived at Pandemic Darlings, https://pandemicdarlings.com/source-documents/crec-crec-2020-07-27-crec-2020-07-27-pt1-pgs4493-3-5858c16cea/, SHA-256 0dad932f1df0831dd54f6771a20a07b66835909f4182baab46bfac2f7bcbe6bf.

Full text

                                             July 27, 2020                                     CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                                 S4493
                                               The senior assistant legislative clerk                 proposal     among     themselves.    Ten              hearted. How cruel. Is it that those
                                             proceeded to call the roll.                              weeks—ten weeks after Democrats                        wealthy, rightwing people who don’t
                                               Mr. SCHUMER. Madam President, I                        passed a comprehensive bill through                    want to pay any taxes say kids
                                             ask unanimous consent that the order                     the House, Senate Republicans couldn’t                 shouldn’t eat? Because the private sec-
                                             for the quorum call be rescinded.                        even agree on what to throw on the                     tor ain’t doing it. You need the govern-
                                               The PRESIDING OFFICER. Without                         wall.                                                  ment.
                                             objection, it is so ordered.                               Last week was a slow-motion train                      Hazard pay for essential workers,
                                                 RECOGNITION OF THE MINORITY LEADER                   wreck on the Republican side. It                       risking their lives for us—what about
                                              The PRESIDING OFFICER.                           The    couldn’t have come at a worse time,                    funding for State and local and Tribal
                                             Democratic leader is recognized.                         and it will cause immense and, poten-                  governments? Their budgets are in the
                                                                                                      tially, irrevocable damage to our coun-                tank. We are approaching a new
                                                        REMEMBERING JOHN LEWIS
                                                                                                      try.                                                   month. Many, many, many essential
                                                Mr. SCHUMER. Madam President, a                                                                              workers will be laid off—busdrivers and
                                                                                                        Protections against evictions expired
                                             short time ago, a ceremony honoring                                                                             sanitation workers and firefighters.
                                                                                                      last week, at a time when over 12 mil-
                                             the life of the great Representative                                                                            The Republican proposal will ignore
                                                                                                      lion persons lived in households that
                                             John Lewis was held in the Capitol Ro-                                                                          not one or two or three but scores of
                                                                                                      missed the rent payment last month.
                                             tunda—the first time in our Nation’s                                                                            major crises in America right now.
                                                                                                      Enhanced unemployment benefits for
                                             history that an African-American law-                                                                             In addition, based on what the leader
                                                                                                      20 to 30 million Americans out of work
                                             maker had laid in state.                                                                                        has said, the Republican proposal will
                                                                                                      expire this week, without a proper so-
                                                Last week, I shared my reflections on                                                                        not go nearly far enough, even in the
                                                                                                      lution.
                                             the life and legacy of John Lewis here                                                                          pieces they try to do something with—
                                                                                                        No matter what we do, States will
                                             on the floor. In the story of America,                                                                          the small number, the disparate num-
                                                                                                      not be able to quickly restart any en-
                                             John was one of those special heroes                                                                            ber, the unaggregated number—since
                                                                                                      hanced unemployment benefits because
                                             whose moral clarity shown out like a                                                                            each piece seems to be separate be-
                                                                                                      Senate Republicans dithered for what
                                             beacon for others to follow, a North                                                                            cause they can’t seem to get agreement
                                                                                                      seems like an eternity.
                                             Star who inspired his fellow Americans                                                                          among themselves.
                                                                                                        We are on the precipice of several
                                             to join him in the glorious work of per-                                                                          When it comes to our schools, the Re-
                                                                                                      cliffs—destructive cliffs—for one rea-
                                             fecting our Union.                                                                                              publican proposal does not provide
                                                                                                      son and one reason only: The White
                                                Today, as we honor his extraordinary                                                                         enough resources for them to reopen
                                                                                                      House and Senate Republicans couldn’t
                                             life here in the Capitol, many of us—                                                                           safely.
                                                                                                      get their act together and wasted pre-
                                             his friends, his colleagues—are filled                                                                            Major League Baseball, an organiza-
                                                                                                      cious time.
                                             with a deep sense of loss, but I want to                   These issues could have been solved                  tion with vastly more resources than
                                             share a short message of hope. It seems                  months ago, but the lack of any ur-                    the average school district, has taken
                                             easy to forget that John Lewis was just                                                                         great pains to restart its season safely,
                                                                                                      gency and understanding and empathy
                                             a teenager when he started the work of                                                                          and yet we learned today that 13 play-
                                                                                                      for people who need help from Senate
                                             ‘‘redeeming the soul of America,’’ as he                                                                        ers and staff on 1 team alone have con-
                                                                                                      Republicans has led us to a very pre-
                                             put it. He was 18 years old when he                                                                             tracted the coronavirus.
                                                                                                      carious moment.                                          How can Republicans ask our schools
                                             first met Dr. King, 21 when he was ar-                     Today, it seems, we may finally see
                                             rested as a freedom fighter, 25 when he                                                                         to protect the safety of our children
                                                                                                      the Republican proposal on the next
                                             was beaten bloody on a Sunday in                                                                                without the necessary resources or
                                                                                                      phase of COVID relief. Who knows if we                 guidance, when multibillion-dollar in-
                                             Selma.                                                   will see legislative text or just an out-
                                                The fight for civil rights has always                                                                        dustries like baseball are having trou-
                                                                                                      line. It also appears the Republican                   ble doing it? And are they just afraid of
                                             been driven by the righteous indigna-                    proposal will not be an actual, coher-
                                             tion of our young people, and our time                                                                          President Trump, who wants the
                                                                                                      ent bill but rather a series of small,                 schools to open without any help, for
                                             is no different. Once again, young peo-                  piecemeal ideas. That is a metaphor for
                                             ple across the country are rising in a                                                                          whatever is in his own head, which
                                                                                                      their first 100 days: lack of unity. They              isn’t about the safety of America? The
                                             mighty movement for justice and                          can’t even put one bill together—they
                                             equality, supported by the vast major-                                                                          plan is totally inadequate.
