Court filing
ORDER RE 124 PLAINTIFFS' ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO CONSIDER WHETHER… — Brooks v. Thomson Reuters Corporation (Dkt. 147)
Summary
Document 147, filed 12/07/22 in Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC (Brooks v. Thomson Reuters Corporation, N.D. Cal.), is an order re Plaintiffs' Administrative Motion to Consider Whether Another Party's Material Should Be Sealed (Dkt. 124), captioned [PROPOSED] ORDER and ending "IT IS SO ORDERED. DATED: December 7, 2022" over Hon. Edward M. Chen. It recites that the Court considered the motion and Thomson Reuters' Statement in Response, including exhibits 1-4 and the declaration of Kevin Appold, and finds good cause and compelling reasons to seal listed portions of Plaintiffs' class certification brief, the Fox deposition, the Turow Report and other exhibits. It also seals in their entirety listed declaration exhibits, described generally as internal emails, an internal FAQ, powerpoints, spreadsheets, and the individual CLEAR reports for Plaintiffs Cat Brooks and Rasheed Shabazz.
Summary drafted by a model from the document's text below and checked by script against that text before publication. It is a navigation aid, not a reading of what the document proves. Where AI is used
Cite this document
“ORDER RE 124 PLAINTIFFS' ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO CONSIDER WHETHER… — Brooks v. Thomson Reuters Corporation (Dkt. 147).”
Original at ecf.cand.uscourts.gov, No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC, Doc. 147. Archived at Pandemic Darlings, https://pandemicdarlings.com/court-filings/full-docket-brooks-thomsonreuters-cand-374304/2022-12-07-gov-uscourts-cand-374304-147-0-doc-147/
, SHA-256 5b13f03f8d45eb37ff1603f200f983a25fcccb4e6aa7def6d28761a11f01ebe9.Full text
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 147 Filed 12/07/22 Page 1 of 8
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
9
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
10
SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION
11
12
CAT BROOKS and RASHEED SHABAZZ, Case No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC
13 individually and on behalf of all others
similarly situated, [PROPOSED] ORDER RE PLAINTIFFS’
14 ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO
Plaintiffs, CONSIDER WHETHER ANOTHER
15 PARTY’S MATERIAL SHOULD BE
v. SEALED (DKT. 124)
16
THOMSON REUTERS CORPORATION, Judge: Hon. Edward M. Chen
17
Defendant.
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Case No. 3:21-CV-01418-EMC [PROPOSED] ORDER
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 147 Filed 12/07/22 Page 2 of 8
1 The Court, having considered Plaintiffs’ Administrative Moton to Consider Whether
2 Another Party’s Material Should be Sealed and all supporting materials thereto, and having
3 considered Defendant Thomson Reuters’ Statement in Response and all supporting materials
4 thereto, including exhibits 1-4 and the declaration of Kevin Appold, finds that good cause and
5 compelling reasons exist to seal:
6 (1) The following portions of Plaintiffs’ Brief in Support of Motion for Class
7 Certification (“Moton”) and the following portions of the following Exhibits to the Declaration of
8 Andre Mura in support of the Motion (“Declaration Exhibits”):
9 Dkt. No. / Ex. Portion(s) to Seal
10 Dkt. 124-3 After “private investigators, even” and before “millions of dollars each
1:11 year”
11
Dkt. 124-3 After “arrested in” and before “for example”
12 4:18
Dkt. 124-3 After “It licenses it through” and before “third parties”
13 4:23
Dkt. 124-3 FN 3: After “(“Jane” Powerpoint)” and before “Ex. 32”
14 5:23-24
Dkt. 124-3 FN 3: After “(August 2015 Legal Powerpoint)” and before “Ex. 33”
15 5:25
Dkt. 124-3 FN 3: After “(Email 6/15-7/5)” and before “Ex. 6”
16 5:25-27
Dkt. 124-3 After “considered” and before “See Ex. 50”
17 6:13
Dkt. 124-3 After “analysts discussing that they” and before “Ex. 51”
18 6:14-15
Dkt. 124-3 After “(discussing” and before “Ex. 52”
19 6:16-17
Dkt. 124-3 After “to control their personal information” and before “See Ex. 54”
20 6:20-21
Dkt. 124-3 FN 4: After “See Ex. 44 (Email 6/13-6/14)” and before “[.]”); Ex. 45”
21 6:22-23
Dkt. 124-3 FN 4: After “Ex. 45 (Email 7/17-2/13)” and before “Ex. 46 (Public
22 6:24-25 Records Compliance Chart)”
Dkt. 124-3 FN 4: After “Ex. 47 (Email 3/5-4/20)” and before “Ex. 48”
23 6:25-26
Dkt. 124-3 FN 4: After “Ex. 48 (Email 1/28-1/29)” and before “Ex. 49 (Email
24 6:26-27 11/21-12/9)”
Dkt. 124-3 FN 4: After “Ex. 49 (Email 11/21-12/9)” to end of sentence in FN 4
25 6:28
Dkt. 124-3 Beginning of first line of page and before “Ex. 55”
26 7:1-2
Dkt. 124-3 After “Ex. 55 (Email 2/2-2/11)” and before “see also Ex. 56”
27 7:3-6
Dkt. 124-3 After “Thomson Reuters found” and before “Ex. 57”
28 7:7-10
Case No. 3:21-CV-01418-EMC -1- [PROPOSED] ORDER
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 147 Filed 12/07/22 Page 3 of 8
1 Dkt. No. / Ex. Portion(s) to Seal
