Court filing
Complaint — Hart v. Facebook
Filed August 31, 2021 in Hart v. Facebook; one of 10 filings from this case.
Record facts
| Court | U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Francisco Division |
|---|---|
| Filed | 2021-08-31 |
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Francisco Division · No. 3:22-cv-00737-CRB · Doc. 1 · 2021-08-31 · Docket on CourtListener
Full text
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 1 of 24
-G:=JL# /QD=J
. )
JLQD=JLQD=J:MJK;@ ;GE
)9<9) #A?M=J9
. )
F@A?M=J9LQD=J:MJK;@ ;GE
/QD=JMJK;@ ''+
'9KJAK9K-<
(MJJA=L9 9DA>GJFA9
+@GF=
!9P
JA9F&=DK=Q42%'"-')>GJL@;GEAF?
/=FF=KK==9J)ME:=J
:C=DK=QDB; GJ?
(9DDGJQ-=9<=J42%'"-')>GJL@;GEAF?
(A;@A?9F9J)ME:=J+
EJ=9<=JDB; GJ?
'A:=JLQ%MKLA;==FL=J
2 %9;CKGFDN< .L=
@A;9?G $DDAFGAK
+@GF=
!9P
66241):5*24/%-16-**
%0./$)#-/
+D9AFLA>>
'21CV1543 MMA WVG
9K=)G 88888888888888888
88888888888888888
N
! **& $) /2$// - $)
1$1 &(0-/#4AF@AKG>>A;A9D;9H9;ALQ9K
0FAL=<.L9L=K.MJ?=GF"=F=J9D%*. +#-
$ ) %- AF @AK G>>A;A9D ;9H9;ALQ 9K
+J=KA<=FL G> L@= 0FAL=< .L9L=K L@=
+-/( )/ *! # '/# )
#0(). -1$ .9F<L@=*!!$ *!
()" ( )/)0" /
=>=F<9FLK
Case No.
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 2 of 24
=>=F<9FLK ;GFKHAJ=< LG J=EGN= >JGE L@= AFL=JF=L KG;A9D E=<A9 HGKLK :Q
+D9AFLA>> %MKLAF#9JL :=;9MK=L@=Q<AK9?J==<OAL@@AKNA=OHGAFL
!AJKL #9JL:JAF?KL@AK9;LAGFLG<=>=F<L@=>J==<GEG>KH==;@>JGENA=OHGAFL
:9K=< <AK;JAEAF9LGJQ ;GDDMKAGF :=LO==F HJAN9L= KG;A9D E=<A9 ;GEH9FA=K 9F< L@= >=<=J9D
?GN=JFE=FL
W$L AK 9PAGE9LA; L@9L L@= ?GN=JFE=FL E9Q FGL J=?MD9L= KH==;@ :9K=< GF ALK
KM:KL9FLAN=;GFL=FLGJL@=E=KK9?=AL;GFN=QK X25)1&)4+)48)'624"-5-62452*6,)
!1-8 2* "% 0 . 0F<=J L@= !J== .H==;@ D9MK= G> L@= !AJKL
E=F<E=FL W<AK;JAEAF9LAGF 9?9AFKL KH==;@ :=;9MK= G> ALK E=KK9?= AK HJ=KME=< LG :=
MF;GFKLALMLAGF9D X(
2@=F L@= >=<=J9D ?GN=JFE=FL 9<EALK LG ;GFKHAJAF? OAL@ KG;A9D E=<A9
;GEH9FA=K LG ;=FKGJ E=KK9?=K OAL@ O@A;@ AL <AK9?J==K 9K AL @9K AF L@AK ;9K= :GL@ L@=
?GN=JFE=FL 9F< L@= HJAN9L= ;GEH9FA=K 9J= ?MADLQ G> MF;GFKLALMLAGF9D NA=OHGAFL
<AK;JAEAF9LAGF W%GAFL 9;LAGF =PAKLK O@=J= L@= ?GN=JFE=FL =F;GMJ9?=K
MF;GFKLALMLAGF9D ;GF<M;L L@JGM?@ ALK AFNGDN=E=FL OAL@ 9 HJAN9L= H9JLQ X ,12 8
$%570% ! < L@AJ ;D=9F=<MH
/@AKGMJLK@GMD<<=;D9J=L@=9;LAGFKG>=>=F<9FLK!9;=:GGC $F; /OALL=J
$F; +J=KA<=FL A<=F 9F< .MJ?=GF "=F=J9D (MJL@Q MF;GFKLALMLAGF9D 9F< H=JE9F=FLDQ
=FBGAF L@=E >JGE EGFALGJAF? >D9??AF? 9F< <=D=LAF? KG;A9D E=<A9 HGKLK :9K=< GF L@=
NA=OHGAFLKL@=HGKLK=KHGMK=
.=;GF< =>=F<9FLK L@==H9JLE=FL G> #=9DL@ 9F< #ME9F .=JNA;=K9F<L@=
*>>A;=G>(9F9?=E=FL9F<M<?=L@9N=J=>MK=<LGHJGNA<=#9JLOAL@<G;ME=FLKL@9L9J=
J=D=N9FLLGL@AKD9OKMAL O@A;@@=@9KJ=IM=KL=<HMJKM9FLLGL@=!J==<GEG>$F>GJE9LAGF;L
9F<L@AKGMJLK@GMD<GJ<=JL@=J=D=9K=G>L@GK=<G;ME=FLK
/@AJ< =>=F<9FLK!9;=:GGC $F; 9F</OALL=J $F; NAGD9L=<#9JLZKJA?@LLG!J==
.H==;@ MF<=J L@= 9DA>GJFA9 GFKLALMLAGF O@=F L@=Q <=HJAN=< @AE G> 9F =KK=FLA9D 9F<
AFN9DM9:D=>GJME>GJKH=9CAF?@AKEAF<
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 3 of 24
!GMJL@ =>=F<9FLK!9;=:GGC $F; 9F</OALL=J $F; 9J=DA9:D=>GJHJGEAKKGJQ
=KLGHH=D>GJHJGEAKAF?#9JLL@=MK=G>L@=AJKG;A9DE=<A9HD9L>GJEKLG>MJL@=J@AK:MKAF=KK
AFL=J=KLK9F<L@=FJ=K;AF<AF?L@AKHJGEAK=9>L=J@=J=DA=<GFL@=ELG@AK<=LJAE=FL
!A>L@ =>=F<9FL!9;=:GGC $F; AKDA9:D=LG#9JL>GJAFL=FLAGF9DAFL=J>=J=F;=
OAL@ 9 ;GFLJ9;L >GJ CFGOAF?DQ <=FQAF? @AE L@= 9:ADALQ LG >MD>ADD @AK ;GFLJ9;LM9D <MLQ LG
9<EAFAKL=JL@=!9;=:GGC9;;GMFLG>GFGJ:MJ=9M ''
.APL@ =>=F<9FL !9;=:GGC $F; AK DA9:D= LG #9JL >GJ F=?DA?=FL AFL=J>=J=F;=
OAL@ 9 HJGKH=;LAN= =;GFGEA; 9<N9FL9?= >GJ CFGOAF?DQ <AKJMHLAF? L@= ;GFLJ9;LM9D
J=D9LAGFK@AH:=LO==FGFGJ:MJ=9M ''9F<@AE:QHJ=N=FLAF?@AE>JGE9<EAFAKL=JAF?L@=
!9;=:GGC9;;GMFLG>GFGJ:MJ=9M
!GJL@=K=J=9KGFK #9JL:JAF?KL@AKD9OKMAL9F<K==CK<=;D9J9LGJQ AFBMF;LAN=
9F<EGF=L9JQJ=DA=>>GJL@=AFBMKLA;=K@=@9KKM>>=J=<9LL@=@9F<KG>=>=F<9FLK
+D9AFLA>> %MKLAF #9JL AK 9 F9LMJ9D H=JKGF <GEA;AD=< AF .9F A=?G GMFLQ
9DA>GJFA9
=>=F<9FL !9;=:GGC $F; W!9;=:GGCX AK 9 ;GJHGJ9LAGF AF;GJHGJ9L=< AF
=D9O9J=OAL@9HJAF;AH9DHD9;=G>:MKAF=KK9L 2ADDGO-G9< (=FDG+9JC 9DA>GJFA9
AF.9F(9L=GGMFLQ
=>=F<9FL/OALL=J $F; W/OALL=JXAK9;GJHGJ9LAGFAF;GJHGJ9L=<AF=D9O9J=
OAL@ 9 HJAF;AH9D HD9;= G> :MKAF=KK 9L (9JC=L .LJ==L .MAL=
.9F !J9F;AK;G
9DA>GJFA9AFL@=ALQ9F<GMFLQG>.9F!J9F;AK;G
=>=F<9FL1AN=C(MJL@QAKKM=<AF@AKG>>A;A9D;9H9;ALQ9KL@=.MJ?=GF"=F=J9D
