Pandemic Darlings The pandemic economy, in original documents
Home Source documents Post Meeting Packet - Florida Senate Commerce and Tourism (January 10, 2022)

Post Meeting Packet - Florida Senate Commerce and Tourism (January 10, 2022)

Summary

A post-meeting packet for the Florida Senate Committee on Commerce and Tourism meeting of Monday, January 10, 2022, in the 2022 Regular Session, with Senator Hooper as Chair and Senator Wright as Vice Chair. The expanded agenda lists SB 842 by Brodeur (Invalid Restrictive Covenants in Health Care), SB 418 by Pizzo (Assistive Technology Advisory Council), SB 546 by Gruters (Consumer Finance Loans) and SB 946 by Gruters (Entertainment Industry). It records SB 842 as Favorable with Yeas 10 and Nays 0, and SB 946 with Yeas 9 and Nays 1. The packet ends with a timed meeting record stating that SB 418 and SB 842 were reported favorably.

Summary drafted by a model from the document's text below and checked by script against that text before publication. It is a navigation aid, not a reading of what the document proves. Where AI is used

Cite this document

“Post Meeting Packet - Florida Senate Commerce and Tourism (January 10, 2022).” Archived at Pandemic Darlings, https://pandemicdarlings.com/source-documents/2022-01-10-post-meeting-packet-4886-a2344cc5ee/, SHA-256 1c80a0db1eebd6aa2b7bef3d3b32471fef90ffac804e36eeddfad11ca6f783c5.

Full text

Selection From: 01/10/2022 - Commerce and Tourism (4:00 PM - 6:00 PM)                             2022 Regular Session
Customized                                                                                        01/12/2022 11:35 AM
Amendment Status

Tab 1    SB 842 by Brodeur; (Identical to H 01449) Invalid Restrictive Covenants in Health Care

         SB 418 by Pizzo (CO-INTRODUCERS) Jones, Gruters, Perry; (Identical to H 00055) Assistive Technology
Tab 2
         Advisory Council

Tab 3    SB 546 by Gruters; (Similar to CS/H 00123) Consumer Finance Loans

         SB 946 by Gruters (CO-INTRODUCERS) Wright, Hooper, Stewart, Berman, Jones, Harrell, Taddeo,
Tab 4
         Gibson, Torres, Polsky, Ausley, Rouson; (Similar to H 00217) Entertainment Industry




                                                       Page 1 of 1
2022 Regular Session                                The Florida Senate
                             COMMITTEE MEETING EXPANDED AGENDA
                                               COMMERCE AND TOURISM
                                                 Senator Hooper, Chair
                                               Senator Wright, Vice Chair

            MEETING DATE:    Monday, January 10, 2022
                    TIME:    4:00—6:00 p.m.
                  PLACE:     Toni Jennings Committee Room, 110 Senate Building

                  MEMBERS:   Senator Hooper, Chair; Senator Wright, Vice Chair; Senators Diaz, Garcia, Gruters, Hutson, Pizzo,
                             Powell, Taddeo, and Torres

                                                        BILL DESCRIPTION and
 TAB       BILL NO. and INTRODUCER                   SENATE COMMITTEE ACTIONS                             COMMITTEE ACTION

   1    SB 842                            Invalid Restrictive Covenants in Health Care; Defining       Favorable
        Brodeur                           the terms “hospital” and “physician”; specifying that            Yeas 10 Nays 0
        (Identical H 1449)                certain restrictive covenants in employment
                                          agreements between physicians and hospitals do not
                                          support a legitimate business interest; authorizing a
                                          party to an employment agreement to elect to have a
                                          mutually agreed upon arbitrator make a specified
                                          binding determination, etc.

                                          CM       01/10/2022 Favorable
                                          HP
                                          RC


   2    SB 418                            Assistive Technology Advisory Council; Revising              Favorable
        Pizzo                             provisions relating to the membership of and                     Yeas 10 Nays 0
        (Identical H 55)                  appointments and reappointments to the Assistive
                                          Technology Advisory Council; requiring council
                                          members to select a chair from among the council
                                          membership; revising provisions relating to
                                          committees appointed to perform the council’s
                                          functions; expanding the council’s functions to include
                                          fundraising activities, etc.

                                          ED       11/30/2021 Favorable
                                          CM       01/10/2022 Favorable
                                          RC


   3    SB 546                            Consumer Finance Loans; Authorizing an applicant             Favorable
        Gruters                           for a license to make and collect loans under the                Yeas 10 Nays 0
        (Similar CS/H 123)                Florida Consumer Finance Act to provide certain
                                          documents in lieu of evidence of liquid assets;
                                          prohibiting a person licensed to make and collect
                                          consumer finance loans from charging prepayment
                                          penalties for loans; authorizing a licensee or an
                                          applicant for a license to make and collect consumer
                                          finance loans to provide a surety bond, certificate of
                                          deposit, or letter of credit in lieu of evidence of liquid
                                          assets; modifying grounds for denial of license or
                                          disciplinary action for certain violations of the Florida
                                          Consumer Finance Act, etc.

                                          BI       12/01/2021 Favorable
                                          CM       01/10/2022 Favorable
                                          RC




                                                                                                                     S-036 (10/2008)
01102022.1638                                                                                                            Page 1 of 2
COMMITTEE MEETING EXPANDED AGENDA
Commerce and Tourism
Monday, January 10, 2022, 4:00—6:00 p.m.

                                                       BILL DESCRIPTION and
 TAB      BILL NO. and INTRODUCER                   SENATE COMMITTEE ACTIONS                           COMMITTEE ACTION

  4     SB 946                            Entertainment Industry; Creating the Targeted High        Favorable
        Gruters                           Wage Production Program within the Department of              Yeas 9 Nays 1
        (Similar H 217)                   Economic Opportunity under the supervision of the
                                          Commissioner of Film and Entertainment; requiring
                                          that film, television, and digital media projects being
                                          produced in this state meet specified criteria to be
                                          eligible for tax credit awards; requiring a certified
                                          project to make a good faith effort to use existing
                                          providers of infrastructure or equipment in this state
                                          and to employ residents of this state; requiring the
                                          Florida Film and Entertainment Advisory Council to
                                          determine a score for each qualified project using
                                          specified criteria; requiring the department to
                                          disqualify a project under certain circumstances, etc.

                                          CM       01/10/2022 Favorable
                                          FT
                                          AP


        Other Related Meeting Documents




                                                                                                                   S-036 (10/2008)
01102022.1638                                                                                                          Page 2 of 2
                                                      The Florida Senate
                  BILL ANALYSIS AND FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT
              (This document is based on the provisions contained in the legislation as of the latest date listed below.)

                  Prepared By: The Professional Staff of the Committee on Commerce and Tourism

BILL:           SB 842
INTRODUCER:     Senator Brodeur
SUBJECT:        Invalid Restrictive Covenants in Health Care
DATE:           January 7, 2022                 REVISED:


           ANALYST                    STAFF DIRECTOR                 REFERENCE                                 ACTION
1. McMillan                         McKay                                 CM              Favorable
2.                                                                        HP
3.                                                                        RC



  I.    Summary:


        SB 842 amends Florida’s non-compete statute, which allows for the enforcement of contracts
        that restrict or prohibit competition as long as such contracts are reasonable in time, area, and
        line of business. Under current law, a person seeking enforcement of a non-compete agreement
        must prove the existence of one or more “legitimate business interests,” which include trade
        secrets; valuable confidential business or professional information; substantial relationships with
        specific prospective or existing customers, patients, or clients; customer goodwill associated with
        an ongoing business by way of trade name, specific geographic location, or specific marketing or
        trade area; or extraordinary or specialized training.

        The bill provides that a restrictive covenant in an employment agreement between a physician
        and a hospital is not supported by a legitimate business interest if it does not include an option
        for the physician to buy out of the restrictive covenant at a reasonable price. If such an option is
        not provided, the restrictive covenant is void and unenforceable. This provision applies to
        restrictive covenants entered into on or after July 1, 2022. The bill also provides that any party to
        an employment agreement which believes that the price to buy out of the restrictive covenant in
        the agreement is unreasonable may elect to have a mutually agreed upon arbitrator determine a
        reasonable price.

        The bill takes effect July 1, 2022.
BILL: SB 842                                                                                                    Page 2

    II.   Present Situation:

          Federal Antitrust Laws

          In 1890, Congress passed the first antitrust law, the Sherman Act, as a comprehensive charter of
          economic liberty aimed at preserving free and unfettered competition as the rule of trade.
          Congress subsequently passed two additional antitrust laws in 1914: the Federal Trade
          Commission Act, which created the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), and the Clayton Act.
          Currently, these are the three core federal antitrust laws.1

          The Sherman Act
          The Sherman Act outlaws every contract, combination, or conspiracy in restraint of trade, and
          any monopolization, attempted monopolization, or conspiracy or combination to monopolize.
          The Sherman Act does not prohibit every restraint of trade, only those that are unreasonable. For
          example, an agreement between two individuals to form a partnership may restrain trade, but
          may not do so unreasonably, and thus may be lawful under the antitrust laws. In contrast, certain
          acts are considered “per se” violations of the Sherman Act because they are so harmful to
          competition. These include plain arrangements among competing individuals or businesses to fix
          prices, divide markets, or rig bids.2

          The penalties for violating the Sherman Act can be severe. Although most enforcement actions
          are civil, the Sherman Act is also a criminal law, and individuals and businesses that violate it
          may be prosecuted by the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ). Criminal prosecutions are typically
          limited to intentional and clear violations, such as when competitors fix prices or rig bids. The
          Sherman Act imposes criminal penalties of up to $100 million for a corporation and $1 million
          for an individual, along with up to 10 years in prison.3 Under some circumstances, the maximum
          fines can reach twice the gain or loss involved.4

          The Federal Trade Commission Act
          The Federal Trade Commission Act prohibits unfair methods of competition and unfair or
          deceptive acts or practices. The Supreme Court has said that all violations of the Sherman Act
          also violate the FTC Act. Therefore, the FTC can bring cases under the FTC Act against the
          same kinds of activities that violate the Sherman Act. The FTC Act also reaches other practices
          that harm competition but that may not fit neatly into categories of conduct formally prohibited
          by the Sherman Act. Only the FTC brings cases under the FTC Act.5




1
  See The Antitrust Laws, Federal Trade Commission, available at https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-
guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/antitrust-laws (last visited Jan. 7, 2022).
2
  Id.
3
  See Antitrust Enforcement and the Consumer, U.S. Department of Justice, available at
https://www.justice.gov/atr/file/800691/download (last visited Jan. 7, 2022).
4
  Id.
5
  See The Antitrust Laws, Federal Trade Commission, available at https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-
guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/antitrust-laws (last visited Jan. 7, 2022).
BILL: SB 842                                                                                                            Page 3

         The Clayton Act
         The Clayton Act addresses specific practices that the Sherman Act does not clearly prohibit, such
         as mergers and interlocking directorates.6 It also bans mergers and acquisitions where the effect
         may substantially lessen competition or create a monopoly. As amended by the Robinson-
         Patman Act of 1936, the Clayton Act also prohibits certain discriminatory prices, services, and
         allowances in dealings between merchants. The Clayton Act was amended again in 1976 by the
         Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act to require companies planning large mergers or
         acquisitions to notify the government of their plans in advance. Additionally, private parties are
         authorized to sue for triple damages when they have been harmed by conduct that violates either
         the Sherman or Clayton Act and to obtain a court order prohibiting the anticompetitive practice
         in the future.7

         Florida Antitrust Laws

         Florida law also provides protections against anticompetitive practices. Chapter 542, F.S., the
         Florida Antitrust Act of 1980, has a stated purpose to complement the body of federal law
         prohibiting restraints of trade or commerce in order to foster effective competition.8 It outlaws
         every contract, combination, or conspiracy in restraint of trade or commerce in Florida9 and any
         person from monopolizing or attempting or conspiring to monopolize any part of trade.10

         Contracts in Restraint of Trade or Commerce
         Generally, a contract in restraint of trade or commerce in Florida is unlawful.11 However, non-
         competition restrictive covenants12 contained in employment agreements that are reasonable in
         time, area, and line of business are not prohibited.13 In any action concerning enforcement of a
         restrictive covenant, a court may not enforce a restrictive covenant unless it is set forth in a
         writing signed by the person against whom enforcement is sought, and the person seeking
         enforcement of a restrictive covenant must prove the existence of one or more legitimate
         business interests justifying the restrictive covenant.14 The term “legitimate business interest”
         includes, but is not limited to:
          Trade secrets;15
          Valuable confidential business or professional information that otherwise does not qualify as
             trade secrets;


6
  “Interlocking directorates” means the same person making business decisions for competing companies. See also Id.
7
  Id.
8
  Section 542.16, F.S.
9
  Section 542.18, F.S.
10
   Section 542.19, F.S.
11
   Section 542.18, F.S.
12
   Section 542.335, F.S. employs the term “restrictive covenants” and includes all contractual restrictions such as
noncompetition/nonsolicitation agreements, confidentiality agreements, exclusive dealing agreements, and all other
contractual restraints of trade. See Henao v. Prof'l Shoe Repair, Inc., 929 So.2d 723, 726 (Fla. 5th DCA 2006).
13
   Section 542.335(1), F.S.
14
   Id.
15
   Section 688.002(4), F.S., defines a trade secret as information, including a formula, pattern, compilation, program, device,
method, technique, or process that derives independent economic value, actual or potential, from not being generally known
to, and not being readily ascertainable by proper means by, other persons who can obtain economic value from its disclosure
or use; and is the subject of efforts that are reasonable under the circumstances to maintain its secrecy.
BILL: SB 842                                                                                                             Page 4

            Substantial relationships with specific prospective or existing customers, patients, or clients;
            Customer, patient, or client goodwill associated with:
             o An ongoing business or professional practice, by way of trade name, trademark, service
                mark, or “trade dress”;
             o A specific geographic location; or
             o A specific marketing or trade area; or
            Extraordinary or specialized training.16

         Any restrictive covenant not supported by a legitimate business interest is unlawful and is void
         and unenforceable.17 A person seeking enforcement of a restrictive covenant must prove that the
         contractually specified restraint is reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate business interest
         or interests justifying the restriction.18

         Restrictive Covenants in Healthcare
         Currently in Florida, a restrictive covenant entered into with a physician who practices a medical
         specialty in a county where one entity employs or contracts with all physicians who practice that
         specialty in that county is not supported by a legitimate business interest, and is void and
         unenforceable.19 The restrictive covenant remains void and unenforceable until 3 years after the
         date on which a second entity that employs or contracts with one or more physicians who
         practice that specialty begins serving patients in that county.20

III.     Effect of Proposed Changes:

         The bill amends s. 542.336, F.S., to provide that a restrictive covenant in an employment
         agreement between a physician and a hospital is not supported by a legitimate business interest if
         it does not include an option for the physician to buy out of the restrictive covenant at a
         reasonable price.21 If such an option is not provided, the restrictive covenant is void and
         unenforceable. This provision applies to restrictive covenants entered into on or after July 1,
         2022. The bill also provides that any party to an employment agreement which believes that the
         price to buy out of the restrictive covenant in the agreement is unreasonable may elect to have a
         mutually agreed upon arbitrator determine a reasonable price.

         The bill establishes the following definitions:
          “Hospital” means a hospital as defined in s. 395.002(13), F.S.,22 which is licensed under
            Chapter 395 of the Florida Statutes and part II of Chapter 408 of the Florida Statutes; and

16
   Section 542.335(1)(b), F.S.
17
   Id.
18
   Section 542.335(1)(c), F.S.
19
   Section 542.336, F.S.
20
   Id.
21
   The bill does not define the term “reasonable price,” which may lead to differing interpretations of the meaning of the term.
22
   Section 395.002(13), F.S. defines “hospital” as any establishment that offers services more intensive than those required
for room, board, personal services, and general nursing care, and offers facilities and beds for use beyond 24 hours by
individuals requiring diagnosis, treatment, or care for illness, injury, deformity, infirmity, abnormality, disease, or pregnancy,
and regularly makes available at least clinical laboratory services, diagnostic X-ray services, and treatment facilities for
surgery or obstetrical care, or other definitive medical treatment of similar extent, except that a critical access hospital, as
defined in s. 408.07, F.S., must not be required to make available treatment facilities for surgery, obstetrical care, or similar
BILL: SB 842                                                                                                              Page 5

             “Physician” means a person licensed to practice medicine under Chapter 458 of the Florida
              Statutes or osteopathic medicine under Chapter 459 of the Florida Statutes.

         The bill takes effect July 1, 2022.

IV.      Constitutional Issues:

         A.       Municipality/County Mandates Restrictions:

                  None.