                                                                                                      are so divided—so a few Senators put in                  It appears that Senate Republicans
                                             ity of Americans. The memory and leg-                    this one, a few Senators put in that
                                             acy of John Lewis’s life lives on in each                                                                       have finally come around to the fact
                                                                                                      one, a few Senators put in another one.                that the Democratic position on ex-
                                             and every one of them, and that fills                      Not only do we not know if the Presi-
                                             me with hope.                                                                                                   tending the moratorium on evictions
                                                                                                      dent supports any of these proposals,                  or it may be just the moratorium on
                                                                CORONAVIRUS                           we don’t even know if Senate Repub-                    foreclosures—we will see what is in the
                                               Madam President, on a very different                   licans fully support them.                             proposal. They have come around to
                                             subject, over the past several months,                     Yesterday, the Republican chairman                   that, but they don’t support helping
                                             Senate Democrats have been appalled                      of the Judiciary Committee said half of                Americans actually afford the rent or
                                             that our Republican colleagues have                      the Republican caucus will vote no on                  their next mortgage payment. That
                                             refused to work with us in any signifi-                  any additional stimulus.                               makes no sense.
                                             cant way to help defeat COVID–19 or                        The greatest crisis America has faced                  We can prevent landlords or banks
                                             provide relief to Americans during                       in close to a century on health, 75                    from kicking Americans out of their
                                             these unprecedented times.                               years on the economy, and our Repub-                   homes for another 6 months, but what
                                               We do not understand how, faced                        lican colleagues can’t even agree                      then? Those same Americans may be 6
                                             with the greatest economic threat in 75                  among themselves about what to do                      months behind on their rent or mort-
                                             years and the greatest public health                     and have put out a few piecemeal                       gage. They will have no hope of making
                                             threat in a century, the Senate Repub-                   pieces that don’t come close to doing                  up the difference.
                                             lican majority was content to do al-                     the job.                                                 And what will the landlords do? Not
                                             most nothing for 3 long months, as                         We have waited months—months for                     all landlords are big companies. Some
                                             more people died, more were thrown                       the Republican COVID relief bill, and it               of them, just like in my neighborhood,
                                             out of work, more small businesses                       turns out we will not even get a bill,                 are landlords of a two- or three-family
                                             went under.                                              and Republicans probably will not sup-                 house. If no one can pay the rent, that
                                               Last week, finally, our Republican                     port it.                                               hurts them too. How are they going to
                                             colleagues said they were coming out                       Worse still, based on reports and                    pay for heat or electricity?




Dlhill on DSK120RN23PROD with SENATE
                                             with a plan, but even after all the                      Leader MCCONNELL’s speech just now,                      It is essential that we do what is in
                                             delay, even after Leader MCCONNELL                       the Republican legislative response to                 the Democratic Heroes Act and provide
                                             put the Senate on pause for 3 months,                    COVID–19 is totally inadequate. It will                money to pay the rent or the mort-
                                             Senate Republicans and the White                         not include food assistance for hungry                 gages for those thrown out of work,
                                             House were so unprepared and so di-                      kids—kids, whose parents can’t feed                    through no fault of their own, with no
                                             vided, they couldn’t even agree on a                     them. They say no relief. How hard-                    income.



                                       VerDate Sep 11 2014   02:43 Jul 28, 2020   Jkt 099060   PO 00000   Frm 00003   Fmt 4624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G27JY6.003   S27JYPT1
                                             S4494                                             CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                          July 27, 2020
                                               The Heroes Act provides $100 billion                   up with a plan, and it doesn’t work. It                workable. It will delay benefits for
                                             to help renters pay the rent; $75 billion                is going to be impossible to implement.                weeks, if not months, as we slide into
                                             to help homeowners pay the mortgage.                       Republicans, at the last minute,                     a greater degree of recession.
                                             The Heroes Act would prevent another                     while they waited and waited and wait-                   By the way, the idea that we need to
                                             housing crisis in America. The Repub-                    ed—3 weeks ago Speaker PELOSI and I                    drastically reduce these benefits be-
                                             lican proposal, assuming they even ad-                   wrote to Leader MCCONNELL and said:                    cause workers will stay home other-
                                             dress housing issues, would only delay                   Sit down and talk to us now. We heard                  wise is greatly exaggerated. Most
                                             a catastrophe a few months.                              nothing.                                               Americans are not going to quit their
                                               The greatest deficiency in the Repub-                    So they waited and waited and wait-                  jobs, forgo benefits and a steady salary
                                             lican proposal may be their plan for                     ed until they are up to the cliff, and                 in order to receive temporary unem-
                                             unemployment insurance. According to                     now they come up with an entirely new                  ployment benefits. That is what lead-
                                             reports, the White House and Senate                      system, where States would have to                     ing economists have said. These bene-
                                             want to extend the enhanced unem-                        calculate a different benefit for each                 fits are a lifeline to tens of millions
                                             ployment benefits the Democrats se-                      individual worker. Well, the implemen-                 who want to work, are ready to work,
                                             cured in the CARES Act but only pro-                     tations will be a nightmare.                           but can’t find work because there
                                             vide a percentage of a worker’s former                     Let me read you—my office called                     aren’t jobs for them. The vast majority
                                             wage.                                                    some State unemployment offices                        of these people don’t have a job to go
                                               There are four reasons this is a ter-                  about this Republican proposal.                        to.