G>L@=0FAL=<.L9L=K $FL@9LJGD= @=<AJ=;LKL@=G>>A;=G>L@=.MJ?=GF"=F=J9D
=>=F<9FL%GK=H@- A<=F %J AKKM=<AF@AKG>>A;A9D;9H9;ALQ9KL@=+J=KA<=FL
G>L@=0FAL=<.L9L=K $FL@9LJGD= @=<AJ=;LKL@==P=;MLAN=:J9F;@G>L@=>=<=J9D?GN=JFE=FL
AF;DM<AF?2@AL=#GMK=KL9>>
=>=F<9FL L@= =H9JLE=FL G> #=9DL@ 9F< #ME9F .=JNA;=K W##.X AK 9F
9?=F;Q
OAL@AF L@= =P=;MLAN= :J9F;@ G> L@= >=<=J9D ?GN=JFE=FL O@A;@ E9AFL9AFK 9?=F;Q
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 4 of 24
J=;GJ<K >GJ L@= .MJ?=GF "=F=J9D G> L@= 0FAL=< .L9L=K @AK G>>A;= 9F< GL@=JK OAL@AF L@=
<=H9JLE=FL
=>=F<9FL L@= *>>A;= G> (9F9?=E=FL 9F< M<?=L W*(X AK 9F 9?=F;Q
OAL@AF L@= P=;MLAN= *>>A;= G> L@= +J=KA<=FL O@A;@ E9AFL9AFK 9?=F;Q J=;GJ<K >GJ L@=
+J=KA<=FLG>L@=0FAL=<.L9L=K @AKKL9>> 9F<GL@=JKOAL@AFL@==P=;MLAN=:J9F;@
/@AK;9K=J9AK=K>=<=J9D;D9AEKMF<=JL@=!AJKLE=F<E=FLG>L@=0FAL=<.L9L=K
GFKLALMLAGF9F<L@=!J==<GEG>$F>GJE9LAGF;L 0 . SL@=J=>GJ= L@=GMJL@9K
KM:B=;L E9LL=JBMJAK<A;LAGFGN=JL@AK9;LAGFHMJKM9FLLG0 . S
/@AKGMJL@9KBMJAK<A;LAGFLGAKKM=AFBMF;LAN=J=DA=>LGHJGL=;L;GFKLALMLAGF9D
JA?@LK 4)) 16)4 71( 8 7& 2 ''2716-1+ 8)45-+,6 ( 0 . F
/@=GMJL@9KBMJAK<A;LAGFLGAKKM=<=;D9J9LGJQJ=DA=>HMJKM9FLLG0 . S
9F< LG GJ<=J >MJL@=J F=;=KK9JQ GJ HJGH=J J=DA=> :9K=< GF 9 <=;D9J9LGJQ BM<?E=FL GJ
<=;J==HMJKM9FLLG0 . S
/@= GMJL @9K BMJAK<A;LAGF LG GJ<=J L@= HJG<M;LAGF G> 9?=F;Q J=;GJ<K
AEHJGH=JDQOAL@@=D<HMJKM9FLLG0 . S9
/@=GMJL@9KKMHHD=E=FL9DBMJAK<A;LAGFGN=JL@=9DA>GJFA9KL9L=D9O;D9AEK
HMJKM9FLLG0 . S
/@=GMJL@9KH=JKGF9DBMJAK<A;LAGFGN=J=>=F<9FLK(MJL@Q A<=F ##. 9F<
*(:=;9MK=L@=Q9J=G>>A;=JKGJ9?=F;A=KG>L@=0FAL=<.L9L=K
/@= GMJL @9K H=JKGF9D BMJAK<A;LAGF GN=J =>=F<9FLK !9;=:GGC 9F< /OALL=J
:=;9MK=L@=QE9AFL9AFL@=AJHJAF;AH9DHD9;=KG>:MKAF=KKAF9DA>GJFA9
1=FM=EMKLDA=AFL@AK<AKLJA;LMF<=J0 . S9OAL@J=?9J<KLG
L@=;D9AEMF<=JL@=!J==<GEG>$F>GJE9LAGF;L:=;9MK=#9JLJ=KA<=KAF.9FA=?GGMFLQ
9DA>GJFA9 1=FM= DA=K AF L@AK <AKLJA;L MF<=J 0 . S = 9F< : :=;9MK=
=>=F<9FLK(MJL@Q A<=F ##. 9F<*(9J=G>>A;=JKGJ9?=F;A=KG>L@=0FAL=<.L9L=K9
KM:KL9FLA9DH9JLG>L@==N=FLK?ANAF?JAKAF?LGL@=;D9AEKG;;MJJ=<@=J=
O@=J=#9JL9;;=KK=K
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 5 of 24
@AK!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=J9;;GMFLK#9JLJ=KA<=K@=J=9F<FGJ=9DHJGH=JLQAKAFNGDN=<AF
L@=9;LAGF
*F GJ 9JGMF< %MDQ #9JL HGKL=< LG @AK H=JKGF9D !9;=:GGC H9?= 9
?J9H@A;=FLALD=< W(9KCAF?@AD<J=FAK$EHJ9;LA;9D9F<)GL9;C=<:Q-=K=9J;@GJ-=9D
2GJD<9L9 X
=DGOAK9H@GLGG>L@=?J9H@A;AFL@=HGKL
/@=?J9H@A;#9JLHGKL=<AKK;A=F;= :9K=<9F<;GFL9AFK>GGLFGL=KLGK;A=FLA>A;
=NA<=F;=KMHHGJLAF?ALK;D9AEK
!9;=:GGC >D9??=< L@= 9:GN= HGKL GF GJ 9JGMF< %MDQ OAL@ L@=
>GDDGOAF?FGLA;=
*0)5/+*./*-*(( )/!*-3.
/@AKAK:=;9MK=QGMHJ=NAGMKDQHGKL=<KGE=L@AF?L@9L<A<FZL>GDDGOGMJ
GEEMFALQ.L9F<9J<K
/@AKHGKL?G=K9?9AFKLGMJKL9F<9J<KGFEAKAF>GJE9LAGFL@9L;GMD<;9MK=
H@QKA;9D@9JE KGGFDQQGM;9FK==AL
-)(*- *0/0+/ ./**0-./)-.
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 6 of 24
*FGJ9JGMF<%MDQ #9JLHGKL=<LG@AKH=JKGF9D/OALL=JH9?=9LO==L
L@9LJ=9<
.GL@=BMKLJ=HGJL=<L@9L G>L@GK=O@G;9E=<GOFOAL@*N$<
KQEHLGEK@9<:==FO=9JAF?9E9KC 2=CFGOL@9LE9KCK<GFZLHJGL=;LQGMT
:ML9LKGE=HGAFLQGM@9N=LGOGF<=JA>L@=Q9J=+-/G>L@=HJG:D=E
/OALL=JDG;C=<#9JLZK9;;GMFLGFGJ9JGMF<%MDQ OAL@L@=>GDDGOAF?
FGLA;=K=FLLG@AK=E9AD
$0./$) -/
*0- *0)/ %0./$)#-/ #. ) '*& !*- 1$*'/$)" /# 2$// -
0' .
.H=;A>A;9DDQ>GJ1AGD9LAF?L@=HGDA;QGFKHJ=9<AF?EAKD=9<AF?9F<HGL=FLA9DDQ
@9JE>MDAF>GJE9LAGFJ=D9L=<LG*1$
2AL@AF <9QK G> L@=K= LOG J=EGN9DK L@= 9<EAFAKLJ9LAGF G> =>=F<9FL A<=F
J=N=9D=<HM:DA;DQL@9LALAK<AJ=;LAF?KG;A9DE=<A9;GEH9FA=KLGJ=EGN=HGKLKAL<==EKLG:=
KHJ=9<AF?EAKAF>GJE9LAGFJ=?9J<AF?*1$
*F %MDQ 9L 9 2@AL= #GMK= +J=KK GF>=J=F;= =>=F<9FL (MJL@Q
KL9L=< W2=ZJ= 9KCAF? 6GMJ L=;@FGDG?Q ;GEH9FA=K7 LG ;GFKAKL=FLDQ L9C= 9;LAGF 9?9AFKL
EAKAF>GJE9LAGFKMH=J KHJ=9<=JKGFL@=AJHD9L>GJEK X
/@=2@AL=#GMK=J=N=9D=<L@9L9L=9EG>?GN=JFE=FL=EHDGQ==K9J=9;LAN=DQ
J=K=9J;@AF?9F<LJ9;CAF?KG;A9DE=<A9HGKLKOAL@O@A;@AL<AK9?J==K9F<J=D9QAF?L@GK=HGKLK
LGKG;A9DE=<A9;GEH9FA=KOAL@AFKLJM;LAGFKLGL9C=L@=E<GOF
1AN=C # (MJL@Q 2@AL= #GMK= +J=KK JA=>AF? %MDQ LJ9FK;JAHL 9N9AD9:D= 9L
@LLHK OOO O@AL=@GMK= ?GN :JA=>AF? JGGE HJ=KK :JA=>AF?K HJ=KK :JA=>AF? :Q
HJ=KK K=;J=L9JQ B=F HK9CA 9F< KMJ?=GF ?=F=J9D <J NAN=C @ EMJL@Q BMDQ
D9KL
NAKAL=<M?
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 7 of 24
2@AL= #GMK= +J=KK .=;J=L9JQ %=F +K9CA 9<EALL=< W2=ZN= AF;J=9K=<
<AKAF>GJE9LAGFJ=K=9J;@9F<LJ9;CAF?OAL@AFL@=.MJ?=GF"=F=J9DZKG>>A;= 2=ZJ=>D9??AF?