         B.       Public Records/Open Meetings Issues:

                  None.

         C.       Trust Funds Restrictions:

                  None.

         D.       State Tax or Fee Increases:

                  None.

         E.       Other Constitutional Issues:

V.       Fiscal Impact Statement:

         A.       Tax/Fee Issues:

                  None.

         B.       Private Sector Impact:

                  The ability for physicians to buy out of a restrictive covenant in an employment
                  agreement with a hospital may provide patients with more access to physicians and
                  decrease healthcare costs.

         C.       Government Sector Impact:

                  None.

VI.      Technical Deficiencies:

         None.




services as long as it maintains its critical access hospital designation and must be required to make such facilities available
only if it ceases to be designated as a critical access hospital.
 BILL: SB 842                                                                                                                              Page 6

VII.        Related Issues:

            If parties to an employment agreement mutually agree that arbitration is necessary, the Florida
            Arbitration Code applies.23

VIII.       Statutes Affected:

            This bill substantially amends section 542.336 of the Florida Statutes.

 IX.        Additional Information:

            A.        Committee Substitute – Statement of Changes:
                      (Summarizing differences between the Committee Substitute and the prior version of the bill.)

                      None.

            B.        Amendments:

                      None.

              This Senate Bill Analysis does not reflect the intent or official position of the bill’s introducer or the Florida Senate.




 23
      See s. 682.013, F.S.
       Florida Senate - 2022                                           SB 842          Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 842



       By Senator Brodeur




       9-00540-22                                                   2022842__          9-00540-22                                                 2022842__
1                              A bill to be entitled                            30     in that county is not supported by a legitimate business
2             An act relating to invalid restrictive covenants in               31     interest. The Legislature finds that such covenants restrict
3             health care; amending s. 542.336, F.S.; defining the              32     patient access to physicians, increase costs, and are void and
4             terms “hospital” and “physician”; specifying that                 33     unenforceable under current law. Such restrictive covenants
5             certain restrictive covenants in employment agreements            34     shall remain void and unenforceable for 3 years after the date
6             between physicians and hospitals do not support a                 35     on which a second entity that employs or contracts with, either
7             legitimate business interest; authorizing a party to              36     directly or through related or affiliated entities, one or more
8             an employment agreement to elect to have a mutually               37     physicians who practice such specialty begins offering such
9             agreed upon arbitrator make a specified binding                   38     specialty services in that county.
10            determination; providing a legislative finding;                   39          (3) A restrictive covenant in an employment agreement
11            providing applicability; providing an effective date.             40     between a physician and a hospital is not supported by a
12                                                                              41     legitimate business interest if it does not include an option
13     Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:                42     for the physician to buy out of the restrictive covenant at a
14                                                                              43     reasonable price. Any party to an employment agreement which
15            Section 1. Section 542.336, Florida Statutes, is amended to       44     believes that the price to buy out of the restrictive covenant
16     read:                                                                    45     in the agreement is unreasonable may elect to have a mutually
17            542.336 Invalid restrictive covenants.—                           46     agreed upon arbitrator determine a reasonable price, and such
18            (1) As used in this section, the term:                            47     arbitrator’s decision is binding on the parties. The Legislature
19            (a) “Hospital” means a hospital as defined in s.                  48     finds that a restrictive covenant without this option limits
20     395.002(13) which is licensed under chapter 395 and part II of           49     patient access to physicians and increases costs and is void and
21     chapter 408.                                                             50     unenforceable. This subsection applies to restrictive covenants
22            (b) “Physician” means a person licensed to practice               51     entered into on or after July 1, 2022.
23     medicine under chapter 458 or osteopathic medicine under chapter         52          Section 2. This act shall take effect July 1, 2022.
24     459.
25            (2) A restrictive covenant entered into with a physician
26     who is licensed under chapter 458 or chapter 459 and who
27     practices a medical specialty in a county wherein one entity
28     employs or contracts with, either directly or through related or
29     affiliated entities, all physicians who practice such specialty

                                    Page 1 of 2                                                                   Page 2 of 2
     CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.           CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
                                                        The Florida Senate
                    BILL ANALYSIS AND FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT
                (This document is based on the provisions contained in the legislation as of the latest date listed below.)

                    Prepared By: The Professional Staff of the Committee on Commerce and Tourism

BILL:             SB 418
INTRODUCER:       Senator Pizzo and others
SUBJECT:          Assistive Technology Advisory Council
DATE:             January 7, 2022                 REVISED:


           ANALYST                      STAFF DIRECTOR                 REFERENCE                                 ACTION
1. Palazesi                           Bouck                                 ED              Favorable
2. McMillan                           McKay                                 CM              Favorable
3.                                                                          RC



    I.    Summary:

          SB 418 modifies the composition of the Florida Assistive Technology Advisory Council
          (Council), which is responsible for the comprehensive statewide program of technology related
          assistance for individuals with disabilities. The bill also:
           Removes the maximum limit on Council membership and modifies requirements specifying
              representation on the Council;
           Requires the appointment of a single chair of the Council;
           Modifies requirements for reappointments to the Council;
           Removes the designation of specific committees; and
           Expands the Council’s functions to include fundraising activities.

          The bill takes effect on July 1, 2022.

    II.   Present Situation:

          Assistive technology helps people with disabilities live, work, learn, and play as independently
          as possible. It is any device, item, gadget, tool, hardware, or software used to increase, maintain,
          or improve the functional capabilities of both individuals of all ages who have disabilities and
          older adults who may find a need for assistance. Assistive technology provides people who have
          disabilities the option to access education and the workplace, to live within their communities,
          and enjoy recreational activities.1




1
 Florida Alliance for Assistive Services & Technology, What is Assistive Technology (A.T.)? https://faast.org/ (last visited
Jan. 7, 2022).
BILL: SB 418                                                                                             Page 2

         Federal Law

         In 2004, the Assistive Technology Act of 1998 was amended by the Assistive Technology Act of
         2004 (Act), to recognize the substantial progress that had been made in the development of
         assistive technology devices that benefit individuals with disabilities.2 The Act requires the
         Secretary of Education to support state grant programs that assist states in undertaking activities
         for maximizing the ability of individuals with disabilities across the human lifespan and across
         the wide array of disabilities.3 In addition, the Act requires states to establish advisory councils
         for the purpose of consumer-response and consumer-driven advice to the state for planning,
         implementation, and evaluation of activities carried out through the grants made available by the
         Act.4

         The state implemented advisory council must be comprised of the following members:5
          Individuals with disabilities that use assistive technology or the family members or guardians
            of the individuals;
          A representative of the designated State agency;
          A representative of a state center for independent living;
          A representative of the state workforce development board established under section 101 of
            the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act;
          A representative of the State educational agency; and
          Representatives of other state agencies, public agencies, or private organizations, as
            determined by the state.

         Further, states are required to ensure a majority of the members of the advisory council are
         members appointed as individuals with disabilities, or family members or guardians of
         individuals with disabilities that use assistive technology.6 The council must also be
         geographically representative of the state and reflect the diversity of the state with respect to
         race, ethnicity, types of disabilities across the age span, and users of types of services that an
         individual with a disability may receive.7

         Florida Law

         The Assistive Technology Advisory Council (Council) is responsible for ensuring consumer
         involvement in the creation, application, and distribution of technology-related assistance to and
         for persons who have disabilities.8 The Council acts as the board of directors and provides
         direction, through a not-for-profit corporation created by the Division of Vocational




2
  29 U.S.C. s. 3001, et. seq.
3
  29 U.S.C. s. 3003(a).
4
  29 U.S.C. s. 3003(c)(2)(A).
5
  29 U.S.C. s. 3003(c)(2)(B)(i).
6
  29 U.S.C. s. 3003(c)(2)(B)(ii)(I).
7
  29 U.S.C. s. 3003(c)(2)(B)(iii).
8
  Section 413.407, F.S.
BILL: SB 418                                                                                                                Page 3

         Rehabilitation (DVR) of the Department of Education, to Florida’s Alliance for Assistive
         Services and Technology.9

         The Council may not exceed 27 members at any one time. The Council must be composed of the
         following members:10
          Individuals who have disabilities11 and who are assistive technology consumers or family
             members or guardians of those individuals;12
          Representatives of consumer organizations concerned with assistive technology;
          Representatives of business and industry, including the insurance industry, concerned with
             assistive technology;
          A representative of the Division of Vocational Rehabilitation;
          A representative of the Division of Blind Services;
          A representative of the Florida Independent Living Council;
          A representative of CareerSource Florida, Inc.;
          A representative of the Department of Education; and
          Representatives of other state agencies that provide or coordinate services for persons with
             disabilities.

         The Council is appointed by the Commissioner of Education from a list of candidates proposed
         by the director of the DVR.13 The Council is required to appoint two co-chairs among the
         membership of the Council.14 Members of the Council serve for a term of 3 years and cannot
         serve more than two consecutive terms, and a member that has served two consecutive terms
         must be retired from the council for at least 1 year prior to reappointment.15

         Members of the Council are required to appoint committees made up of members of the council
         to focus on specific issues within the council’s mandates.16 The Council’s committees must
         include, but are not limited to:17
          An interagency committee composed of those members representing state agencies;18



9
  Section 413.407(2)(a) F.S. Florida’s Alliance for Assistive Services and Technology is a project sponsored by the
Department of Education for the coordination and delivery of appropriate, cost-effective, state-of-the-art assistive technology
services and devices. See Id.
10
   Section 413.407(1)(a), F.S.
11
   A “disability” means a physical or mental impairment that constitutes or results in a substantial impediment to
employment. See s. 413.20(7), F.S.
12
   These individuals must make up a majority of the membership.
13
   Section 413.407(1)(b), F.S.
14
   Section 413.407(1)(d), F.S.
15
   Section 413.407(1)(e), F.S.
16
   Committees may request and accept in-kind contributions of personnel from public or private entities to supply such
staffing as the committees deem necessary to carry out their individual mandates. See s. 413.407(2)(b), F.S.
17
   Section 413.407(2)(b), F.S.
18
  The interagency committee must work towards the development of cooperative agreements among government agencies
and perform other duties as the council deems appropriate. The interagency committee’s members must assign staff from
their respective agencies to the alliance, as an in-kind contribution for a specified period of time, to review federal and state
legislation and agency policies and practices and to identify both facilitators of, and barriers to, accessibility and utilization of
assistive technology services, devices, and funding sources. See s. 413.407(2)(b)1., F.S.
BILL: SB 418                                                                                           Page 4

           A technology-awareness committee to guide the Council’s public awareness, coordination,
            and collaboration activities; and
           A public policy and advocacy committee to review federal and state legislation and agency
            policies and practices and to identify facilitators of and barriers to access and utilization of
            assistive technology services, devices, and funding sources.

III.   Effect of Proposed Changes:

       The bill modifies s. 413.407, F.S., to revise the composition of the Florida Assistive Technology
       Council (Council) to allow only one representative of a consumer organization and one
       representative of business and industry. The bill authorizes a representative from a center for
       independent living, rather than from the Florida Independent Living Council. The bill also
       provides that a representative from another state agency that provides or coordinates services for
       persons with disabilities can be added to the Council if requested by a majority vote of the
       Council members, and that representative must be appointed by the head of the corresponding
       state agency. Additionally, the bill removes the requirement that Council membership may not
       exceed 27 members.

       The bill aligns the Council membership with federal requirements that members of the Council
       be geographically representative of the state, reflective of the diversity of the state’s population
       with respect to race, ethnicity, age, gender, type of disability, and type of disability-related
       services and devices received. The bill directs the Council to elect a single chair of the council.
       The bill maintains the limit of two consecutive terms for members, but revises the number of
       years a council member must be retired from the Council after two consecutive terms to be
       reappointed, from 1 year to 3 years.

       The bill deletes the requirement that Council members form a technology awareness committee
       and a public policy and advocacy committee. The bill removes the interagency committee, and
       assigns the duties of that committee to the members representing state agencies. The bill also
       allows Council members to participate in fundraising activities on behalf of the Council, which
       could lead to additional funding for the Council.

       The bill takes effect on July 1, 2022.

IV.    Constitutional Issues:

       A.      Municipality/County Mandates Restrictions:

               None.

       B.      Public Records/Open Meetings Issues:

               None.

       C.      Trust Funds Restrictions:

               None.
 BILL: SB 418                                                                                                                         Page 5

        D.       State Tax or Fee Increases:

                 None.

        E.       Other Constitutional Issues:

                 None.

  V.    Fiscal Impact Statement:

        A.       Tax/Fee Issues:

                 None.

        B.       Private Sector Impact:

                 None.

        C.       Government Sector Impact:

                 None.

 VI.    Technical Deficiencies:

        None.

VII.    Related Issues:

        The bill allows the Council to do fundraising activities. Section 20.03, F.S., provides that a
        “council” or “advisory council” means an advisory body created by specific statutory enactment
        and appointed to function on a continuing basis for the study of the problems arising in a
        specified functional or program area of state government and to provide recommendations and
        policy alternatives.

VIII.   Statutes Affected:

        This bill substantially amends section 413.407 of the Florida Statutes.

 IX.    Additional Information:

        A.       Committee Substitute – Statement of Changes:
                 (Summarizing differences between the Committee Substitute and the prior version of the bill.)

                 None.

        B.       Amendments:

                 None.

         This Senate Bill Analysis does not reflect the intent or official position of the bill’s introducer or the Florida Senate.
       Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 418          Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 418



       By Senator Pizzo




       38-00542-22                                                2022418__          38-00542-22                                                2022418__
1                              A bill to be entitled                          30          1. Persons Individuals who have disabilities and who are
2           An act relating to the Assistive Technology Advisory              31     assistive technology consumers or family members or guardians of
3           Council; amending s. 413.407, F.S.; revising                      32     those persons individuals.
4           provisions relating to the membership of and                      33          2. A representative Representatives of a consumer
5           appointments and reappointments to the Assistive                  34     organization organizations concerned with assistive technology.
6           Technology Advisory Council; requiring council members            35          3. A representative Representatives of business and
7           to select a chair from among the council membership;              36     industry, including the insurance industry, concerned with
8           revising provisions relating to committees appointed              37     assistive technology.
9           to perform the council’s functions; expanding the                 38          4. A representative of the Division of Vocational
10          council’s functions to include fundraising activities;            39     Rehabilitation.
11          providing an effective date.                                      40          5. A representative of the Division of Blind Services.
12                                                                            41          6. A representative of a center for independent living the
13     Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:              42     Florida Independent Living Council.
14                                                                            43          7. A representative of CareerSource Florida, Inc.
15          Section 1. Section 413.407, Florida Statutes, is amended to       44          8. A representative of the Department of Education.
16     read:                                                                  45          9. A representative Representatives of any other state
17          413.407 Assistive Technology Advisory Council.—There is           46     agency agencies that provides or coordinates provide or
18     created the Assistive Technology Advisory Council, responsible         47     coordinate services for persons with disabilities, if requested
19     for ensuring consumer involvement in the creation, application,        48     by a majority vote of the council members.
20     and distribution of technology-related assistance to and for           49
21     persons who have disabilities. The council shall fulfill its           50     Total membership on the council may not exceed 27 at any one
22     responsibilities through statewide policy development, both            51     time. A majority of the members shall be appointed in accordance
23     state and federal legislative initiatives, advocacy at both the        52     with subparagraph 1.
24     state and federal levels level, planning of statewide resource         53          (b) Members of the council shall be appointed by the
25     allocations, policy-level management, and reviews of both              54     Commissioner of Education from a list of candidates proposed by
26     consumer responsiveness and the adequacy of program service            55     the division director. However, a member who is a representative
27     delivery, and by performing the functions listed in this               56     of a state agency shall be appointed by the head of that state
28     section.                                                               57     agency.
29          (1)(a) The council shall be composed of:                          58          (c) A majority of council members must shall be persons who

                                   Page 1 of 6                                                                    Page 2 of 6
     CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.         CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
       Florida Senate - 2022                                        SB 418           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 418




