Court filing
Order by Judge Edward M Chen granting 124 PLAINTIFFS ADMINISTRATIVE… — Brooks v. Thomson Reuters Corporation (Dkt. 134)
Summary
A [Proposed] Order Re: Plaintiffs' Administrative Motion to Consider Whether Another Party's Materials Should Be Sealed, Document 134, filed 11/10/22 in Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC, Cat Brooks and Rasheed Shabazz v. Thomson Reuters Corporation, Case No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC-KAW, in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California, San Francisco Division, eight pages, before Hon. Edward M. Chen. The proposed order, under Local Rule 79-5, states that listed portions of Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification and supporting documents may be filed under seal. The table lists exhibits to the Andre M. Mura Declaration, including portions of the Fox deposition, a Turow Report and portions of the Buckethal and Godlewski depositions, with Defendant as the designating party.
Summary drafted by a model from the document's text below and checked by script against that text before publication. It is a navigation aid, not a reading of what the document proves. Where AI is used
Cite this document
“Order by Judge Edward M Chen granting 124 PLAINTIFFS ADMINISTRATIVE… — Brooks v. Thomson Reuters Corporation (Dkt. 134).”
Original at ecf.cand.uscourts.gov, No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC, Doc. 134. Archived at Pandemic Darlings, https://pandemicdarlings.com/court-filings/full-docket-brooks-thomsonreuters-cand-374304/2022-11-10-gov-uscourts-cand-374304-134-0-doc-134/
, SHA-256 53e341e0160a91e3940a7d6c3aec1eba594904b48d72e6c6f72f03c59ce90146.Full text
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 134 Filed 11/10/22 Page 1 of 8
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
10 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION
11
12 CAT BROOKS and RASHEED SHABAZZ, Case No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC-KAW
individually and on behalf of all others
13
similarly situated, [PROPOSED] ORDER RE: PLAINTIFFS’
14 ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO
Plaintiffs, CONSIDER WHETHER ANOTHER
15 PARTY’S MATERIALS SHOULD BE
v.
16 SEALED
THOMSON REUTERS CORPORATION,
17 Hon. Edward M. Chen
18 Defendant.
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: PLAINTIFFS’ ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO CONSIDER
WHETHER ANOTHER PARTY’S MATERIALS SHOULD BE SEALED
Case No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC-KAW
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 134 Filed 11/10/22 Page 2 of 8
1 Having con sidered Plaintiffs' Administrative Motion to Consider Whether Another
2 Party's Materials Should Be Sealed, relating to Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification
3 (Motion") and materials in support of that Motion, pursuant to Local Rule 79-5;
4 IT IS HEREBY ORDERED:
5 The following portions of Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification and supporting
6 docum en ts may be filed under seal:
7 Exhibit to Andre M. Mura Declaration in Designating Ruling
Support of Motion or Portion of Motion Party
8
Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 32:20-33:3 Defendant
9 Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 35:16-37:23 Defendant
Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 38:15-24 Defendant
10
Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 50:10-15 Defendant
11 Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 60:21-61:14 Defendant
Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 62:21-25 Defendant
12
Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 69:8-16 Defendant
13 Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 95:3-96:19 Defendant
Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 98:19-99:20 Defendant
14
Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 102:25-103:5 Defendant
15 Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 104:13-107:17 Defendant
16 Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 108:15-110:17 Defendant
Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 121:15-122:4 Defendant
17 Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 122:21-25 Defendant
18 Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 123:5-123:12 Defendant
Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 150:2-9 Defendant
19 Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 156:11-157:4 Defendant
20 Ex. 1 (Fox Dep. 169:21-170:4 Defendant
Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 178:2-24 Defendant
21 Ex. 1 (Fox Dep.) 189:16-23 Defendant
22 Ex. 2 (TR-BROOKS026283-TR-BROOKS026284) Defendant
Ex. 3 (TR-BROOKS023888) Defendant
23 Ex. 4 (Turow Report) Defendant
24 Ex. 5 (Buckethal Dep.) 23:19-25 Defendant
Ex. 5 (Buckethal Dep.) 32:13-23 Defendant
25 Ex. 6 (Godlewski Dep.) 33:4-7 Defendant
26 Ex. 6 (Godlewski Dep.} 151:22-152:24 Defendant
Ex. 6 (Godlewski Dep.) 163:15-21 Defendant
27 Ex. 6 (Godlewski Dep.) 164:10-12 Defendant