HJG:D=E9LA;HGKLK>GJ!9;=:GGCL@9LKHJ=9<<AKAF>GJE9LAGF X
+K9CA9DKGJ=N=9D=<L@9LL@=2@AL=#GMK==>>GJLLGKMHHJ=KK>J==KH==;@J=9;@=K
9DDL@=O9QLGL@=D=N=DG>K=FAGJKL9>>>GJ=>=F<9FLA<=F
+K9CA?9N=9?DAEHK=G>@GOL@=K;@=E=OGJCKWO=9J=AFJ=?MD9JLGM;@OAL@
L@=K=KG;A9DE=<A9HD9L>GJEK 9F<L@GK==F?9?=E=FLKLQHA;9DDQ@9HH=FL@JGM?@E=E:=JKG>
GMJK=FAGJKL9>> :ML9DKGE=E:=JKG>GMJ*1$ L=9E X
/@=F=PL<9QK@=J=N=9D=<L@9LL@=>9J J=9;@AF?=>>GJLL9J?=L=<EMDLAHD=HGKLK
GF EMDLAHD= KG;A9D E=<A9 KAL=K W4GM K@GMD<FZL := :9FF=< >JGE GF= HD9L>GJE 9F< FGL
GL@=JK X
=>=F<9FLK A<=F 9F< (MJL@Q <AJ=;L=< >GMJ C=Q ;@9F?=K >GJ KG;A9D E=<A9
HD9L>GJEK /@= >AJKL AK L@9L L@= ;GEH9FA=K WE=9KMJ= 9F< HM:DA;DQ K@9J= L@= AEH9;L G>
EAKAF>GJE9LAGFGFL@=AJHD9L>GJE X
.=;GF< A<=F9F<(MJL@Q<AJ=;L=<;GEH9FA=KLGW;J=9L=9JG:MKL=F>GJ;=E=FL
KLJ9L=?QL@9L:JA<?=KL@=AJHJGH=JLA=K9F<HJGNA<=KLJ9FKH9J=F;Q9:GMLL@=JMD=K X
/@AJ< A<=F 9F< (MJL@Q KLJ=KK=< L@9L WALZK AEHGJL9FL LG L9C= >9KL=J 9;LAGF
9?9AFKL @9JE>MD HGKLKX :=;9MK= WAF>GJE9LAGF LJ9N=DK IMAL= IMA;CDQ GF KG;A9D E=<A9
%=F +K9CA 2@AL= #GMK= +J=KK JA=>AF? %MDQ LJ9FK;JAHL 9N9AD9:D= 9L
@LLHK OOO O@AL=@GMK= ?GN :JA=>AF? JGGE HJ=KK :JA=>AF?K HJ=KK :JA=>AF? :Q
HJ=KK K=;J=L9JQ B=F HK9CA 9F< KMJ?=GF ?=F=J9D <J NAN=C @ EMJL@Q BMDQ
D9KL
NAKAL=<M?
(
%=F +K9CA 2@AL= #GMK= +J=KK JA=>AF? %MDQ LJ9FK;JAHL 9N9AD9:D= 9L
@LLHK OOO O@AL=@GMK= ?GN :JA=>AF? JGGE HJ=KK :JA=>AF?K HJ=KK :JA=>AF? :Q
HJ=KK K=;J=L9JQ B=F HK9CA BMDQ D9KLNAKAL=<M?
+K9CA 5734%FGL=
(
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 8 of 24
HD9L>GJEK KGE=LAE=K ALZK FGL 9;;MJ9L= F< !9;=:GGC F==<K LG EGN= EGJ= IMA;CDQ LG
J=EGN=@9JE>MD NAGD9LAN=HGKLK6 7X
!GMJL@ A<=F9F<(MJL@Q<AJ=;L=<!9;=:GGCLGWHJGEGL=IM9DALQAF>GJE9LAGF
AFL@=AJ>==<9D?GJAL@E X
L L@= <AJ=;LAGF G> A<=F (MJL@Q ;J=9L=< 9F< HM:DAK@=< 9F =FLAJ= H9?=
<NAKGJQOAL@AFKLJM;LAGFKGF@GOKG;A9DE=<A9;GEH9FA=KK@GMD<J=EGN=HGKLKOAL@O@A;@
(MJL@Q9F<A<=F<AK9?J==
A<=F>MJL@=JL@J=9L=F=<KG;A9DE=<A9;GEH9FA=KO@G<GFGL;GEHDQOAL@@AK
<AJ=;LAN=K:QHM:DA;DQK@9EAF?9F<@MEADA9LAF?L@=E KL9LAF? W/@=QZJ=CADDAF?H=GHD= X
*FAF>GJE9LAGF9F<:=DA=> =>=F<9FLKA<=F9F<(MJL@Q<AJ=;L=<=>=F<9FLK
!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=JLGJ=EGN=#9JLZKKG;A9DE=<A9HGKLK:=;9MK=L@=Q<AK9?J==<OAL@L@=
NA=OHGAFLK@==KHGMK=<AFL@=E9F<;GFKHAJ=<OAL@!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=JLG<GKG
=>=F<9FL!9;=:GGCAKGF=G>L@=EGKLHGHMD9JKG;A9DE=<A9KAL=K $L:G9KLK
WEGJ= L@9F :ADDAGF EGFL@DQ MK=JK OGJD<OA<= X O@G MK= AL >GJ :GL@ :MKAF=KK 9F<
HD=9KMJ= DEGKL G> E=JA;9FK MK= !9;=:GGC AF KGE= ;9H9;ALQ *> L@=K= MK=JK
(
(
1AN=C # (MJL@Q 21*4216-1+ )%/6, -5-1*240%6-21 ,) ! 74+)21 )1)4%/=5
(8-524: 21 7-/(-1+ % )%/6,: 1*240%6-21 18-2410)16 9N9AD9:D= 9L
@LLHK OOO @@K ?GN KAL=K <=>9MDL >AD=K KMJ?=GF ?=F=J9D EAKAF>GJE9LAGF 9<NAKGJQ H<> D9KL
NAKAL=<M?
'9MJ=F ?9F ; ,):=4).-//-1+3)23/)< -()1&/%0)5%')&22.26,)452'-%/0)(-%*24
%//29-1+ 28-( 0-5-1*240%6-21 ) )=OK %MDQ +( 9N9AD9:D= 9L
@LLHK OOO F:;F=OK ;GE HGDALA;K O@AL= @GMK= L@=Q J= CADDAF? H=GHD= :A<=F :D9E=K
>9;=:GGC GL@=J KG;A9D E=<A9 FD9KLNAKAL=<M?
%G@F"J9EDA;@ *%'65%&2760)4-'%15%1(%')&22. +=O-=K=9J;@=FL=J%MF=
9N9AD9:D= 9L @LLHK OOO H=OJ=K=9J;@ GJ? >9;L L9FC >9;LK 9:GML
9E=JA;9FK 9F< >9;=:GGC D9KLNAKAL=<M?
(
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 9 of 24
NAKAL!9;=:GGC<9ADQ
!9;=:GGCZKK=JNA;=KAFNGDN=;J=9LAF?9KGJLG>H=JKGF9DO=:KAL=>GJALKMK=JK
O@G;9FHGKLHA;LMJ=KG>L@=EK=DN=K9F<GL@=JK ;J=9L=HGKLKGFL@=AJO9DDO@=J=L@=Q;9F
W<=:9L= J=DA?AGF 9F< HGDALA;K OAL@ L@=AJ >JA=F<K 9F< F=A?@:GJKGJ K@9J= N9;9LAGF H@GLGK X
%'.-1+,%08246,%42/-1% . L /@=K=HGKLK;9F9DKGAF;DM<=
DAFCKLGF=OK9JLA;D=K9F<NA<=GK *L@=JMK=JK;9FHGKL;GEE=FLKGF9MK=JZKHGKLK9F<
L@=J=:Q @9N=9<A9DG?M=OAL@GF=GL@=J 0K=JKE9Q9DKGK=F<=9;@GL@=J<AJ=;LE=KK9?=K
L@JGM?@!9;=:GGCZK(=KK=F?=J>=9LMJ=
"AN=F L@AK LJ=E=F<GMK GHHGJLMFALQ LG F=LOGJC 9F< KH=9C OAL@ GL@=J H=GHD=
L@JGM?@GMLL@=0FAL=<.L9L=K9F<=N=FL@=OGJD< MK=JK>J=IM=FLDQMK=ALLGHJGEGL=L@=AJ
:MKAF=KK W/@=J=9J=GN=J EADDAGF9;LAN=:MKAF=KK6H79?=KXGF!9;=:GGC (ADDAGFKG>
:MKAF=KK=KH9QLG:=9;LAN=9<N=JLAK=JK
!9;=:GGCZK @GKLAF? G> 9<N=JLAK=E=FLK AK N=JQ DM;J9LAN= >GJ AL $F AL
?=F=J9L=<9LGL9DG> :ADDAGFAFJ=N=FM= 9F<G>L@9L;9E=>JGE9<KGF!9;=:GGC
9F<GL@=JHD9L>GJEKL@9LALGOFK KM;@9K$FKL9?J9E
!9;=:GGCZKL=JEKG>K=JNA;=AFNAL=K:MKAF=KK=KLGMK=ALKK=JNA;=KLGW;GFF=;L
OAL@ 6GL@=J H=GHD=7 :MAD< ;GEEMFALA=K 9F< ?JGO :MKAF=KK=K X !9;=:GGC <=K;JA:=K ALK
(
&AL .EAL@ 1'4)(-&/) %')&22. 6%6-56-'5 %1( %'65 J9F<O9L;@ %MF=
9N9AD9:D= 9L @LLHK OOO :J9F<O9L;@ ;GE :DG? >9;=:GGC KL9LAKLA;K D9KL NAKAL=< M?
(
JAFD9;C 29%')&22.0%.)5021):&:6%4+)6-1+%(5(-4)'6/:62:27 )HJ
9N9AD9:D= 9L @LLHK OOO ;F:; ;GE @GO >9;=:GGC AFKL9?J9E
O@9LK9HH 9F< E=KK=F?=J E9C=
EGF=Q @LED88KGMJ;=>9;=:GGCE9AF>:;DA<$O- K+'B4/0*>4)N,,5O
*A(4E%KF(, 'M0)4I3C939!0+HF#MGD9KLNAKAL=<M?