                                             rible policy.                                              A medium-size State on the west                        Let’s face it, folks. Our country is in
                                               First, it would hurt the unemployed.                                                                          the middle of multiple crises. Tens of
                                                                                                      coast: It would take months. We don’t
                                             If you lost your job through no fault of                                                                        millions of Americans are jobless.
                                                                                                      even have a way of calculating the
                                             your own, Republicans want you to                                                                               American families are struggling to
                                                                                                      wages of individuals. We are not
                                             take a 30-percent pay cut. Can you be-                                                                          keep food on the table and a roof over
                                                                                                      equipped to do anything but a flat
                                             lieve that? You have lost your job; you                                                                         their heads. Nearly 150,000 Americans
                                                                                                      amount. Need a serious transition pe-
                                             can’t get to work; the administration                                                                           have died—a stunning and heart-
                                                                                                      riod. Even changing the dollar amount
                                             has bungled this crisis; and now they                                                                           breaking loss of life—and, in response,
                                                                                                      would take 2 to 4 weeks—2 to 4 weeks
                                             want to take $1,600 out of your pocket                                                                          Senate Republicans have presented us
                                                                                                      where people have no money.
                                             every single month, blaming the vic-                                                                            with a half-hearted, half-baked legisla-
                                                                                                        Another Southeastern State, medium
                                             tim—blaming the victim.                                                                                         tive proposal.
                                               Maybe, again, some of those Repub-                     size again: Very difficult. This State
                                                                                                      said: We need public statements from                     In short, the Republican plan is too
                                             lican, hard-right money people who
                                                                                                      the Feds that people will not be able to               little, too late. The Republican plan is
                                             don’t want to pay taxes to help any-
                                                                                                      get benefits for many weeks or months.                 weak tea when our problems need a
                                             body, don’t want the Federal Govern-
                                                                                                      Need to be realistic so our offices                    much stronger brew.
                                             ment to help anybody. Let me tell you,
                                                                                                      aren’t overwhelmed. Even if you do a                     I heard Leader MCCONNELL’s ‘‘Alice
                                             my Republican friends, you can’t do
                                                                                                      clean $600, you have to reapply in our                 in Wonderland’’ interpretation of what
                                             this without the Federal Government
                                                                                                      State.                                                 happened in the last 3 months. The
                                             and the Federal Government’s re-
                                                                                                        From a small State in the North-                     first bill, he says, was the way we
                                             sources. The private sector can’t take
                                                                                                      east—these are workers, people in the                  should go. Well, let’s remember what
                                             care of this on their own. That is one
                                                                                                      Governor’s offices or the unemploy-                    happened. Republicans put their own
                                             reason.
                                               Second, it would exacerbate poverty.                   ment offices:                                          bill on the floor; Democrats said no.
                                             A recent study showed the enhanced                         Even clean extensions of FPUC [that is               Then, finally, you folks came to the
                                             benefits have prevented 12 million                       pandemic uninsurance] will take weeks to               table, negotiated with us, and the bill
                                             Americans from slipping into poverty.                    implement. Can’t even speculate how long it            is far more a Democratic bill than a
                                             It has probably been the greatest anti-                  would take to do wage replacement. Will not            Republican bill. You know that, and we
                                                                                                      have to reapply for a clean $600, but it will          know that.
                                             poverty program that we have had in a
                                                                                                      take weeks to do retroactive payments.                   On the other hand, the other alter-
                                             very, very long time. Why on Earth
                                             would we slash and burn benefits keep-                     From three States—a very big State                   native, which the leader referred to as
                                             ing American families out of poverty?                    in the West, a big State in the Mid-                   the Justice in Policing Act, was totally
                                               Third, it will devastate our economy.                  west, and a smaller State in the West:                 partisan.
                                             One of the few things that has this                      It would take many months. This                          Sometimes I am amazed at the words
                                             economy not getting worse is that peo-                   would cause chaos with our constitu-                   the Republican leader can use. He says
                                             ple have money in their pockets to buy                   ents.                                                  that he wants to be nonpartisan, and
                                             goods. Consumer spending is going up.                      From a Great Plains State: 2 months                  our bill is a socialist manifesto. Well,
                                             Do you know why, my Republican                           minimum to implement.                                  which one is it? Which one is it?
                                             friends? In large part because of the                      From a big State in the Northeast,                     Here is what we should do. Repub-
                                             generous benefit in the pandemic un-                     smaller State in the West: 8 weeks or                  licans should scrap their approach. We
                                             employment insurance. Mark Zandi                         more to implement.                                     don’t even know how many are for—
                                             and other great economists have said                       From a small State in the West:                      and what pieces. They should use the
                                             just that—just that.                                       We have turned off the $600 FPUC effective           Heroes Act—comprehensive, strong,
                                               Consumer purchases are helping the                     benefit week ending July 25, per law. Any              and bold for negotiations—and start
                                             economy from getting worse. There is                     claims not decided prior to that date will             talking with Democrats in a serious
                                             money in the pockets of consumers to                     still have benefit of [the] FPUC if found eli-         way about the real problems our coun-
                                             help them pay the bills and shop in                      gible. Any claims filed yesterday forward              try is facing.
                                                                                                      would not. As for options, another flat                  Again, this is a serious, serious cri-
                                             stores and more. What do our Repub-
                                                                                                      amount is best.                                        sis. It is the biggest health crisis in 100
                                             lican friends want to do? Cut the bene-
                                             fits to Americans who are spending the                       From a large State in the East:                    years, the biggest economic crisis in 75.