2 Dkt. 124-3 After “has made over” and before “million selling access”
7:13
3 Dkt. 124-3 After “seeing revenues grow from” and before “See Ex. 60.”
7:17-18
4 Dkt. 124-3 After “list of clients that are” and before “corporate and government
7:19-20 customers.”
5 Dkt. 124-3 After “customers for a central purpose:” and before “See Ex. 61.”
7:25-26
6 Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 50:15-19 (after “believe it’s about” to the end of line 19)
Ex. 1
7 Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 64:15-20 (after “type of data.” to the end of line 20)
Ex. 1
8 Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 80:1-2
Ex. 1
9 Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 95:7-96:19
Ex. 1
10 Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 99:12-18
Ex. 1
11 Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 105:14-15
Ex. 1
12
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 106:11-106:12 (after “detail, please,” and before “correct?”)
13 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 106:17
14 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 106:20
15 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 108:16-18 (after “where it says,” to the end of line 18)
16 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 108:20-21 (after “referencing the addition of” and before
17 Ex. 1 “to the CLEAR - - strike that.”)
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 108:23 (beginning of line and before “to CLEAR?”)
18 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 110:2-3 (beginning of line and before “new driver’s”)
19 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 110:8 (after “is” to end of line 8)
20 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 110:9-12 (after “And we don’t - - and” to end of line 12)
21 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 116:17-18 (after “based on previous testimony,” and before
22 Ex. 1 “it enters into our systems,”)
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 121:15-122:4
23 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 122:21-25
24 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 123:5-12
25 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 156:13-157:4
26 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 169:21-22
27 Ex. 1
Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 170:2-4
28 Ex. 1
Case No. 3:21-CV-01418-EMC -2- [PROPOSED] ORDER
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 147 Filed 12/07/22 Page 4 of 8
1 Dkt. No. / Ex. Portion(s) to Seal
2 Dkt. 124-4 Fox Dep. at 178:2-24
Ex. 1
3 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 12, line 4 (beginning of line and before “pages”.)
Ex. 4
4 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 12, FN 30 (after “listing” and before “Fox Dep.
Ex. 4 98:21-22”)
5 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 12, FN 31 (after “listing” and before “Fox Dep.
Ex. 4 98:21-22”)
6 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 14, FN 40 (after “In fact, I understand that” and
Ex. 4 before “Fox Dep. 132:20-133:19”)
7 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 14, FN 40 (after “Fox Dep. 132:20-133:19” to the
Ex. 4 end of FN 40)
8 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 20, line 5 (after “add to CLEAR, including,
Ex. 4 potentially” to the end of sentence)
9 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 20, FN 59 (after “listing” and before “in a page of a
Ex. 4 presentation”)
10 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 20, FN 59 (after “exploring the addition of” and
Ex. 4 before “to its CLEAR profiles”)
11 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 21, FN 64 (entire footnote)
Ex. 4
12
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 26, first row of table - continuation from previous
13 Ex. 4 page re beg bates TR-BROOKS018865 - in the document description
column (after “discussing” and before “(June 2015)”)
14 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 26, sixth row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “Annual Subscription Renewal” and before “& West
15 Publishing Corporation”)
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 26, seventh row of table in the document description
16 Ex. 4 column (after “Weekly Data Updates,” and before “& West Publishing
Corporation”)
17 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 26, eighth row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “West Group &” and before “(Sept. 21, 2000)”)
18 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 26, ninth row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “Contract” and before “(June 16, 1999)”)
19 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 26, tenth row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “Contractual Agreement Between” and before “& West
20 Publishing Corporation”)
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 26, eleventh row of table in the document