/=JEK G> .=JNA;= !9;=:GGC 9N9AD9:D= 9L @LLHK OOO >9;=:GGC ;GE L=JEK H@H D9KL
J=NAK=<*;L D9KLNAKAL=<%MDQ
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 10 of 24
K=JNA;=K9KW6=7EHGO=J6AF?7QGMLG=PHJ=KKQGMJK=D>9F<;GEEMFA;9L=9:GMLO@9LE9LL=JK
LGQGM X
/@= L=JEK G> K=JNA;= J=IMAJ= MK=JK LG >GDDGO ALK WGEEMFALQ .L9F<9J<K X
/@GK=KL9F<9J<KKL9L=L@9L!9;=:GGCAKW9K=JNA;=>GJEGJ=L@9FLOG:ADDAGFH=GHD=LG>J==DQ
=PHJ=KKL@=EK=DN=K9;JGKK;GMFLJA=K9F<;MDLMJ=K9F<AF<GR=FKG>D9F?M9?=K X/@=Q?GGF
LGKL9L= W/G=FKMJ=L@9L=N=JQGF=ZKNGA;=AKN9DM=< O=L9C=?J=9L;9J=LG;J9>LHGDA;A=KL@9L
9J=AF;DMKAN=G><A>>=J=FLNA=OK9F<:=DA=>K AFH9JLA;MD9JL@GK=G>H=GHD=9F<;GEEMFALA=K
L@9LEA?@LGL@=JOAK=:=GN=JDGGC=<GJE9J?AF9DAR=< X
/@=DAEALKGFL@AKHJG >J==KH==;@KL9F;=AF;DM<=9:KLJ9;L;9L=?GJA=KKM;@9K
W1AGD=F;= 9F< JAEAF9D =@9NAGJ X W.9>=LQX O@A;@ AF;DM<=K W.MA;A<= 9F< .=D> $FBMJQ X
W@AD< .=PM9D
PHDGAL9LAGF :MK= 9F< )M<ALQ X W.=PM9D PHDGAL9LAGF G> <MDLK X
WMDDQAF? 9F< #9J9KKE=FL X W#ME9F PHDGAL9LAGF X 9F< W+JAN9;Q 1AGD9LAGFK 9F< $E9?=
+JAN9;Q -A?@LK W*:B=;LAGF9:D= GFL=FLX O@A;@ AF;DM<=K W#9L= .H==;@ X W1AGD=FL 9F<
"J9H@A; GFL=FL X W<MDL )M<ALQ 9F< .=PM9D ;LANALQ X 9F< W.=PM9D .GDA;AL9LAGFX
W$FL=?JALQ9F<ML@=FLA;ALQ XO@A;@AF;DM<=KW;;GMFL$FL=?JALQ9F<ML@=FLA;$<=FLALQ X
W.H9E X WQ:=JK=;MJALQ X W$F9ML@=FLA; =@9NAGJ X W!9DK= )=OK X W(9FAHMD9L=< (=<A9 X
9F<W(=EGJA9DAR9LAGFX 9F<W-=KH=;LAF?$FL=DD=;LM9D+JGH=JLQ X!GJL@=W!9DK=)=OKXKM:
;9L=?GJQ !9;=:GGC KL9L=K L@9L WO= <G FGL J=EGN= >9DK= F=OK >JGE !9;=:GGC :ML O=
KA?FA>A;9FLDQJ=<M;=ALK<AKLJA:MLAGF:QK@GOAF?ALDGO=JAF)=OK!==< X
LFGHGAFLAFL@=L=JEKG>K=JNA;=GJGEEMFALQ.L9F<9J<K<G=K!9;=:GGC
HJG@A:ALNA=OHGAFLKL@9LGHHGK=E9CAF?;@AD<J=FO=9JE9KCK
(
(
GEEMFALQ
.L9F<9J<K
!9;=:GGC
9N9AD9:D=
@LLHK OOO >9;=:GGC ;GE ;GEEMFALQKL9F<9J<K D9KLNAKAL=<%MDQ
(
(
9L
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 11 of 24
+D9AFLA>> %MKLAF#9JL AK9F=P=;MLAN=;GFKMDL9FLOAL@GN=JQ=9JKZ=PH=JA=F;=
;J=9LAF?<9L9 <JAN=FKGDMLAGFK>GJ!GJLMF=
;GEH9FA=K9F<HJ=KA<=FLA9D;9EH9A?FK9DAC=
#=AKL@=@A=>9L9F9DQKL9F<>GMF<=JG>-9LAGF9D"JGMF< ;GE O@A;@@=DHK;GEH9FA=K
HM:DA;HGDA;QG>>A;A9DK 9F<H9J=FLK?9M?=L@=AEH9;LG>*1$ 9;JGKKL@=;GMFLJQ
#=@9KMK=<!9;=:GGCZKK=JNA;=KKAF;=
MK=JKO@G>GDDGO@AK9;;GMFL 9F<JGM?@DQ
#=@9KJGM?@DQ
!9;=:GGC
!9;=:GGC>JA=F<K
#=MK=K@AK!9;=:GGC9;;GMFL9K9>==<=J>GJ@AKGL@=JKG;A9DE=<A99;;GMFLK
9K9F=LOGJCAF?LGGD>GJ@AK;GFKMDLAF?:MKAF=KK 9F<9K9HJGEGLAGF>GJ@AKGFDAF=O=:KAL=
-9LAGF9D"JGMF< ;GE O@=J=@=K=DDKKM:K;JAHLAGFKLG@AK9JLA;D=K9F<J=K=9J;@GF*1$
9F<L@=?GN=JFE=FLZKJ=KHGFK=LGAL
"AN=F#9JLZKMK=G>!9;=:GGC>GJ@AK:MKAF=KK @=@9K:GM?@L9<KGF!9;=:GGC
L@9LHJGEGL=@AK;GFKMDLAF?:MKAF=KK *N=JL@=Q=9JK #9JL@9KKH=FLL@GMK9F<KG><GDD9JKGF
!9;=:GGC9<N=JLAK=E=FLK
#9JL @9K 9DKG :GM?@L 9<K >GJ @AK ;GFKMDLAF? ;DA=FLK GN=J L@= Q=9JK KH=F<AF?
L=FKG>L@GMK9F<KG><GDD9JK
*F @AK O=:KAL= -9LAGF9D"JGMF< ;GE #9JL G>>=JK KGE= G> @AK 9JLA;D=K
=P;DMKAN=DQLGKM:K;JA:=JK #AKKM:K;JAHLAGFK?=F=J9L=L@GMK9F<KG><GDD9JKH=JEGFL@
*FGJ9JGMF<.=HL=E:=J !9;=:GGCAKKM=<#9JL9O9JFAF?J=?9J<AF?
9HGKL@=@9<E9<=AF%MDQ O@A;@@9<;GFL9AF=<9NA<=GG>HJGL=KLGJK9LL=EHLAF?LG
L=9J<GOF9KL9LML=G>@JAKLGH@=JGDME:MKAF@A;9?G #9JLZK;GEE=FLGFL@=HGKLJ=9<
W'( .%2 J9DDQ AF @A;9?G LG L=9J <GOF L@= KL9LM= G> @JAKLGH@=J GDME:MK GHK
<=>=F<AF?L@=HD9;=9K@MF<J=<KG>YH=9;=>MDZHJGL=KLGJKL@JGO:GLLD=K ;9FK ;9F=K JG;CK
MLL@=:=KLL@AF?9:GMLL@AKNA<=GAKL@=!ZK)*/?AN=F:QL@=K=G>>A;=JK "GLL9DGN=
@A;9?G X$F=PHDA;9:DQ L@=O9JFAF?;D9AE=< W!9DK=AF>GJE9LAGF9:GML*1$ >GMF<
AFQGMJHGKL FGLA;=O9K9<<=<LGQGMJHGKL X
*FGJ9JGMF<.=HL=E:=J !9;=:GGC;D9AE=<L@9L9J=;=FLHGKL:Q#9JL
NAGD9L=<ALKGEEMFALQ.L9F<9J<K9F<:9FF=<@AE>JGE9<N=JLAKAF?>GJ <9QK9F<>JGE
?GAF?WDAN=X>GJ
<9QK "GAF?WDAN=XGF!9;=:GGC9DDGOK9MK=JLG@9N=9NA<=G;9DDOAL@
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 12 of 24
>GDDGO=JKAFJ=9D LAE= /@=HGKLKL9L=< WY.HGLA>QK==EKDAC=9?J=9LHD9;=LGOGJCZU%GK=H@
"G=::=DK X
*FHJAD !9;=:GGCJ=KLJA;L=<L@=9:ADALQG>#9JLLGHGKLGJ;GEE=FL
>GJ@GMJK:=;9MK=AL;D9AE=<L@=>GDDGOAF?L@J==HGKLKNAGD9L=<ALKGEEMFALQ.L9F<9J<K
9
*FGJ9JGMF<HJAD #9JL;J=9L=<9HGKLGF!9;=:GGC
KL9LAF? W$>QGM=N=JO9FLLGCFGOO@=J=QGMJ'(<GF9LAGFAK?GAF?UL@=
;G >GMF<=JYLJ9AF=<(9JPAKLZ+9LJAK==MDD9JKUBMKL:GM?@LL@AK9E9RAF?@GE=
AF'X9F<ALAF;DM<=<9DAFCLG9HA;LMJ=G>L@=@GMK=
:
/@9LK9E=<9Q 9K=;GF<HGKLG>@AKO9KJ=EGN=<>JGE!9;=:GGC
;
*F HJAD @= ;J=9L=< 9 HGKL KL9LAF? L@9L W/@AK AK L@=
LJML@GNA<AK9DEGKL?GF=AFE=JA;9 #GKHAL9DK9J=DAL=J9DDQ=EHLQ N=JQ
OADDAF?K=FAGJ@9K9DJ=9<Q:==FN9;;AF9L=< $F9>=OO==CK=N=JQOADDAF?9<MDL
;9F:=T
'GKAF?L@=9:ADALQLG;GFF=;LOAL@H=GHD=L@JGM?@@AK!9;=:GGC9;;GMFL@9K
@9JE=<#9JLZKGFDAF=:MKAF=KK9F<OGJCLG@=DHGL@=JK #=AK9DKGKM>>=JAF?AFBMJQ:=;9MK=
@=K=JN=K9KL@=9<EAFAKLJ9LGJG>9LD=9KLGF=G>@AK;DA=FLZK!9;=:GGCH9?=K 2@AD=#9JLZK
H=JKGF9D9;;GMFLAKKMKH=F<=< @=;9FFGLK=JNA;=L@AK9;;GMFL
!9;=:GGCZKKL9F<9J<K>GJ;=FKGJK@AH9J=;GFKL9FLDQK@A>LAF?