                                             money as soon as they get it, taking                       Extension of $600, could be seamless. Lower          The Republican mantra to let the pri-
                                             one of the few policies stimulating the                  flat, will take time. Percentage of wages is           vate sector do it is just not going to
                                                                                                      impossible.                                            work. You have to understand that the
                                             economy off the table.
                                               That is why an analysis from re-                         Chaos. Chaos. If you change the un-                  times are different. The crisis is real.
                                             spected     economic    forecasters    at                employment benefit, it is going to take                We need an active, bold series of gov-
                                             Moody’s—hardly a political organiza-                     weeks if not months for most people to                 ernment programs—not just cutting




Dlhill on DSK120RN23PROD with SENATE
                                             tion—say that reducing these benefits                    get it. The economy crashes. People                    and cutting and eliminating and elimi-
                                             or letting them expire could cost over                   are hurt. They get kicked out of their                 nating—to solve our health problems
                                             a million jobs—a million more jobs this                  homes, and they can’t feed their kids.                 and get the economy out of the morass.
                                             year.                                                    What are you doing?                                      We Democrats have been waiting to
                                               And     fourth    and    finally,   the                  The Republican proposal on unem-                     negotiate with our Republican col-
                                             ideologues here get together and come                    ployment benefits, simply put, is un-                  leagues for more than 2 months. I am



                                       VerDate Sep 11 2014   02:43 Jul 28, 2020   Jkt 099060   PO 00000   Frm 00004   Fmt 4624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G27JY6.006   S27JYPT1
                                             July 27, 2020                                     CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                                 S4495
                                             bitterly disappointed and frustrated by                    What this country needs is more                      Without action from Congress, the liti-
                                             their delay and now by the inadequacy                    workers. If we are going to get this                   gation epidemic will potentially sink
                                             of their product. We need to imme-                       country turned around, it is not going                 the very businesses and enterprises
                                             diately enter into bipartisan, bi-                       to come from money from unemploy-                      that we hoped we could sustain
                                             cameral negotiations to develop a bill                   ment to individuals because govern-                    through this crisis.
                                             that actually matches the scale of the                   ment doesn’t create wealth; it only                       Today, Leader MCCONNELL and I in-
                                             crisis and the needs of the American                     consumes wealth. If you want to create                 troduced the Safe to Work Act, which
                                             people.                                                  a bigger economic pie for everybody,                   will ensure that those operating in
                                               Speaker PELOSI this morning called                     more workers are going to be necessary                 good faith and following all the rel-
                                             on Leader MCCONNELL and Leader                           for a bigger economic pie.                             evant guidelines cannot be sued out of
                                             MCCARTHY and representatives of the                        Going to our tax provisions in this                  existence.
                                             President to join me and her in the                      same bill, our tax provisions aim to                      To be clear, this is not a blanket li-
                                             Speaker’s office half an hour after the                  help Americans get back to work and                    ability shield. It will not prevent bad
                                             Republican bill is released. Repub-                      help businesses safely open. We expand                 actors from facing the consequences of
                                             licans in the House and Senate must                      access to the CARES Act employment                     their actions when they are intentional
                                             join us. We are running out of time.                     tax credit for small and medium-sized                  or reckless. It will not ban coronavirus
                                             The Senate Republicans just ran down                     businesses. We expand the work oppor-                  lawsuits, and it will not give anyone a
                                             the clock and tossed an air ball.                        tunity tax credit for larger employers                 ‘‘get out of jail free’’ card.
                                               I yield the floor.                                     hiring people currently receiving un-                     What it will do, though, is put safe-
                                               The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                        employment compensation. We also                       guards in place that will prevent oppor-
                                             ator from Iowa.                                          provide a new credit for expenses, like                tunistic lawsuits from harming the
                                               Mr. GRASSLEY. About half an hour                       personal protective equipment and                      workers and institutions we are de-
                                             ago, Leader MCCONNELL gave an out-                       cleaning needed to maintain a safe and                 pending on to see us through this cri-
                                             line of the bill that will be before the                 healthy workplace for employees and                    sis.
                                             Senate in regard to carrying on where                    for customers. The Republican plan                        First and foremost are protections
                                             the CARES Act left off. Those of us                      provides for another round of $1,200                   for our incredible healthcare heroes
                                             who are chairmen of various commit-                      economic impact payments for most                      who made the tremendous physical and
                                             tees or have input into this process                     American adults, but we also include in                mental sacrifices over the last few
                                             would like to go into some detail—but                    the additional $500 for each depend-                   months. This legislation sets a willful
                                             not in-depth detail—of our parts of the                  ent—some people we didn’t intend to                    misconduct or gross negligence stand-
                                             bill. I am chairman of the Senate Fi-                    leave out last time, but we did. So re-                ard for coronavirus-related medical li-
                                             nance Committee, and within our juris-                   gardless of age, some of these depend-                 ability suits to ensure that only meri-
                                             diction, our proposals take on several                   ents will now be helped.                               torious cases are brought against our
                                             issues facing Americans during the cri-                    For healthcare providers we relax the                healthcare workers.
                                             sis.                                                     terms of loans received from Medicare.
                                               For unemployment insurance, we                                                                                   I would add that the costs of litiga-
                                                                                                      We ensure that Medicare telehealth op-                 tion itself can be enough to put some-
                                             boost the Federal Government’s reim-                     tions don’t expire before Congress can
                                             bursement to local governments and                                                                              body out of business, even though you,
                                                                                                      determine what should be made perma-                   in the end, ‘‘win’’ the lawsuit. The cost
                                             nonprofits to 75 percent, up from 50                     nent. We extend for 5 years the CARES
                                             percent in the first CARES Act. We do                                                                           of defending a case that you ultimately
                                                                                                      Act provision that pays clinics and                    win can be so big that it will put you
                                             that to prevent further layoffs from                     health centers for telehealth to provide
                                             local governments and nonprofit orga-                                                                           out of business by itself.