       38-00542-22                                              2022418__            38-00542-22                                                2022418__
59     have disabilities as defined in s. 413.20 and s. 413.20(7) who        88      council shall be filled in the same manner as the original
60     are also consumers of assistive technology or family members or       89      appointment. A vacancy does not affect the power of the
61     guardians of such persons.                                            90      remaining members to execute the duties of the council.
62          (d) Members of the council must be geographically                91           (2) In addition to the other functions specified in this
63     representative of the state and reflect the diversity of the          92      section, the council shall:
64     state’s population with respect to race, ethnicity, gender, age,      93           (a) Act as the board of directors of a not-for-profit
65     type of disability, and type of disability-related services and       94      corporation created by the division. Through the corporation,
66     devices received.                                                     95      the council shall provide direction to the Florida Florida’s
67          (e)(d) The members of the council shall select a chair two       96      Alliance for Assistive Services and Technology, a project
68     co-chairs from among the membership of the council.                   97      sponsored by the department for the coordination and delivery of
69          1. One co-chair may be selected from the group described in      98      appropriate, cost-effective, state-of-the-art assistive
70     paragraph (c) and one co-chair shall be selected from the other       99      technology services and devices.
71     council members.                                                      100          (b) Appoint committees made up of members of the council to
72          2. The chair No co-chair may not be an elected member or an      101     focus on specific issues within the council’s mandate.
73     employee of a state agency or of any political subdivision of         102     Committees may request and accept in-kind contributions of
74     the state.                                                            103     personnel from public or private entities to supply such
75          (f)1.(e)1. Each member of the council shall serve for a          104     staffing as the committees deem necessary to carry out their
76     term of not more than 3 years, except that a member appointed to      105     individual mandates. These committees shall include, but are not
77     fill a vacancy occurring before prior to the expiration of the        106     limited to:
78     term for which a predecessor was appointed shall be appointed         107          1. Members who are representatives of state agencies
79     for the remainder of such term.                                       108     serving on the committees An interagency committee composed of
80          2. A No member of the council may not serve more than two        109     those members representing state agencies. The interagency
81     consecutive terms; however, any appointment under subparagraph        110     committee shall work towards the development of cooperative
82     1., if for less than 18 months, is shall not be considered a          111     agreements among government agencies and perform such other
83     term for the purposes of this section.                                112     duties as the council deems appropriate.
84          3. A member who has served two consecutive terms and has         113          2. Members who are representatives of state agencies
85     been retired from the council for at least 3 years 1 year may be      114     serving on the committees The interagency committee’s members
86     reappointed to the council on the same basis as a new member.         115     shall assign staff from their respective agencies to the
87          (g)(f) Any vacancy occurring in the membership of the            116     alliance, as an in-kind contribution for a specified period of

                                    Page 3 of 6                                                                    Page 4 of 6
     CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.         CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 418           Florida Senate - 2022                                        SB 418




        38-00542-22                                                2022418__           38-00542-22                                                2022418__
117     time, to review federal and state legislation and agency               146     of its discussions and recommendations and must, all of which
118     policies and practices and to identify both facilitators of, and       147     reports shall be made available to the public.
119     barriers to, accessibility and utilization of assistive                148          (3) In accordance with Pub. L. No. 108-364, the council
120     technology services, devices, and funding sources.                     149     shall:
121          2. A technology-awareness committee to guide the council’s        150          (a) Investigate financing options that will increase access
122     public awareness, coordination, and collaboration activities.          151     to and funding for assistive technology devices and assistive
123          3. A public policy and advocacy committee to review federal       152     technology services.
124     and state legislation and agency policies and practices and to         153          (b) Develop assistive technology demonstrations,
125     identify facilitators of and barriers to access and utilization        154     reutilization programs, and loan programs.
126     of assistive technology services, devices, and funding sources.        155          (c) Provide training and technical assistance in order to
127          (c) Review and approve all reports, recommendations, and          156     increase knowledge and awareness of the uses and benefits of
128     proposed actions of committee staff.                                   157     assistive technology devices and assistive technology services.
129          (d) Appoint the executive director of the alliance who is.        158          (d) Promote public awareness activities designed to provide
130     The executive director shall be responsible for the overall            159     information relating to the benefits of assistive technology
131     administration and day-to-day direction of the alliance,               160     devices and assistive technology services.
132     including the as well as supervision of all staff.                     161          (e) Promote coordination and collaboration among public and
133          (e) Annually review and approve the strategic or business         162     private entities that are responsible for policies, procedures,
134     plan of the alliance, as submitted by the executive director.          163     or funding for the provision of assistive technology devices and
135          (f) Submit an annual comprehensive report of the activities       164     assistive technology services.
136     of the council, the corporation, and the alliance to the               165          Section 2. This act shall take effect July 1, 2022.
137     division director.
138          (g) Perform such other functions, including fundraising
139     activities, as the council determines to be appropriate which
140     are comparable to functions performed by the council.
141          (h) Convene at least four meetings each year in locations
142     that such places as it determines to be necessary to conduct
143     council business and may conduct such forums or hearings as it
144     the council considers appropriate. The council shall make a
145     report of each meeting which must contain shall include a record

                                   Page 5 of 6                                                                    Page 6 of 6
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
                      2021 AGENCY LEGISLATIVE BILL ANALYSIS
                         Florida Office of Financial Regulation


                                         BILL INFORMATION

BILL NUMBER:        HB 895

BILL TITLE:         Consumer Finance Loans

BILL SPONSOR:       Representative Stevenson

EFFECTIVE DATE:     July 1, 2021


         COMMITTEES OF REFERENCE                                       CURRENT COMMITTEE
1)

2)

3)                                                                         SIMILAR BILLS
                                                         BILL NUMBER:
4)
                                                         SPONSOR:
5)


                                                                          IDENTICAL BILLS
                                                         BILL NUMBER:
              PREVIOUS LEGISLATION
BILL NUMBER:                                             SPONSOR:

SPONSOR:
YEAR:
LAST ACTION:                                             Is this bill part of an agency package?

                                                         No
                                   BILL ANALYSIS INFORMATION
DATE OF ANALYSIS:              February 17, 2021

LEAD AGENCY ANALYST:           Alexander J. Anderson, Director of Legislative Affairs
                               (850) 410-9601
ADDITIONAL ANALYST(S):         Gregory C. Oaks, Director, Division of Consumer Finance
                               (850) 410-9601
LEGAL ANALYST:                 Tony Cammarata, General Counsel
                               (850) 410-9601
FISCAL ANALYST:                Buckley Vernon, Financial Administrator
                               (850) 410-9673
2021 Agency Bill Analysis




                                                     POLICY ANALYSIS

    1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
         The legislation would amend s. 516.031, F.S., by explicitly prohibiting a consumer finance company licensee from
         charging a prepayment penalty to a borrower paying all or part of loan principal before the due date.

         The legislation would amend s. 516.36, F.S., by requiring a consumer finance loan to have a loan term of at least
         90 days for loans with a principal balance of no more than $4,000 at the time of origination, or a term of at least
         12 months for loans with a principal balance exceeding $4,000 at the time of origination.

         The legislation would also apply to a financial technology sandbox licensee licensed pursuant to chapter 559,
         F.S., offering consumer finance loans under chapter 516, F.S.

         The provisions of the bill would take effect July 1, 2021.

    2. SUBSTANTIVE BILL ANALYSIS
    1. PRESENT SITUATION:
       The Office of Financial Regulation has regulatory oversight over consumer finance companies licensed pursuant
       to chapter 516, F.S., money services businesses licensed pursuant to chapter 560, F.S., and financial technology
       sandbox business entities licensed pursuant to chapter, F.S., and other financial services entities. As of February
       16, 2021, the office records reflect 170 consumer finance companies who hold a total of 382 licenses.

         Under the current provisions of chapter 516, F.S., in order to lend any amount up to $25,000 and charge an interest
         greater than 18% per annum, a person must be licensed as a consumer finance company. The maximum interest
         rates on a consumer finance loan are incremental: 30% per annum, computed on the first $3,000 of the principal
         amount; 24% per annum computed on the part of the principal amount exceeding $3,000 and up to $4,000; and
         18% per annum on the part of the principal exceeding $4,000 and up to $25,000.

         In addition to interest charges, current law only allows the following charges: an amount up to $25 for costs
         related to investigating the character and credit of the borrower; an annual fee of $25 on each line-of-credit
         account; charges paid for the brokerage fee on a loan or line of credit of more than $10,000; a delinquency
         charge of up to $15 for each payment in default for at least 10 days if the charge is agreed upon, in writing,
         between the parties before imposing the charge; and certain other allowable ancillary fees and charges related
         to the loan. See s. 516.031(3), F.S.

         If all or part of the consideration for a new loan contract is the unpaid principal balance of a prior loan, the principal
         amount payable under the new loan contract may include not more than 60 days’ unpaid interest accrued on the
         prior loan.

         Every loan made pursuant to chapter 516, F.S., except for lines of credit, are to be repaid in periodic
         installments as nearly equal as mathematically practicable, except that the final payment may be less than the
         amount of the prior installments. Installments may be due every 2 weeks, semimonthly, or monthly.

         Section 516.15(3), F.S., requires a licensee to permit payment of a loan, in whole or in part, prior to its
         maturity, with interest owed up until the date of such payment.

         Section 516.031, F.S., sets forth the only charges permissible under chapter 516, F.S. As a pre-payment penalty
         is not an allowable charge under section 516.031, F.S., a licensee is implicitly prohibited from charging a
         prepayment penalty.
         Current law does not set a minimum or maximum loan term. The loan term is negotiated between the licensee and
         borrower.

         Certain financial technology sandbox business entities licensed pursuant to s. 559.952, F.S., may operate as
         consumer finance companies pursuant to limited provisions of chapter 516, F.S. Such licensees are subject to the
         provisions of section 516.031, F.S., which sets forth the only allowable charges. Additionally, such licensees are


                                                                                                                                2
2021 Agency Bill Analysis


         subject to the provisions of section 516.36, F.S., meaning such licensees must act in accordance with installment
         loan requirements found in section 516.36, F.S.

         Persons licensed pursuant to part IV, of chapter 560, F.S., as deferred presentment providers are authorized to
         enter into deferred presentment installment transactions with consumers. Such transactions allow a consumer to
         borrow up to $1,000 for a period of at least 60-days, but not beyond 90-days, repayable in substantially equal and
         consecutive installments according to a payment schedule agreed upon by the parties with no less than 13 days
         and not more than 1 calendar month between payments, except that the first payment may be longer than 13 days
         and may be greater than the rest of the payments.


    2. EFFECT OF THE BILL:
         Section 1 explicitly provides that a licensee may not require a borrower to pay a prepayment penalty for paying
         all or part of a loan principal before the payment due date. Section 516.15, F.S., requires a licensee to allow
         payment of a loan, in part or whole, prior to its maturity with interest owed up until the date of such payment. As
         such, the proposed law and the current law allow for the pre-payment of a loan before it reaches maturity. The
         proposed law prohibits a pre-payment penalty, while the current law in section 516.15, F.S., prohibits the
         assessment of interest after the payment.
         Section 516.031, F.S., limits a licensees’ ability to assess certain charges. Consequently, only those charges
         explicitly set forth in section 516.031, F.S., may be charged. A pre-payment penalty is not one of the charges
         prescribed in s. 516.031, F.S., hence, a licensee is prohibited from charging a borrower a pre-payment penalty.
         Much like the proposed language, section 516.031, F.S., prohibits a licensee from charging a pre-payment
         penalty, except that once the proposed language becomes law, such behavior would be an explicit prohibition
         rather than an implied prohibition.
         Additionally, the bill would require other entities licensed by the Office to comply with its provisions. Certain
         financial technology sandbox business entities licensed pursuant to section 559.952, F.S., may operate as
         consumer finance companies pursuant to limited provisions of chapter 516, F.S. Such licensees are subject to the
         provisions of section 516.031, F.S., and would therefore need to comply with the bill’s provisions.


         Section 2 requires loan terms of at least 90 days for loans with a principal balance of no more than $4,000 at the
         time of origination, while requiring a loan term of at least 12 months for loans with a principal balance exceeding
         $4,000 at the time of origination. Current law does not set forth a minimum or maximum loan term. As such, the
         new provisions would now require licensees to set minimum and maximum loan terms in accordance with
         statutory provisions.
         Once in effect, the new provisions would create a loan product substantially similar to a deferred presentment
         installment product offered under part IV of chapter, 560, F.S. Under chapter 560, a customer may enter into a
         deferred presentment installment transaction that allows a customer to borrow up to $1,000 for a period of at least
         60-days, but not beyond 90-days.
         This new provision would not only include consumer finance companies licensed under chapter 516, F.S., but
         would also include financial technology sandbox licensees licensed pursuant to chapter 559, F.S., offering
         consumer finance loans. Once in effect, the new provisions would require such licensees to set minimum and
         maximum loan terms.
         Section 3 provides an effective date of July 1, 2021, meaning the Office would begin enforcing the provisions of
         Section 1 and Section 2, on or after July 1, 2021.


    3. DOES THE LEGISLATION DIRECT OR ALLOW THE AGENCY/BOARD/COMMISSION/DEPARTMENT TO
       DEVELOP, ADOPT, OR ELIMINATE RULES, REGULATIONS, POLICIES, OR PROCEDURES? Y☐ N☒
       If yes, explain:

       Is the change consistent
       with the agency’s core                                       Y☐ N☒
       mission?
       Rule(s) impacted (provide
       references to F.A.C., etc.):   None


                                                                                                                               3
2021 Agency Bill Analysis


    4. WHAT IS THE POSITION OF AFFECTED CITIZENS OR STAKEHOLDER GROUPS?
       Proponents and summary
       of position:                   Unknown
       Opponents and summary of
       position:                      Unknown


    5. ARE THERE ANY REPORTS OR STUDIES REQUIRED BY THIS BILL?                 Y☐ N☒
       If yes, provide a
       description:
       Date Due:

       Bill Section Number(s):



    6. ARE THERE ANY NEW GUBERNATORIAL APPOINTMENTS OR CHANGES TO EXISTING BOARDS, TASK
       FORCES, COUNCILS, COMMISSIONS, ETC. REQUIRED BY THIS BILL?             Y☐ N☒
       Board:

       Board Purpose:

       Who Appoints:

       Changes:

       Bill Section Number(s):




                                                FISCAL ANALYSIS

    1. FISCAL IMPACT TO LOCAL GOVERNMENT                                      Y☐ N☒
       Revenues:

       Expenditures:

       Does the legislation
       increase local taxes or        No
       fees? If yes, explain.
       If yes, does the legislation
       provide for a local
       referendum or local
       governing body public vote
       prior to implementation of
       the tax or fee increase?


    2. FISCAL IMPACT TO STATE GOVERNMENT                                       Y☐ N☒
       Revenues:

       Expenditures:


                                                                                       4
2021 Agency Bill Analysis




       Does the legislation contain
       a State Government             No
       appropriation?
       If yes, was this
       appropriated last year?


    3. FISCAL IMPACT TO THE PRIVATE SECTOR                                          Y☐ N☒
       Revenues:                      Unknown

       Expenditures:
                                      Unknown
       Other:
                                      Unknown


    4. DOES THE BILL INCREASE OR DECREASE TAXES, FEES, OR FINES?                   Y☐ N☒
       If yes, explain impact.

       Bill Section Number:




                                                TECHNOLOGY IMPACT
    1. DOES THE BILL IMPACT THE AGENCY’S TECHNOLOGY SYSTEMS (I.E. IT SUPPORT, LICENSING
       SOFTWARE, DATA STORAGE, ETC.)?                                                Y☐ N☒
       If yes, describe the
       anticipated impact to the
       agency including any fiscal
       impact.




                                                 FEDERAL IMPACT
    1. DOES THE BILL HAVE A FEDERAL IMPACT (I.E. FEDERAL COMPLIANCE, FEDERAL FUNDING, FEDERAL
       AGENCY INVOLVEMENT, ETC.)?                                                   Y☐ N☒
       If yes, describe the
       anticipated impact including
       any fiscal impact.


                                            ADDITIONAL COMMENTS




                                                                                             5
2021 Agency Bill Analysis



                            LEGAL - GENERAL COUNSEL’S OFFICE REVIEW
       Issues/concerns/comments:   OGC has reviewed the agency’s bill analysis concerning HB 895, and the
                                   analysis sufficiently details the effect of the bill and the areas of impact. OGC
                                   has no issues, concerns or further comments regarding the bill.




                                                                                                                       6
                                                        The Florida Senate
                    BILL ANALYSIS AND FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT
                (This document is based on the provisions contained in the legislation as of the latest date listed below.)

                    Prepared By: The Professional Staff of the Committee on Commerce and Tourism

BILL:             SB 546
INTRODUCER:       Senator Gruters
SUBJECT:          Consumer Finance Loans
DATE:             January 7, 2022                 REVISED:


           ANALYST                      STAFF DIRECTOR                 REFERENCE                                 ACTION
1. Arnold                             Knudson                               BI              Favorable
2. Harmsen                            McKay                                 CM              Favorable
3.                                                                          RC



    I.    Summary:

          SB 546 amends the Florida Consumer Finance Act, ch. 516, F.S., to:
           Expressly prohibit prepayment penalties for consumer finance loans;
           Authorize an applicant for licensure as a consumer finance lender or a licensee to provide a
             surety bond, certificate of deposit, or letter of credit in the amount of $25,000, in lieu of the
             application requirement to prove that they have at least $25,000 in liquid assets;
           Require a company with at least one currently licensed location to provide a rider or surety
             bond of at least $5,000 for each additional license; however, the maximum aggregate
             requirement for such a company is $100,000; and
           Make conforming changes.