!GJ=P9EHD= KAF;==9JDQ L@=J=@9K:==FOA<=KHJ=9<<=:9L=GN=JO@=L@=J
*1$ O9KE9<=:Q@ME9FKAF9D9:AF2M@9F @AF99F<=K;9H=<>JGEL@=D9:GJ
O@=L@=JALKL9JL=<F9LMJ9DDQL@JGM?@9FAE9DLG@ME9FLJ9FKEAKKAGF =KHAL=L@AK<=:9L= AF
!=:JM9JQ !9;=:GGC9FFGMF;=<ALOGMD<J=EGN=HGKLKL@9LKM??=KL=<L@=NAJMKO9K
E9F E9<= KL9LAF?L@9LL@=L@=GJQ@9<:==F<=:MFC=<:QHM:DA;@=9DL@G>>A;A9DK MLAF
(9Q 9>L=JA<=F9;CFGOD=<?=<L@=HGKKA:ADALQG>L@=L@=GJQ !9;=:GGCJ=N=JK=<ALK
+=L=J.M;AM 2'-%/)(-%&276%') %')&22.#21=6)028)/%-0528-(#%5%1
%()
!GJ:=K
(9Q
+(
9N9AD9:D=
9L
@LLHK OOO >GJ:=K ;GE KAL=K H=L=JKM;AM KG;A9D E=<A9 9:GML >9;= >9;=:GGC
J=EGN= ;D9AEK ;GNA< O9K E9F E9<= K@<= ;999 D9KL NAKAL=< M?
OGFL
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 13 of 24
HGDA;Q9F<9FFGMF;=<L@9LALOGMD<FGDGF?=JJ=EGN=HGKLK=PHJ=KKAF?L@9LNA=OHGAFL
/@=J=>GJ= !9;=:GGCAKKLA>DAF?L@=>J==<=:9L=G>K;A=FLA>A;L@=GJA=K:QL9CAF?ALK<AJ=;LAGFK
>JGEL@=>=<=J9D?GN=JFE=FL
=>=F<9FL/OALL=JAK9DKG9HGHMD9JKG;A9DE=<A9KAL=EGJ=L@9FGF=AF>AN=
9<MDLE=JA;9FKMK=L@=HD9L>GJE *>L@=K=MK=JK NAKAL/OALL=J<9ADQ
/OALL=JZKK=JNA;=KAFNGDN=;J=9LAF?9H=JKGF9DHJG>AD=>JGEO@A;@ALKMK=JK;9F
WLO==LXVE=9FAF?HGKLE=KK9?=K H@GLGK 9F<O=:DAFCKLGL@=AJ>==<>GJGL@=JMK=JKLGK==
0K=JK;9FWDAC= XJ=HGKL GJJ=HDQLGGL@=JMK=JKZLO==LK
/OALL=J9DDGOKMK=JKLG@9N=9<A9DG?M=GF9N9JA=LQG>AKKM=K AF;DM<AF?LGHA;K
G> F9LAGF9D AEHGJL9F;= G> 0 . 9<MDLK GF /OALL=J K9Q L@=Q MK= L@= KAL= LG <AK;MKK
HGDALA;K /OALL=JAKCFGOF>GJ:=AF?WGF=G>L@=KG;A9DE=<A9KAL=KOAL@L@=EGKLF=OK
>G;MK=<MK=JK X G>9<MDL/OALL=JMK=JKAFL@=0 . MK=L@=KAL=LG?=LF=OK
W/@= /OALL=J -MD=KX HJG;D9AE L@9L W/OALL=JZK HMJHGK= AK LG K=JN= L@= HM:DA;
;GFN=JK9LAGF X
GFA=*Z.MDDAN9F%GJ<9F19DAFKCQ %')&22.9-//12/21+)44)028)'/%-056,%628-(
9%5 0%10%() )) MKAF=KK (9Q +( 9N9AD9:D= 9L
@LLHK OOO ;FF ;GE L=;@ >9;=:GGC ;GNA< GJA?AF ;D9AEK
J=EGN9D AF<=P @LEDD9KLNAKAL=<M?
JGGC=MPA=J(GFA;9F<=JKGF 2'-%/)(-%!5)-1 +=O-=K=9J;@=FL=J
HJAD 9N9AD9:D= 9L @LLHK OOO H=OJ=K=9J;@ GJ? AFL=JF=L KG;A9D
E=<A9 MK= AF D9KLNAKAL=<%MDQ
(
<9E#M?@=K.L=>9F2GB;AC *%'65%&2760)4-'%15%1( 9-66)4 +=O-=K=9J;@
=FL=JM? 9N9AD9:D=9L@LLHK OOO H=OJ=K=9J;@ GJ? >9;L L9FC
>9;LK 9:GML 9E=JA;9FK 9F< LOALL=J D9KLNAKAL=<%MDQ
(
(
/@= /OALL=J -MD=K /OALL=J 9N9AD9:D= 9L @LLHK @=DH LOALL=J ;GE =F JMD=K 9F<
HGDA;A=K LOALL=J JMD=KD9KLNAKAL=<M?
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 14 of 24
/@=DAEAL9LAGFKGFL@9LWHM:DA;;GFN=JK9LAGFXAF;DM<=/O==LKL@9LL@J=9L=FGJ
?DGJA>Q NAGD=F;= GJ L=JJGJAKE K=PM9DDQ =PHDGAL ;@AD<J=F 9:MK= GJ @9J9KK GL@=J H=GHD=
HJGEGL= K=D> @9JE GJ KMA;A<= K@GO =P;=KKAN=DQ ?GJQ E=<A9 GJ 9<MDL ;GFL=FL OAL@AF DAN=
NA<=GKGJHJG>AD=H@GLGK GJK=JN=9FQMFD9O>MDHMJHGK=
L FG HGAFL AF L@= L=JEK G> K=JNA;= GJ /OALL=J -MD=K <G=K /OALL=J HJG@A:AL
NA=OHGAFLKL@9LGHHGK=O=9JAF?E9KCK
#9JL@9KMK=</OALL=JZKK=JNA;=KKAF;=
#=MK=K@AK/OALL=J9;;GMFL9K9>==<=J>GJ@AKGL@=JKG;A9DE=<A99;;GMFLK 9K
9 F=LOGJCAF? LGGD >GJ @AK ;GFKMDLAF? :MKAF=KK 9F<9K 9HJGEGLAGF G>@AKGFDAF=O=:KAL=
-9LAGF9D"JGMF< ;GE O@=J=@=K=DDKKM:K;JAHLAGFKLG@AK9JLA;D=K9F<J=K=9J;@GF*1$
9F<L@=?GN=JFE=FLZKJ=KHGFK=LGAL
#9JL@9KHMJ;@9K=<9<KGF/OALL=JLGHJGEGL=@AK;GFKMDLAF?:MKAF=KK *N=J
L@=Q=9JK @=@9KKH=FLL@GMK9F<KG><GDD9JKGF/OALL=J9<K #9JLHD9FF=<LGAF;J=9K=@AKMK=
G>/OALL=J9<N=JLAKAF? :ML@=O9K<=FA=<>JGE<GAF?KG:Q/OALL=J
'GKAF?L@=9:ADALQLG;GEEMFA;9L=OAL@H=GHD=L@JGM?@@AK/OALL=J9;;GMFL@9K
@9JE=<@AKGFDAF=:MKAF=KK
4 - + #
0-/#3$ ) **&)2$// -1$*'/ /# - + #'0. *!/# $-./
( )( )/2# )/# 3/ %*$)/'3/*- (*1 -/5..*$'( $+*./.)'*&
#$(!-*(0.$)"#$.*0)/.
/@= 9DD=?9LAGFK AF L@= HJ=;=<AF? H9J9?J9H@K 9J= AF;GJHGJ9L=< @=J=AF :Q
J=>=J=F;=
W/@=!AJKLE=F<E=FLAK9CAF<G> IM9D+JGL=;LAGFD9MK=>GJA<=9K X%448
055=12*2/-6-'%/2157/6%165 . L HDMJ9DALQ ?GN=JFE=FL
NAGD9L=K L@AK HJGEAK= G> =IM9D LJ=9LE=FL >GJ A<=9K O@=F AL =F?9?=K AF NA=OHGAFL
<AK;JAEAF9LAGF 25)1&)4+)4 0 . 9L
(
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 15 of 24
(MJL@Q 9F< A<=F =F?9?=< AF NA=OHGAFL <AK;JAEAF9LAGF O@=F L@=Q <AJ=;L=<
!9;=:GGC 9F< /OALL=J LG J=EGN= KG;A9D E=<A9 HGKLK DAC= L@GK= G> #9JL L@9L ;GFL9AF=< 9
NA=OHGAFLGF*1$ L@9L<A<FGL>ALOAL@L@=AJGOFHGDALA;9DF9JJ9LAN=
+JAN9L= ;GEH9FA=K =F?9?= AF KL9L= 9;LAGF O@=F L@=Q OGJC OAL@ ?GN=JFE=FL
G>>A;A9DKLG<=HJAN=AF<ANA<M9DKG>L@=AJ;GFKLALMLAGF9DJA?@LK 7+%48(021(521-/2
0 .