                                                                                                      a downpayment on meeting healthcare
                                             nizations.                                                                                                         In    addition    to    protecting our
                                                                                                      needs in rural America, and we help by
                                               In the same legislation we maintain                                                                           healthcare heroes, we need to ensure
                                                                                                      freezing Medicare premiums at 2020
                                             some of the current boosted benefits,                                                                           that fear of lawsuits does not prevent
                                                                                                      levels to head off a predicted spike
                                             but we must also responsibly hone                                                                               our schools, nonprofits, small busi-
                                                                                                      next year that would otherwise happen
                                             those programs to target help where it                                                                          nesses, and a range of other organiza-
                                                                                                      to senior citizens. We also assist nurs-
                                             is really needed.                                                                                               tions and institutions that are vital to
                                                                                                      ing home patients and workers.
                                               Our bill transitions from a flat rate                                                                         our communities from opening their
                                                                                                        State and local governments have
                                             to a replacement of 70 percent of lost                                                                          doors. This will spell out in black and
                                                                                                      also asked for Federal help. Our pro-
                                             wages for people who have become un-                                                                            white that these entities will be pro-
                                                                                                      posal extends the timeframe in which
                                             employed. This is a much more respon-                                                                           tected from COVID–19 exposure claims
                                                                                                      governments can utilize the $150 billion
                                             sible approach that we didn’t have time                                                                         as long as they have made a good-faith
                                                                                                      in funding provided under the first
                                             to work out in the first CARES Act.                                                                             effort to comply with mandatory pub-
                                                                                                      CARES Act by also providing more
                                             Regardless, the boosted unemployment                                                                            lic health guidelines.
                                                                                                      flexibility and allowing some funds to
                                             benefit is significantly more than                       be used to cover revenue shortfalls.                      By the way, a number of States have
                                             Democratic Senate and Democratic                           This proposal sets out a responsible,                already provided similar protections,
                                             Presidents approved in the 2009 eco-                     holistic approach to address the prob-                 including the minority leader’s State
                                             nomic crisis, which, by the way, was                     lems our country faces. I hope my                      of New York, and it is time we extend
                                             only an additional $25 a month when                      Democratic colleagues are interested                   these liability limitations to the rest
                                             we had the worst recession in this                       in compromise and solutions for the                    in the country. This is not a red State
                                             country since the Great Depression of                    benefit of all of the American people.                 or blue State issue. We are all in this
                                             the 1930s.                                                 I yield the floor.                                   together, and that is why red State and
                                               So I heard people cry just a few min-                    The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                      blue State legislators and Governors
                                             utes ago about our not doing enough. It                  ator from Texas.                                       have already acted in a similar fashion
                                             doesn’t make sense to do what we knew                      Mr. CORNYN. Madam President, as                      to what I am describing here.
                                             we were doing wrong, but we had to do                    we continue to work on supporting our                     In order for our country to recover,
                                             it to get help out to the people who                     country’s recovery from the COVID–19                   the workers and institutions we depend
                                             were unemployed. For the last 4                          crisis, one critical piece of the CARES                on now need to know with confidence
                                             months, we were paying out of the Fed-                   2 legislation is liability reform.                     that if they are operating in good faith
                                             eral Treasury $600 a week, in addition                     Across the country we are seeing                     and obeying health guidelines, they are
                                             to what each State would pay for those                   lawsuits rolling in, targeting the very                not going to become victims of a feed-




Dlhill on DSK120RN23PROD with SENATE
                                             unemployed. In other words, we have                      healthcare workers who are on the                      ing frenzy. This legislation will provide
                                             learned what we knew at the time—                        frontlines performing essential work                   that confidence, and I hope my col-
                                             that when you pay people more not to                     for patients suffering from the COVID–                 leagues on both sides of the aisle will
                                             work than they would get working,                        19 virus. We are seeing lawsuits focus-                join me in supporting these common-
                                             what do you expect? People will not                      ing on nursing homes, universities,                    sense reforms.
                                             work.                                                    nonprofit businesses—you name it.                         I yield the floor.



                                       VerDate Sep 11 2014   02:43 Jul 28, 2020   Jkt 099060   PO 00000   Frm 00005   Fmt 4624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G27JY6.007   S27JYPT1
                                             S4496                                             CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                        July 27, 2020
                                               The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr.                             the summer, his inn would be nearly                    riety of different reasons, and espe-
                                             BOOZMAN). The Senator from South                         full every single night, but this July                 cially the sort of microbusinesses—the
                                             Carolina.                                                his business is down by 93 percent.                    smaller ones. Some of these funds will
                                               Mr. SCOTT of South Carolina. Mr.                         The bill that Senator RUBIO and I are                be set aside for employers that have 10
                                             President, as we continue our efforts to                 introducing would allow the hardest                    employees or less, to make sure that
                                             tackle the effects of COVID–19, both in                  hit small employers—those whose rev-                   the money doesn’t run out without
                                             terms of healthcare and the economic                     enue has declined by 50 percent or even                that group of small businesses getting
                                             fallout, CARES 2 could be a critical                     more—to receive a second PPP forgiv-                   the assistance they need.