21 Ex. 4 description column (after “Agreement” and before “West Services Inc.
&”)
22 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 26, eleventh row of table in the document
Ex. 4 description column (after “West Services Inc. &” and before “(Feb. 8,
23 2013)”)
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 27, fifth row of table in the document description
24 Ex. 4 column (after “West Publishing &” and before “(Aug. 25, 2016)”)
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 27, sixth row of table in the document description
25 Ex. 4 column (after “West Services &” and before “(July 19, 2004)”)
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 27, seventh row of table in the document description
26 Ex. 4 column (after “West Services &” and before “(Aug. 29, 2006)”)
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 27, eighth row of table in the document description
27 Ex. 4 column (after “West Services &” and before “(June 1, 2007)”)
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 27, ninth row of table in the document description
28 Ex. 4 column (after “West Services &” and before “(Nov. 29, 2006)”)
Case No. 3:21-CV-01418-EMC -3- [PROPOSED] ORDER
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 147 Filed 12/07/22 Page 5 of 8
1 Dkt. No. / Ex. Portion(s) to Seal
2 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 27, tenth row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “Purchase Order,” to the end of description)
3 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 27, eleventh row of table in the document
Ex. 4 description column (after “Supply Agreement,” and before “& West
4 Services, Inc.”)
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 28, first row of table in the document description
5 Ex. 4 column (after “Supply Agreement,” and before “& West Services, Inc.”)
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 28, second row of table in the document description
6 Ex. 4 column (after “License Agreement,” and before “& West Services,
Inc.”)
7 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 28, third row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “License Agreement,” and before “& West Services,
8 Inc.”)
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 28, fourth row of table in the document description
9 Ex. 4 column (after “Second Addendum,” and before “& West Services,
Inc.”)
10 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 28, fifth row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “Order Form for,” and before “West Services &”)
11 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 28, fifth row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “West Services &” and before “(Dec. 14, 2014)”)
12 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 28, sixth row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “West Publishing &” and before “(Mar. 1, 2017)”)
13 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 28, seventh row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “West Publishing &” and before “(May 25, 2019)”)
14
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 28, eighth row of table in the document description
15 Ex. 4 column (after “Reseller Agreement,” and before “& West Publishing
Corporation”)
16 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 28, ninth row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “West Publishing &” and before “(Aug. 1, 2017)”)
17 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 28, tenth row of table in the document description
Ex. 4 column (after “West Services &” and before “(Nov. 13, 2009)”)
18 Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 29, first row of table - continuation from previous
Ex. 4 page - in the document description column (after “West Services &” and
19 before “(Feb. 2, 2010)”)
Dkt. 124-7 Turow Report page 29, second row of table re beg bates TR-
20 Ex. 4 BROOKS040077 - in the document description column (after
“personnel and client” and before “discussing CLEAR matching”)
21 Dkt. 124-9 Godlewski Dep. at 131:6-9
Ex. 6
22 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 1, line 16 (after “shows total net profits of
Ex. 59 approximately” and before “as of the end of 2021.”)
23 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 5, FN 15 (after “TR-BROOKS082062 (listing” and
Ex. 59 before “Fox Dep. 98:7-8”)
24 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 6, line 4 (entire line except footnote)
Ex. 59
25 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 6, (entire image of powerpoint slide in middle of
Ex. 59 page)
26 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 10, (all data underneath the table column header titled:
Ex. 59 “Total Revenue ($MMs)”)
27 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 11, last two lines 26-27 (after “(e.g.,” and before
Ex. 59 “etc.).”)