W/@=.MHJ=E=GMJL@9K9JLA;MD9L=<>GMJL=KLK>GJ<=L=JEAFAF?O@=L@=J9FGF
?GN=JFE=FL9DH=JKGFZK9;LAGFK9EGMFLLGKL9L=9;LAGFL@=HM:DA;>MF;LAGFL=KLL@=
BGAFL9;LAGFL=KLL@=KL9L=;GEHMDKAGFL=KL9F<L@=?GN=JFE=FL9DF=PMKL=KL X,12
8$%570% ! < L@AJ ;D=9F=<MH
W%GAFL9;LAGF=PAKLKO@=J=L@=?GN=JFE=FL9>>AJEK 9ML@GJAR=K =F;GMJ9?=K GJ
>9;ADAL9L=KMF;GFKLALMLAGF9D;GF<M;LL@JGM?@ALKAFNGDN=E=FLOAL@9HJAN9L=H9JLQ X,128
$%570% ! < L@AJ ;D=9F=<MH
/@=)AFL@AJ;MAL>AF<KBGAFL9;LAGFO@=FWKL9L=G>>A;A9DK9F<HJAN9L=H9JLA=K
@9N=9;L=<AF;GF;=JLAF=>>=;LAF?9H9JLA;MD9J<=HJAN9LAGFG>;GFKLALMLAGF9DJA?@LK X 5%28
)5)46%/%')1' ! < L@AJ ;D=9F=<MH W/@AKJ=IMAJ=E=FL
;9F := K9LAK>A=< =AL@=J :Q HJGNAF? L@= =PAKL=F;= G> 9 ;GFKHAJ9;Q GJ :Q K@GOAF? L@9L L@=
HJAN9L= H9JLQ O9K 9 OADD>MD H9JLA;AH9FL AF BGAFL 9;LAGF OAL@ L@= .L9L= GJ ALK 9?=FLK X (
;D=9F=<MH W+9JLA;MD9JDQJ=D=N9FL@=J=AKL@=E9PAEL@9LA>L@=KL9L=CFGOAF?DQ9;;=HLK
L@=:=F=>ALK<=JAN=<>JGEMF;GFKLALMLAGF9D:=@9NAGJ L@=FL@=;GF<M;L;9F:=LJ=9L=<9KKL9L=
9;LAGF X( ;D=9F=<MH
!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=J=F?9?=<AFKL9L=9;LAGFO@=FL@=QJ=EGN=<HGKLKDAC=
#9JLZK9LL@=J=IM=KLG>(MJL@Q9F<A<=F:9K=<GFL@=NA=OHGAFLG>L@GK=HGKLK
!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=JOGJC=<AF;GF;=JL9F< GJ;GFKHAJ9;QOAL@(MJL@Q9F<
A<=FLG<=HJAN=#9JLG>@AK!AJKLE=F<E=FLJA?@LLG!J==.H==;@
(MJL@Q 9F< A<=F 9>>AJE=< 9ML@GJAR=< =F;GMJ9?=< 9F< GJ >9;ADAL9L=<
!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=JZKMF;GFKLALMLAGF9D;GF<M;LG>;=FKGJK@AH
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 16 of 24
!9;=:GGC 9F< /OALL=J O=J= =AL@=J OADD>MD H9JLA;AH9FLK O@=F L@=Q J=EGN=<
HGKLK:9K=<GFL@=AJNA=OHGAFL9LL@=<AJ=;LAGFG>(MJL@Q9F<A<=FGJL@=QO=J=KM:B=;LLG
?GN=JFE=FL;GEHMDKAGF =AL@=JG>O@A;@9EGMFLKLGKL9L=9;LAGF
(MJL@Q9F<A<=FCFGOAF?DQ9;;=HL=<L@=:=F=>ALKG>;=FKGJ=<KH==;@<=JAN=<
>JGEL@=MF;GFKLALMLAGF9D:=@9NAGJG>!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=JAFJ=EGNAF?HGKLK:9K=<GF9
NA=OHGAFLOAL@O@A;@(MJL@Q9F<A<=F<AK9?J==<
!9;=:GGC 9F< /OALL=J FGO J=IMAJ= L@9L #9JL 9F< GL@=J MK=JK =PHJ=KK 9
?GN=JFE=FL 9HHJGN=<NA=OHGAFLLGMK=L@=AJHD9L>GJEK
#9JLAK=FLALD=<LG<=;D9J9LGJQ9F<AFBMF;LAN=J=DA=>9?9AFKL(MJL@Q9F<A<=F
>GJNAGD9LAF?@AKJA?@LLG!J==.H==;@
#9JLAK=FLALD=<LG<=;D9J9LGJQ9F<AFBMF;LAN=J=DA=>9KO=DD9K;GEH=FK9LGJQ9F<
FGEAF9D<9E9?=K>JGE!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=J>GJNAGD9LAF?@AKJA?@LLG!J==.H==;@
4 - *(*!)!*-(/$*)/
)1$*'/ /# - *(*!)!*-(/$*)/2# )/# 3!$' /*- .+*)
/*'$)/$!!5.- *-.- ,0 ./2$/#$)/# .//0/*-3/$( !-(
/@= 9DD=?9LAGFK AF L@= HJ=;=<AF? H9J9?J9H@K 9J= AF;GJHGJ9L=< @=J=AF :Q
J=>=J=F;=
%MKLAF#9JL L@JGM?@@AK;GMFK=D KM:EALL=<9J=IM=KL>GJ<G;ME=FLKHMJKM9FL
LGL@=!J==<GEG>$F>GJE9LAGF;LW!*$X 0 . S LG:GL@L@==H9JLE=FLG>
#=9DL@9F<#ME9F.=JNA;=K9F<L@=*>>A;=G>(9F9?=E=FL9F<M<?=LGF%MDQ
0F<=JL@=!*$ 9?=F;A=K9J=?J9FL=<LO=FLQ :MKAF=KK<9QKLGJ=KHGF<LG
9J=IM=KL>GJJ=;GJ<K 0 . S9A
/G<9L= AL@9K:==FLO=FLQ =A?@L:MKAF=KK<9QKKAF;=#9JLJ=IM=KL=<L@=
<G;ME=FLK )=AL@=J##.FGJ*(@9N=HJGNA<=<L@=J=;GJ<KJ=IM=KL=<:Q#9JL FGJ@9N=
L@=QHJGNA<=<9<=FA9DG>@AKJ=;GJ<KJ=IM=KLK
/@= GFDQ J=KHGFK= J=;=AN=< O9K >JGE *( GF M?MKL <=FQAF?
=PH=<AL=<HJG;=KKAF?G>L@=J=;GJ<KJ=IM=KL
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 17 of 24
2@=F 9F 9?=F;Q >9ADK LG J=KHGF< LG L@= J=IM=KL=J OAL@AF L@= KL9LMLGJQ LAE=
DAEAL L@=J=IM=KL=JWK@9DD:=<==E=<LG@9N==P@9MKL=<@AK9<EAFAKLJ9LAN=J=E=<A=K6 7X
0 . S9A
/@=J=>GJ= #9JLE9QDG<?=L@AKGEHD9AFL9?9AFKL##.9F<*(
##.9F<*(@9N=AEHJGH=JDQOAL@@=D<L@=J=IM=KL=<J=;GJ<K>JGE#9JL
#9JL AK =FLALD=< LG 9 BM<?E=FL >JGE L@AK GMJL GJ<=JAF? ##. 9F< *(
AEE=<A9L=DQLGHJG<M;=L@=J=;GJ<K@=J=IM=KL=<
4 '$!*-)$ - + #
**&)2$// -1$*'/ /# - + #'0. *!/# '$!*-)$ *)./$/0/$*)
2# )/# 3'*& -/5..+ #
!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=J9J=;GEEGF;9JJA=JKG>AF>GJE9LAGF9F<9J=FGL9:D=LG
KMHHJ=KKKH==;@:9K=<GFNA=OHGAFL
$F471):%4(,233-1+)16)4 L@=9DA>GJFA9.MHJ=E=GMJLJ=;G?FAR=<L@9L
L@=KM:MJ:9FK@GHHAF?;=FL=JV=N=FGF=KL@9L9J=HJAN9L=DQGOF=<V9J=9FW=KK=FLA9D9F<
AFN9DM9:D=>GJME>GJ=P=J;AKAF?XKH==;@JA?@LK + < 9D /@=;GMJL
J=9KGF=<L@9LK@GHHAF?;=FL=JK9J=O@=J=EGKLH=GHD=WKH=F<L@=EGKLKA?FA>A;9FL9EGMFL
G> 6L@=AJ7 LAE= AF KM:MJ:9F 9J=9K O@=J= 6L@=AJ7 F==<K 9F< O9FLK 9J= K9LAK>A=<X :=;9MK=
WK@GHHAF? ;=FL=JK HJGNA<= L@= DG;9LAGF ?GG<K 9F< K=JNA;=K LG K9LAK>Q 6L@=AJ7 F==<K 9F<
O9FLK X(9L
/@= 0 . .MHJ=E= GMJL E9<= 9 KAEAD9J G:K=JN9LAGF 9:GML L@= AFL=JF=L AF
%'.-1+,%0 . L 9L /@=J= L@= GMJL ;GEH9J=< KG;A9D E=<A9 LG 9
WIMAFL=KK=FLA9D>GJMEX>GJ=F?9?AF?AFKH==;@KM;@9KW9KLJ==LGJH9JC X$L>MJL@=J>GMF<
L@9L L@= EGKL AEHGJL9FL >GJME LG<9Q >GJ KH==;@ AK W;Q:=JKH9;=VL@= YN9KL <=EG;J9LA;
>GJMEKG>L@=$FL=JF=LZAF?=F=J9D 9F<KG;A9DE=<A9AFH9JLA;MD9J X(IMGLAF?)128
0)4-'%1-8-/-&)46-)5!1-21 0 . . L ' < <
.G;A9DE=<A9HD9L>GJEK9J=L@=EG<=JF <9QLGOFKIM9J=
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 18 of 24
=;9MK=!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=JHJGNA<=9F=KK=FLA9D9F<AFN9DM9:D=>GJME>GJ
=P=J;AKAF?#9JLZKJA?@LLG!J==.H==;@MF<=JL@=9DA>GJFA9GFKLALMLAGF L@=QNAGD9L=<KM;@
JA?@LO@=FL@=QJ=EGN=<#9JLZKHGKLK9F<KMKH=F<=<@AK9:ADALQLGKH=9CGFL@=AJHD9L>GJEK
#9JLAK=FLALD=<LG<=;D9J9LGJQ9F<AFBMF;LAN=J=DA=>9KO=DD9K;GEH=FK9LGJQ9F<
FGEAF9D<9E9?=K>JGE!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=J>GJNAGD9LAF?@AKJA?@LLG!J==.H==;@MF<=J
L@=9DA>GJFA9GFKLALMLAGF
-*($..*-3 ./*++ '
**&)2$// -*(($// +-*($..*-3 ./*++ '3)*/!0'!$''$)"/# $-+-*($.
!*- -//*0. /# $-+'/!*-(!*-#$.0.$) ..