28 Ex. 6 (Godlewski Dep.) 172:22-173:5 Defendant
Ex. 6 (Godlewski Dep. 191:10-13 Defendant
1
[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: PLAINTIFFS' ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO CONSIDER
WHETHER ANOTHER PARTY'S MATERIALS SHOULD BE SEALED
Case No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC-KAW
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 134 Filed 11/10/22 Page 3 of 8
1 Exhibit to Andre M. Mura Declaration in Designating Ruling
Support of Motion or Portion of Motion Party
2
Ex. 6 (Godlewski Dep.) 220:1-20 Defendant
3 Ex. 7 (Attachment A to Defendant's Responses to Defendant
Plaintiffs' First Set of Interrogatories, pp. 14-21)
4
Ex. 8 (TR-BROOKS052568) Defendant
5 Ex. 9 (TR-BROOKS426763) Defendant
Ex. 12 (TR-BROOKS020865-TR-BROOKS020890) Defendant
6
Ex. 15 (TR-BROOKS020567) Defendant
7 Ex. 16 (TR-BROOKS101145-TR-BROOKS101149) Defendant
Ex. 17 (TR-BROOKS013854) Defendant
8
Ex. 19 (TR-BROOKS072364-TR-BROOKS072636 Defendant
9 Ex. 20 (TR-BROOKS020290-TR-BROOKS020293) Defendant
Ex. 21 (TR-BROOKS332920) Defendant
10
Ex. 23 (TR-BROOKS284900-TR-BROOKS284905) Defendant
11 Ex. 24 (TR-BROOKS422796) Defendant
12 Ex. 25 (TR-BROOKS060012-TR-BROOKS060013) Defendant
Ex. 26 (TR-BROOKS020178) Defendant
13 Ex. 27 (TR-BROOKS060007-TR-BROOKS060008) Defendant
14 Ex. 28 (TR-BROOKS225965) Defendant
Ex. 29 (TR-BROOKS383370-TR-BROOKS383372) Defendant
15 Ex. 30 (TR-BROOKS020176-TR-BROOKS020177) Defendant
16 Ex. 31 (TR-BROOKS316008-TR-BROOKS316036) Defendant
Ex. 32 (TR-BROOKS135830-TR-BROOKS135836) Defendant
17 Ex. 33 (TR-BROOKS317004-TR-BROOKS317006) Defendant
18 Ex. 34 (TR-BROOKS418771-TR-BROOKS418776) Defendant
Ex. 35 (TR-BROOKS028621-TR-BROOKS028622) Defendant
19 Ex. 36 (TR-BROOKS024022-TR-BROOKS024023) Defendant
20 Ex. 37 (TR-BROOKS079617) Defendant
Ex. 38 (TR-BROOKS040077-TR-BROOKS040089) Defendant
21 Ex. 39 (TR-BROOKS138062-TR-BROOKS138064) Defendant
22 Ex. 41 (TR-BROOKS280153-TR-BROOKS280161) Defendant
Ex. 42 (TR-BROOKS296841-TR-BROOKS296863) Defendant
23
Ex. 43 (TR-BROOKS020396) Defendant
24 Ex. 44 (TR-BROOKS274854-TR-BROOKS274861) Defendant
Ex. 45 (TR-BROOKS408706-TR-BROOKS408712) Defendant
25
Ex. 46 (TR-BROOKS013613-TR-BROOKS013615) Defendant
26 Ex. 47 (TR-BROOKS297996-TR-BROOKS298005) Defendant
Ex. 48 (TR-BROOKS273025-TR-BROOKS273031) Defendant
27
Ex. 49 (TR-BROOKS044835-TR-BROOKS044837) Defendant
28 Ex. 50 (TR-BROOKS171366-TR-BROOKS171367) Defendant
Ex. 51 (TR-BROOKS018865-TR-BROOKS018867) Defendant
2
[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: PLAIN TIFFS' ADMIN ISTRATIVE MOTION TO CONSIDER
WHETHER ANOTHER PARTY'S MATERIALS SHOULD BE SEALED
Case No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC-KAW
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 134 Filed 11/10/22 Page 4 of 8
1 Exhibit to Andre M. Mura Declaration in Designating Ruling
Support of Motion or Portion of Motion Party
2
Ex. 52 (TR-BROOKS019226-TR-BROOKS019228) Defendant
3 Ex. 53 (TR-BROOKS418877-TR-BROOKS418881) Defendant
Ex. 54 (TR-BROOKS253461) Defendant
4
Ex. 55 (TR-BROOKS175246-TR-BROOKS175249) Defendant
5 Ex. 56 (TR-BROOKS251168- TR-BROOKS251170) Defendant
Ex. 57 (TR-BROOKS189667) Defendant
6
Ex. 58 (TR-BROOKS062991-TR-BROOKS062998) Defendant
7 Ex. 59 (FSG Report) Defendant
8
Ex. 60 (Thomson Reuters' First Supplemental Defendant
Answer to Plaintiffs' First Set of Intenogatories)
9 Ex. 61 (TR-BROOKS123263-TR-BROOKS123277) Defendant
10 Ex. 62 (TR-BROOKS311495) Defendant
Ex. 67 (TR-BROOKS027757-TR-BROOKS027761) Defendant
11 Ex. 70 (TR-BROOKS017559) Defendant
12 Ex. 71 (TR-BROOKS332968) Defendant
Ex. 72 (TR-BROOKS332921-TR-BROOKS332967) Defendant
13 Ex. 73 (TR-BROOKS005220-TR-BROOKS008254) Defendant
14 Ex. 74 (TR-BROOKS008353-TR-BROOKS008718) Defendant
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 1, line 4 Defendant
15 (between " abou t" and en d of sentence)
16 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 1, line 9 Defendant
(first full sen tence)
17 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 1, lines Defendant
18 10-11 (between "including" and " of dollars")
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 1, lines Defendant
19 15-16 (between "In fact," and "let alone")
20 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 1, line Defendant
19 (between "including" and end of sen ten ce)
21 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 1, line Defendant
22 22 (between "is" and en d of sen ten ce)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 2, line Defendant
23 16 (between "a" and "for")
24 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 2, line Defendant
17 (between " on" and "Californians")
25 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 2, lines Defendant
26 19-22 (en tire sentence)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, lines Defendant
27 1-2 (between " purp oses:" and " have all bought
28 access to CLEAR")
3
[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: PLAINTIFFS' ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO CONSIDER