          The bill takes effect October 1, 2022.

    II.   Present Situation:

          The Office of Financial Regulation’s (OFR) Division of Consumer Finance (Division) licenses
          and regulates non-depository financial service entities and individuals, and conducts
          investigations of licensed entities to determine their compliance with Florida law.1 One such
          product regulated by the OFR is consumer finance loans. A consumer finance loan is a loan of
          money, credit, goods, or interests valued at $25,000 or less with permitted interest rates of
          between 18 and 30 percent per year.2 This is not a traditional loan made by a bank, credit union,




1
  Fla. Office of Fin. Reg, Division of Consumer Finance: What We Do,
https://flofr.gov/sitePages/DivisionOfConsumerFinance.htm (last visited Jan. 7, 2022).
2
  Sections 516.01(2) and 516.031(1), F.S. See also, Fla. Office of Fin. Reg, Consumer Finance Companies,
https://flofr.gov/sitePages/ConsumerFinanceCompanies.htm (last visited Jan. 7, 2022).
BILL: SB 546                                                                                                        Page 2

        or similar institution. The consumer finance lenders do not accept deposits, and earn their
        revenue from the fees charged on the loans they make.3

        Licensure

        Entities that engage in the business of making consumer finance loans must be licensed by the
        Office pursuant to the Florida Consumer Finance Act, ch. 516, F.S. (“the Act”). Each location of
        a consumer finance lender must be separately licensed, even if the separate locations are
        operated by the same business entity.4

        As of February 16, 2021, there are 170 licensed consumer finance loan companies operating in
        Florida across a total of 382 locations. The yearly data for licensure under ch. 516, F.S., is
        contained in the charts below.5

                                            Chapter 516, F.S., Licenses by Year
                           10-11    11-12     12-13   13-14    14-15    15-16   16-17    17-18    18-19    19-20
          Applications
                            175       41       82      116      66      102       55       96      109      100
            Received
          Applications
                            137       37       53      113      37       81       36       83      104       98
            Approved
              Active
                            347      303       293     349      331     349       338     373      348      390
             Licenses
           Renewals &
                            226       0        258      0       312       0       326      0       342       0
          Reactivations

        A consumer finance lender applicant must submit an application fee of $625 and an investigation
        fee of $200 with its application for licensure.6 At the time of application, the applicant must
        provide evidence that it has liquid assets of at least $25,000 on deposit with an insured
        institution.7 An applicant’s failure to maintain liquid assets of at least $25,000 constitutes
        grounds for denial of an application for licensure, and grounds for revocation or suspension of an
        active license.8 Consumer finance lender licenses granted under the Act must be renewed every
        two years, at which time the licensee must pay a $625 biennial license fee.9

        The Act does not apply to persons doing business under state or federal laws governing banks,
        savings banks, trust companies, building and loan associations, credit unions, or industrial loan
        and investment companies.10

3
  Naveen Reddy, What are the Primary Functions of Finance Companies? (Nov. 9, 2020),
https://smallbusiness.chron.com/primary-functions-finance-companies-40480.html (last visited January 7, 2022). Also note,
payday lenders are separately regulated pursuant to ch. 560, F.S.
4
  Sections 516.01(6) and 516.05(3), F.S.
5
  Office of Financial Regulation, Active Licenses, https://www.flofr.com/sitePages/documents/finregstats.pdf (last visited
January 7, 2022).
6
  Section 516.03(1), F.S. See also, Fla. Office of Fin. Reg., Application for Consumer Finance Company License,
https://flofr.gov/sitePages/documents/OFR-516-01.pdf (last visited January 7, 2022).
7
  Section 516.03(1), F.S. Fla. Admin. Code R. 69V-160.030(1)(d).
8
  Section 516.07(1), F.S.
9
  Sections 516.03(1) and 516.05(1) & (2), F.S.
10
   Section 516.02(4), F.S.
BILL: SB 546                                                                                                            Page 3


         Permissible Interest Rates and Fees

         Florida’s prohibition on usury generally prohibits11 interest rates in excess of 18 percent per
         annum simple interest on any loan, advance of money, line of credit, or forbearance. 12 Licensed
         consumer finance lenders, however, may offer interest rates greater than 18 percent per annum
         simple interest, up to the following limits, which are based on the amount of the loan’s
         principal:13
          30 percent on the first $3,000.
          24 percent on principal above $3,000 and up to $4,000.
          18 percent on principal above $4,000 and up to $25,000.

         The Act prohibits lenders from directly or indirectly charging borrowers additional fees as a
         condition to the grant of a loan, except for the following:14
          Up to $25 for investigating the credit and character of the borrower;
          A $25 annual fee on the anniversary date of each line-of-credit account;
          Brokerage fees for certain loans, title insurance, and appraisals of real property offered as
            security;
          Intangible personal property tax on the loan note or obligation, if secured by a lien on real
            property;
          Documentary excise tax and lawful fees for filing, recording, or releasing an instrument
            securing the loan;
          The premium for any insurance in lieu of perfecting a security interest otherwise required by
            the licensee in connection with the loan;
          Actual and reasonable attorney fees and court costs;
          Actual and commercially reasonable expenses for repossession, storing, repairing and placing
            in condition for sale, and selling of any property pledged as security;
          A delinquency charge of up to $15 for each payment in default for at least 10 days, if agreed
            upon in writing before the charge is imposed; and
          A bad check charge of up to $20.

         A consumer finance lender may offer optional credit property, credit life, and disability
         insurance at the borrower’s expense via a deduction from the principal amount of the loan.15

         A prepayment penalty is not included in the above permissible fees, then impliedly a licensee
         cannot charge a borrower a prepayment penalty.16



11
   Various lenders and credits licensed or chartered under the laws of the United States or specified chapters of the Florida
Statutes may charge interest at the maximum rate of interest permitted by law for similar loans or extensions of credit. See s.
687.12(1), F.S.
12
   Sections 687.02 and 687.12, F.S.
13
   Section 516.031(1), F.S.
14
   Section 516.031(3), F.S.
15
   Section 516.35(2), F.S.
16
   Section 516.031(3), F.S. Fla. Office of Fin. Reg., Agency Analysis of 2021 House Bill 895, p. 2 (Feb. 17, 2021) (on file
with the Senate Committee on Commerce and Tourism).
BILL: SB 546                                                                                          Page 4

III.   Effect of Proposed Changes:

       Prepayment Penalties

       Section 2 amends s. 516.031, F.S., to expressly prohibit prepayment penalties on consumer
       finance loans. Florida law allows consumer finance lenders to charge certain expressly stated
       fees. Because the list of statutorily-permissible fees does not include a prepayment penalty, by
       implication, a consumer finance lender cannot charge a prepayment penalty. The bill makes this
       prohibition on prepayment penalties explicit.

       Asset Requirements in Lender Application

       Section 3 creates s. 516.05(10), F.S., to allow a consumer finance lender applicant or licensee to
       file proof of one of the following with the OFR in lieu of the current $25,000 liquid asset
       application requirement:
        A surety bond in the amount of at least $25,000 that is issued by a bonding company or an
            insurance company that is authorized to do business in Florida;
        A certificate of deposit in the amount of at least $25,000 deposited in a financial institution
            as defined in s. 655.005(1)(i), F.S; or
        An irrevocable letter of credit in the amount of at least $25,000.

       The bill requires lenders with multiple locations to provide a surety bond or rider in the amount
       of at least $5,000 for each additional license. The total aggregate amount of a surety bond
       required for a lender with multiple locations may not exceed $100,000.

       If the licensee’s surety bond, certificate of deposit, or letter of credit is reduced below the
       required amount at any point during the licensee’s activity, the licensee must furnish additional
       instruments to restore its capacity to a sum equal that required by the bill. In the alternative, the
       licensee may provide an endorsement from the company that issued the original instrument that
       reinstates the required principal amount.

       The applicant must file the surety bond, certificate of deposit, or letter of credit with the OFR,
       name the OFR as a beneficiary, and ensure that the instrument is payable on a pro rata basis.
       Although the OFR serves as the named beneficiary, the bill grants both the OFR and any
       claimant the right to bring an action on the bond, certificate of deposit, or letter of credit in the
       case of injury to a borrower who was injured by the licensee’s wrongful acts. If any such claim is
       paid, the bonding company, insurance company, or financial institution that held the instrument
       must notify the OFR within 10 days of the claim.

       A licensee cannot cancel its surety bond, certificate of deposit, or letter of credit without
       providing the OFR with 30 calendar days’ notice by certified mail. Following the licensee’s
       cessation of operation in the state, its surety bond, certificate of deposit, or letter of credit must
       remain in place for a period of 2 years, although the OFR may allow for a reduction in its amount
       to the extent that the licensee’s outstanding loans are reduced.

       The bill authorizes the Financial Services Commission to initiate rulemaking to adopt forms and
       procedures to implement the alternatives to the liquid asset requirement.
BILL: SB 546                                                                                   Page 5


      Conforming Changes

      Sections 1, 4, and 5 amend ss. 516.03, 516.07, 559.952, F.S., respectively, to make conforming
      changes to reflect the consumer finance loans licensing requirements added by section three of
      this bill.

      Effective Date

      Section 6 provides an effective date of October 1, 2022.

IV.   Constitutional Issues:

      A.       Municipality/County Mandates Restrictions:

               None.

      B.       Public Records/Open Meetings Issues:

               None.

      C.       Trust Funds Restrictions:

               None.

      D.       State Tax or Fee Increases:

               None.

      E.       Other Constitutional Issues:

               None identified.

V.    Fiscal Impact Statement:

      A.       Tax/Fee Issues:

               None.

      B.       Private Sector Impact:

               This may allow companies with less liquid assets to become licensed as a consumer
               finance lender.

      C.       Government Sector Impact:

               The OFR may be required to update Rule 69V-160 of the Florida Administrative Code to
               reflect changes made by the bill. Additionally, the OFR may need to amend their
               applications for consumer finance loan company licenses to allow applicants to assert
 BILL: SB 546                                                                                                                         Page 6

                 what amount of liquid assets, surety bond, letter of credit, or certificate of deposit is
                 required of them since their business relation to a previously-licensed entity may reduce
                 their surety bond, letter of credit, or certificate of deposit requirements.

 VI.    Technical Deficiencies:

        None.

VII.    Related Issues:

        None.

VIII.   Statutes Affected:

        This bill substantially amends the following sections of the Florida Statutes: 516.03, 516.031,
        516.05, 516.07, and 559.952.

 IX.    Additional Information:

        A.       Committee Substitute – Statement of Changes:
                 (Summarizing differences between the Committee Substitute and the prior version of the bill.)

                 None.

        B.       Amendments:

                 None.

         This Senate Bill Analysis does not reflect the intent or official position of the bill’s introducer or the Florida Senate.
       Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 546          Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 546



       By Senator Gruters




       23-00431-22                                                2022546__          23-00431-22                                               2022546__
1                              A bill to be entitled                          30     under this chapter shall be in the form prescribed by rule of
2           An act relating to consumer finance loans; amending s.            31     the commission. The commission may require each applicant to
3           516.03, F.S.; authorizing an applicant for a license              32     provide any information reasonably necessary to determine the
4           to make and collect loans under the Florida Consumer              33     applicant’s eligibility for licensure. The applicant shall also
5           Finance Act to provide certain documents in lieu of               34     provide information that the office requires concerning any
6           evidence of liquid assets; amending s. 516.031, F.S.;             35     officer, director, control person, member, partner, or joint
7           prohibiting a person licensed to make and collect                 36     venturer of the applicant or any person having the same or
8           consumer finance loans from charging prepayment                   37     substantially similar status or performing substantially similar
9           penalties for loans; amending s. 516.05, F.S.;                    38     functions or concerning any individual who is the ultimate
10          authorizing a licensee or an applicant for a license              39     equitable owner of a 10-percent or greater interest in the
11          to make and collect consumer finance loans to provide             40     applicant. The office may require information concerning any
12          a surety bond, certificate of deposit, or letter of               41     such applicant or person, including, but not limited to, his or
13          credit in lieu of evidence of liquid assets; providing            42     her full name and any other names by which he or she may have
14          requirements for such bonds, certificates of deposit,             43     been known, age, social security number, residential history,
15          and letters of credit; providing rulemaking authority             44     qualifications, educational and business history, and
16          to the Financial Services Commission; amending s.                 45     disciplinary and criminal history. The applicant must provide
17          516.07, F.S.; modifying grounds for denial of license             46     evidence of liquid assets of at least $25,000 or documents
18          or disciplinary action for certain violations of the              47     satisfying the requirements of s. 516.05(10). At the time of
19          Florida Consumer Finance Act; amending s. 559.952,                48     making such application the applicant shall pay to the office a
20          F.S.; revising exceptions for a licensee during the               49     nonrefundable biennial license fee of $625. Applications, except
21          Financial Technology Sandbox period; providing an                 50     for applications to renew or reactivate a license, must also be
22          effective date.                                                   51     accompanied by a nonrefundable investigation fee of $200. An
23                                                                            52     application is considered received for purposes of s. 120.60
24     Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:              53     upon receipt of a completed application form as prescribed by
25                                                                            54     commission rule, a nonrefundable application fee of $625, and
26          Section 1. Subsection (1) of section 516.03, Florida              55     any other fee prescribed by law. The commission may adopt rules
27     Statutes, is amended to read:                                          56     requiring electronic submission of any form, document, or fee
28          516.03 Application for license; fees; etc.—                       57     required by this act if such rules reasonably accommodate
29          (1) APPLICATION.—Application for a license to make loans          58     technological or financial hardship. The commission may

                                   Page 1 of 7                                                                  Page 2 of 7
     CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.         CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
       Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 546           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 546




       23-00431-22                                                2022546__           23-00431-22                                              2022546__
59     prescribe by rule requirements and procedures for obtaining an         88      least $25,000.
60     exemption due to a technological or financial hardship.                89           (b) The original surety bond, certificate of deposit, or
61          Section 2. Subsection (6) is added to section 516.031,            90      letter of credit must be filed with the office, and the office
62     Florida Statutes, to read:                                             91      must be named as beneficiary. The surety bond, certificate of
63          516.031 Finance charge; maximum rates.—                           92      deposit, or letter of credit must be for the use and benefit of
64          (6) PREPAYMENT PENALTIES PROHIBITED.—A licensee may not           93      any borrower who is injured by acts of a licensee involving
65     require a borrower to pay a prepayment penalty for paying all or       94      fraud, misrepresentation, or deceit, including willful
66     part of the loan principal before the date on which the payment        95      imposition of illegal or excessive charges, or
67     is due.                                                                96      misrepresentation, circumvention, or concealment of any matter
68          Section 3. Subsection (10) is added to section 516.05,            97      required to be stated or furnished to a borrower, where such
69     Florida Statutes, to read:                                             98      acts are in connection with a loan made under this chapter. The
70          516.05 License.—                                                  99      office, or any claimant, may bring an action in a court of
71          (10)(a) In lieu of the $25,000 liquid asset requirement in        100     competent jurisdiction on the surety bond, certificate of
72     s. 516.03(1), a licensee or an applicant may provide to the            101     deposit, or letter of credit. The surety bond, certificate of
73     office:                                                                102     deposit, or letter of credit must be payable on a pro rata
74          1.a. A surety bond in the amount of at least $25,000,             103     basis, but the aggregate amount may not exceed the amount of the
75     issued by a bonding company or an insurance company authorized         104     surety bond, certificate of deposit, or letter of credit.
76     to do business in this state.                                          105          (c) The surety bond, certificate of deposit, or letter of
77          b. A company with at least one currently licensed location        106     credit may not be canceled by the licensee, bonding or insurance
78     must provide to the office a rider or surety bond in the amount        107     company, or financial institution except upon notice to the
79     of at least $5,000 for each additional license, issued by a            108     office by certified mail. A cancellation may not take effect
80     bonding company or an insurance company authorized to do               109     until 30 calendar days after receipt by the office of the
81     business in this state. However, the aggregate amount of the           110     written notice.
82     surety bond required for a company with multiple licenses may          111          (d) The bonding or insurance company or financial
83     not exceed $100,000.                                                   112     institution must, within 10 calendar days after it pays a claim,
84          2. Evidence of a certificate of deposit in the amount of at       113     give written notice to the office by certified mail of such
85     least $25,000. The certificate of deposit must be deposited in a       114     payment, with details sufficient to identify the claimant and
86     financial institution as defined in s. 655.005(1)(i).                  115     the claim or judgment paid.
87          3. An irrevocable letter of credit in the amount of at            116          (e) If the principal sum of the surety bond, certificate of