                                             piece to the puzzle.                                     able loan. And to ensure that we are                     In addition, we know that minority
                                               Americans continue to mask up, so-                     targeting assistance to the employers                  and underserved small businesses have
                                             cial distance, and do what we can do as                  that need help the most, we limit those                been disproportionately impacted by
                                             individuals to slow the spread of the                    second loans to small businesses with                  the lockdowns that we have seen. Many
                                             virus. Here, in the Senate, we know                      300 or fewer employees.                                of them, obviously, often lack signifi-
                                             that we must find additional ways to                       Our bill would also expand forgivable                cant cash reserves. They historically
                                             keep our people as healthy as possible                   PPP expenses to include investments                    face challenges being able to get tradi-
                                             while we reopen our economy as safely                    needed to protect both employees and                   tional means of capital. So, as part of
                                             as we can.                                               customers, such as masks, plexiglass                   this proposal, separate from PPP and
                                               We also know that low wage and                         shields, and improved HVAC systems.                    in addition to it, we are proposing an
                                             service industry workers have taken                      This could include, for example, the ex-               additional type of loan that would be
                                             the hardest economic hit from the                        pense of expanding outdoor seating,                    longer term, more targeted, and at low
                                             virus. This stems, in part, from res-                    which is especially important to res-                  interest, designated for small busi-
                                             taurants either being closed or oper-                    taurants that are still under dining re-               nesses that are either seasonal employ-
                                             ating at a limited capacity. In April,                   strictions.                                            ers or located in low-income commu-
                                             one out of four individuals to lose their                  We include a number of other impor-
                                                                                                                                                             nities and have 500 or fewer employees.
                                             jobs lost their jobs in the restaurant                   tant provisions, such as allowing sea-
                                                                                                                                                             It provides them flexible long-term
                                             industry. That is 5.5 million Americans                  sonal businesses more flexibility in cal-
                                                                                                                                                             working capital to help ensure that
                                             who lost their jobs in the restaurant                    culating their loan amounts and sim-
                                                                                                                                                             these most vulnerable and underserved
                                             business.                                                plifying the loan forgiveness process
                                                                                                                                                             small businesses don’t go out of busi-
                                               While those losses have certainly                      for smaller borrowers.
                                                                                                        I hope that our proposal will help ad-               ness because of the pandemic but al-
                                             begun to recover, and even as our res-                                                                          lows them to borrow up to two times
                                             taurants adjust and innovate to find                     vance bipartisan negotiations to ex-
                                                                                                      tend this vital program before August                  their annual revenues on a 20-year loan
                                             new ways to serve customers, there is                                                                           term at 1 percent interest.
                                             no doubt they need some additional                       8, when applications will no longer be
                                                                                                      accepted. There are so many small em-                    Again, don’t confuse that with PPP.
                                             help. That is why I worked on the pro-                                                                          This is a separate target product to try
                                                                                                      ployers and their employees who have
                                             vision in this legislation that will pro-                                                                       to help those who are in low-income
                                                                                                      been kept afloat by the first PPP loan
                                             vide a 100-percent deduction for busi-                                                                          neighborhoods, as defined by their cen-
                                                                                                      they received but need a second one to
                                             ness meals—up from 50 percent.                                                                                  sus track. So, consider, for example, a
                                                                                                      survive this persistent pandemic.
                                               We know that through outdoor din-                                                                             small business with $400,000. A 5-year
                                                                                                        The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-
                                             ing, carryout, delivery, and, in some                    ator from Florida.                                     loan at 71⁄2 percent interest rate, that
                                             places around the country, limited in-                     Mr. RUBIO. Mr. President, to follow                  today would be equal to $8,000 monthly
                                             door dining, we can keep folks safe.                     up on Senator COLLINS’ outline of the                  payments. But if they are able to refi-
                                             This incentive will lead to more orders                  second round of PPP, I think it is im-                 nance that existing loan at 1 percent,
                                             that will translate into more take-                      portant, first, to remind everybody                    the payments fall to $1,840. So it is an
                                             home pay and more hours for wait staff                   how we got to this place.                              additional amount of assistance.
                                             and kitchen staff and more revenues                        The goal, when we did it the first                     The bottom line is that we all recog-
                                             for millions of small businesses. That                   time, was to not only allow small busi-                nize the importance of small business.
                                             is a great thing and an easy thing to                    nesses to survive what was then uncer-                 We should all recognize that this is not
                                             accomplish with this simple provision.                   tain as to how long it would take but                  a bailout. These are viable businesses,
                                               The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                        also to keep their workers attached to                 and the only reason they are struggling
                                             ator from Maine.                                         employment. We know how devastating                    is because the government has stepped
                                               Ms. COLLINS. Mr. President, the                        it is to a family and to an individual                 in—like it does, for example, in emi-
                                             Paycheck Protection Program of for-                      when they get disconnected from em-                    nent domain—and said: For the public
                                             givable loans has been a lifeline to mil-                ployment, and, by and large, we believe                good, it is important for us to infringe
                                             lions of our small businesses and their                  the program has been incredibly suc-                   upon your right to make money and
                                             employees. According to a recent cen-                    cessful. But it has room for improve-                  conduct business.
                                             sus survey, more than 76 percent of                      ment, and we have learned from those                     I think when government does that
                                             Maine’s small businesses reported re-                    things along the way with some of the                  in the public good, just like in eminent
                                             ceiving a PPP loan. An estimated                         different changes that were made in                    domain, the government also has an
                                             240,000 Maine jobs have been supported                   providing more flexibility and the like.               obligation to step forward and help
                                             by this critically important program,                      This new program comes at a timely                   these companies from going out of
                                             which has brought more than $2.2 bil-                    moment because we are now beginning                    business. Otherwise, we will lose not
                                             lion to our State. Nationwide, more                      to see that as the PPP funds are being                 just the backbone of our economy but
                                             than 5 million small employers have                      exhausted, some companies are having                   the millions of jobs that come with it,
                                             received PPP loans.                                      to face, once again, the potential of                  and the impact would be catastrophic.