WHETHER ANOTHER PARTY'S MATERIALS SHOULD BE SEALED
Case No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC-KAW
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 134 Filed 11/10/22 Page 5 of 8
1 Exhibit to Andre M. Mura Declaration in Designating Ruling
Support of Motion or Portion of Motion Party
2
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, lines Defendant
3 4-5 (between " Californians" and " and n one" )
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, line Defendant
4
12 (en tire senten ce)
5 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, lines Defendant
14-15 (between " a" and " that may be available.")
6
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, lines Defendant
7 17-18 (between " information " and " live cell
phone" )
8
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, lines Defendant
9 19-20 (between "facilities," and " professional")
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, line Defendant
10
20 (between " profession al" and " licenses")
11 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, lines Defendant
21-23 (between " licenses" and " arrest records")
12
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, lines Defendant
13 23-24 (between " arrest records," and " and
m ore.")
14
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, line Defendant
15 26 (between "from " and " to" )
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, lines Defendant
16 26-27 (between " to" and en d of sentence)
17 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 3, lines Defendant
27-28 (between " that" and " is available" )
18 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 4, lines Defendant
19 3-5 (en tire sentence)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 4, lines Defendant
20 8-9 (between " othe1w ise" and end of sen ten ce)
21 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 4, lines Defendant
10-14 (between " access to" and end of sen ten ce)
22 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 4, lines Defendant
23 16-17 (en tire sentence)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 4, lines Defendant
24 17-20 (between " (CLEAR RTIA Spreadsheet)"
25 and "See, e.5:., i'd.. ")
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 4, line Defendant
26 23 (between " through" and " third parties")
27 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 4, lines Defendant
23-24 (between " eve1y one from " and en d of
28 sen tence)
4
[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: PLAINTIFFS' ADMIN ISTRATIVE MOTION TO CONSIDER
WHETHER ANOTHER PARTY'S MATERIALS SHOULD BE SEALED
Case No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC-KAW
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 134 Filed 11/10/22 Page 6 of 8
1 Exhibit to Andre M. Mura Declaration in Designating Ruling
Support of Motion or Portion of Motion Party
2
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 4, lines Defend ant
3 26-27 (en tire sentence)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 4, line Defendant
4
28 (en tire senten ce)
5 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 5, line 2 Defendant
(between " at once - " and en d of sentence)
6
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 5, lines Defendant
7 4-5 (between "search function " and en d of
sentence)
8
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 5, line 7 Defendant
9 (between beginning of sentence and " which" )
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 5, lines Defendant
10
7-8 (between " gathers" and "from the third
11 parties")
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 5, lines Defendant
12 8-10 (en tire sentence)
13 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 5 lines Defendant
12-13 (between " it is" and en d of citation
14 paren thetical)
15 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 5, line Defendant
15 (between " its" and "and paten ted")
16 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 5, line Defendant
17 15 (between " database" and "which associates")
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 5, lines Defendant
18 23.5-24 (en tire citation paren thetical)
19 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 5, line Defendant
25 (en tire citation paren thetical)
20 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 5, lines Defendant
21 25-27.5 (en tire citation paren thetical)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, line 3 Defendant
22 (between "by its" and " CLEAR custom ers")
23 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, line 5 Defendant
(between " claim s to restrict" and " cherry-
24 picking")
25 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, line 6 Defendant
(between " terms" and end of sen ten ce)
26 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, line 7 Defendant
27 (between " But" and " is n ot")
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, lines Defendant
28 8-10 (between "by" and en d of sen tence)