                                    Page 3 of 7                                                                     Page 4 of 7
     CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 546           Florida Senate - 2022                                        SB 546




        23-00431-22                                                2022546__           23-00431-22                                                2022546__
117     deposit, or letter of credit is reduced by one or more                 146     location.
118     recoveries or payments, the licensee must furnish to the office        147          Section 5. Paragraph (a) of subsection (4) of section
119     a new or additional surety bond, certificate of deposit, or            148     559.952, Florida Statutes, is amended to read:
120     letter of credit so that the total or aggregate principal sum          149          559.952 Financial Technology Sandbox.—
121     equals the amount required under this subsection. Alternatively,       150          (4) EXCEPTIONS TO GENERAL LAW AND WAIVERS OF RULE
122     a licensee may furnish an endorsement executed by the bonding or       151     REQUIREMENTS.—
123     insurance company or financial institution reinstating the             152          (a) Notwithstanding any other law, upon approval of a
124     required principal amount.                                             153     Financial Technology Sandbox application, the following
125          (f) The required surety bond, certificate of deposit, or          154     provisions and corresponding rule requirements are not
126     letter of credit must remain in place for 2 years after the            155     applicable to the licensee during the sandbox period:
127     licensee ceases licensed operations in this state. During the 2-       156          1. Section 516.03(1), except for the application fee, the
128     year period, the office may allow for a reduction or elimination       157     investigation fee, the requirement to provide the social
129     of the surety bond, certificate of deposit, or letter of credit        158     security numbers of control persons, evidence of liquid assets
130     to the extent the licensee’s outstanding consumer finance loans        159     of at least $25,000 or documents satisfying the requirements of
131     in this state are reduced.                                             160     s. 516.05(10), and the office’s authority to investigate the
132          (g) The commission may prescribe by rule forms and                161     applicant’s background. The office may prorate the license
133     procedures to implement this subsection.                               162     renewal fee for an extension granted under subsection (7).
134          Section 4. Paragraph (b) of subsection (1) of section             163          2. Section 516.05(1) and (2), except that the office shall
135     516.07, Florida Statutes, is amended to read:                          164     investigate the applicant’s background.
136          516.07 Grounds for denial of license or for disciplinary          165          3. Section 560.109, only to the extent that the section
137     action.—                                                               166     requires the office to examine a licensee at least once every 5
138          (1) The following acts are violations of this chapter and         167     years.
139     constitute grounds for denial of an application for a license to       168          4. Section 560.118(2).
140     make consumer finance loans and grounds for any of the                 169          5. Section 560.125(1), only to the extent that the
141     disciplinary actions specified in subsection (2):                      170     subsection would prohibit a licensee from engaging in the
142          (b) Failure to maintain liquid assets of at least $25,000         171     business of a money transmitter or payment instrument seller
143     or a surety bond, certificate of deposit, or letter of credit in       172     during the sandbox period.
144     the amount required by s. 516.05(10) at all times for the              173          6. Section 560.125(2), only to the extent that the
145     operation of business at a licensed location or proposed               174     subsection would prohibit a licensee from appointing an

                                     Page 5 of 7                                                                     Page 6 of 7
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                           SB 546




        23-00431-22                                                  2022546__
175     authorized vendor during the sandbox period. Any authorized
176     vendor of such a licensee during the sandbox period remains
177     liable to the holder or remitter.
178            7. Section 560.128.
179            8. Section 560.141, except for s. 560.141(1)(a)1., 3., 7.-
180     10. and (b), (c), and (d).
181            9. Section 560.142(1) and (2), except that the office may
182     prorate, but may not entirely eliminate, the license renewal
183     fees in s. 560.143 for an extension granted under subsection
184     (7).
185            10. Section 560.143(2), only to the extent necessary for
186     proration of the renewal fee under subparagraph 9.
187            11. Section 560.204(1), only to the extent that the
188     subsection would prohibit a licensee from engaging in, or
189     advertising that it engages in, the selling or issuing of
190     payment instruments or in the activity of a money transmitter
191     during the sandbox period.
192            12. Section 560.205(2).
193            13. Section 560.208(2).
194            14. Section 560.209, only to the extent that the office may
195     modify, but may not entirely eliminate, the net worth, corporate
196     surety bond, and collateral deposit amounts required under that
197     section. The modified amounts must be in such lower amounts that
198     the office determines to be commensurate with the factors under
199     paragraph (5)(c) and the maximum number of consumers authorized
200     to receive the financial product or service under this section.
201            Section 6. This act shall take effect October 1, 2022.




                                     Page 7 of 7
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
                                                          The Florida Senate
                      BILL ANALYSIS AND FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT
                  (This document is based on the provisions contained in the legislation as of the latest date listed below.)

                      Prepared By: The Professional Staff of the Committee on Commerce and Tourism

BILL:               SB 946
INTRODUCER:         Senator Gruters and others
SUBJECT:            Entertainment Industry
DATE:               January 7, 2022                 REVISED:


             ANALYST                      STAFF DIRECTOR                 REFERENCE                                 ACTION
1. Renner                               McKay                                 CM              Favorable
2.                                                                            FT
3.                                                                            AP



    I.     Summary:

           SB 946 creates the Targeted High Wage Production Program (program) within the Department
           of Economic Opportunity (DEO) in order to broaden the entertainment industry’s impact,
           enhance tourism, and encourage more family-friendly productions to be produced in Florida.

           The program gives tax credit awards on qualified expenditures to film, television, and digital
           media production projects that, among other requirements, employ a crew of which at least 60
           percent are Florida residents and spend at least 70 percent of their production days in Florida. A
           project may only receive a tax credit award after it has completed production and its
           expenditures have been verified by the DEO.

           The Revenue Estimating Conference has not yet reviewed the economic impact of this bill.

           The bill takes effect upon becoming law.

    II.    Present Situation:

           The Florida Office of Film and Entertainment (OFE) within the DEO develops, markets,
           promotes, and provides services to the state’s entertainment industry.1 The Florida Film and
           Entertainment Advisory Council (council) serves as an advisory body to the DEO and OFE to
           provide industry insight and expertise related to the state’s entertainment industry.2

           Entertainment Industry Sales Tax Exemption

           The Entertainment Industry Sales Tax Exemption (tax exemption program), administered by the
           OFE, offers a sales and use tax certificate of exemption to production companies that create
1
    Section 288.1251, F.S.
2
    Section 288.1252, F.S.
BILL: SB 946                                                                                                    Page 2

        qualified productions in Florida.3 The tax exemption program offers exemptions from taxes
        levied under ch. 212, F.S., for the following:
         Lease or rental of real property used as an integral part of the performance of qualified
            production services, including photography, casting, location scouting, stage support, and
            wardrobe;4
         Fabrication labor when a producer is using his or her own equipment and personnel to
            produce a qualified motion picture;5
         Purchase or lease of motion picture or video equipment and sound recording equipment used
            in Florida for motion picture or television production or for the production of master tapes
            and master records;6 and
         Purchase, lease, storage, or use of blank master tapes, records, films, or video tapes.7

        To qualify for these tax exemptions, production companies must submit an application to the
        Department of Revenue (DOR) which must then be approved by the OFE.8 If a company has
        operated a business in Florida at a permanent address for at least 12 consecutive months, it is
        eligible for a one-year certificate of exemption. Companies that do not qualify for a one-year
        certificate are eligible for a 90-day certificate of exemption.

        The OFE has estimated that qualified production companies have received $46.3 million in
        exemptions between Fiscal Years 2016-2017 and 2018-2019.9

        Entertainment Industry Financial Incentive Program

        The Entertainment Industry Financial Incentive Program (incentive program) was created to
        encourage the use of Florida as a site for filming, for the digital production of films, and to
        develop and sustain the workforce and infrastructure for film, digital media, and entertainment
        production.10 The incentive program offered transferrable tax credits for qualified expenditures
        relating to filming and media production activities in Florida, including wages, equipment,
        rentals, and other expenditures made to Florida vendors for qualified entertainment industry
        productions. Qualified productions that completed their projects and had their expenses verified
        by the OFE could receive 20 percent of their qualified expenditures in tax credits, capped at $8
        million in tax credits awarded per project.11 Recipients were permitted to apply their tax credits
        to their corporate income taxes, sales taxes, or both; alternately, recipients could sell their tax
        credits on the market or back to the state at a reduced rate.12



3
  Section 288.1258, F.S.
4
  Section 212.031(1)(a)9, F.S.
5
  Section 212.06(1)(b), F.S.
6
  Section 212.08(5)(f), F.S.
7
  Section 212.08(12)(a), F.S.
8
  Supra note 3
9
  Office of Economic and Demographic Research, Return on Investment for the Entertainment Industry Incentive Programs,
7 (2021), available at http://edr.state.fl.us/Content/returnoninvestment/EntertainmentIndustryIncentivePrograms2021.pdf
(last visited Jan. 7, 2022).
10
   Section 288.1254(2), F.S.
11
   Section 288.1254(4)(b), F.S.
12
   Supra note 9, at 5 and 6.
BILL: SB 946                                                                                                           Page 3

         The incentive program began on July 1, 2010, and sunset on June 30, 2016.13

         Local Incentive Programs

         Several local governments in Florida offer their own film and entertainment production
         incentives, including:14
          Miami-Dade County’s TV, Film, and Entertainment Production Incentive, a performance-
             based program that grants up to $100,000 to productions that spend at least $1 million in the
             county if at least 70 percent of the hired vendors are county registered businesses;
          Hillsborough County’s rebate program, which offers a rebate of up to 10 percent on
             expenditures within the county in excess of $100,000; and
          Duval County’s Jacksonville Film and Television Job and Business Creation Program, a
             performance-based program that offers a 10 percent rebate upon spending at least $50,000 on
             qualified expenditures and hiring Duval County residents.

         Other States’ Incentives

         The popularity of entertainment industry incentives has decreased among state legislatures. In
         2009, 44 states offered some form of incentive, compared to only 31 states that offered an
         incentive in 2018.15 Of states considered competitive to Florida, Georgia offers one of the most
         generous incentive programs; the state continues to fund its tax credit program at the level of
         demand by placing no cap on tax credits that can be earned.16

III.     Effect of Proposed Changes:

         The bill creates the Targeted High Wage Production Program (program) within the DEO, to be
         supervised by the Commissioner of Film and Entertainment (commissioner). The program gives
         tax credit awards to film, television, and digital media production projects that provide high
         returns on investment and economic benefit to the state in order to broaden the entertainment
         industry’s impact, enhance tourism, and encourage more family-friendly productions to be
         produced in Florida.

         Upon completion, a project is eligible to receive a tax credit award of up to 23 percent of its
         qualified expenditures, or $2 million, whichever is less. A project’s qualified expenditures must
         be verified before the project may receive a tax credit award, and awards are subject to
         repayment if a project submits fraudulent information.

         General Requirements

         A project is eligible for a tax credit award under the program if it:


13
   Id.
14
   Film Florida, Local Incentive Programs, available at https://filmflorida.org/state-resources/ (last visited Jan. 7, 2022).
15
   National Conference of State Legislatures, State Film Production Incentives and Programs (February 2018), available at
https://www.ncsl.org/research/fiscal-policy/state-film-production-incentives-and-programs.aspx (last visited Jan. 7, 2022).
16
   Georgia Department of Economic Development, Film, Television, and Digital Entertainment Tax Credit, available at
https://www.georgia.org/industries/film-entertainment/georgia-film-tv-production/production-incentives (last visited Jan. 7,
2022).
BILL: SB 946                                                                                        Page 4

         Is a film, television, or digital media project that is not obscene, as defined in s. 847.001,
          F.S.;
         Has projected qualified expenditures of at least $1.5 million if the project is a film or digital
          media project, or at least $500,000 per episode if the project is a television show;
         Employs a crew of which at least 60 percent are Florida residents and at least one is a
          military veteran;
         Is projected to spend at least 70 percent of its total production days in the state;
         Will not receive a sales tax exemption through the Florida entertainment sales tax exemption
          established under s. 288.1258, F.S.;
         Makes a good faith effort to use existing Florida providers of infrastructure or equipment and
          to employ cast and crew who are Florida residents;
         Agrees to include marketing that promotes Florida tourism or Florida’s film and
          entertainment industry on its project, including, at minimum, placing a “Filmed in Florida” or
          “Produced in Florida” logo in its end credits;
         Permits the commissioner or an affiliate and at least two guests to visit the project’s
          production site; and
         Provides at least five photos of the production to the commissioner for use in promoting
          Florida as a film, television, or digital media production location or tourist destination.

      Application Process

      To become a qualified project that is eligible to receive a tax credit award, an applicant must
      submit an application to the commissioner. There are two application windows for the tax credit
      award program per fiscal year, the start date of which will be determined by the commissioner.
      The first window may begin before, and must end no later than 5 business days after, July 1. The
      second window must end no later than 5 business days after December 1.

      An applicant may submit an application for no more than five projects in any one fiscal year.
      Except in the case of a television pilot and the television series the pilot is based on being
      certified in the same fiscal year, however, only one project per applicant may be certified within
      a fiscal year. A proposed project must begin production within 6 months of July 1 if applying in
      the first application window, or within 6 months of January 1, if applying in the second window.

      Application
      In addition to an affidavit signed by the applicant that the information on the application is
      correct and the applicant’s Florida tax identification number, applications must include a film,
      television, or digital media project’s:
       Proof of funding;
       Employment information, including employment numbers for Florida residents;
       Line-item budget and detailed qualified expenditures budget;
       Distribution plan to assist in determining the project’s potential economic impact in the state;
       Expected total qualified expenditures for wages paid to Florida residents;
       Expected total qualified and nonqualified expenditures in the state;
       Latest script, a production schedule, a Day Out of Days report, and a list of the expected
          shooting locations, if the project is a film or a pilot episode of a television project;
BILL: SB 946                                                                                                          Page 5

            Latest scripts for at least two episodes, a production schedule, a Day Out of Days report, and
             a list of the expected shooting locations, if the project is a television project; and
            Game design document, including a production schedule, if the project is a digital media
             project.

         Scoring Criteria
         The commissioner and the council must devise, before the first application window opens, a
         priority order and scoring system that qualified projects will be evaluated based on. In addition to
         other criteria the council may deem necessary, the scoring system must include consideration of
         a project’s:
          Overall qualified expenditures;
          Full-time equivalent jobs created;
          Length of employment and wages paid to Florida residents, in addition to pension, health,
             and welfare benefits;
          Estimated direct and indirect tourism benefit;
          Production in an underutilized area;
          Status as a family-friendly production;
          Employment of a Florida resident as a writer, producer, director, or star;
          Use of a Florida film, television, or digital media school’s assistance;
          Leadership team’s track record;
          Employment of veterans who are residents of Florida; and
          Employment of graduates of Florida film schools.

         Review
         Within a reasonable period of time after an application window’s last day, the commissioner
         must complete a review of the applications. The commissioner must then submit to the council a
         package detailing each applicant’s:
          Eligibility for the tax credit award program;
          Expected qualified expenditures;
          Maximum award amount;
          Status as a family friendly project;17
          Percent of production proposed to occur in an underutilized area,18 if any; and
          Registration as a corporation in the state.

         The commissioner may contact each applicant with questions and gather any additional
         information as necessary and must notify the council of the date and time the council must
         convene to score each qualified project.19 The council may meet in person or by conference call.

17
   The bill defines “family friendly” as having cross-generational appeal; being appropriate in theme, content, and language
for a broad family audience; embodying a responsible resolution of issues; not containing any act of drunkenness, illicit drug
use, sex, nudity, gratuitous violence, or vulgar or profane language; and not portraying smoking any substance in a positive
manner.
18
   The bill defines “underutilized area” as any county within the state other than Broward, Hillsborough, Miami-Dade,
Orange, Pinellas, or Seminole County.
19
   A film, television, or media project for which a complete application has been submitted to the commissioner and accepted
for consideration and scoring is considered a “qualified project”.
BILL: SB 946                                                                                                            Page 6


         Using its scoring system, the council will determine a score for each qualified project; the
         highest scores must be applied to projects determined to provide the best economic impact and
         return on investment to the state. The commissioner makes the final decision on certifying or
         rejecting each qualified project.

         Award of Tax Credit Awards and Verification of Expenditures

         After the council scores a project, the commissioner must make a determination on whether to
         certify or reject each project and send a notice of the decision to each applicant. The
         commissioner must include in a certified project’s notice the specific percentage of qualified
         expenditures for which it is eligible and the maximum award it may receive.