28
Case No. 3:21-CV-01418-EMC -4- [PROPOSED] ORDER
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 147 Filed 12/07/22 Page 6 of 8
1 Dkt. No. / Ex. Portion(s) to Seal
2 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 12, FN 42 (after “over the years 2010-2017, from” and
Ex. 59 before “TR-BROOKS123263;”)
3 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 13, FN 47 (after “testifying that about” and before “of
Ex. 59 CLEAR’s current customers”)
4 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 14, line 5 (after “the data indicates that
Ex. 59 approximately” and before “of all CLEAR searches”)
5 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 14, FN 49 - continuation from previous page (after
Ex. 59 “showing” and before “of CLEAR usage transactions”)
6 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 14, FN 49 - continuation from previous page (after
Ex. 59 “CLEAR Desktop and” and before “occurring through CLEAR S2S,”)
7 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 14, FN 49 - continuation from previous page (after
Ex. 59 “with the remaining” and before “attributable to Batch searches”)
8 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 16, lines 23-26 (after “was entered into between
Ex. 59 Thomson Reuters and” and before “[fn59] As a second example,”)
9 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 16, line 27 (after “As a second example, an agreement
Ex. 59 between Thomson Reuters and” and before “to be made available
10 through”)
Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report pages 16 through 17, bottom line 29 through top of next
11 Ex. 59 page line 1 (after “California, with royalties of” through end of sentence
at top of next page before “[fn60] Absent”)
12 Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 17, line 10 (after “consistently at or below” and before
Ex. 59 “of the corresponding revenues.”)
13
Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 17, line 11 (after “my calculations use the” and before
14 Ex. 59 “figure as a reasonable estimate”)
Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 17, bottom of page (all information/data contained
15 Ex. 59 underneath table titled: 2021 - total of two columns and 9 rows)
Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 18, middle of page (all information/data contained
16 Ex. 59 below the table column headers - total of 6 columns and 11 rows)
Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report page 19, line 6 (after “can be calculated as approximately”
17 Ex. 59 to the end of sentence)
Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report Exhibit 1 (entire document)
18 Ex. 59
Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report Appendix A page 12, line 3 (after “Email from Alan
19 Ex. 59 Schafer Re:” and before TR-BROOKS04729-TR-BROOKS047039”)
Dkt. 127-12 FSG Report Appendix A page 13, line 7 (after “Email from Britton
20 Ex. 59 Wolf re:” and before “TR-BROOKS176757-TR-BROOKS176764”)
Dkt. 127-13 Page 3, lines 5-14 (all data underneath table column 2 titled: “Recurring
21 Ex. 60 Revenue Attributed to CLEAR” and all data underneath table column 3
titled: “Transactional Revenue Attributed to CLEAR”)
22 Dkt. 127-17 All 75 pages of “Excel Sheet 2,” which follow directly after first two
Ex. 70 pages which comprise “Excel Sheet 1”
23
24 (2) The following Declaration Exhibits in their entirety:
25 Dkt. No. / Ex. Document
26 Dkt. 124-5 Internal training materials in the form of talking points for sales
Ex. 2 personnel to use with prospective CLEAR customers
27 Dkt. 124-11 Internal spreadsheet of CLEAR customers
Exs. 8
28
Case No. 3:21-CV-01418-EMC -5- [PROPOSED] ORDER
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 147 Filed 12/07/22 Page 7 of 8
1 Dkt. No. / Ex. Document
2 Dkt. 124-12 Internal spreadsheet of CLEAR customers
Exs. 9
3 Dkt. 124-13 Sample CLEAR report
Ex. 12
4 Dkt. 124-14 Internal email discussing needed clarifications as to what information is
Ex. 15 and is not accessible through CLEAR
5 Dkt. 125-1 Internal employee training materials in the form of a test with questions
Ex. 16 and answers
6 Dkt. 125-3 Email conversation among employees in response to a request for
Ex. 19 information for marketing materials
7 Dkt. 125-4 Email conversation among employees regarding enhancements made to
