Get Bloomberg's most popular newsletters.Get Bloomberg's most popular newsletters.Get Bloomberg's mostpopular newsletters
Summary
Exhibit 44 to Document 585 in Case 1:21-md-02989-CMA (Document 585-11), entered on the FLSD docket June 30, 2023: a nine-page printout of the Bloomberg Markets article "Robinhood's Collateral-Crunch Explanation Puzzles Wall Street" by Annie Massa, Yalman Onaran and Matthew Leising, published February 6, 2021. The article reports that Wall Street risk professionals questioned how Robinhood was unprepared for the collateral calls behind its limits on trading hot stocks, quoting consultant David Weisberger, and recounts Chief Executive Officer Vlad Tenev linking the restrictions to a roughly $3 billion collateral call from part of the DTCC early on January 28, of which the DTCC ultimately accepted $700 million. It notes that Robinhood raised about $3.4 billion from investors at the end of January and proposed moving U.S. stock settlement to a real-time process.
Summary drafted by a model from the document's text below and checked by script against that text before publication. It is a navigation aid, not a reading of what the document proves. Where AI is used
- Date
- 2023-06-30
Cite this document
“Get Bloomberg's most popular newsletters.Get Bloomberg's most popular newsletters.Get Bloomberg's mostpopular newsletters.”
Original at archive.org, dated 2023-06-30. Archived at Pandemic Darlings, https://pandemicdarlings.com/source-documents/2023-06-30-covid-era-misc-4b2331d2-1/
, SHA-256 4b2331d2fcabb6a9196840e2e5c9512f1d24e4567f348b64da021b40b445f72b.Full text
Case 1:21-md-02989-CMA Document 585-11 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/30/2023 Page 1 of 9
EXHIBIT
44
Case
6/29/23, 1:21-md-02989-CMA
12:42 PM Document 585-11
Robinhood’s Entered
Collateral-Crunch on FLSD
Explanation Docket
Puzzles Wall 06/30/2023
Street - Bloomberg Page 2 of 9
Markets
Robinhood’s Collateral-Crunch
Explanation Puzzles Wall Street
Veterans say estimating DTCC requests is just part of business
Yet ‘they obviously fell very, very short’ of the money needed
B
Retail Revolution: The Rise of Reddit and Robinhood Traders
By Annie Massa, Yalman Onaran and Matthew Leising
February 6, 2021 at 8:00 AM EST
Get Bloomberg's most popular newsletters.Get Bloomberg's most popular newsletters.Get Bloomberg's most
popular newsletters.
Subscribe now to get the Evening Briefing, Five Things, Matt Levine's Money Stuff, Balance of Power and Tech Daily.Subscribe now to get the
Evening Briefing, Five Things, Matt Levine's Money Stuff, Balance of Power and Tech Daily.Subscribe now to get the Evening Briefing, Five
Things, Matt Levine's Money Stuff, Balance of Power and Tech Daily.
Sign up to this newsletter
A week after Robinhood Markets tried to clear the air by explaining why it slapped controversial limits on trading hot stocks,
Wall Street’s risk professionals are still perplexed: How was the firm so ill-prepared for an obvious surge in collateral calls?
To the financial industry, anticipating collateral demands from hubs such as the Depository Trust & Clearing Corp. is Brokerage
101. Major firms assign teams to study the DTCC’s methodology, estimate its requests and make sure ample cash is available.
Everyone grumbles, sure, but they also know what happens when firms fall short: They scramble for a lifeline or shut down.
Robinhood gathered billions from backers to keep it going.
“They obviously fell very, very short,” said David Weisberger, a market-structure consultant who built trading systems at
Salomon Brothers and Morgan Stanley. He said he’s been puzzling over Robinhood, given what he called the “well known”
requirements of clearinghouses. “This was a franchise-threatening event.”
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-06/robinhood-s-collateral-crunch-explanation-puzzles-wall-street 1/8
Case
6/29/23, 1:21-md-02989-CMA
12:42 PM Document 585-11
Robinhood’s Entered
Collateral-Crunch on FLSD
Explanation Docket
Puzzles Wall 06/30/2023
Street - Bloomberg Page 3 of 9
The Silicon Valley startup left users fuming by temporarily restricting certain purchases at the height of January’s mania over
GameStop Corp. and other “meme stocks” that were in the midst of skyrocketing. By the end of this week, as millions of
customers were downloading its app to trade the fallen darlings and new ones, risk managers were still stuck on how
Robinhood ended up in the predicament.