         The commissioner must also give the DEO a list of certified projects20 and each project’s
         maximum allowance in order for the DEO to set aside enough money to fund the total maximum
         tax credit awards that may be awarded. However, when setting aside funds for applications
         submitted and certified during the first application window, the DEO may not use more than 60
         percent of the tax credit awards available for any fiscal year. Any tax credit award funds not set
         aside for the first application window roll over for use in the next application window. If all
         awards are set aside for certified projects, additional applications cannot be accepted until more
         funds become available. If only a partial amount of tax credit awards are available during the
         application period, the applicant must notify the commissioner in writing of its decision to either
         accept the partial award as the maximum certified tax credit award it would be eligible for or
         reject it and drop out of the program. The applicant is not eligible for any additional tax credit
         awards that may become available after the application period. Funds appropriated to the credit
         award program are not subject to reversion.

         Tax Credit Award Allowances
         Under the bill, certified projects may receive a tax credit award of up to 20 percent of its verified
         qualified expenditures. A project may receive an additional 3 percentage points if 60 percent of
         the project’s production takes place in an underutilized area or if its content is deemed family
         friendly. A project may not receive more than one bonus, and tax credit awards may not exceed
         $2 million.

         The bill defines “qualified expenditures” to mean expenditures made in the state made solely for
         preproduction, production, or postproduction of a qualified project, including:
          Rented or leased goods or services provided by a vendor that is registered with the
            Department of State or the Department of Revenue, has a physical address in the state other
            than a post office box, and employs one or more Florida residents on a full-time basis;
          Salaries and wages of up to $200,000 for Florida residents;
          Rented or leased cars, trucks, and trailers;
          Catered meals and on-set craft service supplies; and
          Rented hotel rooms or other accommodations.


20
  A qualified project is considered to be a “certified project” after it has been scored, has been determined to meet or exceed
the desired criteria, and has funds allocated to it based on its estimated qualified expenditures.
BILL: SB 946                                                                                          Page 7

      Qualified expenditures exclude expenditures made before a qualification for the program;
      expenditures made via Internet transaction; expenditures for airfare; or any costs related to
      development, marketing, or distribution.

      Verification
      The commissioner must develop a process to verify a certified project’s actual qualified
      expenditures and bonus eligibility after a certified project has completed its work in the state.
      The process must require the submission by a project within 120 days after making its last
      qualified expenditure, but no later than 1 year after its production start date, of:
       Data substantiating each qualified expenditure, as verified by an independent certified public
         accountant (CPA) licensed by the state;
       Documents verifying the Florida residency of persons represented as such, including an
         affidavit signed by each resident;
       The project’s final script;
       The project’s most recent production board and shooting schedule;
       The project’s most recent credit list, which shows where the required marketing logo will
         appear;
       The project’s cast list and final crew list with contact information;
       Verification that at least one person employed by the project is a military veteran; and
       An affidavit or written declaration signed under the penalty of perjury that states that all
         salaries, wages, and other compensation submitted as qualified expenditures are in
         compliance with the program’s requirements.

      The verification process must also require a compliance audit, conducted by an independent CPA
      at the project’s expense, to substantiate a project’s qualified expenditures. The audit and a report
      of the audit’s findings must be submitted to the commissioner within a reasonable period of time
      after the commissioner’s initial receipt of records from the project.

      The commissioner must report to the DEO the final verified amount of actual qualified
      expenditures a project made and the amount of the total tax credit award owed to a project. The
      DEO must then determine and approve the final tax credit award amount based on the final
      verified amount of actual qualified expenditures; notify the DOR that the certified production has
      met the requirements and of the final amount of the tax credit award; and issue the award within
      a reasonable period of time.

      Disqualification
      A certified project may be disqualified and may not receive a tax credit award if it:
       Does not begin principal photography within 30 days before or 90 days after the project’s
         start date;
       Does not abide by the policies, procedures, deadlines, or requirements of the program’s
         verification process;
       Changes the project’s start date without notifying the commissioner;
       Submits fraudulent information; or
       Uses the entertainment industry sales tax exemption established under s. 288.1258, F.S.
BILL: SB 946                                                                                        Page 8

      Applicants that submit fraudulent information are liable for reimbursement of the costs
      associated with the review, processing, investigation, and prosecution of the fraudulent
      submission, in addition to a penalty double the tax credit award amount and any criminal penalty
      assessed.

      Election and Transfer of Tax Credits
      A certified production company receiving a tax credit award must, at the time the credit is
      awarded by the DEO, make an irrevocable election to apply the credit against income taxes due,
      against state sales taxes collected or accrued, or against a combination of the two taxes. The
      election is binding on any distribute, successor, transferee, or purchaser. The DEO must notify
      the DOR of any election made.

      Tax credits awarded may not be claimed against sales and use tax liabilities or corporate income
      tax liabilities before July 1, 2022, regardless of when the credits are applied for or awarded.

      A certified production company that files a consolidated return as a member of an affiliated
      group under s. 220.131(1), F.S., may use the credit on a consolidated return basis up to the
      amount of the tax imposed upon the consolidated group under ch. 220, F.S. Additionally, a
      certified production company that is not a corporation under s. 220.03(1)(e), F.S., can elect to
      distribute tax credits to its partners or members in proportion to their distributive income or loss
      in the taxable year in which the tax credits were awarded.

      Tax credits may succeed to a surviving or acquiring entity; however, the tax credits cannot be
      transferred by the surviving or acquiring entity.

      If a certified production company cannot use the entire tax credit in the taxable year or reporting
      period in which the credit is awarded, any excess amount may be carried forward to a succeeding
      taxable year or reporting period for a maximum of five years after the date the credit is awarded,
      after which the credit expires and may not be used again.

      A certified production company, or a partner or member of a certified production company that
      has received a distribution may elect to transfer, in whole or in part, any unused credit amount it
      was granted. An election to transfer any unused income tax or state sales tax credit amount must
      be made no later than 5 years after the date the credit is awarded, after which period the credit
      expires and may not be used. The DEO must notify the DOR of the election and transfer.

      The original transferee and any subsequent transferee must be either the certified company’s
      parent company, a subsidiary company, or certain businesses with a certain North American
      Industry Classification System code.


      A certified production company that elects to apply a credit amount against state sales taxes is
      allowed a one-time transfer of unused credits to one transferee. A certified production company
      that elects to apply a credit amount against income taxes is allowed a one-time transfer of unused
      credits to no more than four transferees, and the transfers must occur on the same taxable year.
BILL: SB 946                                                                                          Page 9

      A transferee receiving the tax credit has the same rights and is subject to the same limitations as
      the certified production company that was awarded the tax credit, except that a transferee
      receiving the tax credit is prohibited from subsequently transferring the tax credit.

      Relinquishment of Tax Credits
      Starting July 1, 2022, a certified production company, or a person who has acquired a tax credit
      from a production company, can elect to relinquish the tax credit to the DOR in exchange for
      payment of 85 percent of the amount of the relinquished tax credit. The DOR is authorized to
      approve the payments.

      The DOR is authorized to approve payments to entities relinquishing tax credits. Additionally,
      the DOR, subject to legislative appropriation, must request the Chief Financial Officer to issue
      warrants to entities relinquishing tax credits. Payments must be made from the funds from which
      the proceeds from the taxes against which the tax credits could have been applied according to
      the irrevocable election made by the certified production company.

      Annual Allocation of Tax Credits
      The aggregate amount of tax credits allocated to the program must equal, but not exceed, $20
      million each fiscal year beginning in fiscal year 2022-2023 through fiscal year 2025-2026. Any
      portion of the maximum amount that is not certified by the end of that fiscal year must be carried
      forward and made available for certification during the following two fiscal years in addition to
      the amounts available for those fiscal years.

      After approval of the final tax credit award amount, an amount equal to the difference between
      the maximum tax credit award amount previously certified and the approved final tax credit
      award amount will immediately be available for recertification during the current and following
      fiscal years, in addition to the amounts available for those fiscal years.

      If the total amount of credits applied for during a fiscal year exceeds the amount of credits
      available for certification in that fiscal year, the excess will be treated as having been applied for
      on the first day of the next fiscal year in which credits remain available for certification.

      Other Provisions

      The DEO is granted rulemaking authority to administer the tax credit award program.

      The DOR is authorized to conduct audits to verify that tax credits are received, transferred, and
      applied accordingly to the requirements under the program. If the DOR determines that tax
      credits are not received, transferred or applied as required, the DOR may pursue recovery of the
      funds. The DOR is granted rulemaking to administer this provision. Additionally, the DEO is
      authorized to revoke or modify any written decision qualifying, certifying, or otherwise granting
      eligibility for tax credits if an applicant submits false statements, records, reports, plans, or other
      documents. The DEO must immediately notify the DOR in such cases. Forfeited funds must be
      paid into the General Revenue Fund.
BILL: SB 946                                                                                      Page 10

      The commissioner must provide an annual report on the program each November 1 identifying
      the return on investment and economic benefits attributable to the program for the previous fiscal
      year.

      The Targeted High Wage Production Program expires on June 30, 2026, at which point any
      funds appropriated to the program not earmarked and set aside for certified projects will revert
      back to the General Revenue Fund. All other remaining funds must revert back to the General
      Revenue Fund no later than October 31, 2027.

      The bill takes effect upon becoming law.

IV.   Constitutional Issues:

      A.       Municipality/County Mandates Restrictions:

               None.

      B.       Public Records/Open Meetings Issues:

               None.

      C.       Trust Funds Restrictions:

               None.

      D.       State Tax or Fee Increases:

               None.

      E.       Other Constitutional Issues:

               None.

V.    Fiscal Impact Statement:

      A.       Tax/Fee Issues:

               The Revenue Estimating Conference has not yet determined a fiscal impact of the bill.

      B.       Private Sector Impact:

               Qualified film, television, or digital media projects that make qualified expenditures
               under the program may have their expenses offset by a tax credit award at the
               culmination of the project. Because qualified expenditures are required, to a certain
               extent, to be made to Florida vendors, businesses, and residents, these parties may see a
               positive financial impact.
 BILL: SB 946                                                                                                                             Page 11

            C.       Government Sector Impact:

                     According to the DOR, the bill will have a non-recurring negative fiscal impact in the
                     amount of $39,662 for fiscal year 2021-2022 in order to make modifications to the
                     DOR’s software system.21

                     Additionally, the DOR may be required to undergo rulemaking to update Rule 12-29 of
                     the Florida Administrative Code.

 VI.        Technical Deficiencies:

            Line 568 of the bill refers to paragraph (4)(g), which does not exist. It is unclear if (4)(g) should
            be (12)(e).

VII.        Related Issues:

            The DOR has the following concerns with the bill:22
             The bill only provides rulemaking authority to the department for the audit verification in
               paragraph (17)(a); however the department needs broader rulemaking authority to administer
               other provisions in the bill, particularly the revoked or forfeited tax credits and the
               amendment of tax returns. Furthermore, the bill does not grant the department emergency
               rulemaking authority, which it would need since the bill takes effect upon becoming law.
             On lines 532-538, the bill provides that a credit may not be claimed for any tax period
               beginning before July 1, 2022. However, credits against corporate income/franchise tax do
               not usually start in the middle of a calendar year, as most corporate taxpayers operate on a
               calendar year basis. The department suggests changing the date from July 1, 2022 to January
               1, 2023.

VIII.       Statutes Affected:

            This bill creates an undesignated section of the Florida Statutes.

 IX.        Additional Information:

            A.       Committee Substitute – Statement of Changes:
                     (Summarizing differences between the Committee Substitute and the prior version of the bill.)

                     None.

            B.       Amendments:

                     None.

             This Senate Bill Analysis does not reflect the intent or official position of the bill’s introducer or the Florida Senate.




 21
      Florida Department of Revenue, SB 946 analysis (2022). On file with Senate Commerce & Tourism Committee.
 22
      Id.
       Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946          Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946



       By Senator Gruters




       23-00366A-22                                               2022946__          23-00366A-22                                               2022946__
1                              A bill to be entitled                          30          criteria; requiring the commissioner to take specified
2           An act relating to the entertainment industry;                    31          actions in a timely manner relating to the
3           creating the Targeted High Wage Production Program                32          certification or rejection of qualified projects;
4           within the Department of Economic Opportunity under               33          requiring the department to certify projects and
5           the supervision of the Commissioner of Film and                   34          maximum tax credit awards to qualified applicants and
6           Entertainment; providing a purpose for the program;               35          the executive director of the Department of Revenue;
7           defining terms; requiring that film, television, and              36          requiring the commissioner to develop a process to
8           digital media projects being produced in this state               37          verify the actual qualified expenditures and bonus
9           meet specified criteria to be eligible for tax credit             38          eligibility of a certified project after the project’s
10          awards; authorizing applicants to receive awards up to            39          work in this state is complete; providing requirements
11          a specified amount, including bonuses; requiring a                40          for the verification process; requiring that the award
12          certified project to make a good faith effort to use              41          be issued within a reasonable period of time upon
13          existing providers of infrastructure or equipment in              42          approval of the final award amount; requiring that
14          this state and to employ residents of this state;                 43          certain marketing be included with a project;
15          requiring the commissioner to set application windows;            44          requiring certified projects to allow certain persons
16          providing requirements for the department relating to             45          to visit the production site upon request of the
17          earmarking and setting aside tax credit awards;                   46          commissioner and after providing the commissioner with
18          requiring applicants to either accept a partial tax               47          reasonable notice; specifying that the commissioner or
19          credit award or reject the partial award and drop out             48          his or her affiliate is not required to visit the
20          of the program under certain circumstances; providing             49          production site; requiring the department to
21          procedures and requirements for applicants; requiring             50          disqualify a project under certain circumstances;
22          the commissioner to take specified actions within a               51          providing for liability and imposing civil and
23          reasonable period of time; requiring the Florida Film             52          criminal penalties for an applicant that submits
24          and Entertainment Advisory Council to determine a                 53          fraudulent information; requiring certified production
25          score for each qualified project using specified                  54          companies to make elections relating to tax credit
26          criteria; requiring the commissioner to determine the             55          awards; providing requirements and prohibitions
27          priority order and scoring system of the specified                56          relating to tax credits; authorizing certain entities
28          criteria with assistance from the council and certain             57          to transfer tax credits under certain circumstances;
29          other persons; requiring the council to use specified             58          providing requirements and prohibitions relating to

                                   Page 1 of 24                                                                Page 2 of 24
     CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.         CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
       Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946           Florida Senate - 2022                                        SB 946




       23-00366A-22                                               2022946__           23-00366A-22                                               2022946__
59          transferring tax credits; authorizing certain entities            88      and Entertainment.
60          to relinquish tax credits for payments; providing                 89           (a) The purpose of the performance-based program is to
61          requirements and prohibitions relating to                         90      boost this state’s economic prosperity by:
62          relinquishing tax credits; providing for the annual               91           1. Creating high-paying jobs in an industry with an average
63          allocation of tax credits for the program; authorizing            92      salary 60 percent higher than the state average;
64          the department to adopt rules; authorizing the                    93           2. Enhancing tourism by choosing projects that encourage
65          Department of Revenue to conduct certain examinations             94      tourists to visit this state;
66          and audits and pursue recovery of tax credits;                    95           3. Broadening the film, television, and digital media
67          authorizing the Department of Revenue to adopt rules;             96      industry’s impact on the state by offering a modest bonus for
68          authorizing the Department of Economic Opportunity to             97      projects that take place in underutilized areas; and
69          revoke or modify certain decisions relating to tax                98           4. Encouraging more family-friendly productions to be
70          credit eligibility under certain circumstances;                   99      produced in this state.
71          requiring the department to notify the Department of              100          (b) This purpose shall be accomplished by providing a
72          Revenue of any such revocation or modification;                   101     limited tax credit award to projects that provide the highest
73          requiring applicants to notify the Department of                  102     return on investment and economic benefit to the state which is
74          Revenue of any change in tax credit claimed; providing            103     not awardable until after a project has made its expenditures in
75          for forfeiture of tax credits; requiring the                      104     this state and the expenditures have been verified by the
76          commissioner to provide an annual report to the                   105     department.
77          Governor and the Legislature on a specified date;                 106          (2) DEFINITIONS.—As used in this act, unless the context
78          providing that certain appropriated funds are not                 107     otherwise requires, the term:
79          subject to reversion; providing for the expiration of             108          (a) “Certified project” means a qualified project that has
80          the program; providing an effective date.                         109     been scored by the council, has been determined by the
81                                                                            110     commissioner to meet or exceed the desired economic impact and
82     Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:              111     other criteria of the program, and has tax credits allocated to
83                                                                            112     it based on the project’s estimated qualified expenditures. The
84          Section 1. The Targeted High Wage Production Program.—            113     term does not include a project that may be considered obscene
85          (1) CREATION AND PURPOSE OF PROGRAM.—The Targeted High Wage       114     as defined in s. 847.001, Florida Statutes.
86     Production Program is created within the Department of Economic        115          (b) “Commissioner” means the Commissioner of Film and
87     Opportunity under the supervision of the Commissioner of Film          116     Entertainment as described in s. 288.1251(1)(b), Florida