/@= 9DD=?9LAGFK AF L@= HJ=;=<AF? H9J9?J9H@K 9J= AF;GJHGJ9L=< @=J=AF :Q
J=>=J=F;=
!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=JE9<=W9;D=9J9F<MF9E:A?MGMKHJGEAK=XLG#9JLL@9L
@=;GMD<MK=L@=AJK=JNA;=KLG;GEEMFA;9L=9F<F=LOGJCOAL@GL@=J!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=J
MK=JK 75,)//824+%1,%5)%1. 9D -HLJ < 9D L HH
!9;=:GGC 9F< /OALL=J <A< FGL ;9N=9L L@AK HJGEAK= :Q 9FFGMF;AF? L@9L L@=Q
OGMD<;=FKGJKH==;@GHHGKAF?E9KCK
#9JL =F?9?=< AF WJ=9KGF9:D= >GJ=K==9:D= 9F< <=LJAE=FL9D J=DA9F;=X GF
!9;=:GGCZK9F</OALL=JZKHJGEAK=O@=F@=KL9JL=<MKAF?L@=AJK=JNA;=KLGKH=9COAL@9F<
F=LOGJCOAL@GL@=J!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=JMK=JKLGHJGEGL=@AK:MKAF=KK 75,)// 9D
-HLJ <9L
#9JL =F?9?=< AF WJ=9KGF9:D= >GJ=K==9:D= 9F< <=LJAE=FL9D J=DA9F;=X GF
!9;=:GGCZKHJGEAK=O@=F@=AFN=KL=<KM:KL9FLA9DKMEKG>EGF=QLG9<N=JLAK=GF!9;=:GGC
9F</OALL=J (
!9;=:GGCZK9F</OALL=JZKJ=EGN9D9F<>D9??AF?G>#9JLZKHGKLK9F<KMKH=FKAGF
G> @AK 9;;GMFL >GJ =F?9?AF? AF KH==;@ ;9MK=< @AK J=DA9F;= GF L@=AJ HJGEAK=K LG := LG L@=
<=LJAE=FLG>@AK:MKAF=KK >AF9F;=K 9F<J=HML9LAGF
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 19 of 24
K L@= J=KMDL G> L@AK <=LJAE=FL9D J=DA9F;= #9JL KM>>=J=< EGF=L9JQ 9F< FGF
EGF=L9JQ<9E9?=K
#9JLAK=FLALD=<LGEGF=L9JQJ=DA=>>JGE!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=J>GJ;GEEALLAF?
L@=LGJLG>HJGEAKKGJQ=KLGHH=D
)/ )/$*)')/ -! - ) 2$/# *)/-/
**&*(($// $)/ )/$*)'$)/ -! - ) 2$/#*)/-/3$)/ -! -$)"2$/#
-/5.*)/-/2$/# *)*-0- 0
/@= 9DD=?9LAGFK AF L@= HJ=;=<AF? H9J9?J9H@K 9J= AF;GJHGJ9L=< @=J=AF :Q
J=>=J=F;=
/G=KL9:DAK@9;D9AEG>AFL=FLAGF9DAFL=J>=J=F;=OAL@9;GFLJ9;LM9DJ=D9LAGFK@AH
L@= ;D9AE9FL EMKL K@GO 9 N9DA< ;GFLJ9;L :=LO==F ;D9AE9FL 9F< 9 L@AJ< H9JLQ
<=>=F<9FLZKCFGOD=<?=G>L@AK;GFLJ9;L<=>=F<9FLZKAFL=FLAGF9D9;LK<=KA?F=<LGAF<M;=
9:J=9;@GJ<AKJMHLAGFG>L@=;GFLJ9;LM9DJ=D9LAGFK@AH9;LM9D:J=9;@GJ<AKJMHLAGFG>L@=
;GFLJ9;LM9DJ=D9LAGFK@AH9F<J=KMDLAF?<9E9?= %8-58%(4-', 9D -HLJ <
9D L HH
9DA>GJFA9D9O<G=KFGLJ=IMAJ=L@9LL@=<=>=F<9FL9;LOAL@L@=KH=;A>A;AFL=FL
LG AFL=J>=J= )) -( 9L 7)/-0%1) 2 8 6)9%46 -6/) 7%4%16: 2 + <
/@=LGJLAK9HHDA;9:D=A>L@=<=>=F<9FLCFGOKL@9LL@=AFL=J>=J=F;=AKKM:KL9FLA9DDQ
;=JL9AFGJ;=JL9AFLG@9HH=F9K9J=KMDLG><=>=F<9FLZK9;LAGFK %(4-', 9D -HLJ <9L
#9JL E9AFL9AFK 9 N9DA< =EHDGQE=FL ;GFLJ9;L OAL@ GFGJ:MJ=9M ''
WGFGJ:MJ=9MX 91AJ?AFA9 :9K=<DAEAL=<DA9:ADALQ;GEH9FQ
KH9JLG>@AK=EHDGQE=FL;GFLJ9;L #9JLZKBG:<MLA=KAF;DM<=K=JNAF?9K9F
<EAFAKLJ9LGJGFL@=GFGJ:MJ=9M!9;=:GGC9;;GMFL KG@=;9FHGKL;GFL=FLLGL@=KAL=9F<
E9C=GL@=J;@9F?=KAF9F=>>GJLLGAF;J=9K=GFGJ:MJ=9MZKJ=N=FM=
!9;=:GGC@9KCFGOD=<?=G>L@=J=D9LAGFK@AH:=LO==F#9JL9F<GFGJ:MJ=9M
:=;9MK= AL @9K 9;LM9D FGLA;= L@9L #9JL K=JN=K 9K 9F <EAFAKLJ9LGJ >GJ L@= GFGJ:MJ=9M
9;;GMFL
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 20 of 24
!9;=:GGC AFL=FLAGF9DDQ KMKH=F<=< #9JLZK MK= G> @AK H=JKGF9D !9;=:GGC
9;;GMFL 9F<!9;=:GGCCF=O9F<AFL=F<=<L@9LKM;@9;LAGFOGMD<HJ=N=FL#9JL>JGE<GAF?
@AKOGJC9K9F<EAFAKLJ9LGJGFL@=GFGJ:MJ=9M9;;GMFL
/@=J=>GJ= !9;=:GGC AFL=FLAGF9DDQ AFL=J>=J=< OAL@ #9JLZK ;GFLJ9;L OAL@
GFGJ:MJ=9M
)GL:=AF?9:D=LGK=JNA;=GFGJ:MJ=9MZK!9;=:GGCH9?=HD9;=<#9JLAF:J=9;@
G>@AK;GFLJ9;LOAL@GFGJ:MJ=9M
#9JLKM>>=J=<9F<AKKM>>=JAF?EGF=L9JQ<9E9?=>GJFGL:=AF?9:D=LG>MD>ADD@AK
KG;A9DE=<A9<MLA=KLGGFGJ:MJ=9M
#9JLAK=FLALD=<LGEGF=L9JQJ=DA=>>JGE!9;=:GGC>GJAFL=FLAGF9DDQAFL=J>=JAF?
OAL@@AK;GFLJ9;LOAL@GFGJ:MJ=9M
"'$" )/)/ -! - ) 2$/#-*.+ /$1 *)*($1)/"
**&*(($// ) "'$" )/$)/ -! - ) 2$/#+-*.+ /$1 *)*($1)/"
3$)/ -! -$)"2$/# -/5.*)/-/2$/# *)*-0- 0
/@= 9DD=?9LAGFK AF L@= HJ=;=<AF? H9J9?J9H@K 9J= AF;GJHGJ9L=< @=J=AF :Q
J=>=J=F;=
/G =KL9:DAK@ 9 ;D9AE G> F=?DA?=FL AFL=J>=J=F;= OAL@ 9 HJGKH=;LAN= =;GFGEA;
9<N9FL9?= 9 ;D9AE9FL EMKL K@GO L@= =PAKL=F;= G> 9 N9DA< ;GFLJ9;LM9D J=D9LAGFK@AH
:=LO==FL@=HD9AFLA>>9F<9L@AJ<H9JLQ;GFL9AFAF?L@=HJG:9:ADALQG>>MLMJ==;GFGEA;:=F=>AL
LGL@=HD9AFLA>>L@=<=>=F<9FLZKCFGOD=<?= 9;LM9DGJ;GFKLJM=< G>L@=J=D9LAGFK@AH
L@=<=>=F<9FLZKCFGOD=<?= 9;LM9DGJ;GFKLJM=< L@9LL@=J=D9LAGFK@AHOGMD<:=<AKJMHL=<A>
L@= <=>=F<9FL >9AD=< LG 9;L OAL@ J=9KGF9:D= ;9J= L@= <=>=F<9FLZK >9ADMJ= LG 9;L OAL@
J=9KGF9:D=;9J=9;LM9D<AKJMHLAGFG>L@=J=D9LAGFK@AH9F<J=KMDLAF?=;GFGEA;@9JE
)/5218 7'.)4//-5 9D -HLJ < F 9D HH L
#9JL E9AFL9AFK 9 N9DA< =EHDGQE=FL ;GFLJ9;L OAL@ GFGJ:MJ=9M '' 9
1AJ?AFA9 :9K=<DAEAL=<DA9:ADALQ;GEH9FQ
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 21 of 24
KH9JLG>@AK=EHDGQE=FL;GFLJ9;L #9JLZKBG:<MLA=KAF;DM<=K=JNAF?9K9F
<EAFAKLJ9LGJGFL@=GFGJ:MJ=9M!9;=:GGC9;;GMFL KG@=;9FHGKL;GFL=FLLGL@=KAL=9F<
E9C=GL@=J;@9F?=KAF9F=>>GJLLGAF;J=9K=GFGJ:MJ=9MZKJ=N=FM=
#9JL@9K9HJG:9:ADALQG>>MLMJ==;GFGEA;:=F=>AL:Q>MD>ADDAF?L@=L=JEKG>@AK
=EHDGQE=FL;GFLJ9;LOAL@GFGJ:MJ=9M
!9;=:GGC@9KCFGOD=<?=G>L@=J=D9LAGFK@AH:=LO==F#9JL9F<GFGJ:MJ=9M
:=;9MK= AL @9K 9;LM9D FGLA;= L@9L #9JL K=JN=K 9K 9F <EAFAKLJ9LGJ >GJ L@= GFGJ:MJ=9M
9;;GMFL
2@=F !9;=:GGC KMKH=F<=< #9JLZK MK= G> @AK H=JKGF9D !9;=:GGC 9;;GMFL AL
CF=O GJ K@GMD< @9N= CFGOF L@9L #9JLZK OGJC 9K 9F <EAFAKLJ9LGJ GF L@= GFGJ:MJ=9M
9;;GMFL 9F< @AK J=D9LAGFK@AH OAL@ GFGJ:MJ=9M OGMD< := <AKJMHL=< 9K 9 J=KMDL G> ALK
F=?DA?=FL9;LAGFK
$F FGL HJGNA<AF? #9JL 9FQ 9N=FM= LG 9;;=KK L@= GFGJ:MJ=9M 9;;GMFL
!9;=:GGC>9AD=<LG9;LOAL@J=9KGF9:D=;9J=
!9;=:GGCZK9;LG>KMKH=FKAGF;9MK=<9F9;LM9D<AKJMHLAGFAFL@=J=D9LAGFK@AH
:=LO==F#9JL9F<GFGJ:MJ=9M:=;9MK=@=;GMD<FGLHGKL;GFL=FLLGL@=KAL=GJE9C=GL@=J
;@9F?=KAF@AKOGJCLGAF;J=9K=GFGJ:MJ=9MZKJ=N=FM=
/@=J=>GJ= !9;=:GGCF=?DA?=FLDQAFL=J>=J=<OAL@#9JLZKHJGKH=;LAN==;GFGEA;
9<N9FL9?=>JGE@AK;GFLJ9;LM9DJ=D9LAGFK@AHOAL@GFGJ:MJ=9M
#9JLKM>>=J=<9F<AKKM>>=JAF?EGF=L9JQ<9E9?=>GJFGL:=AF?9:D=LG>MD>ADD@AK
KG;A9DE=<A9<MLA=KLGGFGJ:MJ=9M
#9JLAK=FLALD=<LGEGF=L9JQJ=DA=>>JGE!9;=:GGC>GJF=?DA?=FLDQAFL=J>=JAF?