                                               When Senators RUBIO, CARDIN, SHA-                      having to lay off some of their workers.                 I yield the floor.
                                             HEEN, and I developed this program                       That is why it is time for a second                      The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-
                                             back in March, we had no idea how                        round of PPP assistance.                               ator from Utah.
                                             long economic closures to mitigate the                     A lot of the provisions will be very                   (The remarks of Mr. ROMNEY per-
                                             spread of COVID–19 would last. Many                      familiar. You have heard them al-                      taining to the introduction of S. 4323
                                             small businesses have made consider-                     ready—the 21⁄2 percent payroll and so                  are printed in today’s RECORD under
                                             able investments in personal protective                  forth—but some are new because we                      ‘‘Statements on Introduced Bills and
                                             equipment and facility modifications                     really wanted this to be more targeted.                Joint Resolutions.’’)




Dlhill on DSK120RN23PROD with SENATE
                                             to operate safely during the pandemic                    That is why there is the 300-employee-                   Mr. ROMNEY. I yield the floor.
                                             and yet are still only able to operate at                or-less standard, and you have to have                   The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-
                                             a fraction of their previous capacity.                   50 percent or more of revenue reduc-                   ator from Alabama.
                                               In fact, I talked to an innkeeper in                   tion.                                                    Mr. SHELBY. Mr. President, today I
                                             Maine just this morning who told me                        We also understand that some com-                    introduced legislation that provides
                                             that in normal times, at this point in                   munities have been harder hit, for a va-               $306 billion in additional resources to



                                       VerDate Sep 11 2014   02:43 Jul 28, 2020   Jkt 099060   PO 00000   Frm 00006   Fmt 4624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G27JY6.011   S27JYPT1
                                             July 27, 2020                                     CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — SENATE                                                                 S4497
                                             fight the coronavirus and to mitigate                    You can defer your payment until Oc-                     There will be more funding, as Sen-
                                             its impact on American families,                         tober 1. Well, that is just around the                 ator SHELBY mentioned, to help con-
                                             schools, and businesses. I want to brief-                corner. What we would propose is, you                  tain this sneaky, dangerous virus and
                                             ly highlight some of the main provi-                     don’t have to pay it after October 1 if                give Americans more opportunity for
                                             sions. They have probably been talked                    you have no income. If you do have in-                 access to healthcare. There is more
                                             about already this afternoon.                            come, your monthly payment will                        funding in this overall legislation for
                                               First, $6 billion goes for States to                   never be more than 10 percent of your                  testing, for the National Institutes of
                                             ramp up testing, with a particular em-                   income after deducting the necessities                 Health, community health centers, the
                                             phasis on schools, employers, childcare                  of life, such as rent, mortgage, or food.              distribution of vaccines, and to extend
                                             facilities, and nursing homes.                             No. 2, if you are a parent, this bill                the expansion of teleservice activities
                                               Second, $26 billion goes for the devel-                gives your child more choices of                       that has happened during the pan-
                                             opment and distribution of vaccines,                     schools, provides scholarships so that                 demic.
                                             therapeutics, and diagnostics. We have                   your child can return to the private                     This legislation reflects our Nation’s
                                             made meaningful progress on each of                      school he or she attended before the                   priorities, which are safely back to
                                             these fronts, but we haven’t gotten                      pandemic, and gives other students a                   school, safely back to childcare, and
                                             there yet, as we all know.                               new opportunity to attend private                      safely back to work.
                                               Third, there is $105 billion for the                   school. Senator TIM SCOTT introduced                     I yield the floor.
                                             Education Stabilization Fund to help                     that legislation earlier. I am a cospon-                 The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-
                                             schools adapt to the circumstances                       sor.                                                   ator from Oregon.
                                             they face, which are extraordinary.                        No. 3, if you are a working mom or                           UNANIMOUS CONSENT AGREEMENT
                                             The CDC has emphasized the impor-                        dad, it helps you find childcare so you
                                                                                                                                                               Mr. WYDEN. Mr. President, I ask
                                             tance of getting kids back into school                   can go back to work. A lot of our
                                                                                                                                                             unanimous consent that following the
                                             and has issued guidelines on how to do                   childcare centers operate on a very
                                                                                                                                                             remarks of my Republican colleagues,
                                             so safely. That is why this legislation                  thin margin. They have reduced rev-
                                                                                                                                                             Senators BROWN, MURPHY, and I be per-
                                             provides additional funding for K–12                     enue because they don’t have as many
                                                                                                                                                             mitted to speak for up to 7 minutes
                                             schools to get kids back into the class-                 clients these days. Senator BLUNT’s bill
                                                                                                      and Senator SHELBY’s appropriations                    each and that the previously scheduled
                                             room at least 50 percent of the time,                                                                           votes occur following the remarks of
                                                                                                      bill will provide money so that they
                                             which would be a big start. We recog-                                                                           those listed.
                                                                                                      can stay open and provide safe environ-
                                             nize they will incur additional expense                                                                           The PRESIDING OFFICER. Is there
                                                                                                      ments to two-thirds of the children in
                                             if they reopen safely, and we have to                                                                           objection?
                                                                                                      the United States under age 6 who have
                                             try to provide for that.                                                                                          Without objection, it is so ordered.
                                                                                                      parents in the workforce.
                                               The fourth point I want to highlight                     Finally, our bill—the part I am intro-                 The Senator from South Carolina.