Ex. 20 CLEAR in March of 2021 and regarding an incoming request for
8 proposal
Dkt. 125-5 Internal spreadsheet of CLEAR data sources
9 Ex. 21
Dkt. 125-6 Internal powerpoint presentation providing a detailed review of CLEAR
10 Ex. 23 data licensors
Dkt. 125-7 Internal spreadsheet of upcoming notice due dates for data licensors
11 Ex. 24
Dkt. 125-8 Product ladder of limited distribution that details the features and content
12 Ex. 25 available through various CLEAR plans
13 Dkt. 125-9 Internal spreadsheet of CLEAR search metrics
Ex. 26
14 Dkt. 125-12 Internal announcement about CLEAR product changes
Ex. 29
15 Dkt. 125-13 Email conversation among employees regarding CLEAR search metrics
Ex. 30
16 Dkt. 125-14 Internal training powerpoint presentation providing technical processes
Ex. 31 and capabilities of CLEAR
17 Dkt. 125-15 Internal powerpoint presentation providing information on data licensing
Ex. 32 agreements
18 Dkt. 125-16 Email conversation among employees regarding CLEAR billing usage
Ex. 33 and validation
19 Dkt. 125-17 Internal powerpoint presentation proposing data license agreement
Ex. 34 renewal for a specific data licensor
20 Dkt. 125-18 Internal training materials in the form of talking points for sales
Ex. 35 personnel to use with prospective CLEAR customers
21 Dkt. 125-20 Draft internal training materials in the form of talking points for sales
Ex. 37 personnel to use with prospective CLEAR customers
22 Dkt. 126-1 Email conversations between Thomson Reuters and a CLEAR customer,
Ex. 38 and an internal conversation among employees, regarding the technical
23 processes for pinning data to subjects in CLEAR
Dkt. 126-2 Draft, internal document describing Thomson Reuters’ public records
24 Ex. 39 products
Dkt. 126-3 Internal powerpoint presentation regarding business operations
25 Ex. 41
Dkt. 126-4 Internal powerpoint presentation regarding business operations
26 Ex. 42
Dkt. 126-5 Internal chart mapping the CLEAR credentialing process
27 Ex. 43
Dkt. 126-6 Email conversations regarding permissible use of CLEAR
28 Ex. 44
Case No. 3:21-CV-01418-EMC -6- [PROPOSED] ORDER
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 147 Filed 12/07/22 Page 8 of 8
1 Dkt. No. / Ex. Document
2 Dkt. 126-7 Email conversations regarding permissible uses of CLEAR
Ex. 45
3 Dkt. 126-8 Internal FAQ document addressing compliance investigation questions
Ex. 46
4 Dkt. 126-9 Email conversations in response to customer inquiries
Ex. 47
5 Dkt. 127-1 Email conversation among employees regarding a customer request
Ex. 48
6 Dkt. 127-2 Email conversation among employees regarding data security features of
Ex. 49 CLEAR
7 Dkt. 127-3 Email conversation among employees regarding CLEAR credentialing
Ex. 50
8 Dkt. 127-4 Email conversation among employees regarding CLEAR credentialing
Ex. 51
9 Dkt. 127-5 Email conversation among employees regarding CLEAR credentialing
Ex. 52
10 Dkt. 127-6 Email conversation between Thomson Reuters and a customer regarding
Ex. 53 CLEAR credentialing
11 Dkt. 127-7 Internal email regarding certain information available through CLEAR
Ex. 54
12
Dkt. 127-8 Email from the sales team to a potential client
13 Ex. 55
Dkt. 127-9 Email conversation regarding certain information available through
14 Ex. 56 CLEAR
Dkt. 127-10 Internal email regarding certain information available through CLEAR
15 Ex. 57
Dkt. 127-14 Internal powerpoint presentation regarding CLEAR financial growth
16 Ex. 61 strategy
Dkt. 127-15 Internal training materials in the form of a powerpoint slide describing
17 Ex. 62 the Risk Inform product
Dkt. 127-16 Email conversation regarding a consumer rights request under the CCPA
18 Ex. 67
Dkt. 127-18 Internal spreadsheet of Real-Time Incarceration records coverage per
19 Ex. 71 state
Dkt. 127-19 Internal spreadsheet of Real-Time Incarceration records coverage per
20 Ex. 72 county
Dkt. 128-1 Individual CLEAR report for Plaintiff Cat Brooks
21 Ex. 73
Dkt. 129-1 Individual CLEAR report for Plaintiff Rasheed Shabazz
22 Ex. 74
23
24
IT IS SO ORDERED.
25
DATED: December 7, 2022
26 Hon. Edward M. Chen
United States District Court
27
28
Case No. 3:21-CV-01418-EMC -7- [PROPOSED] ORDER
File and source
- File
- gov.uscourts.cand.374304.147.0.pdf
- Size
- 175,861 bytes
- SHA-256
- 5b13f03f8d45eb37ff1603f200f983a25fcccb4e6aa7def6d28761a11f01ebe9
- Original
- PACER (login required)