5
[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: PLAINTIFFS' ADMIN ISTRATIVE MOTION TO CONSIDER
WHETHER ANOTHER PARTY'S MATERIALS SH OULD BE SEALED
Case No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC-KAW
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 134 Filed 11/10/22 Page 7 of 8
1 Exhibit to Andre M. Mura Declaration in Designating Ruling
Support of Motion or Portion of Motion Party
2
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, lines Defendant
3 11-12 (en tire sentence)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, line Defendant
4
13 (between " considered" and en d of sentence)
5 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, lines Defendant
14-15 (between " that they" and end of
6
paren thetical)
7 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, lines Defendant
16-17 (between " discussing" and en d of
8
paren thetical)
9 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, lines Defendant
20-21 (between " information " and en d of
10 sen tence)
11 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, lines Defendant
22.5-23 (en tire citation paren thetical)
12 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, lines Defendant
13 23.5-25 (en tire citation paren thetical)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, lines Defendant
14 25.5-26 (en tire citation paren thetical)
15 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, lines Defendant
26-27.5 (en tire citation paren thetical)
16 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 6, line Defendant
17 28 (en tire citation paren thetical)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, lines Defendant
18 1-2 (between " discussing" and en d of citation
19 paren thetical)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, lines Defendant
20 3-6 (en tire citation paren thetical)
21 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, lines Defendant
7-10 (between "found" and end of citation
22 paren thetical)
23 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, line Defendant
11 (between " gen erates" and "from selling" )
24 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, line Defendant
25 13 (between " over" and "selling")
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, lines Defendant
26 13-14 (between " access to" and end of sen ten ce)
27 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, line Defendant
16 (between " developed" and " CLEAR" )
28
6
[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: PLAINTIFFS' ADMIN ISTRATIVE MOTION TO CONSIDER
WHETHER ANOTHER PARTY'S MATERIALS SHOULD BE SEALED
Case No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC-KAW
Case 3:21-cv-01418-EMC Document 134 Filed 11/10/22 Page 8 of 8
1 Exhibit to Andre M. Mura Declaration in Designating Ruling
Support of Motion or Portion of Motion Party
2
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, lines Defendant
3 17-18 (between "only" and end of sen ten ce)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, lines Defendant
4
19-20 (between "from" and en d of sentence)
5 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, lines Defendant
21-24 (between "include" and "and more.")
6
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, lines Defendant
7 25-26 (between " purpose:" and en d of sen tence)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 7, line Defendant
8
27 (between "CLEAR" and en d of sentence)
9 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 8, line 1 Defendant
(between "CLEAR" and en d of sentence)
10
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 8, lines Defendant
11 6-7 (between "Californians" and end of sentence)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 8, lines Defendant
12
8-10 (between "for examp le," and end of
13 sen tence)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 8, lines Defendant
14
11-12 (between " part," and en d of sentence)
15 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 9, lines Defendant
7-11 (between "Thomson Reuters" and en d of
16
sentence)
17 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 11, lines Defendant
11-12 (between "information on " and en d of
18 sen tence)
19 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 17, lines Defendant
22-23 (en tire sentence)
20 Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 18, lines Defendant
21 27.5-28 (en tire citation paren thetical)
Pis.' Motion for Class Certification, page 21, line Defendant
22 18 (between "class m embers" and "and would
23 therefore")
24 IT IS SO ORDERED.
25
26 DATED: November 10, 2022
27 EDWARD M. CHEN
United States District Judge
28
7
[PROPOSED] ORDER RE: PLAINTIFFS' ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO CONSIDER
WHETHER ANOTHER PARTY'S MATERIALS SHOULD BE SEALED
Case No. 3:21-cv-01418-EMC-KAW
File and source
- File
- gov.uscourts.cand.374304.134.0.pdf
- Size
- 1,981,997 bytes
- SHA-256
- 53e341e0160a91e3940a7d6c3aec1eba594904b48d72e6c6f72f03c59ce90146
- Original
- PACER (login required)