Full text
1
CORRECTED SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF ERIKA PINHEIRO
I, Erika Pinheiro, under the penalty of perjury pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746, declare as
follows:
1. I make this declaration based on my personal knowledge except where I have
indicated otherwise. If called as a witness, I would testify competently and truthfully to these
matters.
2. I submit this declaration to supplement my previous declaration in East Bay
Sanctuary Covenant v. Trump, which was executed on November 9, 2018.
3. The implementation of the interim final rule, “Aliens Subject to a Bar on Entry Under
Certain Presidential Proclamations; Procedures for Protection Claims,” and the Presidential
Proclamation Addressing Mass Migration Through the Southern Border of the United States has
created a crisis situation for Al Otro Lado.
4. In recent weeks, Grupo Beta, a service by the National Institute of Migration of
Mexico, has refused to allow unaccompanied minors who have journeyed to the southern border
to seek asylum to get on the list to cross the border at a port of entry. Al Otro Lado has been told
that if these children show up at the port of entry and attempt to get on the list, they will be taken
into custody by the Mexican child custody agency.
5. For example, Al Otro Lado is working with a child named B.I., a sixteen year old boy
from Mexico, who left his home along with his sister to escape from violent abuse they had been
suffering from years. On November 1, 2018, B.I. and his sister went to a port of entry (“POE”),
but the U.S. officials would not let them pass into the United States. Instead, the officials held
B.I. and his sister in the POE for several hours, and then moved them to a cell in a different
Case 4:18-cv-06810-JST Document 71-2 Filed 12/04/18 Page 1 of 6
2
building, where they stayed for about 18 hours. After speaking briefly with an official from the
Mexican consulate, B.I. and his sister were deported back to Tijuana without ever having been
given the opportunity to apply for asylum, despite the fact that they indicated that they wanted to
apply for asylum.
6. On November 6, 2018, B.I. and his sister went to a different POE. Rigo, a staff
member at Al Otro Lado, went with them. Grupo Beta, the group organizing the list of asylum
seekers at the POE, told Rigo and B.I. that children could not get on the list unless they had
original identity documents and were accompanied by a parent. B.I. was unaccompanied and did
not have original documents with him. Grupo Beta also said that if any unaccompanied children
tried to get on the list, they will be taken into custody by the Mexican child custody agency.
7. B.I. has no family he can live with safely in Mexico. He does not feel safe staying in
Mexico. He wants to apply for asylum in the United States. He is worried that if he goes back to
a port of entry, he will be unable to get on the list to apply for asylum.
8. Al Otro Lado is also working with another unaccompanied minor, D.D., who had the
same experience when an Al Otro Lado staff member went with her to a POE so that she could
get in line to apply for asylum. D.D. is fifteen years old and fled El Salvador to escape her
grandfather’s sexual abuse.
9. D.D. left El Salvador in the middle of October 2018. It took her about three weeks to
travel from El Salvador to Tijuana. When she got to Tijuana, she went to El Chaparral plaza
near the San Ysidro port of entry. People she was traveling with told her she had to go get a
number in order to apply for asylum in the United States. She went to the plaza and showed her
identity documents, and the people in charge of the list gave her a number. She waited at a
Case 4:18-cv-06810-JST Document 71-2 Filed 12/04/18 Page 2 of 6
3
shelter for youth in Tijuana called Casa Imca.
10. On November 6, 2018, Rigo from Al Otro Lado went with D.D. to El Chaparral
plaza. The people organizing the list of asylum seekers told Rigo and me that unaccompanied
minors could not get on the list unless they had original identity documents and were
accompanied by a parent. D.D. was not accompanied by her parents.
11. D.D. is afraid to return to El Salvador because her family there now knows about the
sexual abuse she suffered. She is afraid that she would be in danger from her grandfather if she
returns. She hopes she will be allowed to apply for asylum in the United States, but is concerned
because she was told that she cannot apply without her parents.