OAL@L@=HJGKH=;LAN==;GFGEA;9<N9FL9?=J=KMDLAF?>JGE@AK;GFLJ9;LOAL@GFGJ:MJ=9M
+D9AFLA>>J=KH=;L>MDDQJ=IM=KLKL@9LL@AKGMJL=FL=JBM<?E=FLAF@AK>9NGJGF=N=JQ
;D9AEK=L>GJL@9:GN=9F<9O9J<@AEL@=>GDDGOAF?J=DA=>
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 22 of 24
=;D9J=L@9LL@=9;LAGFKG>(MJL@Q A<=F !9;=:GGC 9F</OALL=J;GFKLALML=9
NAGD9LAGFG>L@=!J==.H==;@;D9MK=:Q<=FQAF?#9JLL@=9:ADALQLGKH=9CGF!9;=:GGC9F<
/OALL=J
FBGAF (MJL@Q 9F< A<=F >JGE <AJ=;LAF? KG;A9D E=<A9 ;GEH9FA=K LG ;=FKGJ
AF>GJE9LAGFOAL@O@A;@(MJL@Q9F<A<=F<AK9?J==
FBGAF !9;=:GGC 9F< /OALL=J >JGE J=EGNAF? GJ KMKH=F<AF? HGKLK 9L L@=
<AJ=;LAGFG>(MJL@Q9F<A<=F
FBGAF (MJL@Q 9F< A<=F >JGE <AJ=;LAF? KG;A9D E=<A9 ;GEH9FA=K LG ;=FKGJ
#9JLZKKH==;@
FBGAF!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=J>JGEJ=EGNAF?#9JLZKHGKLKGJKMKH=F<AF?@AK
9:ADALQLGHGKL:=;9MK=L@=Q<AK9?J==OAL@L@=;GFL=FLG>@AKHGKLKJ=?9J<AF?E9KCK *1$
GJGL@=J@A?@DQ<=:9L=<LGHA;KG>L@=<9Q
!
*J<=J *( 9F< ##. AEE=<A9L=DQ LG HJG<M;= L@= J=;GJ<K #9JL J=IM=KL=<
HMJKM9FLLGL@=!J==<GEG>$F>GJE9LAGF;L
"
O9J<#9JL9LLGJF=QKZ>==K9F<;GKLK HMJKM9FLLG0 . S9
#
=;D9J=L@9LL@=9;LAGFKG>!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=J;GFKLALML=9NAGD9LAGFG>L@=
!J==.H==;@;D9MK=G>L@=9DA>GJFA9GFKLALMLAGF:Q<=FQAF?#9JLL@=9:ADALQLGKH=9CGF
!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=J
$
O9J< #9JL FGEAF9D <9E9?=K G> =9;@ >JGE !9;=:GGC 9F< /OALL=J >GJ
KM>>=JAF?9NAGD9LAGFG>@AK>=<=J9D9F<KL9L=>J==KH==;@JA?@LK9F<>GJKM>>=JAF?<9E9?=KAF
9DA>GJFA9LGJLD9O
%
O9J< #9JL ;GEH=FK9LGJQ <9E9?=K AF L@= 9EGMFL G> @AK H9KL HJ=K=FL 9F<
>MLMJ=DGKLAF;GE=J=KMDLAF?>JGE!9;=:GGCZK9F</OALL=JZK9;LAGFKG>HJGEAKKGJQ=KLGHH=D
9F< J=KMDLAF? >JGE !9;=:GGCZK AFL=FLAGF9D AFL=J>=J=F;= OAL@ 9 ;GFLJ9;L 9F< F=?DA?=FL
AFL=J>=J=F;=OAL@9HJGKH=;LAN==;GFGEA;9<N9FL9?=
&
O9J<#9JL;GEH=FK9LGJQ<9E9?=KAFL@=9EGMFLG>9J=LMJFG>L@=EGF=Q@=
KH=FLGF!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=J9<N=JLAK=E=FLK:=;9MK=G>!9;=:GGCZK9F</OALL=JZK9;LAGFK
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 23 of 24
G> HJGEAKKGJQ =KLGHH=D 9F< !9;=:GGCZK AFL=FLAGF9D AFL=J>=J=F;= OAL@ 9 ;GFLJ9;L 9F<
F=?DA?=FLAFL=J>=J=F;=OAL@9HJGKH=;LAN==;GFGEA;9<N9FL9?=
'
O9J<#9JL;GEH=FK9LGJQ<9E9?=KAF9F9EGMFLLG>MDDQ;GEH=FK9L=@AE>GJ
L@=LAE=@=KH=FL:MAD<AF?9>GDDGOAF?GF!9;=:GGC9F</OALL=JL@9L@9KFGO:==FO9KL=<
:Q !9;=:GGCZK 9F< /OALL=JZK 9;LAGFK G> HJGEAKKGJQ =KLGHH=D 9F< !9;=:GGCZK AFL=FLAGF9D
AFL=J>=J=F;= OAL@ 9 ;GFLJ9;L 9F< F=?DA?=FL AFL=J>=J=F;= OAL@ 9 HJGKH=;LAN= =;GFGEA;
9<N9FL9?=
(
O9J<#9JL;GEH=FK9LGJQ<9E9?=KAFL@=9EGMFLG>L@=@9JELG@AKJ=HML9LAGF
J=KMDLAF?>JGE!9;=:GGCZK9F</OALL=JZK9;LAGFKG>HJGEAKKGJQ=KLGHH=D9F<J=KMDLAF?>JGE
!9;=:GGCZK AFL=FLAGF9D AFL=J>=J=F;= OAL@ 9 ;GFLJ9;L 9F< F=?DA?=FL AFL=J>=J=F;= OAL@ 9
HJGKH=;LAN==;GFGEA;9<N9FL9?=
)
O9J<9FQ>MJL@=JJ=DA=>LGO@A;@#9JLE9Q:==FLALD=< AF;DM<AF?9LLGJF=QKZ
>==K9F<;GKLK
9L=<M?MKL
-=KH=;L>MDDQKM:EALL=<
K 5REHUW7\OHU888888888
-G:=JL# /QD=J . )
JLQD=JLQD=J:MJK;@ ;GE
)9<9) #A?M=J9 . )
F@A?M=J9LQD=J:MJK;@ ;GE
/QD=JMJK;@ ''+
'9KJAK9K-<
(MJJA=L9 9DA>GJFA9
+@GF=
!9P
JA9F& &=DK=Q42%'"-')>GJL@;GEAF?
/=FF=KK==9J)ME:=J
:C=DK=QDB; GJ?
(9DDGJQ-=9<=J42%'"-')>GJL@;GEAF?
(A;@A?9F9J)ME:=J+
EJ=9<=JDB; GJ?
Case 3:22-cv-00737-CRB Document 1 Filed 08/31/21 Page 24 of 24
'A:=JLQ%MKLA;==FL=J
2 %9;CKGFDN< .L=
@A;9?G $DDAFGAK
+@GF=
!9P
66241):5*24/%-16-**File and source
- File
- gov.uscourts.cand.391509.1.0.pdf
- Size
- 868,970 bytes
- SHA-256
- 4c7fce299d3f144370ff3f6afb72e2bd7f85d4dd2025594fe28a03e63fc63dab
- Our copy
- gov.uscourts.cand.391509.1.0.pdf
- Original
- archive.org