Read more: Robinhood’s 600,000-download day underscores app’s staying power
Reached for comment, a company spokesperson referred to a Thursday blog post by the president and chief operating
officer of Robinhood Securities, Jim Swartwout.
“We have grown rapidly. And we have, at times, encountered challenges as we’ve scaled to meet this moment,” Swartwout
wrote, describing how the firm’s growth and a surge in trading volume fueled collateral demands. “To say the overnight
increases in volume Robinhood experienced last week were extraordinarily high would be a vast understatement. The surge
was magnitudes higher than the norm.”
Chief Executive Officer Vlad Tenev has linked the trading restrictions to a roughly $3 billion collateral call that arrived early Jan.
28 from part of the DTCC, which Robinhood has said contributed to a 10-fold jump in weekly clearinghouse deposit
requirements for equities. While Tenev has credited the DTCC for being reasonable and ultimately accepting $700 million, he
has at times portrayed its formulas as opaque, noting they include a “discretionary” component.
“We don’t have the full details” of how the DTCC arrived at its initial demand, Tenev told Elon Musk last weekend in an
interview broadcast on the social-conversation app Clubhouse. “It would obviously be ideal if there was a little bit more
transparency so we could plan better around that.”
The rejoinder from industry executives: It’s pretty much just math.
‘Shame on Them’
In interviews, more than a half-dozen senior risk executives -- some from Wall Street’s largest firms -- reacted with bemusement
to any assertions that the magnitude of the DTCC’s demands can’t be anticipated. They spoke on the condition they not be
identified, in some cases because they interact with Robinhood.
They acknowledged there’s always complaining about the difficulty of pinpointing what clearinghouses will seek, and that
things can go wrong. Some executives even recounted times when they got pressed for millions of additional cash on short
notice. But overall, the group said that large, well-run firms don’t get surprised by requests that threaten to empty their pockets.
One brokerage executive said Robinhood should have ensured it had enough capital or stopped processing trades of volatile
stocks. Charles Schwab Corp.’s TD Ameritrade, for example, began limiting bets on certain meme stocks the day before
Robinhood did. Robinhood’s later restrictions were more severe, tapering off into the week that followed.
“Once every decade or so there are improbabilities that occur,” said Weisberger, who now runs cryptocurrency venture
CoinRoutes. Self-clearing firms such as Robinhood need to know what potential demands they could face. “If they studied it and
came up with an answer and it was wrong, well shame on the people who studied it,” he said. “If they didn’t study it, well then
shame on them.”
Avoiding Surprises
The DTCC bases much of its deposit demands on elements including a clearing member’s concentration in volatile stocks, the
volume of trades occurring, imbalances in buying and selling, and the firm’s financial condition. The more a brokerage is
exposed to erratic shares, the more collateral it has to post. The less capital a brokerage has on hand, the more severe its
surcharge may be.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-06/robinhood-s-collateral-crunch-explanation-puzzles-wall-street 2/8
Case
6/29/23, 1:21-md-02989-CMA
12:42 PM Document 585-11
Robinhood’s Entered
Collateral-Crunch on FLSD
Explanation Docket
Puzzles Wall 06/30/2023
Street - Bloomberg Page 4 of 9
The goal is to protect the broader financial system from trading defaults. To make collateral calls predictable, the DTCC says it
provides “reporting and other tools to our clearing members to help them anticipate their margin requirements for a particular
portfolio.”
The nightmare that clearinghouses are designed to avoid is that a brokerage loses so much money before a trade is completed
that the firm can’t hold up its end of the transaction. Without a clearinghouse, one firm’s failure could cascade through the
financial system. Unwinding just one trade means undoing all of the subsequent transactions if that share already was resold.
A broker-dealer’s collateral burden rises if it lends money to customers, and especially if they bet heavily on, say, stocks that
have recently multiplied in value, as GameStop and others did last month. If prices suddenly crash -- which also happened -- it
raises the risk that clients may not be able to repay their margin loans, leaving the brokerage to eat their losses. Some of the
recent stock declines may be attributable to Robinhood liquidating clients’ positions to head off defaults on loans, according to
Wall Street risk managers.
Read more: GameStop wraps up worst week ever, leaving $18 billion hole
“Someone’s got to pay,” said Eric Budish, a professor of economics at the University of Chicago’s Booth School of Business. If
you’re a brokerage, “you have capital to deal with that existential risk. I was surprised Robinhood didn’t have more capital for
that scenario.”
Margin lending constituted about 20% of Robinhood’s $6.7 billion balance sheet in mid-2020. Robinhood tapped credit lines and
raised about $3.4 billion from investors at the end of January.