                                             briefly here is $20 billion in additional                                                                         Mr. GRAHAM. Mr. President, it is
                                                                                                      ducing—improves the Strategic Na-
                                             assistance for our Nation’s farmers and                                                                         my pleasure to introduce the Restoring
                                                                                                      tional Stockpile so that we can main-
                                             our ranchers.                                            tain adequate supplies of masks,                       Critical Supply Chains and Intellectual
                                               The fifth and final point: nearly $30                  gloves, protective equipment, as well                  Property Act.
                                             billion to bolster the U.S. defense in-                                                                           China looms large in this debate
                                                                                                      as onshore manufacturing capacity for
                                             dustrial base, which is important to all                                                                        about the coronavirus. That is where
                                                                                                      tests, treatments, and vaccines that we
                                             of us. We must never take our eyes off                   are building now. We want to make                      the virus originated. The lying and de-
                                             the ball there. These resources will pre-                sure that it doesn’t go away and we                    ceptive behavior of the Chinese Com-
                                             vent furloughs of thousands of employ-                   have to rely on other countries in                     munist Party has brought this pan-
                                             ees from across the country who help                     other parts of the world.                              demic to the world. It is the third pan-
                                             Americans stay safe.                                       This legislation is about children,                  demic to come out of China. I think it
                                               I can go on and on, but time is mov-                   jobs, and healthcare.                                  is now time for us to get serious about
                                             ing on here this afternoon. We realize                     As far as schools go, there are 100,000              our dependency on China.
                                             this is just the first step. We have to                  public schools and 35,000 private                        What does this legislation do? It has
                                             work together. We have to work in a                      schools in our country. There are about                four components.
                                             bipartisan fashion here and put Amer-                    5 million students in the private                        The protective equipment that our
                                             ica first.                                               schools and 50 million in the public                   nurses and doctors and all healthcare
                                               We know the House has some high                        schools. Every one of those children is                workers use to protect themselves on
                                             numbers. We have good numbers, I be-                     a treasure. I have worked with Senator                 the frontlines—90 percent of it is made
                                             lieve. I look forward to some bipartisan                 BLUNT to help the country’s 135,000                    in China. We are going to try to bring
                                             help on this and moving these bills                      schools and 6,000 colleges have the                    it back home. We have a ‘‘Buy Amer-
                                             along.                                                   money they need to open with as many                   ican’’ requirement in this bill—a $7.5
                                               I yield the floor.                                     students physically present as is con-                 billion tax credit to reenergize Amer-
                                               The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Sen-                        sistent with safety.                                   ican production of PPE equipment.
                                             ator from Tennessee.                                       The Safely Back to Work and Back                       We are trying to get PPE under the
                                               Mr. ALEXANDER. Mr. President, I                        to School Act poses making $70 billion                 Berry amendment of the Defense bill.
                                             thank Senator WYDEN for his courtesy                     available for schools; another $30 bil-                We require our uniforms for our mili-
                                             in allowing me to go next. I will be suc-                lion for colleges. That means roughly                  tary to be made in America to the ex-
                                             cinct.                                                   $1,200 per student for public and private              tent possible. We are going to try to
                                               The way to get back to work and                        schools across the country. One-third                  create PPE in the same category as a
                                             back to school is to put politics aside                  of the money would be distributed                      national security item.
                                             and work together, as we have been                       automatically to all 135,000 schools.                    There will be a $7.5 billion tax credit
                                             doing, on the COVID–19 response and                      That is probably about $400 a student—                 to jump-start this industry. A lot of
                                             see whether we can get a result for the                  a significant amount of money. Two-                    good jobs will come from this, and we
                                             American people in the next couple of                    thirds of the money would go to                        will be less dependent on China when it
                                             weeks.                                                   schools that are opening with students                 comes to protective equipment.
                                               The part of the Safely Back to Work                    physically present to help pay for the                   I will discuss Senator PORTMAN’s leg-
                                             and Back to School Act that I am in-                     extra costs of providing that instruc-                 islation, Safeguarding American Inno-
                                             troducing today does four things.                        tion in a safe environment. If they are                vation Act, which is included, Senator
                                               First, if you are one of 43 million                    trying to open with students physically                CORNYN’s CHIPS for America Act, and




Dlhill on DSK120RN23PROD with SENATE
                                             Americans with a student loan, it helps                  present, it makes logical sense to say                 Senator MURKOWSKI’s American Min-
                                             you manage your debt. This is the way                    that if they have to have more buses, if               eral Security Act very quickly.
                                             it does it: If you have no income, you                   they have to hire more teachers, if                      Senator CORNYN’s CHIPS for America
                                             have no monthly payment. If you re-                      they have to have more protective                      Act creates tax incentives to return
                                             member, in March, we said to the 43                      equipment, then those schools need                     and grow a domestic semiconductor in-
                                             million Americans with student debt:                     more help paying for that.                             dustry. A Taiwanese firm made a big



                                       VerDate Sep 11 2014   02:43 Jul 28, 2020   Jkt 099060   PO 00000   Frm 00007   Fmt 4624   Sfmt 0634   E:\CR\FM\G27JY6.013   S27JYPT1


File and source

File
CREC_crec-2020-07-27_crec-2020-07-27-pt1-pgs4493-3.pdf
Size
252,762 bytes
SHA-256
0dad932f1df0831dd54f6771a20a07b66835909f4182baab46bfac2f7bcbe6bf
Our copy
CREC_crec-2020-07-27_crec-2020-07-27-pt1-pgs4493-3.pdf
Original
www.govinfo.gov
Back to top