                                 Page 3 of 24                                                                   Page 4 of 24
     CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946




        23-00366A-22                                              2022946__            23-00366A-22                                             2022946__
117     Statutes.                                                              146     of the majority of the crew is dedicated solely to the project.
118          (c) “Council” means the Florida Film and Entertainment            147          (k) “Production start date” means:
119     Advisory Council.                                                      148          1. For film and television projects, the start date of
120          (d) “Department” means the Department of Economic                 149     principal photography, as listed in the project’s application.
121     Opportunity.                                                           150          2. For digital media projects, the start date of final
122          (e) “Digital media project” means a commercial video game,        151     storyboards or a later date as specified in the project’s
123     including an educational video game, which includes at least 30        152     application.
124     minutes of game play time.                                             153          (l) “Qualified expenditures” means:
125          (f) “Family friendly” means having cross-generational             154          1. Expenditures made in this state and paid to residents of
126     appeal; being appropriate in theme, content, and language for a        155     this state or to businesses registered in this state and made
127     broad family audience; embodying a responsible resolution of           156     solely for preproduction, production, or postproduction of the
128     issues; not containing any act of drunkenness, illicit drug use,       157     qualified project, including the following:
129     sex, nudity, gratuitous violence, or vulgar or profane language;       158          a. Rented or leased goods or services provided by a vendor
130     and not portraying smoking any substance in a positive manner.         159     or supplier in this state which is registered with the
131          (g) “Film project” means a theatrical, direct-to-video,           160     Department of State or the Department of Revenue; which has a
132     television, cable, Internet, streaming service, or animated            161     physical address in this state other than a post office box; and
133     narrative motion picture at least 75 minutes in length. The term       162     which employs one or more Florida residents on a full-time
134     does not include a project deemed by the office to have content        163     basis. The term does not include rebilled goods or services
135     that is obscene, as defined in s. 847.001, Florida Statutes.           164     provided by an in-state company from out-of-state vendors or
136          (h) “Florida resident” means a person who has a valid             165     suppliers. When services provided by the vendor or supplier
137     Florida driver license or Florida identification card issued           166     include personal services or labor, only personal services or
138     under s. 322.051, Florida Statutes, and has signed an affidavit        167     labor provided by Florida residents qualify.
139     confirming residency.                                                  168          b. Payments to Florida residents in the form of salary or
140          (i) “Office” means the Office of Film and Entertainment           169     wages up to a maximum of $200,000 per resident, including
141     within the department.                                                 170     amounts paid per diem to a worker who is a Florida resident and
142          (j) “Principal photography” means, for a film project or          171     amounts paid through payroll service companies, and benefits
143     television project, the filming of major or significant                172     such as pension, health, and welfare payments for technical and
144     components of the project which involve lead actors, or, for a         173     production crews, directors, producers, and performers. For
145     digital media project, the period of time during which the work        174     purposes of this sub-subparagraph, payments do not include wages

                                     Page 5 of 24                                                                Page 6 of 24
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946




        23-00366A-22                                               2022946__           23-00366A-22                                              2022946__
175     for executives, legal staff, or other corporate staff who are          204     events show; a sports or sports recap show; a pornographic
176     not employed to work solely on the project.                            205     production; or any production deemed obscene under chapter 847,
177          c. Rented or leased cars, trucks, and trailers, if the            206     Florida Statutes.
178     vehicles or trailers are registered with the Florida Department        207          (n) “Television project” means a television pilot program
179     of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles.                                  208     or a television series that:
180          d. Purchases of catered meals and on-set craft service            209          1. Is a scripted drama, comedy, animation, or reality show;
181     supplies.                                                              210          2. Has a runtime to fit, at a minimum, a 30-minute program
182          e. Rented hotel rooms or other accommodations for cast or         211     slot, but no longer than required to fit a 60-minute program
183     crew.                                                                  212     slot; and
184          2. The term does not include expenditures not expressly           213          3. If the television project is a television series, has a
185     identified in subparagraph 1., expenditures made before                214     minimum of 7 episodes, or, if the television project is a
186     qualification for the program, expenditures made via Internet          215     reality program or series, has at least 10 episodes.
187     transactions, expenditures for airfare, or any costs associated        216          4. Does not include content that is deemed by the office to
188     with development, marketing, or distribution.                          217     be obscene, as defined in s. 847.001, Florida Statutes.
189          3. For the purposes of a digital media project, the term          218          (o) “Underutilized area” means any county in this state
190     includes only those qualified expenditures made within 9 months        219     other than Broward County, Hillsborough County, Miami-Dade
191     after the project’s first qualified expenditure.                       220     County, Orange County, Pinellas County, or Seminole County.
192          (m) “Qualified project” means a film project, television          221          (3) TAX CREDIT AWARD ELIGIBILITY.—
193     project, or digital media project that meets the application           222          (a) To be eligible for a tax credit award, an applicant
194     requirements and for which a complete application for the              223     must be registered to do business in this state and must be
195     program has been submitted to the commissioner and accepted for        224     producing a project that:
196     consideration by the office. The term does not apply to any            225          1. Has projected qualified expenditures of:
197     company doing subsidiary work on a certified production,               226          a. For a film project, at least $1.5 million;
198     including, but not limited to, postproduction, visual effects,         227          b. For a television project, at least $500,000 per episode;
199     and music. The term does not include a weather or market               228     or
200     program; a sporting event or a sporting event broadcast; a gala;       229          c. For a digital media project, at least $1.5 million;
201     an awards show; a production that solicits funds; a home               230          2. Is projected to employ a crew, including cast and stand-
202     shopping program; a political program; a gambling-related              231     ins, but not including extras, also known as background
203     project or production; a concert production; a news or current         232     performers, of which at least 60 percent will be residents of

                                  Page 7 of 24                                                                     Page 8 of 24
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946




        23-00366A-22                                               2022946__           23-00366A-22                                               2022946__
233     this state and at least one member will be a military veteran;         262     fiscal year for applications submitted during each fiscal year’s
234          3. Is projected to spend at least 70 percent of its total         263     first application window. Tax credit award funds not earmarked
235     production days in this state; and                                     264     or set aside for applicants applying during one application
236          4. Will not receive a sales tax certificate of exemption          265     window roll over for use in the next application window.
237     pursuant to s. 288.1258, Florida Statutes, for the project.            266          (b) If all tax credit awards are earmarked and set aside
238          (b) A certified project may receive a tax credit award in         267     for certified projects, additional applications may not be
239     the amount of up to 20 percent of its verified qualified               268     accepted until more funds become available for the program.
240     expenditures. A bonus may be earned in the amount of an                269          (c) If during any application period only a partial amount
241     additional 3 percentage points if 60 percent of the project’s          270     of tax credit awards are available to certify to a project
242     production in this state will take place in an underutilized           271     compared to the full amount for which it would be eligible, the
243     area or if its content is deemed family friendly. A certified          272     applicant must elect to either accept the partial tax credit
244     project may not receive more than one bonus, and the total that        273     award as the maximum certified tax credit award it would be
245     may be awarded under any tax credit award may not exceed 23            274     eligible for or reject it and drop out of the program. The
246     percent of its verified qualified expenditures or $2 million,          275     applicant must notify the commissioner in writing of its
247     whichever is less.                                                     276     decision before the application period ends. If additional tax
248          (c) A certified project must make a good faith effort to          277     credit awards become available after the application period, the
249     use existing providers of infrastructure or equipment in this          278     project of an applicant that accepted a partial tax credit award
250     state, when available, including providers of camera gear, grip        279     is not eligible for any such awards.
251     and lighting equipment, vehicles, and postproduction services,         280          (5) APPLICATION PROCESS.—
252     and to employ residents of this state as cast and crew.                281          (a) A company that plans to produce a film, television, or
253          (4) APPLICATION WINDOWS.—Applications must be accepted for        282     digital project in this state may submit an application to the
254     the program during two application windows each fiscal year. The       283     commissioner during one of the two application windows. Each
255     commissioner shall set a start date for both application               284     fiscal year, a project must have a production start date that is
256     windows. However, the first application window may begin before        285     within 6 months after July 1 if applying in the first window or
257     the start of the fiscal year and must end no later than 5              286     within 6 months after January 1 if applying in the second
258     business days after July 1, and the second application window          287     window.
259     must end no later than 5 business days after December 1.               288          (b) An applicant or its parent company may submit an
260          (a) The department may not earmark or set aside more than         289     application for no more than five projects in any single fiscal
261     60 percent of any tax credit awards available for any given            290     year. However, except in the case of a television pilot and the

                                  Page 9 of 24                                                                   Page 10 of 24
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946




        23-00366A-22                                               2022946__           23-00366A-22                                              2022946__
291     television series the pilot is based on being certified within         320          12. The applicant’s Florida tax identification number.
292     the same fiscal year, only one project per applicant may be            321          (d) Within a reasonable period of time after the last
293     certified within a fiscal year.                                        322     business day of each application window, the commissioner shall:
294          (c) The application must include:                                 323          1. Review all applications submitted during the application
295          1. Proof of funding;                                              324     window and determine the eligibility of each applicant;
296          2. Project-related employment information, including              325          2. Determine each applicant’s expected qualified
297     employment numbers for residents of this state;                        326     expenditures;
298          3. A full line-item budget and a detailed qualified               327          3. Determine the maximum tax credit each qualified
299     expenditures budget;                                                   328     applicant may be awarded;
300          4. A detailed distribution plan to assist with determining        329          4. Determine whether a qualified applicant’s project is
301     the potential economic impact of the project in this state;            330     deemed family friendly;
302          5. The applicant’s expected total qualified expenditures          331          5. Determine the percentage of the applicant’s production,
303     for wages paid to residents of this state;                             332     if any, which is proposed to occur in an underutilized area;
304          6. The applicant’s expected total qualified expenditures          333          6. Determine whether each qualified applicant is a
305     and nonqualified expenditures in this state;                           334     corporation registered in this state;
306          7. For a film project, the latest script, a production            335          7. Contact each applicant with any questions, as necessary;
307     schedule, a Day Out of Days report, and a list of the expected         336          8. Gather any additional information needed to address the
308     shooting locations;                                                    337     criteria specified under subsection (6);
309          8. For a digital media project, a detailed game design            338          9. Assemble a package containing the details of each
310     document, including a production schedule;                             339     qualified applicant’s project and deliver it to each council
311          9. For a television project that is a pilot, a final              340     member; and
312     script, a production schedule, a Day Out of Days report, and a         341          10. Give notice to the council of the date and time when
313     list of the expected shooting locations;                               342     the council must convene to assess each qualified project. The
314          10. For a television project that is a series, the latest         343     council may meet in person or by conference call.
315     scripts for at least two episodes and a production schedule, a         344          (e) The council shall determine a score for each qualified
316     Day Out of Days report, and a list of the expected shooting            345     project using the criteria specified under subsection (6), with
317     locations for the first episode;                                       346     the highest scores going to projects determined to provide the
318          11. An affirmation signed by the applicant that the               347     best economic impact and return on investment to this state.
319     information on the application is correct; and                         348          (6) CRITERIA FOR DETERMINING PROJECT SCORES.—

                                    Page 11 of 24                                                                  Page 12 of 24
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946




        23-00366A-22                                               2022946__           23-00366A-22                                               2022946__
349          (a) The priority order and scoring system of the criteria         378          13. The number of Florida film school graduates the project
350     specified in paragraph (b) must be determined by the                   379     will hire as cast or crew.
351     commissioner, with assistance from the council and other               380          (7) NOTIFICATION OF DECISION.—
352     persons, as determined by the commissioner, before the first           381          (a) After the council determines a project’s score, the
353     application window.                                                    382     commissioner shall, in a timely manner:
354          (b) The council shall use, at a minimum, the following            383          1. Make a final determination on certifying or rejecting
355     criteria in determining a qualified project’s score:                   384     each qualified project, giving consideration to the council’s
356          1. The amount of the project’s overall qualified                  385     scoring.
357     expenditures.                                                          386          2. Provide a list of certified projects to the department
358          2. The amount of the project’s Florida-resident wages.            387     which includes the associated maximum tax credit that each
359          3. The number of full-time equivalent jobs created by the         388     respective applicant may be awarded.
360     project.                                                               389          3. Notify each certified project of the specified
361          4. Whether the project provides pension, health, and              390     percentage of qualified expenditures for which it is eligible
362     welfare benefits to its workforce in this state.                       391     and the maximum tax credit it may be awarded.
363          5. The estimated direct and indirect tourism benefit of the       392          4. Provide a notice of rejection to each rejected
364     project, based on the submitted distribution plan.                     393     applicant; however, the failure to notify an applicant of its
365          6. The duration of Florida-resident employment for the            394     rejection does not deem the applicant’s project a certified
366     project.                                                               395     project.
367          7. What percentage of the project, if any, is being made in       396          (b) Based on the final determination of the commissioner,
368     an underutilized area.                                                 397     the department shall certify the project and its maximum tax
369          8. Whether the project is family friendly.                        398     credit award, if any, to the applicant and to the executive
370          9. Whether the project has a Florida-resident writer,             399     director of the Department of Revenue.
371     producer, director, or star.                                           400          (8) VERIFICATION PROCESS.—
372          10. Whether a Florida film, television, or digital media          401          (a) The commissioner shall develop a process to verify the
373     school will assist with the production of the project.                 402     actual qualified expenditures and bonus eligibility of a
374          11. Whether the project leadership team has a successful          403     certified project after the project’s work in this state is
375     track record.                                                          404     complete. The process must require all of the following:
376          12. The number of Florida-resident veterans the project           405          1. Submission to the commissioner of at least all of the
377     will hire.                                                             406     following information, electronically or in hard copy, or both,

                                  Page 13 of 24                                                                  Page 14 of 24
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946




        23-00366A-22                                               2022946__           23-00366A-22                                               2022946__
407     by each certified project:                                             436     expenditure but no later than 1 year after its production start
408          a. Data substantiating each qualified expenditure which has       437     date. Pursuant to the rules adopted by the department, the
409     been audited by an independent certified public accountant             438     commissioner may, upon a showing of good cause, grant a one-time
410     licensed in this state, as required under subparagraph 4.;             439     extension of this deadline.
411          b. Copies of documents verifying residency of persons             440          4. A compliance audit conducted at the certified project’s
412     represented as being residents of this state, including an             441     expense by an independent certified public accountant who is a
413     affidavit signed by each resident;                                     442     resident of this state to substantiate the qualified
414          c. The final script;                                              443     expenditures, and submission of a report of the audit findings,
415          d. The most recent production board and shooting schedule;        444     including substantiating data, to the commissioner within a
416          e. The most recent credit list showing where the credits          445     reasonable period of time after the initial receipt of records
417     required under subsection (9) will appear;                             446     from the certified project.
418          f. A cast list and a final crew list with contact                 447          (b) The commissioner shall review the report and data
419     information;                                                           448     required under paragraph (a) within a reasonable period of time
420          g. For any veterans employed by the project, a copy of at         449     after receipt of the report and data and shall report to the
421     least one DD Form 214, as issued by the United States Department       450     department the final verified amount of actual qualified
422     of Defense, or another acceptable form of identification as            451     expenditures the certified project made and the amount of the
423     specified by the Department of Veterans’ Affairs; and                  452     total tax credit award due the project.
424          h. Any other information determined necessary by the              453          (c) The department shall determine and approve the final
425     commissioner.                                                          454     tax credit award amount to each certified applicant based on the
426          2. Signing, and submission to the commissioner, by the lead       455     final verified amount of actual qualified expenditures and shall
427     producer or studio executive in charge of the certified project,       456     notify the executive director of the Department of Revenue in
428     of an affidavit or a written declaration signed under the              457     writing that the certified production has met the requirements
429     penalty of perjury as specified in s. 92.525, Florida Statutes,        458     of the incentive program and of the final amount of the tax
430     stating that all salaries, wages, and other compensation               459     credit award. The final tax credit award amount may not exceed
431     submitted as qualified expenditures are in compliance with this        460     the maximum tax credit award amount certified under subparagraph
432     section.                                                               461     (7)(b). The tax credit must be issued within a reasonable period
433          3. The information and affidavit required by subparagraphs        462     of time.
434     1. and 2. must be received by the commissioner within 120 days         463          (9) MARKETING AND TOURISM REQUIREMENT.—
435     after the certified project has made its last qualified                464          (a) The commissioner shall ensure, as a condition of