Robinhood, founded in 2013, has been hiring Wall Streeters to help integrate the startup into the more traditional financial
system. The firm appointed former Securities and Exchange Commission member Dan Gallagher, Fidelity Investments’ Norm
Ashkenas and Wells Fargo & Co.’s Kelly Zigaitis to senior legal and compliance roles.
Robinhood’s Prescription
This week, Robinhood offered its own prescription to avoid future problems: The U.S. stock market should abandon its two-day
settlement system and switch to a real-time process.
Matt Levine's Money Stuff is what's missing from your inbox.Matt Levine's Money Stuff is what's missing from your
inbox.Matt Levine's Money Stuff is what's missing from your inbox.
We know you're busy. Let Bloomberg Opinion's Matt Levine unpack all the Wall Street drama for you.We know you're busy. Let Bloomberg Opinion's
Matt Levine unpack all the Wall Street drama for you.We know you're busy. Let Bloomberg Opinion's Matt Levine unpack all the Wall Street drama for
you.
Sign up to this newsletter
Moving the U.S. equity market to instantaneous settlement is a huge undertaking that would require years of work. Two
components of trading would probably need to be digitized: The securities and the cash to pay for them. Digitally representing a
security like a stock or bond isn’t difficult and a small-scale effort by Paxos Trust Co. to use blockchain to settle stock trades in
near real-time received a green light from the SEC in 2019.
Digitizing U.S. dollars to pay for stocks is years off, if it ever happens. Another hurdle is all of the banks, brokerages, hedge
funds and trading firms that buy and sell shares would need to update their systems to make the change. The transition would
no-doubt be expensive.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-06/robinhood-s-collateral-crunch-explanation-puzzles-wall-street 3/8
Case
6/29/23, 1:21-md-02989-CMA
12:42 PM Document 585-11
Robinhood’s Entered
Collateral-Crunch on FLSD
Explanation Docket
Puzzles Wall 06/30/2023
Street - Bloomberg Page 5 of 9
Australia embarked on a plan to do just that in 2016 when Digital Asset Holdings announced a deal with ASX Inc. to remake the
Australian Stock Exchange so settlement times could be cut from days to minutes. The project has been extended repeatedly
and is currently two years behind schedule.
Meanwhile, Robinhood is fortunate to have access to venture capital to weather a rough patch, said Joanna Fields, founding
principal at market structure consultancy Aplomb Strategies.
“There are firms that have controls, governance frameworks and processes, and that do not have the capability of getting that
kind of capital infusion,” she said.
— With assistance by Jennifer Surane
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-06/robinhood-s-collateral-crunch-explanation-puzzles-wall-street 4/8
Case
6/29/23, 1:21-md-02989-CMA
12:42 PM Document 585-11
Robinhood’s Entered
Collateral-Crunch on FLSD
Explanation Docket
Puzzles Wall 06/30/2023
Street - Bloomberg Page 6 of 9
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-06/robinhood-s-collateral-crunch-explanation-puzzles-wall-street 5/8
Case
6/29/23, 1:21-md-02989-CMA
12:42 PM Document 585-11
Robinhood’s Entered
Collateral-Crunch on FLSD
Explanation Docket
Puzzles Wall 06/30/2023
Street - Bloomberg Page 7 of 9
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-06/robinhood-s-collateral-crunch-explanation-puzzles-wall-street 6/8
Case
6/29/23, 1:21-md-02989-CMA
12:42 PM Document 585-11
Robinhood’s Entered
Collateral-Crunch on FLSD
Explanation Docket
Puzzles Wall 06/30/2023
Street - Bloomberg Page 8 of 9
Terms of Service Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information Trademarks Privacy Policy
©2023 Bloomberg L.P. All Rights Reserved
Careers Made in NYC Advertise Ad Choices Help
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-06/robinhood-s-collateral-crunch-explanation-puzzles-wall-street 7/8
Case
6/29/23, 1:21-md-02989-CMA
12:42 PM Document 585-11
Robinhood’s Entered
Collateral-Crunch on FLSD
Explanation Docket
Puzzles Wall 06/30/2023
Street - Bloomberg Page 9 of 9
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-06/robinhood-s-collateral-crunch-explanation-puzzles-wall-street 8/8
File and source
- File
- gov.uscourts.flsd.590042.585.11.pdf
- Size
- 434,449 bytes
- SHA-256
- 4b2331d2fcabb6a9196840e2e5c9512f1d24e4567f348b64da021b40b445f72b
- Original
- archive.org