12. Before the new rule, those children who were refused entry at a port would then enter
the United States without inspection and turn themselves in to immigration authorities to apply
for asylum.
13. Since the new rule was announced on November 9, 2018, if these children enter
without inspection, they will not be able to apply for asylum. These children now have no way to
apply for asylum in the United States, and are effectively trapped in Mexico in dangerous border
towns, generally without any resources.
14. In the past, children not allowed on a list or not otherwise allowed to present at a port
of entry would have, out of necessity, entered between ports of entry in order to apply for
asylum.
Case 4:18-cv-06810-JST Document 71-2 Filed 12/04/18 Page 3 of 6
4
15. Since the new rule was announced, Al Otro Lado has been overwhelmed with
children who traveled to the southern border of the United States to apply for asylum but now
cannot do so. These children are very vulnerable, as they are unaccompanied and so have no one
to look out for them in Tijuana, a city currently seeing record levels of violence. Lesbian, gay,
bisexual, and transgender unaccompanied minors are especially vulnerable.
16. Caring for these children is incredibly time consuming and causing a near complete
diversion of Al Otro Lado’s resources away from its core mission, which is providing legal
services. In addition to providing these children with legal advice, attending to the many non-
legal needs of Al Otro Lado’s unaccompanied children clients is forcing Al Otro Lado to divert
resources away from advising the many other clients who need the organization’s legal help, thus
undermining our ability to achieve our core mission. For example, staff members are going with
the children to try to get them on the list to cross at the port of entry. Staff have also had to
negotiate with Mexican officials so that they will not take these children into custody and instead
allow them to stay at a local youth shelter while Al Otro Lado determines the best way to ensure
that the children have access to a legal means to seek asylum in the United States.
Accompanying one to two children to do this takes three to four hours. One staff member has
been taking care of these children full-time for the past three days.
17. Al Otro Lado currently is providing legal advice and support to nine children in
Tijuana, Mexico, who wish to seek asylum in the United States. Five of these children are from
Honduras and identify as LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender); they have strong asylum
claims.
Case 4:18-cv-06810-JST Document 71-2 Filed 12/04/18 Page 4 of 6
5
18. Al Otro Lado was connected to these clients by Casa YMCA, a shelter where the
children are staying.
19. These clients have tried to obtain a number to join the list to present themselves for
asylum, but Al Otro Lado has been told by Grupo Beta that the children need to have a parent
and documents in order to present and that if they try to take a number they will be taken into
custody by Mexican officials.
20. These clients cannot be left alone in Tijuana because of the danger of apprehension
by Mexican officials. Al Otro Lado therefore has to accompany them anytime they leave the
shelter at which they are staying for legal proceedings. This effort is far beyond anything Al
Otro Lado usually does for its clients and has been a huge drain on Al Otro Lado’s resources.
21. LGBT children cannot safely stay in Mexico. They are at risk of violence and
persecution. Yet there is now no way for them to access the asylum system in the United States.
Al Otro Lado’s staff members have been overwhelmed by work outside our core mission since
the new rule went into effect.
22. The new rule also seriously jeopardizes a major source of Al Otro Lado’s funding. Al
Otro Lado receives funding from the California Department of Social Services to represent
detained immigrants in their bond proceedings. We have expended significant organizational
resources establishing referral systems with the Federal Public Defender office and Innovation
Law Lab’s Border X Project to receive cases of asylum seekers who have entered without
inspection. Al Otro Lado is required to complete a certain number of cases before the end of
next year. Since the rule went into effect, we have not received a single referral for a bond case,
as persons who enter without inspection are ostensibly being put into “Withholding-only”
proceedings and no longer initially eligible for bond. We will have to significantly remake our
Case 4:18-cv-06810-JST Document 71-2 Filed 12/04/18 Page 5 of 6
Case 4:18-cv-06810-JST Document 71-2 Filed 12/04/18 Page 6 of 6