                                     Page 15 of 24                                                               Page 16 of 24
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946




        23-00366A-22                                               2022946__           23-00366A-22                                            2022946__
465     receiving a tax credit under this section, that a certified            494          (10) DISQUALIFICATION.—The department shall disqualify a
466     project includes marketing promoting this state as a tourist           495     certified project and may not issue a tax credit award to the
467     destination or film and entertainment production destination. At       496     project if the project:
468     a minimum, the marketing must include placement in the end             497          (a) Does not begin principal photography in this state
469     credits of a “Filmed in Florida” or “Produced in Florida” logo,        498     within the period beginning 30 days before and ending 90 days
470     with size and placement commensurate to other logos included in        499     after the project’s listed production start date. Pursuant to
471     the end credits, or, if no logos are used, the statement “Filmed       500     department rule, the commissioner may, upon a showing of good
472     in Florida” or “Produced in Florida” or a similar statement            501     cause, grant a one-time extension of this deadline;
473     approved by the commissioner and the logo of the local film            502          (b) Does not abide by the policies, procedures, deadlines,
474     office, if applicable. A digital media project must also supply        503     or requirements of the application verification process;
475     a 5-second or longer animated logo with “Produced in Florida” or       504          (c) Does not notify the commissioner of any change in the
476     other text, including the logo of the local digital media              505     production start date before commencing production;
477     office, if applicable, as preapproved by the commissioner, in a        506          (d) Submits fraudulent information; or
478     manner easily seen by a consumer of the digital media project.         507          (e) Uses the state sales tax exemption established under s.
479     The commissioner shall provide the logos for the purposes              508     288.1258, Florida Statutes.
480     specified in this paragraph, not including the logo for a local        509          (11) FRAUD.—An applicant that submits fraudulent
481     office, which must be provided by the applicable office.               510     information under this section is liable for reimbursement of
482          (b) A certified project must allow the commissioner, or an        511     the reasonable costs and fees associated with the review,
483     affiliate, and a minimum of two guests to visit the production         512     processing, investigation, and prosecution of the fraudulent
484     site upon the request of the commissioner. Upon such request,          513     submission. An applicant that obtains a tax credit award under
485     the certified project must give the commissioner reasonable            514     this section through a claim that is fraudulent shall reimburse
486     notice of a visit date and time that is acceptable to the              515     the program for the tax credit awarded and reasonable costs and
487     production. The commissioner or an affiliate is not required to        516     fees associated with the review, processing, investigation, and
488     make a visit to the set.                                               517     prosecution of the fraudulent claim and shall pay a civil
489          (c) A certified project must provide at least five                518     penalty in an amount equal to double the tax credit amount and
490     preapproved photos of the production to the commissioner and           519     any criminal penalty assessed against the applicant.
491     grant the commissioner free use of the photos in promoting this        520          (12) ELECTION AND DISTRIBUTION OF TAX CREDITS.—
492     state as a film, television, or digital media production               521          (a) A certified production company receiving a tax credit
493     location or tourist destination.                                       522     award under this section shall, at the time the credit is

                                   Page 17 of 24                                                                 Page 18 of 24
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946




        23-00366A-22                                            2022946__              23-00366A-22                                               2022946__
523     awarded by the department after production is completed and all        552          (e) A certified production company that is not a
524     requirements to receive a credit award have been met, make an          553     corporation as defined in s. 220.03(1)(e), Florida Statutes, may
525     irrevocable election to apply the credit against taxes due under       554     elect to distribute tax credits awarded under this section to
526     chapter 220, Florida Statutes; against state taxes collected or        555     its partners or members in proportion to their respective
527     accrued under chapter 212, Florida Statutes; or against a stated       556     distributive income or loss in the taxable year in which the tax
528     combination of the two taxes. The election is binding upon any         557     credits were awarded.
529     distributee, successor, transferee, or purchaser. The department       558          (f) Tax credits available under this section to a certified
530     shall notify the Department of Revenue of any election made            559     production company may succeed to a surviving or acquiring
531     pursuant to this paragraph.                                            560     entity subject to the same conditions and limitations as
532          (b) A qualified production company is eligible for tax            561     described in this section; however, the credits may not be
533     credits against its sales and use tax liabilities and corporate        562     transferred by the surviving or acquiring entity.
534     income tax liabilities as provided in this section. However, tax       563          (13) TRANSFER OF TAX CREDITS.—
535     credits awarded under this section may not be claimed against          564          (a) Upon application to the Office of Film and
536     sales and use tax liabilities or corporate income tax                  565     Entertainment and approval by the department, a certified
537     liabilities for any tax period beginning before July 1, 2022,          566     production company, or a partner or member of a certified
538     regardless of when the credits are applied for or awarded.             567     production company, that has received a distribution under
539          (c) If the certified production company cannot use the            568     paragraph (4)(g) may elect to transfer, in whole or in part, any
540     entire tax credit in the taxable year or reporting period in           569     unused credit amount granted under this section. An election to
541     which the credit is awarded, any excess amount may be carried          570     transfer any unused tax credit amount under chapter 212, Florida
542     forward to a succeeding taxable year or reporting period. A tax        571     Statutes, or chapter 220, Florida Statutes, must be made no
543     credit applied against taxes imposed under chapter 212, Florida        572     later than 5 years after the date the credit is awarded, after
544     Statutes, or chapter 220, Florida Statutes, may be carried             573     which period the credit expires and may not be used. The
545     forward for a maximum of 5 years after the date the credit is          574     department shall notify the Department of Revenue of the
546     awarded, after which the credit expires and may not be used.           575     election and transfer. The original transferee and any
547          (d) A certified production company that files a                   576     subsequent transferees must be either the certified company’s
548     consolidated return as a member of an affiliated group under s.        577     parent company or a subsidiary company or a business with NAICS
549     220.131(1), Florida Statutes, may use the credit on a                  578     code 512110, 512120, 512191, 512199, 512240, 512250, 512290,
550     consolidated return basis up to the amount of the tax imposed          579     515120, 515210, 517410, 541922, 711130, 711410, or 711510.
551     upon the consolidated group under chapter 220, Florida Statutes.       580          (b) A certified production company that elects to apply a

                                  Page 19 of 24                                                                  Page 20 of 24
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946




        23-00366A-22                                              2022946__            23-00366A-22                                               2022946__
581     credit amount against taxes remitted under chapter 212, Florida        610     program shall equal, but not exceed:
582     Statutes, is allowed a one-time transfer of unused credits to          611          1. For fiscal year 2022-2023, $20 million.
583     one transferee. A certified production company that elects to          612          2. For fiscal year 2023-2024, $20 million.
584     apply a credit amount against taxes due under chapter 220,             613          3. For fiscal year 2024-2025, $20 million.
585     Florida Statutes, is allowed a one-time transfer of unused             614          4. For fiscal year 2025-2026, $20 million.
586     credits to no more than four transferees, and such transfers           615          (b) Any portion of the maximum amount of tax credits
587     must occur in the same taxable year.                                   616     established per fiscal year in paragraph (a) which is not
588          (c) A transferee receiving a tax credit has the same rights       617     certified by the end of that fiscal year shall be carried
589     and is subject to the same limitations as the certified                618     forward and made available for certification during the
590     production company awarded the tax credit except that a                619     following 2 fiscal years in addition to the amounts available
591     transferee receiving a tax credit may not subsequently transfer        620     under paragraph (a) for those fiscal years.
592     the tax credit.                                                        621          (c) Upon approval of the final tax credit award amount
593          (14) RELINQUISHMENT OF TAX CREDITS.—                              622     pursuant to paragraph (8)(c), an amount equal to the difference
594          (a) Beginning July 1, 2022, a certified production company,       623     between the maximum tax credit award amount previously certified
595     or any person who has acquired a tax credit from a certified           624     under subsection (7) and the approved final tax credit award
596     production company, may elect to relinquish the tax credit to          625     amount shall immediately be available for recertification during
597     the Department of Revenue in exchange for payment of 85 percent        626     the current and following fiscal years in addition to the
598     of the amount of the relinquished tax credit.                          627     amounts available under paragraph (a) for those fiscal years.
599          (b) The Department of Revenue may approve payments to             628          (d) If the total amount of credits applied for during a
600     entities relinquishing tax credits pursuant to this subsection.        629     fiscal year pursuant to subsection (5) exceeds the amount of
601          (c) Subject to legislative appropriation, the Department of       630     credits available for certification in that fiscal year, such
602     Revenue shall request the Chief Financial Officer to issue             631     excess shall be treated as having been applied for on the first
603     warrants to entities relinquishing tax credits. Payments under         632     day of the next fiscal year in which credits remain available
604     this subsection shall be made from the funds from which the            633     for certification.
605     proceeds from the taxes against which the tax credits could have       634          (16) RULES, POLICIES, AND PROCEDURES.—The department may
606     been applied pursuant to the irrevocable election made by the          635     adopt rules and develop policies and procedures to implement and
607     certified production company under subsection (4) are deposited.       636     administer this section, including, but not limited to, rules
608          (15) ANNUAL ALLOCATION OF TAX CREDITS.—                           637     specifying requirements for the application and approval
609          (a) The aggregate amount of tax credits allocated to the          638     process, records required for substantiation for tax credits,

                                  Page 21 of 24                                                                  Page 22 of 24
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
        Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946           Florida Senate - 2022                                         SB 946




        23-00366A-22                                               2022946__           23-00366A-22                                               2022946__
639     the manner and form of documentation required to claim tax             668     result of an audit pursuant to paragraph (a) or from information
640     credits awarded, transferred, or relinquished under this               669     received from the Office of Film and Entertainment, that an
641     section, marketing requirements for tax credit recipients, and         670     applicant received tax credits pursuant to this section to which
642     the examination and audit procedures required to administer this       671     the applicant was not entitled is grounds for forfeiture of
643     section.                                                               672     previously claimed and received tax credits. The applicant is
644          (17) AUDIT AUTHORITY; REVOCATION AND FORFEITURE OF TAX            673     responsible for returning forfeited tax credits to the
645     CREDITS; FRAUDULENT CLAIMS.—                                           674     Department of Revenue, and such funds shall be paid into the
646          (a) The Department of Revenue may conduct examinations and        675     General Revenue Fund of the state. Tax credits purchased in good
647     audits as provided in s. 213.34 to verify that tax credits under       676     faith are not subject to forfeiture unless the transferee
648     this section are received, transferred, and applied according to       677     submitted fraudulent information in the purchase or failed to
649     the requirements of this section. If the Department of Revenue         678     meet the requirements in subsection (13).
650     determines that tax credits are not received, transferred, or          679          (18) ANNUAL REPORT.—Each November 1, the commissioner shall
651     applied as required by this section, it may, in addition to the        680     provide an annual report on the program for the previous fiscal
652     remedies provided in this subsection, pursue recovery of such          681     year to the Governor, the President of the Senate, and the
653     funds pursuant to the laws and rules governing the assessment of       682     Speaker of the House of Representatives. The report must
654     taxes. The Department of Revenue may adopt rules to administer         683     identify the return on investment associated with, and economic
655     this paragraph.                                                        684     benefits to this state attributable to, the program.
656          (b) The department may revoke or modify any written               685          (19) FUNDS NOT SUBJECT TO REVERSION.—Notwithstanding s.
657     decision qualifying, certifying, or otherwise granting                 686     216.301, Florida Statutes, funds appropriated for this purpose
658     eligibility for tax credits under this section if it is                687     are not subject to reversion.
659     discovered that the tax credit applicant submitted any false           688          (20) EXPIRATION.— The Targeted High Wage Production Program
660     statement, representation, or certification in any application,        689     expires June 30, 2026, at which point all remaining appropriated
661     record, report, plan, or other document filed in an attempt to         690     funds not earmarked and set aside for certified projects must
662     receive tax credits under this section. The department shall           691     revert to the General Revenue Fund. All remaining appropriated
663     immediately notify the Department of Revenue of any revoked or         692     funds must revert to the General Revenue Fund no later than
664     modified orders affecting previously granted tax credits.              693     October 31, 2027.
665     Additionally, the applicant must notify the Department of              694          Section 2. This act shall take effect upon becoming a law.
666     Revenue of any change in its tax credit claimed.
667          (c) A determination by the Department of Revenue, as a

                                  Page 23 of 24                                                                  Page 24 of 24
      CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.          CODING: Words stricken are deletions; words underlined are additions.
                                 CourtSmart Tag Report
Room: SB 110                         Case No.:                               Type:
Caption: Commerce and Tourism        Judge:

Started: 1/10/2022 4:02:00 PM
Ends:    1/10/2022 4:30:15 PM        Length: 00:28:16

4:01:59 PM    Chair Hooper calls meeting to order
4:02:00 PM    Roll Call by Committee Administrative Assistant
4:02:41 PM    Quorum present
4:02:47 PM    Chair Hooper gives opening comments
4:03:17 PM    Tab 4 - SB 946 by Senator Gruters
4:03:35 PM    Senator Gruters explains the bill
4:04:21 PM    No questions
4:04:35 PM    BD Jogerst, Associated Industries of Florida, waives in support of bill
4:04:40 PM    Bob McKee, Florida Association of Counties, waives in support of the bill
4:04:42 PM    Phillip Suderman, Americans for Prosperity, speaking against the bill
4:07:11 PM    Lauren Starch, Hillsborough County Board of County Commissioners, waives in support of the bill
4:07:20 PM    Senator Steve Geller, Broward County Board of County Commissioners, speaking for the bill
4:10:23 PM    Edward Briggs, Tampa Hillsborough Film and Digital Media Commission, waives in support of the bill
4:10:32 PM    Carolyn Johnson, Florida Chamber of Commerce, waives in support of the bill
4:10:44 PM    John Lux, Film Florida, speaking in favor of the bill
4:13:47 PM    Jess M. McCarty, Executive Assistant County Attorney Miami-Dade County, waives in support of the bill
4:14:02 PM    Senator Wright in debate
4:14:37 PM    Senator Gruters closes on bill
4:16:31 PM    Roll call on SB 946
4:17:31 PM    SB 946 is reported favorably
4:17:53 PM    Tab 3 - SB 546 by Senator Gruters
4:18:10 PM    Senator Gruters explains the bill
4:18:51 PM    Senator Powell in questions
4:19:01 PM    Senator Gruters responds
4:19:22 PM    Ivonne Fernandez, AARP, waives in support of the bill
4:19:31 PM    Scott Jenkins, FL Financial Services Assoc., waives in support of the bill
4:19:45 PM    No debate
4:19:48 PM    Senator Gruters waives close on bill
4:19:55 PM    Roll call on SB 546
4:20:03 PM    SB 546 is reported favorably
4:20:17 PM    Tab 2 - SB 418 by Senator Pizzo
4:20:26 PM    Senator Pizzo explains the bill
4:21:06 PM    No questions
4:21:08 PM    Whitney Doyle, Florida Alliance for Assistive Services and Technology, speaking for the bill
4:22:55 PM    Senator Pizzo in questions
4:23:16 PM    Whitney Doyle responds
4:23:20 PM    No debate
4:23:42 PM    Senator Pizzo closes on bill
4:23:48 PM    Roll call on SB 418
4:23:55 PM    SB 418 is reported favorably
4:24:09 PM    Tab 1 - SB 842 by Senator Brodeur presented by Senator Diaz
4:24:27 PM    Senator Diaz explains the bill
4:24:55 PM    Senator Torres in questions
4:25:08 PM    Senator Diaz responds
4:26:05 PM    Amanda Prater, FGA Action, waives in support of the bill
4:26:13 PM    David Mica Jr., Florida Hospital Association, waives against the bill
4:26:38 PM    David Mica Jr. with Florida Hospital Association speaking against the bill
4:27:21 PM    Senator Pizzo in questions
4:27:32 PM    David Mica Jr. in response
4:27:40 PM    Back and forth in questions
4:29:11 PM    Senator Diaz waives close
4:29:19 PM    Roll call SB 842
4:29:25 PM   SB 842 is reported favorably
4:29:45 PM   Chair Hooper in closing remarks
4:29:59 PM   Senator Hutson moves to adjourn
4:30:05 PM   Meeting is adjourned


File and source

File
2022-01-10_post-meeting-packet_4886.pdf
Size
3,673,954 bytes
SHA-256
1c80a0db1eebd6aa2b7bef3d3b32471fef90ffac804e36eeddfad11ca6f783c5
Our copy
2022-01-10_post-meeting-packet_4886.pdf
Original
No public link identified.
Back to top